Slashdot Mirror
NASA's Deep Impact Moved Into Cruise Phase
karvind writes "NASA is reporting that the Deep Impact spacecraft has completed the commissioning phase of the mission and has moved into the cruise phase. Deep Impact mission planners have separated the spacecraft's flight operations into five mission phases. Cruise phase will continue until about 60 days before the encounter with comet Tempel 1 on July 4, 2005. Deep Impact has been covered on slashdot before"
ok, and when are they sending up Armageddon?
Three rings for the Elven-kings in the sky
This must surely be the fastest collision of non-atomic objects engineered by the human species?
--
Toby
I hope it doesn't crash.
"This is your captain speaking.
:)
We have now reached our cruising speed of 23,000mph. We will shortly be flying into a comet, so please enter your chairs are in the upright, locked position and extinguish all smoking materials.
Thankyou for flying EasyJet."
--
Toby
At completion of the bake-out procedure, test images were taken through the HRI.
Sound's trippy. I'll bring the snacks.
To heck with Armageddon, when do I get to make Deep Impact with Leelee Sobieski?
"BSD: Free as in speech. Linux: Free as in beer. Windows 10: Free as in herpes." --Man On Pink Corner in #52607549.
Phase 6: The press briefing explaining why they missed.
Isn't needed.
AT&ROFLMAO
Is this when the probe goes around looking for other probes of the same type to "dock" with?
Just sit right back and you'll hear a tale, a tale of a fateful trip. That started from this space port, aboard this tiny probe. The mate was a mighty sailin' man, the skipper brave and sure. Five experiments set sail that day, for a sixty day tour, a sixty day tour......... The weather started getting rough, the tiny probe was tossed. If not for the courage of the fearless crew, Deep Impace would be lost; Deep Impace would be lost. The probe smashed in to the shore of this uncharted space rock, with Gilligan, the Skipper too, the Millionaire, and his Wife, the Movie Star, the Professor and Mary Ann, here on Gilligan's Comet.
Ubiquitously - A Ubiquity Developer Community
Meanwhile, at the Springfield Atom Smasher.
"Constable! Make sure to search these workers thoroughly as they leave. Make sure they don't have any atoms in their pockets!"
Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
There's already this exclusive image of Deep Impact's encounter up on the Web.
Don't blame Durga. I voted for Centauri.
uhhh, the reason for the wide range in their estimates is because the composition of the comet is largly unknown. They won't know what its made of until they smash into it and attempt to get some readings from the core of the comet. So it nearly impossible for them to attempt to calculate a reasonable size for this impact since the size of the impact will be determined by the comets composition. Thats the whole point of the mission; to find out what the comet is made of. Since the comet was made during the begining of the our solar system's creation it will give us a good insight into how our solar system was created and what type of materials are most abundant.
No, that would be the mission phase. The decommissioning phase is not scheduled until several microseconds later.
Kinetic energy is 0.5*m.v*v. I guess that the probe is at least 370Kg (3700000 more than your bullet). So to reach the same kinetic energy they only need roughly 0.0005 of the velocity, that is 8 m/s-1. I tried a quick search and found it it is 370 kilos but could not find out what the speed is, but due to relative velocity difference you can bet it is faaaar more than your bullet in KE.
C. Sagan : A demon haunted world:
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0345409469/
visit randi.org
No one earth other than those with proper instrumentation will "feel" the effects of the impact.
Here's a story I ran across that would be of interest to those keeping up with "Independence Day" effects on Earth.
One day it's a giant asteroid that will snuff out all life on earth, another day it's a "super volcano", now this.
Rapidweather's Linux Screenshots.
Hooray for more space exploration! I was totally rivited to the Cassini/Heugens episode, and loved seeing those pictures of Saturn's rings close-up. The resulting images from the drop to Titan had me pretty-much at the console during the whole experience. Can't wait to read about the results of the comet-smash!
Zhrodague.net - I do projects and stuff too.
Any chance of NASA getting Richard Branson to pony up some cash, fund Deep Impact, and engage in some of his dashing-heroic schtick and pilot the thing into the comet? NASA would save some bucks, and we would be free of any future episodes of his dreadful Trump-ripoff reality show "The Billioinaire". Clearly a win-win for all of humanity.
Which one is more likely to fail, an remote-operated robot drill, or a big hammer?
I guess NASA chose the keep-it-simple way, they throw a big hammer on the commet and analyse the dust that will be ejected from the impact. Its way more simple than landing some robot, to rescue it after. Also, the impact will reveal deeper materials than a robot-drill could reach.
---- You know how some doctors have the Messiah complex - they need to save the world? You've got the "Rubik's" complex
wouldn't it be easier to just drill a core sample from the comet?
No.
In the solar system frame, the comet is approaching very fast. Its aphelion is just inside Jupiter's orbit. Our probe is poking along at an Earthlike velocity in a roughly Earthlike orbit- it's the comet that's going to crash into the probe, really, not the other way around.
To get your Black & Decker to it in one piece, you'd have to accelerate to 0 mph relative to the comet. That alone requires gravity assists off other planets. Then you need to design robotics to move around on an object with almost no gravity and a surface that can't be surveyed very well from Earth (thanks to the bright coma). You'd have to drill a hole into a material of unknown composition, in a process lasting minutes to hours rather than microseconds. That means you'll have to make decisions at certain points during the operation, requiring bug-prone programming or impractical communication links to ground-based controllers.
Simply allowing the comet to crash into something and taking pictures of the explosion from a distance is much cheaper and more likely to work.
There are missions in preparation to land on a comet. We have already landed on an asteroid and a comet is no different (just as long as you choose the right one). There are good scientific reasons for both (slamming/drilling) techniques. The drilling would be more accurate for composition (assuming that NASA properly funds the experiments) and the slamming will be giving more information on the "geology" of the body. Both are valuable sources of information on these interesting occupants of our solar system.
"Truth is much too complicated to allow anything but approximations"
In addition to millionthmonkey's reply, I want to add that they're expecting a very deep hole covering a large area (potential up to 150 feet deep). There simply has been no low gravity, remote deep drilling techniques or devices developed. This will hopefully give the scientists a look at any strata that may exist within the comet, as deep as whatever is blown out. Also, the size of the crater should allow help them figure out how well bound together comets are and they will see particles blown out from a large area of the comet's surface, not just the diameter of a drill.
A lander mission has it's own advantages, which is why some scientists want to land on a comet, as well. There's definitely an advantage in getting a lens or a sprectrograph right up against the item of interest and looking at the microscopic instead of macroscopic picture. It's also much more expensive and probably cuts down the number of reasonable targets, since you've got to match orbits with the comet.
The asteroid landing mission another poster mentioned was easier because asteroids generally have less eccentric orbits, which means their velocity in the inner solar system will be closer to that of earth. The landing was actually a bonus feature the science team decided to try after the primary mission of orbiting, photographing and mapping the asteroid was completed, just because they thought it might work. Thanks to the low gravity, the crash/landing actually did work. Theoretically, the probe is still in good condition on the surface and can continue to return images and data, although I don't think there will be another time when it simultaneously faces the earth (for radio contact) and the sun (for power) for several years.
This will hopefully bring to fruition the hard work of Jana and Audrey and all those other Honolulu-based astrobiology folks for whom I sometimes point this scope at comets.
Now I just have to remember to ask way far ahead of time to be running the scope around then. Or... maybe not. Maybe I should just drive up to the visitor station and kick back with their 16-inch Meade and some popcorn.
Village idiot in some extremely smart villages.