Slashdot Mirror


Apple Enters Media Center Domain

An anonymous reader writes "CNN has a story up describing Apple's new media center concept. The software takes on a classic Apple approach: simplicity. 'The program, called Front Row, lets you listen to music, watch videos, play DVDs and display photos from a distance with a few clicks of a lighter-sized, six-button remote control.'" More details available from ThinkSecret.

55 of 241 comments (clear)

  1. Or.... by daeley · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This isn't precisely a secret, however, and hasn't been for the months since it was introduced. :)

    http://www.apple.com/imac/frontrow.html

    --
    I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate.
    1. Re:Or.... by Fahrvergnuugen · · Score: 5, Informative

      The news is in the second link... the article on thinksecrets.com

      Basically the news is that Apple will be letting users stream purchased content from .mac iDisk drives - including full length movies.

      I still can't decide if this is a good idea or not... this model has its advantages, but it most certainly has its disadvantages as well.

      --
      Kiteboarding Gear Mention slashdot and get 10% off!
    2. Re:Or.... by John+Harrison · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I've been proclaiming for weeks that the big announcement the day the iPod with video came out was not the iPod but was that Apple is going to start doing media center stuff. Nobody listened to me. It surprises me how long it has taken people figure this out. Watch a new mac mini come out with Front Row on it that can keep up on the frame rates for HDTV output. People would love something like that in their media centers.

    3. Re:Or.... by Golias · · Score: 5, Informative

      The hype is in the second link... the rumor on thinksecrets.com

      Basically the speculation is that Apple might be letting users stream purchased content from .mac iDisk drives - including full length movies.


      Fixed. :)

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    4. Re:Or.... by timeOday · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Frontrow might be a nice program, but a software package alone is clearly not enough. If these applications (music, pictures, movies) make it into the livingroom, it won't be on an iMac, but integrated with the TV and stereo. The question is, what content distribution network, and what end-user hardware, will make an application like frontrow successful?

    5. Re:Or.... by TinyManCan · · Score: 3, Interesting
      You speak the truth here. As long as the Mini can drive an HD set @ 1080i through a DVI _AND_ component out, I will be happy. Unfortunately I got bit by the HD bug a bit early and bought a mitsubishi HD set before DVI was commonplace. I only have component inputs for HD. Well, and FireWire, but I am not too sure how well that would work for this use.

      If Apple gets a mini out with those specs, I'll be first in line. I've bought several of today's minis, and would not bother buying one to use as a HTPC if it has the right horsepower and connectivity.

    6. Re:Or.... by he-sk · · Score: 3, Informative

      Let's see, my iBook is my stereo (hooked to the receiver and i don't have a cd deck or anything else) and i don't own a tv.

      So front row is all i need for my living room media center thing. And a bigger screen. Those apple cinema screens look nice. :)

      --
      Free Manning, jail Obama.
    7. Re:Or.... by Jozer99 · · Score: 3, Funny

      Thats because everybody else got sick of saying it 6 months before that. Sorry to be rude, but look at the archvives of thinksecret. Every 5th story is something about how Apple is going to kill MCE, or merge with some other media company (TiVo, XM, Sirus, ect...)

    8. Re:Or.... by Tony+Hoyle · · Score: 2, Interesting

      My standard DVD player already does Music, Pictures & Movies.

      OTOH A mac Mini with a decent sized fast hard drive, HDMI, and the right shape for a living room ('lunchbox' doesn't really fit in) sounds cool... provided it has Tivo functionality of course.

    9. Re:Or.... by JazzCrazed · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Hopefully Intel will give the Mini a real good boost, then - or some magic has to be done with the tuner, because the current solution for an Apple-based PVR timeshifting 1080i HDTV requires no less than a dual G5 (click requirements on right side).

      I wouldn't even dream of using one of today's Minis as an HDTV PVR. I got so frustrated with mine that I sold it.

      Not to mention that unless the Mini does real-time compression it'd probably run out of disk space real fast with its 2.5" drives that currently max out at 100GB - at least, for anybody who records a lot (at 8GB/hr. for uncompressed - that is MPEG-2 - 1080i, that's at most 12 hours of recording time before something needs to be compressed, and MPEG-4 compression on today's Mac Minis is, IMHO, HORRENDOUS - it took mine 16 hours to compress MPEG-2 to H.264 MPEG-4 for a 2 hour movie - and that was at DVD res, not 1080i).

      But who knows... Maybe Intel will make this bottom-rung Mac more powerful than some of the top PowerMacs out now. And I'm speculating like the rest anyway, so I hope you had your salt shakers with you while you read this comment. ;)

    10. Re:Or.... by Captain+Splendid · · Score: 2, Interesting
      I still can't decide if this is a good idea or not

      It's not. Having to switch from Front Row to iTunes to do any purchasing is going to be a deal breaker for a lot of people IMO. If the whole thing could be done while sitting back and holding a sleek remote, they'd have a winner, but making the user actually have to physically move around and switch back and forth between interfaces, just to perform what could be a seamless process, is stupid.

      --
      Linux, you magnificent bastard, I read the fucking manual!
    11. Re:Or.... by Golias · · Score: 2, Informative

      Hopefully Intel will give the Mini a real good boost, then - or some magic has to be done with the tuner, because the current solution for an Apple-based PVR timeshifting 1080i HDTV requires no less than a dual G5 (click requirements on right side).

      I wouldn't even dream of using one of today's Minis as an HDTV PVR. I got so frustrated with mine that I sold it.


      You must not have used enough RAM.

      In spite of what the EyeTV box specs say, I used a Mac mini 1.42 as an HDTV PVR from the month that they came out, and it worked like a champ.

      The only reasons I finally upgraded to a G5 tower (just a couple weeks ago) were 1: Decompressing large H264 files on the fly without frame drops, and 2: Better performance when playing games like World of Warcraft.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    12. Re:Or.... by Golias · · Score: 2

      I actually swapped a smaller drive into it (60GB) because i wanted a 7200 RPM drive. I put the old 80 GB into a little USB2 case, which worked out nicely.

      I wasn't compressing anything at all until recently. Compression was too slow and yielded a very poor image quality on HDTV systems. My PVR recordings were the full HD stream, and my DVD rips on the file server were straight full-size rips.

      H264 has changed that a little bit, but also finally provoked me to move up to a faster system this month. I got a hell of a deal on a refurb dual-G5. Handbrake compresses disks to 60% H264 in only slightly more time that it takes to play them.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

  2. Installing Frontrow on any system by Digital+Pizza · · Score: 5, Informative

    There's a utility called "Frontrow Enabler" that will allow you to install FrontRow on any Mac, not just the iMac G5. The utility and instructions are here. You need Pacifist and the latest FrontRow Update from Apple.

    --
    We apologize for the inconvenience.
  3. Not a Media Center by bookemdano63 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "Front Row doesn't display live TV"
    That is pretty limited functionality. So, why would you hook this up to your TV?

    1. Re:Not a Media Center by 99BottlesOfBeerInMyF · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "Front Row doesn't display live TV" That is pretty limited functionality. So, why would you hook this up to your TV?

      TVs already display live TV. The idea is that this can be a replacement for your DVD player and CD player. It lets you easily play music, movies, and TV shows and other video you buy online. I think they are hoping to basically do an end run around the cable and satellite companies. Instead of subscribing to cable, you just buy the shows you want rather than a subscription to a bunch of shows you don't want and a few you do. The main drawback is the cost per show (which seems high). The main advantage is it lets you have a permanent copy and see it whenever you want, instead of on a fixed schedule.

    2. Re:Not a Media Center by lakin · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Most TV's can already handle live TV ;)

      --
      Paul
    3. Re:Not a Media Center by pilgrim23 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I found a far more more elegant solution. My "media" Mac is a G4 dual 867 MDD (wind tunnel) with 3 200gb drives and 2 more external 200gb firewire drives. It lives in the library (with my main work Mac: a Dual 1.8 G5. In the living room near the television, sharing space with the VCR, DVD, Laserdisc, and (since I am old old school) Betamax machines is a little silver box called an EyeHome

      This magic thing is connected to a router (though it also works on a Airport Extreme or other wireless solution) and via Ethernet pumps avi mp4 and other formatted files to my television. It also handles digital optical sound and mp3s. My stereo system can rock to Weird Al or my collection of Dr Demento shows... Pictures can also be displayed and if you are all thumbs, Web surfing is available. It works with 10.3.9 and above (10.2.8 if you are creative) and oh yes, it works from a remote.

      --
      - Minutus cantorum, minutus balorum, minutus carborata descendum pantorum.
    4. Re:Not a Media Center by thatguywhoiam · · Score: 5, Insightful
      TVs already display live TV. The idea is that this can be a replacement for your DVD player and CD player. It lets you easily play music, movies, and TV shows and other video you buy online. I think they are hoping to basically do an end run around the cable and satellite companies. Instead of subscribing to cable, you just buy the shows you want rather than a subscription to a bunch of shows you don't want and a few you do. The main drawback is the cost per show (which seems high). The main advantage is it lets you have a permanent copy and see it whenever you want, instead of on a fixed schedule.

      I think you've hit it on the head. Front Row is going to be a really big deal.

      And a big reason I think this is because of Steve Jobs - let's recap what we know about him, aside from his famous temper:

      - does NOT agree that television and computers will have 'convergence' in the way it is usually described; he thinks more of a co-habitation if you will, with the computer as the ultimate master to all other media slave devices
      - HATES the entrenched media companies (Yes. See: Disney negotiations, major music label negotiations)
      - wants control over the entire user experience
      - is infamous for finding 'end-run' solutions as you put it to sticky delivery problems (or more recently, bailing/sabotaging if it doesn't work, see: ugly dysfunctional iTunes-capable Motorola phone)

      And its been so obvious for old Apple watchers like myself, the pieces have been marshaling for a long time. Right back to the ratification of the QuickTime container for the MPEG-4 spec at NAB, moving through the entire evolution of iTunes and the iTMS. They've got the hardware that everyone thinks is cool; they've got the premiere online model for selling digital content (not even a web page! in their own 'browser', iTunes!); they've got an ancient, highly respected and super-capable media container format; they've got a Disney-level brand. Only thing I think they are missing right now are the video-capable Airport Express and some (admittedly tricky) content deals.

      They could totally kick ass with this thing if they execute well, but its a very weird situation, since the main competition for Living Room Celestial Jukebox are game consoles from Microsoft and Sony. Those are game machines, and Front Row is not, but all these projects have the LRCJ as a major design goal.

      --
      If Jesus wants me it knows where to find me.
    5. Re:Not a Media Center by Reaperducer · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I found a far more more elegant solution.

      Cool. You have my attention. My "media" Mac is a G4 dual 867 MDD (wind tunnel) with 3 200gb drives and 2 more external 200gb firewire drives. It lives in the library (with my main work Mac: a Dual 1.8 G5. In the living room near the television, sharing space with the VCR, DVD, Laserdisc, and (since I am old old school) Betamax machines is a little silver box called an EyeHome

      This magic thing is connected to a router (though it also works on a Airport Extreme or other wireless solution) and via Ethernet pumps avi mp4 and other formatted files to my television. It also handles digital optical sound and mp3s. My stereo system can rock to Weird Al or my collection of Dr Demento shows... Pictures can also be displayed and if you are all thumbs, Web surfing is available. It works with 10.3.9 and above (10.2.8 if you are creative) and oh yes, it works from a remote.


      Still waiting for the "elegant" part.

      --
      -- I'm old enough to have lived through six different meanings of the word "hacker."
  4. Re:About time by mustafap · · Score: 4, Insightful

    >One thing that bugs me is the fact that you're stuck with their display

    I think the Mac Mini demonstrates a willingness to abandon single source on displays. Good thing too, IMHO

    --
    Open Source Drum Kit, LPLC deve board - mjhdesigns.com
  5. Six-button remote control by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

    Five of buttons change the color of media center unit and one is for the mouse click.

  6. read the link! by Chowser · · Score: 5, Informative

    Read the link to the article at Thinksecret. It's more than about Frontrow. The short paragraph linking to the article doesn't really describe it well. Really quite interesting about storage on iDisk and such.

    --
    sig here
    1. Re:read the link! by Golias · · Score: 4, Informative

      In other words, they linked to a story about Front Row to make it seem like news, then linked to a RUMOR about Apple's streaming video plans to make it seem like the media streaming is the news.

      Hence, "Apple Enters Media Center Doman" is a story about a product which has been out for months, with a link to wild speculation about What It All Means.

      Without the redundant link to a useless Front Row review to make the headline kinda-sorta factual, you would be left with the far-less interesting story, "Another Rumor Going Around About Mac Media Centers."

      Lame.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    2. Re:read the link! by vought · · Score: 3, Informative

      Not gonna happen for most users, and that's the way Apple like it I'm sure - every time they replace their machine they need to buy all their music again. Hurray for DRM.

      Every time I think that the completely uninformed Apple-bashing posts have gone away, someone like this pops up like an annoying ad.

      Macs come with neat software that lets you hook old and new machines together via FireWire and migrate all your old stuff over with a couple of clicks.

      Macs have done this for a long time, actually. It's called FireWire disk mode. The migration software is pretty new - I think it was introduced quietly a couple of years ago - but Apple knows that most of their customers are upgrading from one Mac to another and designed this feature to make that task easier.

      What's more, every time you purchase music from iTunes, you get a reminder to Back Your Shit Up(TM). Unfortunately, Apple can't do this for you yet - people do still need to take the initiative and be responsible for preserving the stuff they paid money for.

    3. Re:read the link! by vought · · Score: 2, Informative

      Your itunes purchase is authorized to the machine you bought it on. You cannot copy it to another machine.. that's the whole *purpose* of DRM.

      God damn. Are you being intentionally obtuse?

      Your itunes songs work on up to five CPUs...any of which can be deauthorized from any machine running iTunes.

      Please, PLEASE try and do a little research before spouting ignorance. Yes, the files are DRMed. No, it's not the fucking end of the world odious DRM. In fact, it's pretty damned fair as far as I'm concerned. I have four machines, and they can all play the songs I bought from iTunes. If I buy a new computer, I can deauthorize one of the four authorized ones and authorize the new CPU all by myself.

      You really believed that Apple would make you rebuy all your music when you get a new machine? Geez.

    4. Re:read the link! by aduzik · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Or if you own a Mac and your HD fails, they're even polite about it. The person I talked to (emailed, actually) did give the usual finger-wagging lecture about backing up your stuff, but said, something to the effect of "given the circumstances, it seems appropriate that we let you download all your music again." I think they really didn't care that much since at that time I'd bought exactly one album.

      --
      If it's not one thing it's your mother.
  7. If you will forgive a little whining... by Golias · · Score: 3, Funny

    "Apple Releases Front Row Media Software" is a news story. (Or, at the very least, a slashvertizement worth reading.)

    "Somebody From CNN Write About Apple's Front Row Media Software, Which Was Released About A Month Ago" is the sort of submission that MacSlash and other "what Steve Jobs had for breakfast today is thrilling news to us" sites would probably reject.

    I'd rather read a badly-written review of Front Row by some random slashbot (or a link to some techie-site review, like Ars) than another "OMG! Apple Matters So Much That CNN Is Writing About Their Software" submission. Come on, editors. You can do better.

    --

    Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    1. Re:If you will forgive a little whining... by kerry-buckley · · Score: 2, Funny
      Come on, editors. You can do better.
      Recent experience would appear to indicate otherwise.
  8. Trade Mark by Bloater · · Score: 3, Informative

    > The program, called Front Row, lets you listen to

    I think NTL might have something to say about this name in the UK. Their pseudo-VoD system over cable is called Front Row.

  9. A Good Idea by et764 · · Score: 3, Insightful

    So apparently this is a dupe, but it's the first I've seen of it, so I found it interesting. I looked at the picture of the remote here and I think I like it. Just the other day I was looking at one of those remotes that come with digital cable boxes these days, and there were way too many buttons there. To make matters worse, almost every remote these days has just about as many buttons, but they are generally organized differently, making it harder to switch TV's. How often do people visiting a friend's house have to ask their friend to do something like change the volume, because the remote is overly complicated? I like the idea of a remote with just a couple of buttons.

  10. Oh, no! by __aaclcg7560 · · Score: 3, Interesting

    I hope this isn't supposed to be the surprise announcement for the MacWorld Expo in January. A friend of mine said the leading rumor is that Steve Jobs will introduce the Intel-based laptops six months before they were supposed to come out. I'm delaying my Mac laptop purchase to see if that rumor is true.

  11. six buttons? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    "a few clicks of a lighter-sized, six-button remote control."

    shouldn't it just have 1 button?

  12. Re:Old News? by sgant · · Score: 4, Funny

    In other news, Apple is rumored to be working on an operating system that is based on BSD Unix and will have a user-friendly UI attached to it.

    They are also thinking of getting into the music arena, possibly with portable MP3 players, but analysts say this is just crazy.

    --

    "Leo Fender was in a 'state of grace' when he designed the Stratocaster." -- Paul Reed Smith
  13. Re:Stupid Publicity by remove+office · · Score: 2, Interesting

    actually... what TFA is talking about is a new version of frontrow (2.0) which will be introduced in january along with a new media center edition mac mini (complete with ipod dock built in, possible tivo functionality etc).

    it also looks like they're prepping lots of new content from several new cable networks and other sources. i wouldn't be surprised if pixar started making exclusive shorts for the itms (itunes music, er, media store)...

  14. Personally I would not buy it.... by WTBF · · Score: 4, Interesting

    For a media centre it does not seem to have very many features, even if it is meant to be simple.

    Here is what I use on my MythTV box that are not available for this:
    - Watching live TV
    - Scheduling recording of live TV
    - Web interface to access information
    - Weather
    - Games
    - News feeds
    - Advert detection

    These are all things I use on a daily basis and I think that they should be included in any media centre, and Apple's offering barely meets any of those.

    1. Re:Personally I would not buy it.... by NotoriousQ · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Add to that:
      - Ripping CDs from the menu interface, and adding it to your collection
      - Doing the same with DVDs

      I am willing to bet that Apple will never accomplish the second one.

      My summary of Front Row vs. Mythtv:
      Front Row looks good, but has ass functionality. Mythtv has good functionality, but looks like ass.

      --
      badness 10000
  15. not what I'd hoped by GKevK · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I RTFA... and I'm disappointed. If this is going to depend on programs being cached on iDisk, then why do I need a new Mac Mini at all? Lots of the speculation was that the new mini might get a tv tuner card and lots more storage, to give it DVR functionality etc. How is this different from a website that just streams you video? Media center... yeah right. I'll keep my TiVos.

  16. Re:About time by 99BottlesOfBeerInMyF · · Score: 2, Informative

    One thing that bugs me is the fact that you're stuck with their display.

    So hacksaw it off already. It supports a second display (mirrored). Or you could just wait till they release the new towers and minis and buy one of them and a display of your choice.

  17. for all you dumbasses who didn't read TFA... by remove+office · · Score: 2, Interesting

    actually... what TFA is talking about is a new version of frontrow (2.0) which will be introduced in january along with a new media center edition mac mini (complete with ipod dock built in, possible tivo functionality etc). it also looks like they're prepping lots of new content from several new cable networks and other sources. i wouldn't be surprised if pixar started making exclusive shorts for the itms (itunes music, er, media store)...

  18. Lighter sized remote? by Mashdar · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Hell, I can't find a standard sized remote 1/5 of the time I want it. Does the idea of a tiny remote scare anyone else? A couch has 10^5 times the number of places for one of these bad boys to hide.

    Perhaps Apple will plan ahead and assume the user will lose the remote and put a god damned set of directional arrows on the unit itself. It seems like once a month I encounter a remoteless DVD player with no means of navigation on the main unit. When the first option on the DVD menu is not play it turns into a hell of a time.

  19. Clarity by 99BottlesOfBeerInMyF · · Score: 3, Informative

    Just to clarify this submission for people... it contains two, unrelated links. The first is a CNN article about FrontRow and is old news. The second is speculation on a rumor site about the new version of the mac mini and how Apple will tie in a new video service that is largely inferior to what they are offering now, via iTunes, and that will not work with the new iPods video capabilities. The whole thing sounds rather suspect to me.

  20. Xbox by Nightspirit · · Score: 2, Insightful

    For a "media center", my modded xbox with xbox media center (the open source software, not the MS one) does all this and more, and cost significantly less than a mac mini.

    1. Re:Xbox by jeffy210 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      There is a *big* problem with having an Xbox for a media center... it's puny processor can't handle WMV-HD (or Divx-HD for that matter). yes it has component out and can output a 720p or 1080i stream but it chokes hard on a 700Mhz processor. That's the biggest reason I never considered it. Now the 360 on the other hand... (Also, I want a DVI out instead of just component)

      --
      ------
      "And may your days be long upon the earth."
    2. Re:Xbox by kollivier · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Apple's target audience isn't a group of people who like modding their computer/console hardware. They're selling to people who don't particularly want to mod their stuff, or pay to have it modded.

      Besides, the real value of Apple's solution isn't Front Row itself; the value in Apple's solution lies in their downloadable content. If they can offer affordable movies and TV programs, a new Mac mini would pay for itself in 1-2 years when I can buy the shows I want to watch ala carte rather than paying for cable. I'd be using the computer too, of course, so it would more than pay for itself. The sucky part about TiVo, the XBox MC, MythTV, etc. is that they require setup time and/or subscription fees to work, so unless you watch a LOT of TV (or enjoy the challenge) the boxes just aren't worth the money and/or effort involved. If Apple can bring a buy-as-you-go solution that anyone can use and bundle it with an affordable computer to boot, they'll bring the media center concept to a whole new market of casual buyers/watchers.

  21. six buttons? by cancerward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Six buttons is too many for an Apple object! I suggest just one button, and the remote can
    have a motion detector in it; the user can hold the remote parallel to the appropriate
    face of a cube, and click the button. Simplicity itself!

  22. HUGE announcement from Think Secret by yardbird · · Score: 2, Funny
    WIth the roll-out of the new Mac mini, which sources continue to maintain will be bigger than anyone can imagine...
    So what are we talking about? The Mac Maxi?
    --
    Free, legal music for iTunes users.
    1. Re:HUGE announcement from Think Secret by ta+ma+de · · Score: 2, Funny

      I will buy a mac maxi ASAP, so that my house can evolve into the Mac Maxi Pad it was always intended to be.

  23. At Microsoft Headquarters ... by ta+ma+de · · Score: 3, Funny

    The employees create beowolf clusters with mac mini media centers. The Soviets do it too, but no one cares.

  24. MicroSoft? by putko · · Score: 2, Funny

    I bet MS is kinda scared about this. At this stage in the game, I think there are a lot of satisfied Apple customers who'd love to bring an 'iPod' quality media device into their living room.

    I don't think MicroSoft has built up this sort of goodwill.

    In fact, I saw on TV -- "The Apprentice", where they has MicroSoft on the show. Trump said to them, "I use a lot of MicroSoft, and it works." As if that was news.

    Not "it works fanTASTIcally!" -- but just a limp-sounding "it works."

    Given how much Trump exaggerates, it automatically downgraded his statement to, "on good days it kinda works," -- basically, if something is half-assed, Trump says it is the best thing ever. So I think MicroSoft has a customer-perception problem.

    --
    http://www.thebricktestament.com/the_law/when_to_s tone_your_children/dt21_18a.html
  25. Their MP3 player won't be any good. by ThreeDayMonk · · Score: 4, Funny

    They are also thinking of getting into the music arena, possibly with portable MP3 players, but analysts say this is just crazy.

    I hear that it will have lower capacity than its competitors, and lack wireless. As that's lame, no one will buy it.

    --
    If your comment title says 'Re: Foo', I'm not likely to read it.
  26. Re:About time by SmittyTheBold · · Score: 2, Funny

    I refuse to purchase any machine with the display married to the computer...I love their PowerBooks

    I know it's not really what you meant, but technically...

    --
    ± 29 dB
  27. Re:What a yawn-fest by NoMaster · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Rightly or wrongly, the computer world has been drooling for the convergence of the PC and the loungeroom. So far, that's been a pipe dream - really, it seems the majority of people just don't feel the need for a PC that links into their entertainment systems like that. Which is why stand-alone devices, up to and including TiVo, have worked - while other things, like WinXP MCE, have pretty much been duds.

    Given Apple's track record, their understanding of markets, and their ability to package a whole product which does what it claims to in a simple, useful, and aesthetically pleasing way, this would have a better chance than most previous attempts at being _the_ breakthough device they've been looking for.

    What you denigrate as "cute packaging" - nice box, nice interface, etc - is essentially the only thing the people pushing for this kind of convergence have to offer.

    Which is not to say I agree - despite having a PC permanently in the lounge room, hooked up up to my TV & digital PVR, I really can't see the point. The "converged PC" is a solution to a problem that exists only in the minds of marketers and the wet dreams of futurists - not in the minds of the market itself.

    --
    What part of "a well regulated militia" do you not understand?
  28. I'd buy it.. by tomcres · · Score: 3, Informative
    I don't care one lick about HD, but...

    If Apple put out a mini that came with Front Row and included the remote, I'd buy it in a heartbeat. It would replace my DVD player and I'd get an EyeTV and replace my TiVo as well. I was actually thinking of buying a mini for precisely this purpose, but I'm hesitant to do it without a decent remote control and portal (i.e., Front Row). The beauty of the mini is it's a sub-$600 computer with no frills and takes up next to no space. If they married it to Front Row, they'd easily steal the entry-level (which is, honestly, where average Joe Consumer is) from Windows Media Center, which last I checked, required a behemoth $1000+ PC and is not as simple as FrontRow.

  29. display options by mbaudis · · Score: 2, Interesting

    1. imacs can mirror to another display (vga; dvi only with vga=>dvi box)
    2. screen spanning doctor http://www.rutemoeller.com/mp/ibook/ibook_e.html enables , well, screen spanning on imacs and ibooks
    3. dvd player can be set to disable the other display while playing movies
    4. front row patches have been available for a while, so you can run it on most newer macs. a guy even has put a mac mini in his (off all cars) f150, complete with front row etc: http://www.leftlanenews.com/?p=818

    i personally use a mac mini without display, controlled via VNC (built into OS X 10.4) and a sanyo plv-z2.