Slashdot Mirror


Plugin For Winamp Allows Downloading From iPod

slicenglide writes "A newly released plugin for Winamp allows you to copy music from your iPod to your computer. Wired has picked up the story and includes a link to the WinAmp plugin page where you can grab yourself a copy. "

65 of 398 comments (clear)

  1. Winamp? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    I think my grandparents use to use that back in the early twentieth century...

    1. Re:Winamp? by jxs2151 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      You from Korea by any chance?

  2. Wow, news to me by Kazzahdrane · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I for one never realised that iPods wouldn't let you copy music *off* them. Thank god I never bought one, that would annoy the hell out of me.

    1. Re:Wow, news to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

      It's nice to see dumb people self filtering themselves out of the iPod user base.

    2. Re:Wow, news to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

      Of course they allow you to copy music off of them. They're just plain old firewire/USB hard drives as far as your computer is concerned.

      The only gotchas are that the files are hidden, and the music's filenames are hashed for fast access from a metadata database. Thus when you copy the files back, you have to regenerate their names from their ID3 tags or the metadata database, as this winamp plugin does. You can do this as simply as dragging your music back into iTunes with the 'copy imported music' setting on, and there are plenty of other utilities that do it that have never gotten a /. article.

    3. Re:Wow, news to me by Kazzahdrane · · Score: 4, Informative

      Meh, I wouldn't say I was dumb, I just never investigated iPods in enough depth to discover that you can't take music off the thing. I wonder how many people know about that when they get one, it probably surprises a few people.

    4. Re:Wow, news to me by OwP_Fabricated · · Score: 5, Funny

      It's nice to see that assholes aren't however.

    5. Re:Wow, news to me by Jarlsberg · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I agree with you. If I had bought an Ipod, I would have assumed you could copy tracks back and forth, just like you can with any other MP3 player (that I've used, anyway). I don't really *get* the whole Ipod thing (why all the fuzz over a simple music player?), so I never bothered to buy one.

    6. Re:Wow, news to me by EpsCylonB · · Score: 2, Informative

      Ipods are definitely for Lusers (it surprises me that so many slashdotters rave about them). I don't have a HD based mp3 player yet but there are ones out there that are much more geek friendly than the apple offering. When I do buy one (when the prices fall a bit) I will definitely try and make sure I get one that plays ogg vorbis (this is one of the tests for geekiness).

      To be fair to the Ipod its just DRM'ed music you can't transfer off it, files and such can go both ways AFAIK although you do need the apple software installed. Not like my flash based muvo nx, any relatively recent operating system will see it as a removable hard drive, yes its a lot smaller than a HD based mp3 player but even so it amazes me how useful it can be.

      Nothing wrong Ipod/Itunes, very user friendly which isn't a bad thing, but I don't want to lock myself into such a service, I have a feeling that eventually downloadable music (the legal stuff) will converge into one simple DRM format that all the stores use.

    7. Re:Wow, news to me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      I don't really *get* the whole Ipod thing (why all the fuzz over a simple music player?)

      Because ITS MAED BY TEH APPAL!!!!1!one! Obviously anything that ITS MAED BY TEH APPAL!11one!!three! has to be the only thing in the entire world you should ever own. Even if it is overpriced, DRM crippled, uses a non-standard patent-encumbered format, requires software that only works on MacOS or Windows and is one big cross-promotional tie-in to an online music store that over-charges. It's ITS MAED BY TEH APPAL111oneone!!?seven! and that's all you need to know.

    8. Re:Wow, news to me by callipygian-showsyst · · Score: 3, Interesting
      That's why I got a Sampod.

      It supports open, industry standards like OGG Vorbis. Also, the "DRM" is used by a wide number of vendors, giving me the choice of at least 8 on-line music stores to purchase or "lease" music from.

      I simply plugged it into my Windows XP laptop and it worked--no software to install. Just press the "sync" button from Windows Media player 10.

      Copying music off is as easy as copying music on.

    9. Re:Wow, news to me by newend · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I am also surprised. Especially since the first time I tried to copy music off a friend's iPod onto my computer it worked. The only problem I noticed was that it truncated file names (a bitch and a half to go back and fix).

    10. Re:Wow, news to me by DigitumDei · · Score: 2, Funny

      If I compare you to a nazi bigot can I then call godwin and get all the zealots to shut up?

    11. Re:Wow, news to me by PhilHibbs · · Score: 4, Insightful
      It supports open, industry standards like OGG Vorbis.


      As much as I support OGG Vorbis, and have nearly all my music on my iRiver, I think calling it "industry standard" is way off the mark. MP3 is by far the most widely supported format, and therefore closest to being a de facto standard. The only other competitor is WAV.
    12. Re:Wow, news to me by CaymanIslandCarpedie · · Score: 5, Funny

      Dude, have you been living in a cave???? Haven't you seen those commercials with the cool shadows dancing in front of pretty colors? This is the best tech since Intel released the Blue Man Group.

      Ipod wasn't really meant for those who understand DRM, vendor tie-down, or patent encumbered propietary formats. Its meant for joe-six-pack. However, once it became sooooo cool, even the /. crowd had to get one. I mean when living in your mothers basement, you REALLY cannot afford to let any chance to look cool pass you by ;-)

      --
      "reality has a well-known liberal bias" - Steven Colbert
    13. Re:Wow, news to me by iainl · · Score: 2, Informative

      1) enable your iPod for hard-disc use in the options.

      2) look on the disk (on Windows they're in a hidden directory) and copy all those shiny mp3 files off to a temp directory.

      3) introduce them to iTunes and ask it to consolidate your library if you want the filenames to be sorted out.

      This certainly works on Windows, so I'd be surprised if it doesn't work on OSX as well.

      --
      "I Know You Are But What Am I?"
    14. Re:Wow, news to me by Daytona955i · · Score: 2, Interesting

      First, I think iPod's intent to not allow you to download tracks from your iPod was to help their stance with the music industry. (namely RIAA) However it is really easy to find programs that will allow you to get songs off of your iPod. You can however, easily upload/download other files to your iPod without any external programs.

      Pros and cons of an iPod:
      First, an iPod has one of the best interfaces of any portable music player I've ever seen. However I think the most powerful aspect of the iPod is using it in conjunction with iTunes. Yes, it sucks that it's not available for Linux but I use a powerbook as my main personal desktop and Linux mainly for mythtv and my servers. I really love the smart playlists and the ratings that you have available to you in iTunes. I can easily create complicated filters to say include all songs that have a rating of 4 or higher but don't include any Christmas songs.

      Also while I agree that DRM sucks, you can easily burn a cd and then rip the resulting CD back into mp3s with no DRM. I've also found that the iTunes store has a decent selection of music.

      The iPod also has the ability to remember where you stopped playing audiobooks. I think this is really cool because I have a long commute and I don't have to fiddle with fast forwarding or anything.

      There are a lot of car manufacturers who now offer easy ways of attaching your iPod to your cars stereo, you can also usually use the controls on the steering wheel if your car has them.

      I will admit that the iPod also has some downsides... first if you use napster, you are out of luck. The only option I have seen to get napster songs onto your iPod is to use a program that records the output of your soundcard. This just takes forever. Personally I don't have a napster subscription but I know some people who do and I know that some colleges (like psu) have subscriptions for all their students.

      It also won't play ogg formatted songs. For me this is a biggie. While most of my songs are already in mp3 format, I have been thinking of switching to ogg for my new songs but I guess I will have to wait on that.

      I recently got a 60GB iPod photo and I think it rocks! I plan on getting one of the speaker docks to put in the nursery for our new baby and have a playlist of just children's music. I will also always have said music with me in the car and then when I go to work, I don't have to worry about having the car loaded with children's music, I just change the playlist to one of my own. My wife also has an iPod mini so she can use the speaker dock while I'm at work.

    15. Re:Wow, news to me by mbbac · · Score: 2, Insightful

      It surprises no one because it isn't true.

      --

      mbbac

    16. Re:Wow, news to me by Total_Wimp · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Three simple steps for adding new music to your iPod:
      1: Import a CD or buy some songs in iTunes.
      2: Plug in your iPod.
      3: There's no step three.


      See, that's the problem right there. You gotta have iTunes. Using Apple products really is easier if you use all the products they tell you to, when they tell you to use them. If you want to use anything else and it can quickly turn into a hassle.

      This is simplicity in exactly the same way as "just us Internet Explorer and you wont have rendering or interoperability issues." If I don't give MS a pass on their version of "simplicity", why should I say it's ok for Apple?

    17. Re:Wow, news to me by Total_Wimp · · Score: 2, Insightful

      As I replied to the comment above yours, if it's not ok for Microsoft to lock you in then why should I consider it ok for Apple?

      I just flat out dislike lock in. I have several different MP3 players in my house from several different manufactures. My daughter has an iPod and a previous generation no-name player. I have a Windows Smartphone and a PSP. Of all of them, the iPod is by far the biggest hassle to use because we just happened to be using different desktop music players before I bought the iPod.

      Windows Media Player, WinAmp and MusicMatch all played pretty nicely together, mostly because none of them insisted on doing anything radical. But getting music onto and off of the MP3 players quickly became a hassle. The SmartPhone would only play ball with ActiveSync on a PC while the iPod refused to work with anything but iTunes. The ActiveSync wasn't a huge issue because it didn't necesitate I change my music player, but my daughter experienced all kinds frustration as she had to abandon the way she previously had her music organised and redo it all for iTunes.

      The thing is, I don't want to use iTunes and neither does my daughter. That's not a crack on Apple or the fine people who developed iTunes, I just happen to like what I currently use. What is a crack on Apple is that they had, and IMHO still have the ability to make a portable player that's easy to use with any desktop player and they just refuse to do it. That doesn't make them evil, it just puts them on the same ethical level as Microsoft. If they're ok with that and you're ok with that then more power to you, but it's increasingly looking like this is the first and last iPod in my house unless Apple makes some changes.

      TW

    18. Re:Wow, news to me by Simonetta · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Ipod wasn't really meant for ...It's meant for joe-six-pack.

      I don't believe that anything from Apple Computer is meant for "Joe Six-Pack". It's made for "Megan and Justin Portfolio" - the generic upper-middle-class arts-creative-type person. They have the money to pay the premium Apple price, the ability to best use the advanced design and interface character of Apple products, the distaste for technical details, and the subtle contempt for those who would feel the need or desire to skirt the restrictions imposed by Apple for the benefit of the product/company/community/class. They truly believe that bypassing DRM is bad because they feel that they are or more likely, someday will be making their well-heeled living off high priced 'intellectual property'.

      The "Joe SixPack" type middle-class Chevy-truck Saturday-night-watching-wrestling-on-TV people are using their Walmart CD players for portable music needs. They wouldn't buy Apple products even if they were in the same price range, simply because their inherent social inferiority complex alienates them from image that is created by Apple's advertisements.

    19. Re:Wow, news to me by recursiv · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yeah, you got it all figured out. But what's this? I'll bet you'll be pretty confused by my case. I have and use an ipod, but keep it concealed. I replaced the headphones with normal crappy looking headphones. No one who sees me would know I have an ipod. If I don't want and don't let anyone know I have an ipod, it can't possibly be a status symbol, right?

      So why do I have it? To listen to music. It works well. Previously, I purchased another mp3 player, only slightly cheaper, and had continuous problems with it. And even when it was working as intended, it was harder to use. The ipod is something like half the size and weight, easier to use, more reliable, and the support (which I used once) is vastly superior. Possibly the smoothest technical support experience I have ever had in my life.

      --
      I used to bulls-eye womp-rats in my pants
    20. Re:Wow, news to me by Koiu+Lpoi · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Click wheel. The engineering on it is beautiful.

      Besides that, there are no real amazing things about it. But the click wheel was enough to sell me.

      What bothers me, especially about the iPod, is the attitude people have of "I like this, so you and everyone should like it too!". If the iPod doesn't sit with you, don't buy it. And tell those people who tell you to buy one to shove it in a hole.

    21. Re:Wow, news to me by Total_Wimp · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Apple make the iPod and makes the software to run it.

      MS doesn't own or make the Internet.


      Or you could just reverse it and say:

      MS makes the web server (IIS) the web development software (asp.net) the browser and the OS all these are run on.

      Apple doesn't own or make the MP3 file format or any of the music that runs on their players.

      I'm not actually suggesting this is a reasonable thing to say, but it is similar to your statement.

  3. Big Deal by GrahamCox · · Score: 4, Informative

    iPods store the music totally openly in the directory structure. You can download the music from any file browser that can see the disk - like the command line on OS X for example. It's hardly rocket science.

    1. Re:Big Deal by flamearrows · · Score: 5, Interesting

      But it isn't obvious to the common users, nor is it an easy or efficient method of doing so. The winamp plug-in solves both problems.

      --
      The indiscriminate use of vulgar language is the linguistic crutch of the inarticulate motherfucker
    2. Re:Big Deal by Trillan · · Score: 4, Interesting

      The real problem is that the story is in the mainstream media now.

    3. Re:Big Deal by selderrr · · Score: 2, Funny

      It's hardly rocket science

      um.. no... or there would have to be a rocket involved, not ?

    4. Re:Big Deal by wootest · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Most reviewers who do demand direct directory access are generally clueless about how metadata, organization or both combined work with the devices. Even the iPod shuffle needs to store play order when used in the playlist mode - how do you suppose you put a few songs to the top of the list using folder structures?

      Low-level mavens might be more comfortable with folder arrangements as they involve 'less magic'. But things that can be in more places than one at the same time are just not good things to run directly on folder structures, because they'd require maintenance. I guess playlists are doable via folders of aliases/shortcuts/symlinks, but anything more complicated than that is just not tenable - like smart playlists.

    5. Re:Big Deal by iainl · · Score: 2, Funny

      As someone who did some Rocket Science at university, I'd have to say that it isn't exactly Brain Surgery.

      --
      "I Know You Are But What Am I?"
    6. Re:Big Deal by wootest · · Score: 2, Insightful

      It's called playlists.

  4. Windows ME by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    ""Using it with third-gen iPod and Windows ME," wrote Brian Cape in the Winamp forum. "Absolutely superb, no problems at all." "

    No problems at all with Windows ME? It's a miricle!

  5. Actually, on a Windows box ... by DikSeaCup · · Score: 3, Informative
    I've already been able to do this. Now, I don't get the files in the nifty directory structure of Artist/Album/track# songtitle.mp3, but hey, all I need after copying the files off of the iPod (using standard windows copying), I can just add the copied directory into *any* iTunes Library and iTunes will be nice enough to sort things however I told iTunes to do so.

    Of course I didn't read the article, so there might be something to it ... but I suspect it's not that hard to get the files via a Linux installation. The only platform I have that I have had trouble pulling the files off of the iPod on is Mac.

  6. Re:fuck slashdot by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    fucking nerds

    I wish someone would be. :-(

  7. Copying songs from iPod on Mac OS X by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    To copy songs from your iPod on mac os x, open up the terminal and type:

    # Change directory to the ipod music directory. (I'm not sure if iPod Control is the exact name I'm not on a mac at the moment, but it's similar.)
    cd /Volumes/name_of_ipod/iPod Control/music

    # View the files on the iPod
    ls

    # Then copy whatever the files called.
    cp name_of_file

    No plugins, downloads, whatever required :)

    1. Re:Copying songs from iPod on Mac OS X by temcat · · Score: 2, Funny

      Uh, that's a helluva lot of typing! Especially those lines that begin with #...

  8. now taking bets! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    How long will Apple take to *fix* this?

  9. Meh by Idimmu+Xul · · Score: 2, Informative

    I can copy music from my iRiver to my hdd without th e need for any such plugins, it's just like a removable hdd using the USB Mass Storage Device drivers.

    I pity you fools and your shiny white shackles!

    --
    The problem with slashdot is that most of its users were bullied and stuffed into lockers as kids!
  10. This is news? by moonbender · · Score: 5, Informative

    Maybe this is news for Winamp users - I doubt it, but I don't use it myself. But there has been software to download songs from the iPod to your harddrive for ages. The inability to do so is pretty much limited to iTunes, every other application dealing with the iPod (and there are dozens) enables you to do that. One popular example for Windows is EphPod. Lots and lots more can be found for multiple platforms at iPodlounge.

    Personally, I use foo_pod, a plugin for the foobar2000 audio player. It's quite powerful, including such features as automatic conversion of formats the iPod doesn't know (e.g. ogg or shorten) and automatic generation of audiobooks. For what it's worth - Wired seems to care - foobar and foo_pod are yet half as small than Winamp and that plugin is. Hah.

    --
    Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
  11. hmmm by mrselfdestrukt · · Score: 4, Funny

    But isn't that illegal?
    You are going to make jesus cry.
    N

    --
    "I used to have that really cool,funny sig ,but it got stolen."
  12. Bah by zaxios · · Score: 5, Informative

    This is hardly new nor interesting. There are plenty of programs that work with the iPod other than iTunes. Behold just a few:

    - Anapod Explorer

    - PodUtils

    - GTKpod

    - GNUpod

    And rhythmbox, for example, offers nice integration of music management and iPod operability -- if that's what is supposed to have made this newsworthy.

    1. Re:Bah by sacrilicious · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I've tried two of the utilities you mention (G*) and in each case gave up on getting them to function. I'm sure with enough time and fiddling it would have happened, but getting them to work wasn't high-enough priority for me to warrant putting in lots of time. If this new winamp thing "just works", no compilation/configuring involved, I would consider that a big step forward.

      --
      - First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then ???, then profit.
  13. Direct link to homepage by Will+Fisher · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Here is a direct link to the homepage for the winamp iPod plugin.

    We have many other features than just copy to hard drive, mlipod provides fully fledged iPod management. Go check it out!

    Will - Lead dev for mlipod

    1. Re:Direct link to homepage by Will+Fisher · · Score: 2, Informative

      You can get the source from the sourceforge CVS if you want. To compile it, you'll need the winamp SDK, avaliable in the winamp development section of http://forums.winamp.com/ Dump the source in \gen_ml\ml_ipod\ and it should work.

    2. Re:Direct link to homepage by PhotoBoy · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Great work! I've been using EphPod for ages as it supports Winamp playlists but obviously this is even better, especially since it doesn't crash all the time like EphPod... ;)

      I'm glad there are more and more alternatives to iTunes, it's such a horrid program to use IMO.

    3. Re:Direct link to homepage by sessamoid · · Score: 2, Informative
      My main problem with iTunes is how it likes to organise my music. I had a massive collection of MP3s long before iTunes came out and I organised my music into directories by type and by the name of the CD the music was from.

      Have you actually looked at the iTunes preferences?

      Under "Advanced", uncheck "Copy files to iTunes Music folder when adding to library". Just like magic, iTunes no longer rearranges your music files!

      --
      "No, no, no. Don't tug on that. You never know what it might be attached to."
  14. Newly released? by HoneyBunchesOfGoats · · Score: 3, Informative

    A friend of mine has been using this plugin for months, and prefers to use it in favor of iTunes. It's hardly new though, the earliest release listed on their Sourceforge filelist is from April 2004.

  15. FYI about shuffles by The+Hobo · · Score: 2, Informative

    I've been using this for a while, it works with Ipod Shuffles as well, just drag/drop, haven't tried any of the advanced features though

    --
    There is another kind of evil which we must fear most, and that is the indifference of good men. -- Boondock Saints
  16. When Will They Learn? by gadlaw · · Score: 2, Interesting

    People want to be able to use their music and their devices as they see fit and they will find a way to make that happen when companies try to cripple their otherwise good products. I bought my iPod thinking that it was probably locked down and the ability to transfer songs and files would be limited but I knew you people out there would fix the problem. It is annoying when locked down proprietary design locks the features down of a device I would otherwise buy and so I will look elsewhere when that happens -I'm looking at you Sony. (take your memory sticks and shove them) The iPod is popular despite it's attempted lockdown and they would do well to not follow the Sony example.

    --
    Enjoy your Karma, after all you earned it. Feel your Karma Joe, feel it burn.
  17. You can take music off it by simscitizen · · Score: 2, Interesting

    OP is referring to the fact that you CAN take music off it, and clearly you've not done your research well in the slightest. Just use a program like ephpod.

  18. Lots of great programs... by jmcmunn · · Score: 3, Informative

    There are a ton of programs that already let you do this. Perhaps the coolest in my eyes is a program called SharePod which runs directly from the iPod hard drive, and so requires no installation. It is for Windows only, however, which is the only limitation.

    http://sturm.t35.com/sharepod/

    There are also about a dozen alternatives here, on iPodlounge.com

    http://www.ipodlounge.com/index.php/ipod-software/

    Kudos to the WinAmp guys for doing this though, I'll probably check it out to see how they did it.

  19. Re:Piracy tool? by anime_layer · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Well here in Switzerland it is perfectly legal to hand your iPod to a close friend and let him copy your music off it. You can freely copy copyrighted works between family members and close friends.

  20. Re:Plug-In Useless by peragrin · · Score: 2, Informative

    only for AAC files. of which I have ~10 out of ~1700 songs. And the only reason why i bought those was because I drink pepsi, and got a bunch of free songs.

    Now I will keep my eye on Hymn and see if I can strip the drm from them straight.

    --
    i thought once I was found, but it was only a dream.
  21. Reality Check by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative


    1) any iPod, if initialized using Windows (meaning it's FAT32 formatted), is a standard USB Mass Storage Device that you can plug into any windows box that supports those and start using it as a removable HDD

    2) nothing prevents you from downloading your DRM-free songs from your iPod using only Windows Explorer. However, iTunes arranges all music files in 32/64/128/256 (something like that) folders named 00 through FF (in hex). So your Metallica - St.Anger tracks would be scattered in some 10 folders or so... and it's not that easy to compile the whole album by hand. iPod uses its internal database to find files. All this winamp plugin provides is a convenient way to copy files from your iPod back to your hdd by parsing through this database file and renaming files using the template specified.

    This also means that you can not simply copy mp3 folder to iPod and play them... you have to update the database. This is why you have to use iTunes (or this winamp plugin or similar util) to upload music to your iPod player.

    Yes, it's stupid, compared to the way iRiver players handle files and folders.

    3) I've been using this plugin for about a year now, this is hardly news. I recommend NOT to use it to upload files to your iPod, it once corrupted its database and I had to erase it and copy all the music again.

    4) there is also a plugin for Total Commander (my shell of choice) that provides similar functionality:

    http://www.totalcmd.net/plugring/ipod.html

    1. Re:Reality Check by chriskenrick · · Score: 2, Funny

      For a minute there I wondered why you posted that as AC, rather than yourself. Then I noticed you implied voluntarily having Metallica's St Anger on your computer ;)

  22. Wrong - well, partly anyway by CdBee · · Score: 4, Informative

    iTunes by default rips your Cds to non-protected m4u (AAC) or optionally, Mp3. Only tracks bought from the iTMS will be protected by default.

    I think this plugin is more intended as a utility to allow people to use their iPods to carry mp3s between PCs without the rigmarole of zipping them into an archive.

    --
    I have been a user for about 10 years. This ends Feb 2014. The site's been ruined. I'm off. Dice, FU
  23. Total Commander and Senuti could do this already. by Domini · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Total Commander can see the files on the iPod using this file system plugin. (link to download may be broken, but plugin can be found elsewhere...)

    TC is all you really ever need, and can replace explorer quite effectively with loads of added bonuses.

    I've also used a neat OS X util called Senuti (iTunes backward) to be able to copy from and to the iPod and do all sorts of other cool things.

    (Next to zsh and vi, it's the cheese!) ;)

  24. Re:Ogg fails it by Lurks · · Score: 2, Insightful
    The great thing about Ogg is that is open and not encumbered by patents

    The thing is though, right, who actually cares?

  25. Re:Wrong - well, partly anyway by iainl · · Score: 4, Informative

    Of course you can. It's just that some people find the fact that the filenames and subdirectories are structured to be fast and efficient for the player that keeps track info in a seperate database file, rather than easily human readable. Winamp (and indeed anything else) reads the intact header info on the files to get that for you.

    There's really a sliding 'geek' scale that goes something like this:

    0: doesn't care what they look like on disc, as going looking for the files directory is magic voodoo stuff.

    1: annoyed that the filenames are munged up, making it useless for most purposes.

    2: not that bothered, since they can work around it with the id3 tags. However, possibly irritated that they should have to anyway.

    --
    "I Know You Are But What Am I?"
  26. But does it support Speex? by cduffy · · Score: 2, Interesting

    No, I'm not joking. I occasionally want voice recorder functionality, and just about everyone seems to use some proprietary format or another for their hardware -- while Speex gets compression rates with the best of them, and works on all the platforms I use.

    Once upon a time I might have bought a player with Vorbis support -- but my money's gotten tighter since then, so my requirements have gone up. Where's the dedicated hardware with Speex support?

  27. Re:Wrong - well, partly anyway by Elwood+P+Dowd · · Score: 2, Insightful

    3: not bothered at all; thinks id3 is the right way to do it anyway due to cross platform filename hiccoughs.

    --

    There are no trails. There are no trees out here.
  28. No Need for an Extra Program by stuver · · Score: 2, Informative

    You can download from you iPod by doing the following:

    1. Set your iPod for use as a hard drive.
    2. Make the music directories on the hard drive visible (they are default hidden). You can do this by making visible the folder iPod_Control and clicking on "Apply changes to this folder, subfolders and files".
    3. Set iTunes to keep your music organized (a.k.a. copy them to your hard drive).
    4. Go to Files>Add Folder to Library and add the music folder on the iPod.

    This may take a little time if you have lots of music, but it will only copy the music that you do not already have.

  29. Blue Man Group by MexicanMenace · · Score: 3, Funny

    Intel didn't release the Blue Man Group. They escaped on their own using an elaborate, yet pleasant sounding series of PVC-lined tunnels.

  30. It's easy to get the songs off anyway... by Digital+Pizza · · Score: 3, Informative
    ... at least as long as the songs didn't come from the Apple store. All of mine are ripped from CD's or vinyl to MP3.

    The iPod's Music folder is hidden only in the Finder. On a Mac you can still get to it easily enough via the shell or an alternative file browser; go here:

    /Volumes/[iPod's name]/iPod_Control/Music/

    There are a bunch of folders with names like "F00", "F01", "F02" .. up to "F49" on mine. The MP3's are under these folders. The filenames and ID's are still intact, so it'd be easy to import them all into another program.

    If you want a nice GUI tool to do this, on Mac there is "iPod Access" and "iPodRip" (both shareware), and there is the free program "gtkpod", which I use on my Linux box at work to listen to my iPod songs.

    Apple really doesn't lock you out of your iPod, which is one reason why I love it! Of course, mine's HFS+ formatted; is it hard to do this on Windows?

    --
    We apologize for the inconvenience.
  31. *SIGH* How quickly people forget... by DLWormwood · · Score: 3, Interesting
    If it applies to your own MP3 collection, I'm shocked there has not been more outrage about this. What right does Apple have to restrict how you use YOUR music?!

    I've already mentioned this before, and it looks like I'm going to have to mention it again. It was not Apple's original idea to "prevent" music uploading from MP3 players, but it was the natural result of two factors:

    1. iTunes was originally a third-party sound player called SoundJam, which was originally made to work with players like the Diamond Rio. The original Rios, being very small capacity propretary flash devices, didn't have the circuitry and UI to handle uploading files back to a host computer.
    2. The RIO was challenged in US court by the RIAA as encouraging piracy, but the court found in favor of Diamond partly because the RIAA's argument made no sense for a device that couldn't upload, only download.

    Apple's continued "hiding" of the song files from the rest of the file system is simply legal cover to defend themselves from the RIAA. Do you really think Apple could have gotten the Music Store off the ground if the iPod more openly supported uploading?

    --
    Those who complain about affect & effect on /. should be disemvoweled