Slashdot Mirror


Top 20 Geek Novels

Malacca writes "The Guardian's computer editor Jack Schofield has posted a list of the Top 20 Geek Novels in English since 1932. The polling method is unscientific, but it throws up some interesting choices. Definitions of 'Geek Novels' aside, the usual suspects like Neal Stephenson and William Gibson feature, but Terry Pratchett's 'The Colour of Magic' at #9? Neil Gaiman's "American Gods" at #17?" What would you put on that list?

21 of 563 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Hitchiker's guide to the galaxy series for sure by Catskul · · Score: 2, Informative

    RTFA... its freeking #1 on the list.

    --

    Im not here now... Im out KILLING pepperoni
  2. Re:"I, Robot" not a novel by hobbitofthenorth · · Score: 2, Informative

    I was thinking the same thing. The movie is actually closer to "Caves Of Steel" by Asimov. (i.e. murder, detective, robot etc. etc. etc.)

  3. Brunner's Shockwave Rider by Russ+Nelson · · Score: 2, Informative

    Brunner's Shockwave Rider should be there, as should be the Adolescence of P-1.
    -russ

    --
    Don't piss off The Angry Economist
  4. Good Omens by ZahrGnosis · · Score: 4, Informative

    I'm glad someone mentioned "Good Omens". For anyone who has heard of Neil Gaiman OR Terry Pratchett and hasn't read this book: you're really missing something. It happens that my favorite author for a while was Pratchett, and a good friend of mine was into Gaiman... we recommended the book to each other with serendipitous timing, and it's been a favorite ever since. Highly recommended.

  5. What about "The Adolescence of P-1" by P1 · · Score: 2, Informative

    Great 70's book on a computer program taking over. Worth a read.

  6. Re:The Colour of Magic is a weird choice... by hotzeyboy · · Score: 5, Informative

    While I love all the discworld books, "Going Postal" would definately be the one that I think belongs on this list. It even has a bunch of hackers named the GNU(which is still a recursive acronym), talks about packet space and involves a very low tech spoofing exploit.
    .

  7. 1984 and H2G2, but no Sirens of Titan? by photon317 · · Score: 3, Informative


    I think they polled a not-so-well read segment of the geek population. Anyone who loved 1984 and H2G2 (which made spots 2 and 1 on the list) should have also read Vonnegut's The Sirens of Titan. It fills the space inbetween those two seemingly disconnected books we love so much; in many ways it is the literary bridge from 1984 to H2G2, and one of the greatest works of modern fiction on its own. A fan of either (or both) would see the connections readily, and appreciate it, and it certainly belongs in that list with them.

    --
    11*43+456^2
  8. Re:"I, Robot" not a novel by harlows_monkeys · · Score: 2, Informative
    I, Robot, is the title of the collection of short stories that included the novella "I, Robot" which is long enough to qualify as a novel.

    Actually, there was no story named "I, Robot" in "I, Robot". The stories in "I, Robot" were:

    • Robbie
    • Runaround
    • Reason
    • Catch that Rabbit
    • Liar!
    • Little Lost Robot
    • Escape!
    • Evidence
    • The Evitable Conflict

    There is a story named "I, Robot", but it is not an Asimov story. It was written by Eando Binder and published in 1939.

  9. Re:Start Neal Stephenson by Mathinker · · Score: 3, Informative

    "Bruce Schneier invented a crypto system based on playing cards for the novel."

    Ah, yes, Solitaire. Not that I really believe you're going to use it, but FYI, it's broken.

    It's not by chance, either. Paul Crowley, the guy who broke Solitaire, also tried to invent a strong manual encryption algorithm and failed.

    Not that I'm in the league of those guys, but I've been working on the problem myself and it's not easy.

  10. Re:What's with this "geek" stuff? by erinacht · · Score: 3, Informative

    Boffin

    "The word appeared during World War II, where it was applied with some affection to the people who invented radar, early digital computers, the atomic bomb, and other technologies that gave the Allies an advantage over the Axis during the war."
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boffin

    I've always prefered and will continue to use Boffin. It's a good word that encapsulates all the good of geek and nerd, is a bit more academic. It also has none of the baggage, except perhaps for absent mindedness.

    --
    Colm

  11. Re:What?! No J.R.R?!?! by mike2R · · Score: 2, Informative

    More to the point, he invented five languages as a hobby, and then wrote a book to go with them.

    Definately a geek...

    --
    This sig all sigs devours
  12. The Forever War by GeekDork · · Score: 2, Informative

    The Forever War by Joe Haldeman is a must-read, IMO. It raises some points about war that hold true even on today's tiny scale (who started it? why is it still going on? what the hell are we fighting for?)

    --

    Fight hunger. Filet a politician and send him to a 3rd world country of your choice.

    1. Re:The Forever War by squarooticus · · Score: 2, Informative

      SPOILERS.

      Most of the book was fine, but the end was ridiculous. I mean, an interstellar war starting due to a "misunderstanding"? Please.

      --
      [ home ]
  13. Re:What about Tolkien? by CheechBG · · Score: 2, Informative

    Ahem, not quite. It's Christopher Plummer, and the original quote goes something like this...

    "You have not heard Shakespeare until you have read it in the original Klingon!"

    Guess who's coming to dinner...

  14. Re:Show some love for Arthur by MichaelSmith · · Score: 3, Informative
    I Have heard rumours that he is a pederast, and moved to Sri Lanka to avoid possible prosecution. Is that true?

    He is fairly open about being gay. He won a court case against the british newspaper which made the pedophilia allegations against him.

  15. Re:The Colour of Magic is a weird choice... by TheRaven64 · · Score: 4, Informative
    I think my favourite geeky touch was the cryptographical engine whose acronym was E.N.I.G.M.A. (also not spelt out, and also only spotted on the second reading). The geek references have always been there though. In The Colour of Magic (I believe, possible The Light Fantastic) there is a druid talking about people wanting to upgrade to the latest 33 Megalith stone circles - published when a 486 DX 33 was top of the range.

    Another geeky author I can recommend is Jasper Fforde. The Well of Lost Plots, the penultimate book in the series that started with The Well of Lost Plots would appeal to many Slashdot readers (read the earlier ones first though) dealing, as it does, with the topic of DRM. Set in the book world, the world inside fiction, Thusday Next, litterary detective, discovers that the next version of the book OS (an upgrade from the old 8-plot system to a new, improved, 32-plot system with all sorts of extra features) contains a system which prevents a book from being read more than three times. It's full of references to classic literature and more geeky references (a large number of comments about old versions of the book OS, for example, held for old versions of MS DOS). A good read for anyone, and the book to use to explain DRM to your less technically inclined friends.

    --
    I am TheRaven on Soylent News
  16. Re:Enders Game by zerocool^ · · Score: 2, Informative


    To quote my wife, who has read them all (ender's game, speaker for the dead, xenocide, children of the mind, ender's shadow, shadow of the hegemon, shadow puppets, as well as Songmaster, the call of earth, and probably more - she reads alot):

    "Orson Scott Card is an author who can't write a sequel to save his life."

    ~Will

    --
    sig?
  17. Re:What about Tolkien? by meringuoid · · Score: 2, Informative
    The real trick would be to read it in old entish...

    Interesting. If I remember correctly, the first words of the book were There was Eru. Now, Fangorn tells us that in Old Entish any name is actually in itself the story of what it names. He himself, as perhaps the oldest living thing in Middle-earth (AFAIK only Bombadil, the Maiar and maybe Cirdan are of the same kind of age) has a truly spectacular name that would take days to read in full.

    Now, given Entish naming conventions, what would the name of Eru Iluvatar be like? It seems to me that the Entish name of Eru would in fact be a complete history of Creation, including the entire Silmarillion, because the whole thing is part of Iluvatar's story. It would, then, certainly take several weeks just to read the first page - but you'd be finished after word number three.

    --
    Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
  18. Re:Before there were geeks by Jivecat · · Score: 2, Informative

    RTFA: since 1932. Hence, no Verne either.

    --
    "For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled."--Feynman
  19. LSpace by rjstanford · · Score: 2, Informative

    And if you like pTerry, but you're pretty sure you're not getting all of the jokes (or, better yet, if you actually think you are), you have to check out LSpace (ie: Library Space) and read the annotations. Woefully out of date, they're worth spending a couple of hours on in no uncertain terms.

    --
    You're special forces then? That's great! I just love your olympics!
  20. Re:1984 is not a geek novel by Eli+Gottlieb · · Score: 2, Informative

    Apparently you read it in school. Please reread (especially "The Theory and Practice of Oligarchical Collectivism", which is the author talking directly to us) and learn more than the schools want you to know.