Slashdot Mirror


Emergency Gadgets Reviewed

Carl Bialik writes "When power lines go down, hand-cranked radios and standalone cellphone chargers could come in handy. Wall Street Journal columnist Walt Mossberg reviews emergency gadgets, including a $50 radio that picks up TV audio and gets 35 minutes of power from a 30-second crank. Of course, Mossberg also offers the caveat that these gadgets could be rendered useless 'should the communications infrastructure itself go down.'"

31 of 422 comments (clear)

  1. Useful emergency gadget by Silverlancer · · Score: 4, Funny

    Fire extinguisher. You know, for when the servers catch fire during the slashdotting.

  2. My Mossberg emergency item... by east+coast · · Score: 5, Funny

    It doesn't have a handcrank but it has a pump and a trigger.

    --
    Dedicated Cthulhu Cultist since 4523 BC.
    1. Re:My Mossberg emergency item... by TykeClone · · Score: 5, Funny

      And a point & click interface!

      --
      A fine is a tax you pay for doing wrong and a tax is a fine you pay for doing all right.
    2. Re:My Mossberg emergency item... by Karma_fucker_sucker · · Score: 5, Insightful
      Actually more insightful than funny. It disturbs me that during natural disasters, a few people go nuts and start robbing, raping, killing, etc... The cops can't or won't do anything - it really pissed me off during the LA riots when the cops just drove by the mob that was kicking the shit out of that trucker.

      In short, it never ceases to amaze me how humanity devolves during disasters and make a bad situation even worse.

      --
      Evil people don't think they're evil. - George Lucas, Making of Ep III
    3. Re:My Mossberg emergency item... by Ruprecht+the+Monkeyb · · Score: 4, Funny

      If it just goes 'click', you've got a problem...

    4. Re:My Mossberg emergency item... by dougmc · · Score: 5, Insightful
      it really pissed me off during the LA riots when the cops just drove by the mob that was kicking the shit out of that trucker.
      I vaguely remember what you're referring to, but not the specifics ...

      But it doesn't matter. Police, firemen and similar people are generally trained to take care of #1 first, not to be a hero. (Now, many people do disregard this and do dangerous things, but they're usually disciplined afterwards, assuming they live.)

      If you've got two police officers in a car, and you see a very angry mob beating somebody, intervening immediately is not usually the smartest thing to do. You'd be putting yourself into extreme danger, and may in fact make things worse for the person being beaten.

      A much smarter response would be to stay back and call it in and get lots of reinforcements, cops in riot gear, and THEN you can go in. When you're ready, not before. If you're going to enter a battle, make sure it's a battle you're likely to win. If you're not planning to win, don't enter.

      Individuals respect cop's authority. Even large crowds generally respect police. But an angry mob? No way would two smart cops do anything about that on their own beyond getting reenforcements.

    5. Re:My Mossberg emergency item... by RapmasterT · · Score: 4, Insightful
      It disturbs me that during natural disasters, a few people go nuts and start robbing, raping, killing, etc..
      It should disturb you that the mayor of NOLA sent the police and national guard door to door confiscating all the legally owned firearms in an extremely misguided and probably illegal effort to quell the violent outbreak of anarchy.

      Private citizens were stripped of their ability to protect themselves by the very people who admitted they were unable to protect anyone. And since it's been very popular to blame racism for everything else that's gone poorly in NOLA, it appears that the local government doesn't think poor black folk can be trusted with guns.

    6. Re:My Mossberg emergency item... by composer777 · · Score: 4, Insightful
      In short, it never ceases to amaze me how humanity devolves during disasters and make a bad situation even worse.

      The devolution and degradation of humanity happened long before the riots. It started several hundred years ago when the first slave was taken to America. That's not an excuse for the violence that was inflicted on Reginald Denny, but we should look in the mirror at our own savage behavior, that happens every day when we ignore poverty in our own country, before pointing at the relatively brief amount of "savage" behavior that happens during riots. Quite a bit of their anger is righteous.

      There are still pockets of slavery in the South today and the racist tradition is alive and well. Sure, technically they're free, but poverty and social roles still enforces behavior that is very similar in functionality to slavery. My Mom was raised by a black woman. I met her a few times, and she still lives on property owned by my Mom's family (as far as I know, I try not to think of the situation). When I was growing up, my mom referred to her as grandma any time she would speak of her. She was paid a weekly stipend and lived in servant's quarters. My grandparents weren't rich, certainly not well-off enough to pay someone a decent wage. But, this type of arrangement was common, because after slavery was abolished, many black people fell into familiar roles of servant and laborer, and never managed to climb out of them. She is still alive, and while technically free, the woman has never owned anything of any significance in her entire life. I grew up in Missouri (my mom's family lives in Georgia), far enough away from the south to gain perspective on how strange the situation was, and only met her twice (my Mom was estranged from her family a large part of my childhood), but I can't help but think that this strange situation is a common thing. When she talks to anyone white, she calls them Mr. or Ms., to this day. I saw her 3 years ago at my grandfather's funeral, and I was 28, and she was around 90, and she referred to me as Mr. Jon! What year are we in?

      So, it's pretty easy (for me) to understand the anger that black people feel, in light of the fact that there are still some who are living the life of modern day slaves. Note that this isn't the kind of legacy that people talk about, and I would like to believe that only having visited my Mom's family in GA twice in my 31 years absolves me of responsibility, but does it? How exactly do I pay her for what she has lost, 90 years of lost opportunity?

      This is part of the problem, is that racism is an embarrassing legacy for whites, so it often is not talked about. This is the first time I've written about this part of my family legacy, and I hesitated, even though I am pseudo-anonymous, but stories like these need to be told more often, so that people understand what is really going on. It's similar to the story of the teenage girl that is raped and has an abortion. As compelling of a case as it makes for abortion, the story is not told, often because people are embarrassed and ashamed. So, the injustice remains hidden.

  3. That's revolutionary! by garcia · · Score: 5, Funny

    After thirty seconds of cranking I'm usually asleep for thirty-five minutes!

    Sorry, I couldn't resist ;)

  4. TV on Radio by minus_273 · · Score: 4, Informative

    As anyone who has lived in the 3rd world can tell you, you can pick up TV on ordinary FM radios it is a matter of tuning it to the right frequency. I have seen these things in Asia for years.

    --
    The war with islam is a war on the beast
    The war on terror is a war for peace
    1. Re:TV on Radio by Phreakiture · · Score: 5, Informative

      As anyone who has lived in the 3rd world can tell you, you can pick up TV on ordinary FM radios it is a matter of tuning it to the right frequency. I have seen these things in Asia for years.

      This is 100% dependent on the frequency structure in the country in which you are located. To do this with an "ordinary" FM radio in the US, you can only pick up channel 6, at 87.75MHz (with 87.7 being close enough). If you have one of the Japanese radios that has extended coverage to do both the Japanese 72-93MHz FM and the American/European 88-108MHz FM bands, then you can also get audio from US TV stations on channels 4 (75.75MHz) and 5 (81.75MHz).

      There are other radios out there that have got TV audio capability on them. They frequently only cover channels 2-13 because it is easier to build a VHF than a UHF radio.

      For reference, the frequencies are as follows:

      Channels 2-6: 59.75, 65.75, 75.75, 81.75, 87.75 (note the gap betwen 3 and 4 is 10MHz, not 6MHz as elsewhere)

      Channels 7-13: 179.75, 185.75, 191.75, 197.75, 203.75, 209.75, 215.75

      Channels 14-69: 475.75, 481.75, 487.75, etc, every six MHz up to 805.75

      Note also that frequencies within any vacant TV channels in the channel 14-20 range (470-512MHz) may also be licenced to business or public safety two-way radio users, especially in larger metro areas.

      Last note, which I am providing to explain the huge gap between frequencies: the structure of a TV channel is this: It is 6MHz wide. The audio is 5.75MHz from the bottom of the channel, and uses the upper .5MHz of the channel (that is, 5.75MHz +/- .25MHz). The video is at 1.25MHz from the bottom of the channel to 5.5MHz from the bottom of the channel. Below the 1.25MHz point is cruft called a Vestigial Side Band. For example, on channel 2, 54.00-55.25 is cruft, 55.25 is the video carrier, 55.25 to 59.5 is video, 59.5 to 60.0 is audio, 59.75 is the audio carrier.

      --
      www.wavefront-av.com
  5. Of course! by CorruptMayor · · Score: 4, Funny

    Compact Power Systems also introduced a product called the iRecharge, a rechargeable portable battery that fits snugly around your iPod, iPod mini or iPod shuffle giving the iPod and iPod mini 12 hours of extra play time and the iPod shuffle 40 extra hours.

    I mean, in an emergency, I want my iPod recharged!

  6. Anyone? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Anyone have a hand-crankable EMP?

  7. Limited Usefulness Lifespan by smbarbour · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The $50 radio that picks up TV audio will be useless when the mandatory switch to digital OTA broadcasts occurs. (Unless something interesting will be broadcast on those frequencies after that point.)

    1. Re:Limited Usefulness Lifespan by Chairboy · · Score: 5, Funny

      Breaking news: Some of the other emergency supplies you purchase (food, medicine, batteries) may also become unusable sometime in the future because of a limited shelflife.

      Because of this, I recommend holding off on purchases of emergency supplies until a few days before the emergency happens, that way freshness and technological protocol compliance can be assured. Alternately, don't schedule any emergencies until after a digital television compliant emergency radio is available for purchase.

      (PS, the radio also picks up... radio.)

  8. Emergency by pete-classic · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If you're charging your iPod you aren't having a fucking emergency.

    A radio could be quite useful, but not nearly as useful as a couple of cases of bottled water.

    -Peter

  9. Judging by recent events by katana · · Score: 5, Insightful

    A hand-cranked device that could produce 3-5 days of food and water would probably be popular.

  10. The least problem by salzbrot · · Score: 5, Funny

    [...]these gadgets could be rendered useless 'should the communications infrastructure itself go down.'

    If you can no longer get shortwave signals on your radio because the communications infrastructure itself went down, listening to the latest news is the least of your problems. You should be looking for the stone ax and the closest cave to move into.

    1. Re:The least problem by Hoi+Polloi · · Score: 4, Funny

      If it got that bad I'd also suggest getting yourself a bright red mohawk, some leather biker gear, and then forming a gang of post-apocalyptic outlaws.

      --
      It is by the juice of the coffee bean that thoughts acquire speed, the teeth acquire stains. The stains become a warning
  11. Baylis generator = no batteries at all by jakedata · · Score: 5, Informative

    I have been using my original Freeplay radio for about 8 years now.

    Unlike the more recent models, it operates on a spring driven generator for about 45 minutes, or in sunlight. It has no internal batteries at all.

    The lack of batteries is a Very Good Thing. Rechargable batteries die, and sometimes they short out. If so, you got no radio - cranked or solar.

    The downside is that the radio is the size of a loaf of bread. The upside is that it has a very large speaker and very nice sound.

    I toyed with the idea of adding an external power tap, but there are dire warnings about opening it up and releasing the giant spring. Someday perhaps...

    1. Re:Baylis generator = no batteries at all by stefanlasiewski · · Score: 5, Informative

      Freeplay still makes an AM/FM/SW1/SW2 windup & solar powered (no battery) radio, but it's mostly intended for rural African communities. But you can buy one and donate a second radio for the Freeplay Foundation.

      It's the size of a loaf of bread, and it's ugly, but it's not really aimed for American gageteers.

      --
      "Can of worms? The can is open... the worms are everywhere."
  12. Does it get cable? by jnadke · · Score: 4, Funny

    Sweet, now I can listen to the Playboy channel when the Apocalypse comes. Nothin better than a little porn to calm those nerves.

  13. iRecharge? by brunes69 · · Score: 4, Funny

    Compact Power Systems also introduced a product called the iRecharge, a rechargeable portable battery that fits snugly around your iPod, iPod mini or iPod shuffle giving the iPod and iPod mini 12 hours of extra play time and the iPod shuffle 40 extra hours. It has an on/off switch, so you can charge your iPod as needed, as well as a charge-level indicator that glows to tell you how much juice is left.

    My house is destroyed, I have no food and water, but thank god I can still listen to U2 - Vertigo!

  14. sounds like me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    I can get 35 minutes of pleasure from a 30 second crank.

  15. Only of limited use anyway by tgd · · Score: 4, Insightful

    While there may be value to hearing whats going on in an emergency, I'd be able to actually call for help should I need it.

    A technicians-class FCC license is very easy to get, and small handheld tranceivers are not very expensive.

    Thats MUCH more useful in an emergency than a TV. I can hear the weater broadcasts, radio, and emergency bands and much more usefully, I can actually transmit.

    1. Re:Only of limited use anyway by __aamcgs2220 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Amen! Luckily for non-hams, most hams are thoughtful enough to help their neighbors in an emergency and not just themselves. The more hams we have, the better off we would be in an emergency. It's not that expensive, and it doesn't take that much time to do. Contact the ARRL for more information on how to get your license. Handheld 2m/73cm radios can be bought very inexpensively in many places. Brands include Icom, Yaesu, Kenwood, Radio Shack, Alinco, ADI, and others. Check out eBay, lots of inexpensive radios and batteries to be bought there.

  16. Re: Mossberg also offers the caveat... by Alex+P+Keaton+in+da · · Score: 4, Interesting

    That is why I have a CB with sideband. Even if everything else goes down, I can still talk to others who have CBs and find out some info. I can broadcast and receive from my truck. I always keep one of my fuel tanks on my truck full, and don't usually let the other go below half.
    Also, shortwave is always a good bet. And finding a way to listen the Hams is always good, even when you aren't in an emergency.

    --
    And All I Ask is a Tall Ship And a Star to Steer Her By
  17. Review? by Shadow+Wrought · · Score: 4, Insightful

    They review two crank radios and then extra battery cells for your cell phone and iPod? How 'bout an actual review of several hand crank radios. At the local Radio Shack they had three different ones, as does Sharper Image and other stores. Just because it says "Wall Street Journal" doesn't mean its useful.

    --
    If brevity is the soul of wit, then how does one explain Twitter?
  18. Multiband radios by stefanlasiewski · · Score: 4, Informative
    Look around for other reviews of the Eton FR300 (Formally Grundig). While many people like the features, this radio is NOT as reliable as the legendary Grundig FR200. Go find one and play with it-- many pieces feel like they will snap off after a couple uses.

    It's a cheap gizmo for the beach or a day outing, not a sturdy radio for emergencies. Of course, an iPod charger isn't exactly an "Emergency Device" either.

    What I'm really looking looking for:
    • Power: Radio Hand-crank power, Solar power, DC or AC input, LED light, replacable batteries
    • Receives most available radio frequencies: AM, FM, audio for VHF TV (Channels 2-6) & VHF TV (Channels 7-13), audio for UHF TV, NOAA Weather Band and Shortwave.


    There are several radios which use which have some of this feature set, but it seems like there is a market for a radio which has all of these features.

    To be truthful, I want a pony.
    --
    "Can of worms? The can is open... the worms are everywhere."
  19. cheaper, better hand-cranked radios by Yrrebnarg · · Score: 5, Informative

    Take a look at http://www.radios4you.com/ or http://www.kaitousa.com/ and invest in a radio that also does shortwave if you're looking for an emergency radio. For far less than the $50 you'd spend on the yuppie crud in TFA, you can pick up a solar/crank/charger model and a decent antenna reel, which would let you pick up broadcasts from europe, cuba, the USA, the caribbean (BBC news), or just about anywhere else. All you lose is _local_ broadcasts when the communication infrastructure takes a nose-dive.

  20. "Hummer" flashlight by b1t+r0t · · Score: 4, Informative
    The Hummer branding of it may be a bit cheesy, but the Hummer Shake Flashlight that you can get at Sharper Image works great. 20 years ago my mom got a flashlight which ran with a squeeze grip geared into a toy motor. Last year we got a couple of these and it is so much better.

    First of all, it's a linear generator, so each time the weight inside crosses the center it makes power; second, it uses an LED which is much lower power than old incandescent bulbs; and third, it has a supercapacitor which can power the LED for a few minutes with 30 seconds of shaking. Just be sure to shake it horizontally, as the instructions warn that you might break it if the weight hits an end too hard on a vertical downstroke.

    The best part is you never have to worry about the batteries running down or leaking when you don't use it, and you never have to avoid using regularly for fear of running the batteries down. It has a power switch, so you can shake it up and use it as needed, then just shake it again when it runs down.

    Slashdot readers would be recommended to get the "red" model, as that is translucent and you can see the guts of it operating, for higher geek value.

    --

    --
    "Open source is good." - Steve Jobs
    "Open source is evil." - Microsoft