Slashdot Mirror


Unsung Heroes of Open Source

Yosef writes "Jon Udell uses his experience from using and hacking the free software BitPim to say that developers of such less-known projects are the true heroes of open source: 'For solving a host of vexing problems with quiet competence, and for doing it in ways that invite others to stand on their shoulders, I salute them all.'"

44 of 164 comments (clear)

  1. So true... by VegetableMatter · · Score: 4, Interesting

    When it comes to open-source, Mozilla and Linux get all the glory. But it's this guy and his amazing SEPY text editor that make my life the joy that it is!

  2. Thanking the developers by nadamsieee · · Score: 5, Insightful

    We could all thank them by donating a buck or two to their projects.

    1. Re:Thanking the developers by beevan_jedi · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually, The BitPim developer(s) don't accept financial contributions...

      http://www.bitpim.org/testhelp/contributing.htm

    2. Re:Thanking the developers by nadamsieee · · Score: 2, Insightful

      But many of the 'unsung heros of opensource' do accept monetary donations.

      Of course, you could always donate some time & effort (as others have pointed out).

    3. Re:Thanking the developers by SharpFang · · Score: 5, Insightful

      In most cases they would be more grateful for a neat patch with some feature, for some words of praise, and especially with success stories of their software.
      I wrote this little piece of crap. Okay, it got obsoleted really fast, it does the job but isn't anything great and there's practically no audience. But then I found this blog entry (fish link) and felt really special :) It's what makes such projects great, people's gratitude. Not money. Just the fact that you're the hero.

      --
      45 5F E1 04 22 CA 29 C4 93 3F 95 05 2B 79 2A B2
  3. Different Perspectives by bigtallmofo · · Score: 4, Funny

    What Jon Udell calls a "List of Unsung Heroes", Microsoft calls a "Hit List".

    --
    I'm a big tall mofo.
  4. YOU can also be a hero! by xiando · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Do you use Linux? Know how to code?

    If so, then you can be a hero too. I never paid for software in the form of money, I personally feel it is alright to spend some of the saved money in the form of personal time when I find bugs, missing features and so on. Sadly, I am not a very experienced programmer, but I have managed to get some small patches into Open Source projects.

    This is how you can be a hero also, even if it is just a line of code - the sum of all small snippets like that does eventually help the evolution of Open Source.

    So skilled or not, you can be a hero too! Some are great big heros, but even if you just translated a text string, fixed a few lines or code, or just made some graphics -- then you are a small hero (in my eyes) also!

    1. Re:YOU can also be a hero! by omicronish · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Do you use Linux? Know how to code? If so, then you can be a hero too.

      A lot of people equate open source with Linux, but there's quite a lot of it for Windows and other operating systems as well. Firefox, Mozilla, Eclipse, Python, and Mono all run on Windows. SourceForge lists over 10,000 projects for Windows. In fact, I'm a Windows user who wouldn't be able to live without Python, Bitlbee, Subversion, and wget.

      So Windows users who are interested, join in on the fun. OSS isn't limited to Linux users.

    2. Re:YOU can also be a hero! by Eberlin · · Score: 2, Funny

      Can I use my not-so-Mad Rhyming Skillz to translate some documentation for Ubuntu? I had a really really old soundblaster-compatible card that needed some hocus pocus ALSA config stuff that took me a week to figure out with the help of google and people posting oodles of info. (ok, hocus pocus to me, but I figure the rest of you think it's damn simple)

      So I was in despair
      In need of a good driver
      Swimming 'round Google
      like a clueless scuba diver

      I'm a cheap bastard
      and I ain't droppin' thirty
      On an audigy that's bork
      so now I've got my hands dirty

      No AlsaConfig
      dot-deb for Warty
      So I aliened from mandrake
      And started to party

      The configs, still shot
      Victory untasted
      So I got on the web
      I cut and I pasted

      Now it's all runnin,
      though far from perfection
      I gots kickin' bass
      for my OGG collection.

      Mad props to da G's --
      coders of da OSS Nation
      and shout outs to all y'all
      Who write good documentation.

      To quote Axl Rose at the end of "Garden of Eden" I think..."Awwwright, that SUCKED!"

    3. Re:YOU can also be a hero! by Nutria · · Score: 2, Insightful

      A holy war will never impact the The Borg's bottom line. Better software will.

      MSFT isn't, though, lying down. It will fight FLOSS on both the legal and technical fronts, and there will be (metaphoric) blood spilt.

      --
      "I don't know, therefore Aliens" Wafflebox1
  5. Michael Elkins by defile · · Score: 4, Insightful

    All mail clients suck, mutt just sucks the least.

  6. Where are they all hiding? by Glowing+Fish · · Score: 4, Funny

    I know a lot more open source developers than the average person. (although perhaps not more than the average Slashdotter), and I can't figure out how there can be enough of them to keep all these projects floating.
    For example, how many people were neccesary to put together libsdl-sound1.2 which is one of tens of thousands of packages hiding in the Debian repository, which is just a small piece of all open source projects.
    Where are all these open source developers hiding? Is this what my bus driver does when they aren't at work?

    --
    Hopefully I didn't put any [] around my words.
    1. Re:Where are they all hiding? by Zarf · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I would guess that a great number of OSS projects are driven by people who need things for work, but whose work isn't exclusivley demanding ownership of their code. Small shops that need probelms solved that are very nearly solved already... and can spare a developers time to solve them... and won't be hurt by releasing the code. That's the idea I get in my mind.

      For example, I'm considering making contributions to several projects myself. My contributions may be tiny but they may help to add up to a real finished product. It's all about the aggregate contributions of the many many tiny improvements people make adding up to make major differences... Open Source projects build up the same way civilisation does. Millions of small contributions over time.

      I'm probably wrong but it sounds good to me...

      So stop reading slashdot and go code something.

      --
      [signature]
    2. Re:Where are they all hiding? by QuantumG · · Score: 2, Interesting
      Wow the necessity is the mother of inventory (or scratching the itch) explaination for open source is still popular? I've found that the vast majority of open source projects are started by people who had "some interest" in coding what they started coding. It's not because they've got work to do and can't find anything to do it (if you've got work to do you do the damn the work, you don't sit down and write tools so you can do it better), it's because they wanted to enjoy themselves coding something that they hadn't coded before. Or, like an artist, they had a vision in their head how a piece of software could be written so they laboured to bring that vision into the real world, purely for the joy of "getting it out" to other human beings.

      Sure, after these pioneers have produced what they produce people often come along and hack on it so they can get real work done with it, but in the case of a sound driver, we're not talking about getting work done here, we're talking about the artifacts of intellectual curiousity that us programmers hate to see "go to waste", so we share it.

      --
      How we know is more important than what we know.
    3. Re:Where are they all hiding? by Zarf · · Score: 2, Insightful

      if you've got work to do you do the damn the work, you don't sit down and write tools so you can do it better

      True story: I have this job. I write code. Much of this job ended up writing the same types of programs over and over again. So I got tired of writing the same thing over and over again and I wrote a tool to do my job better. The Objects I wrote allow me to make a program in a few minutes that used to take several days to create.

      If I worked with the attitude that I don't get paid to make tools to do things better my productivity would never advance. I would never have had time to move on to more advanced projects. I would have only done the "damn" work and only the "damn" work would have been done.

      Because I was able to be more than a code robot I was able to introduce other new tools to my company. Tools that allow others to produce more. Tools that will allow my company to be more profitable.

      It's good for me. Good for my company. And if I felt it would benefit others I'd go ahead and release my code base because if others benefit from what I wrote, and others use the same tools/environment, it improves the market share for my skills. It makes me more valuable, it makes my skill set more valuable, it makes my company incrementally more valuable by improving it's status (and at worst doesn't hurt it at all).

      So my view may not be fashionable, but it does seem to resonate with some people. It would be the reason I would make Open Source contributions. I know I have several itches that need scratching... and if I don't find existing projects to contribute to then I'll make something from scratch.

      --
      [signature]
  7. Making technical information available by Husgaard · · Score: 5, Interesting

    The interesting point he is making here is that FOSS people not only write software - they also make obscure technical information available and accessible.

  8. Life is easier due to them by SunFan · · Score: 3, Interesting


    I remember using gnuplot to make great EPS (encapsulated PostScript) graphs for papers in college. I'm not sure of a better way to put nice charts into LaTeX documents. Even the developers of LaTeX modules for things like rotated charts with regular headers and footers deserve a share of credit.

    --
    -- Microsoft is the most expensive commodity operating system and office suite vendor in the marketplace.
  9. Recognition helps by karvind · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Recognition always helps. An earlier Slashdot story

  10. Here are my unsung heroes by Anthony+Boyd · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I would say the gentleman behind HT Track is an unsung hero. I sent him a bug report with pseudo-code as a guess to how to fix it. The very next day, he had sent me a thank-you email and had released a new version. I also found the Mozilla team to be very responsive to my suggestions here on Slashdot (one post turned into a new Mozilla feature -- pre-fetching). And the HTML-Kit team is very responsive to bug reports and patches too. I like all three teams at the geek level. Their products satisfy an important niche in Web development, they're responsive and accept code patches (even my poorly done offerings, with cleanup of course). I feel quite happy to call them unsung heroes of the OSS movement, and this is my second shot at singing their praises (see previous "unsung heroes of open source" article).

    1. Re:Here are my unsung heroes by dasunt · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I have a similar story with a small dockapp called wmfuzzy that displays a time string.

      When I switched to OpenBSD on a laptop, it didn't work. I informed the author, and he rewrote some code so it would. I tested it, found a few bugs, and told them of it. Although I couldn't code C at the time, I could read the asset reports and change the system clock so that the bugs would trigger.

      Its a great feeling to submit a bug report in the morning and by the next day have a patched version of the code to test.

      Its also nice to get a point release and credit in the changelog. :)

      Another time, I was playing slash'em and I found that I could get some rather strange error messages with One-Eyed Sam in a certain scenerio. I talked to one of the developers on IRC, narrowed down the problem, and filed a bug report. Last I heard, it was fixed in the next release. (The bug wasn't a game-crashing bug, just slash'em realizing that the shop didn't have a shop keeper.)

  11. Just one example? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    BitPim is the only example in that story? I was expecting to see a top 10 list of unsung heroes, but he just writes about one niche piece of software he found useful. You can find more in the average Slashdot article's comments.

  12. The ONE thing I take away, having read your post.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    You've never seen MY code.

    My code is like my handwriting, I know what it's about at the time, but no one, myself included, can decipher it if it comes up again.

  13. Roger Binns no longer unsung by osewa77 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    John Udell, by writing this post, has just succeeded on bringing one unsung hero - Roger Binns - out of obscurity. Well done, John!!

  14. Do you use Linux? Know how to breath. by oliverthered · · Score: 4, Insightful

    You don't need to code to help out OSS.

    Finding bugs, fix spelling mistakes, doing thorough reviews or usability studies, translating help into different languages or even setting you granny up with Linux all go to help OSS.

    I think the translates do a Gem of a job, and make OSS accessible to a huge proportion of the world.

    --
    thank God the internet isn't a human right.
  15. Absolutely true by robertjw · · Score: 3, Interesting
    While I think that many of us do owe these big names like Linus, etc... I know that personally I owe much more to many of the 'unsung heros'. Guys like: and many others. The big projects help us get things done, but the small projects make the big projects barable.
  16. Heroes by SassyDave · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'll bet there are hundreds of open source developers scouring these posts right now to see if they show up on someone's list.

  17. There are many fringe benefits by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    For example, how many commercial software development jobs come with benefits like this ?

  18. ob quote: the out-of-work ex-leper by Avishalom · · Score: 3, Interesting

    "what, one Shekel for an unemployed ex-leper"
    "well i guess there's no pleasing some people"
    "that's just what he said, bloody do-gooder"

  19. My Hero is... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    My personal hero in the Open Source community is Bill Gates. He has done so much to spur to growth of good software and open source its hard not to pay some tribute to this man.

  20. another one by Avishalom · · Score: 2, Interesting
  21. GNUplot. by Grendel+Drago · · Score: 2, Informative

    Yes, I too know the delights of gnuplot for graphs, and the usage of make to smush together twenty graphs and diagrams (mmm, dia) into one LaTeX output document.

    Have you seen WikiTeX? It allows for direct inclusion of graphviz, gnuplot, LaTeX and LilyPond directly into a wiki page. (It's a MediaWiki extension.) You lose the excellent typesetting, but man is it ever quick and easy.

    --grendel drago

    --
    Laws do not persuade just because they threaten. --Seneca
  22. DikuMUD and CircleMUD creators by Magnifico · · Score: 2, Informative

    Many developers I know began writing code in college and compiling using gcc for MUDs. Most popular MUDs in my circles were DikuMUD based derived from the work of Sebastian Hammer, Tom Madsen, Katja Nyboe, Michael Seifert, and Hans Henrik Staerfeldt. (The creator fo CircleMUD, Jeremy Elson, also deserves a mention in my opinion too.) Freely available MUD code helped promote using open source software. I and many of my friends had our first introduction to Linux by finding a OS to run our MUD since we were getting booted off our university's unix boxes. So if you're looking for unsung open source heros, look at those who created and opened up their MUD source code back in the early 1990s.

  23. Roland McGrath, Brian Fox by codergeek42 · · Score: 2, Informative

    McGrath is the head developer of the GNU C Library, which is an absolute necessity for an entirely F/OSS system.

  24. Duncan Booth by rekrutacja · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Duncan Booth is supporting Nethack port for Psion computers (do you remeber them?) for years. Only small fraction of people (Psion users which are Nethack lovers too) will ever notice value of his work. But for us, Nethack addicts which happen to be also Psion users, he is an ultimate hero. Check it: http://www.suttoncourtenay.org.uk/duncan/Nethack.h tm

    I'm sure you can find such people everywhere. Whatever obscure activity you undertake, or whatever strange problem happens to you, you sooner or later meet your hero. I mean - this is how free software works, isn't it?

    --
    This Is Not a Sig
  25. It's like high school all over again. by IGnatius+T+Foobar · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's true. Lately I've been noticing that living in the open source universe can be a lot like attending high school: everything is a popularity contest. If you're not one of the "cool kids" you don't get any attention, even if what you're working on is more mature, more sophisticated, and just plain better than what they're working on.

    What I'm about to say is probably not going to be taken well, but here goes anyway: Slashdot is probably the "football team / cheerleading squad" of the open source high school -- the place where the coolest of the cool get the most concentrated doses of glory and attention. There are certain people (whose names I shall not defame in this post, lest I get moderated down to -99 or something) who could make a stupid remark about how they think it would be better if people didn't wear matching shoes, and Slashdot would run half a dozen stories about it.

    The best example of unsung heroes might be Linas Vepstas. He wasn't one of the "cool kids" so the world pretty much ignored his project, which was to port Linux to IBM mainframes -- he actually got it working, for the most part. IBM ignored his work and went it alone, and nobody knows much about Linas Vepstas now.

    Unsung heroes indeed. Let's all try to avoid making open source a fashion show. Most of our best technology was built by nerds, and nerds aren't known for their social skills.

    --
    Tired of FB/Google censorship? Visit UNCENSORED!
  26. So why don't we do something about it? by jalefkowit · · Score: 5, Interesting

    The Slashdot audience is probably better positioned to recognize the true "unsung heroes of OSS" than anyone else.

    So -- hey editors, you listening? -- why don't we have a monthly nomination for Unsung Hero of the Month? Let readers send in their candidates, along with a pitch for why they should be featured as an Unsung Hero; then have the editors pick the best pitch, and give that developer a front-page interview on Slashdot.

    Heck, maybe even throw in some ad space for his/her project (we're all in this OSS thing together right?). You could probably even have a corporate sponsor pick up the tab for the ad space (the cost would be pretty low, and you could offer them naming rights -- make it, say, the "IBM Open Source Unsung Hero of the Month").

    Then archive the interviews in a section of their own (just like "Developers", "Your Rights Online", etc.) so that once there's a bunch of these in the archives they can serve as a kind of Hall of Fame.

    This would help introduce people to a whole range of great OSS projects they might otherwise never discover, and give the developers the "ego payment" that for so many folks is the only real reimbursement they get for their hard work...

  27. Roger Binns responds ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    The funny thing is that none of my friends would call me unsung or obscure :-)

    As someone else quoted we do not accept money, kickbacks or other forms of financing for BitPim. This is simply because it creates issues. Firstly some initial amount of that will be squandered on dealing with the tax situation it creates. Secondly it creates certain expectations. For example if someone donates and mentions they primarily use a particular operating system, then they wouldn't expect us to drop support for that operating system. Developer time is the most valuable thing, and it is best allocated without being biased by this kind of expectation.

    The best kind of help is time from developers, and reproducible issues that on fixing improve the product from users. But anything that is an improvement anywhere is nice.

    Don't worry about Microsoft. I've turned down the opportunity to even consider working for them several times. I've even reverse engineered several of their protocols, but sadly the results are all closed source. And I do know several people who have ended up at Microsoft. Not bad people as individuals, but the aggregate actions of the company are questionable.

    Yes, I use Linux. And Windows. And a Mac Mini. To me open source and free software is about freedom of choice as an end user. I can use things for whatever they are best at, and later take my data with me to something that is better. Funnily enough, the games I most enjoy come from Microsoft (eg Rise of Nations).

    BitPim got started because the closed source people in the cell phone space only supported Windows, and only allowed one installation of their software. (That isn't one concurrent use - it is one installation total. If you have two machines you would have to uninstall and reinstall.)

    None of my time on BitPim has been paid for by anyone else. My regular consulting gigs do take time away, but also pay me something to live on :-) Having something like BitPim on my resume has been very useful to show that I can actually do things.

    There are also several other people who contribute to BitPim. And *way* more contribute to the components that we use. BitPim is also an example of what you can do with Python.

    You can read more at http://groups-beta.google.com/group/comp.lang.pyth on/msg/16c51c50418bbb7f

    Roger

    1. Re:Roger Binns responds ... by Jeremy+Allison+-+Sam · · Score: 2, Interesting

      No Roger, you're not unsung or obscure.

      You're just a git :-).

      To those who don't know, Roger Binns is responsible for Samba having the fastest share-mode lock code possible, as he goaded me into doing it by claiming it required a lock daemon. I was determined to prove him wrong... :-).

      Roger is also responsible for VisionFS (the *old*, good SCO's decent SMB file/print server).

      Plus he holds a mean barbequeue :-). Even though his taste in toenail polish is *deplorable* :-).

      Jeremy.

  28. I add: Donald Becker by WMD_88 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The guy that wrote like half the ethernet drivers (including all the 3com ones) in the main kernel tree, among other things. You need that NIC support, after all! ;)

  29. Praise by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny
    Let us all praise the hung heroes of open sores: the slashdot trolls.

    HAND.

  30. Re:Maybe of the day by jalefkowit · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The idea isn't to recognize every single worthy hacker out there. It's to recognize many worthy hackers who would otherwise never get recognition.

    Even if you do this for years and only cover less than 1% of the total number of deserving hackers, you're still helping promote a huge number of great projects, which is a net win no matter how you slice it. Of course you're not going to be able to cover everybody. Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.

    And I would argue that if something like this ends up focusing primarily on people contributing to projects like KDE, GNOME, etc. it'd be missing the point. Jon's column was about the huge number of tiny, useful projects out there that are maintained by one or a few dedicated people, toiling away in obscurity. KDE doesn't need the exposure, these projects do.

  31. Re:SEPY by Zorilla · · Score: 2, Funny

    SEPY is a flash debugger. Why would anyone on /. want to encourage or faclitate the creation of flash content?

    Sure. Flash is only used to annoy the fuck out of you - and the exclusive purpose of VCRs is to flagrantly infringe on media producers' precious IP. Hypocrites.

    Get off you VT100 and come join us in this century.

    --

    It would be cool if it didn't suck.
  32. My unsung hero by Quattro+Vezina · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Joe Allen, the creator of Joe's Own Editor (JOE), my favourite text editor.

    It has the perfect balance of simplicity and power. Thank you, Joe!

    --
    I support the Center for Consumer Freedom
  33. Re: this century by Anomalyst · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Actually I prefer to be in the next century when "intent to deceive" laws are strictly enforced and violators receive a lifetime incarceration in the moon.
    I have yet to encounter a flash presentation with all the useless twirling geometrics, gradient colors (yeth, Doktor Frankenstein, yeth. We must add gradient colors. Hmpf, hmpf.) and a barrage of MTV-style image cuts that were shot from odd perspectives that could not have been improved upon by a simple black on white hyperlinked bullet list.
    I don't want to be sold about the chome plating, I don't want to be marketed about the sizzle, I want to be informed about the facts of the product and what makes it different from the competitors. I want to be given full disclosure about how much I will have to pay to drag it out the door, right there on the site! I don't want $CALL, I don't want to contact my local reseller. If they can't post the price, then, ipso facto, it obviously has no value. Compare the business ethics of Newegg where the price quoted is before rebates to marketroid efforts of Tigerdirect, Compusa and most others looking to sucker you with small-print, higher out-of-pocket prices, bait & switch tactics and "extended warranty" scams. I am sure it is only a matter of time before a "doc fee" is added by these bozos. Welcome to the reality of a consumer in this century.

    P.S. The only VCR I have is gathering dust in a box of stuff I inherited on the death of my parents. I was timeshifting HDTV on a scratch built PVR long before MythTV became all the craze. Yous, I imagine is still blinking 12:00 on the display.
    P.P.S. Get a larger vocabulary, profanity generally negates any point attempting to be made and marks one as an insensitive clod and/or an ignoramus.

    Momma told me there'd be .sigs like this.

    --
    There is no right to feel safe thru security vaudeville at the expense of everyone's freedom, privacy and tax money.