Slashdot Mirror


Indoctrinating The Young As Gamers

Gamers with Jobs has an interesting look at what it's like to indoctrinate the next generation of gamer. From the article: "Now, as I stumble through my fourth decade on this spinning marble in space, it is my great privilege to pass this obsession on to my own son. It is something of a shock to me that my years of gaming can be measured reasonably in terms of percentage of a century. I shudder to think how many productive hours and how much money I have sacrificed to my passion. Instead of dwelling on that point, I pretend that the question doesn't even exist, in much the same way that I occasionally like to pretend the mortgage doesn't exist when a desired game finds its way onto store shelves. And now, already, my own son has begun his own epic sacrifice to the pastime, so that someday he too can struggle in the decision between food and maintaining his subscription to World of Warcraft."

42 comments

  1. Hmmmm by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 4, Interesting
    You know, I was thinking about this the other day and realized that I don't think of this as wasting my time and money (well...especially since I haven't paid for any media of any sort since Napster was born). Gaming and media in general has become such an integral part of society that I consider it to be an essential part of my everyday life. Communication is becoming more and more vital to us, as is entertainment. Now yes, you have your old forms of entertainment....but these are just new forms. And if people don't consider old forms of entertainment to be wastes, I don't know why they would consider these new ones to be.

    Besides, its snowing like crazy now, its 20 degrees outside, what the hell else am I going to do?

    --
    Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    1. Re:Hmmmm by Seumas · · Score: 1

      Besides, its snowing like crazy now, its 20 degrees outside, what the hell else am I going to do?

      Well, it has been about -6 here in Broomfield the last few days. I thought playing a board game or some cards would be fun. Unfortunately of the two people I live with, one was busy chatting on AIM and playing around the crapfest that is MySpace and the other was busy playing a videogame.

    2. Re:Hmmmm by amrust · · Score: 1
      The wife and I were just talking the other day, about maybe buying the board game Life... it's been forever since either of us played it. Sounds like it could be fun to mess with over the winter. We have Backgammon, but she hates it.

      Board games are cool. Or at least, I think they were.

      --
      VOTE!
    3. Re:Hmmmm by Meagermanx · · Score: 2, Funny

      Life? Isn't that like Monopoly but with little pegs you can stick in your car?
      Right.
      You're better off with a strategic board game, like Chess, Checkers, Go, or something like that.

    4. Re:Hmmmm by amrust · · Score: 1

      Yeah, it's semi-childish. But that's the point. Just something fun to relive the old days. We have Monopoly, we break that out occasionally. We may pick up Life, then pass it on to her niece.

      Besides, didn't Life have some way to "choose your destiny" or something? That sounds kinda fun.

      --
      VOTE!
    5. Re:Hmmmm by drsquare · · Score: 1

      Besides, its snowing like crazy now, its 20 degrees outside, what the hell else am I going to do?

      Play football?

      Seriously though, we don't need another generation of kids growing up in front of the computer getting fat and pale. Obesity's at its highest level in history, we should be condemning slothful activities in favour of more beneficial activities.

      Get him playing sport instead. He'll be healthier, he'll concentrate better at his schoolwork, he'll develop more social skills.

      If he wants to play computer games then fine, if he wants to buy games with his own money then let him, but don't indoctrinate him into it.

    6. Re:Hmmmm by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Now yes, you have your old forms of entertainment....but these are just new forms. And if people don't consider old forms of entertainment to be wastes, I don't know why they would consider these new ones to be.

      I'm inclined to agree. But on the other hand, some people take gaming so seriously, you would hardly think that games were meant to be entertainment.

      "This may be just a game to them now, but it will not be a game for them later. In war, they will only face miserable defeat and gruesome deaths."

      -- North Korean review of the X-Box game 'Ghost Recon 2'

    7. Re:Hmmmm by sdhankin · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Classic mistake: life isn't an either/or game. My son is an avid gamer and D&D (PnP) player. He's 13, and been doing this for at least 6 years. His favorite TV shows are Xplay and various anime shows. He loves reading fantasy books. He'll play video games or do D&D (as GM - he likes designing the scenarios for others more than playing) as much as we let him. So, of course, we impose limits.

      He's also an A+ student in a very competitive school system, in advanced classes where they're available. He practices cello 30 minutes a day, and is an accomplished soccer player. He's tall and lean and fit, and has been the fastest in his class in the mile run several times.

      I'm not going to claim that his playing video games has improved his problem solving skills or other similar claims (though he's often better than I am at some of these); it's a hobby he enjoys.

      It's all about balance.

    8. Re:Hmmmm by steveo777 · · Score: 1
      well...especially since I haven't paid for any media of any sort since Napster was born

      Besides, its snowing like crazy now, its 20 degrees outside, what the hell else am I going to do?

      I don't care how much you think you're getting screwed out of your money, buy some of the shit you use and complain about DRM and RIAA with the rest of us. And since you can't play outside, maybe you should get off your ass and find a way to generate some income. I'm assuming your hands work well enough to do data entry... or stuffing envelopes, so get to it! Hmmm...? Too young for a job? Go play in the snow like normal kids do. I'm 25 and that's still one of my favorite forms of entertainment. Finds some kids in the park and start a snowball war!

      Back when I was young my parents only let us bust out the Commadore 64 if and only if it was too dangerous to play outside (like, temp below absolute zero, those windchills, I tell ya). For those of you who were in MN for the Halloween blizzard of 92 (or was it 91..), I was outside building tunnles and bunkers with the neighborhood kids.

      Wait a second, "Back when I was young..."?!! I am getting old...

      --
      This sig isn't original enough, it's time to come up with something witty...
    9. Re:Hmmmm by Meagermanx · · Score: 1

      Sir, it sounds like you haven't played Life in a while.
      I suspect you will soon find that spinning a spinner and moving the token accordingly gets old about two rounds into the game.

      I understand wanting to relive the old days, or whatever you old codgers are always rambling on about, but why not go for something from Cheapass games?
      They're cheap, they're original, and you're not paying $14.95 for a copy of Life.
      Or how about The Sims? That has destiny-choosing too.

      Come on, man. I'm only trying to save you from yourself.

    10. Re:Hmmmm by amrust · · Score: 1
      Sounds like you haven't been married in awhile. This was all HER idea, you know. And we're prolly not as old as you'd think. Sure, we both graduated HS when Guns 'N Roses was still making music, but still. ;)

      I'd much rather play some backgammon, or use one of the 2 chess sets we own, but whatever. We have Scrabble, and Yahtzee. Yahtzee is fun, maybe we'll break that out. But I like the site you mentioned. I'm considering a few now. As a matter of fact, 'Get Out' looks like it might be cool. And 'Mana Burn' maybe.

      Thanks for the link.

      --
      VOTE!
    11. Re:Hmmmm by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 1
      Well, while I do think I'm getting screwed out of SOME of my money, I'm not exactly claiming I'm innocent and justified in what I do. But I do it anyway. If that pisses you off then so be it.

      And for the record, even though I'm a recent college grad, I'm fairly successful, so that is not the main reason. I just feel like it, and most of the time it is the most convenient way for me to get these things.

      Especially for music since what I listen to (mostly full electronic DJ sets) is not purchaseable.

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
    12. Re:Hmmmm by steveo777 · · Score: 1
      Especially for music since what I listen to (motly full electronic DJ sets) is not purchaseable

      I'm with you there. A good deal of my music is very hard to find or import (or too expensive). But, given the oppurunity, I'll usually purchase it in one form or another (I don't buy songs off iTunes or other sites, I want the full quality CD tracks).

      What pisses me off is people that don't buy any of their music (and in college, when Napster came out, in a week I went from a fast connection to borrowing my parents' dial-up account because of all the bastards hogging bandwith... napster was finally blocked about 6-8 months in, but it didn't help as there were a bunch of students with off-site proxys). But that's a matter of principles. I'm not concerned if random successful band X gets my money, they won't notice a few thousand people downloading a few songs, but they will notice when one guy buys their music and gives it to a few thousand people, over and over. Bands on smaller labels don't see a lot of money. A lot of the time these guys' talent is off the charts when compared with mainstream music or even the Paul Van Dykes and Crystal Methods.

      That's my take.

      --
      This sig isn't original enough, it's time to come up with something witty...
    13. Re:Hmmmm by FlipFlopSnowMan · · Score: 1

      I think most of the reason that people are downloading music so rapidly is that artists quit making a great ALBUM and started concentrating on making good SINGLES. The download industry will (hopefully) kill pop music and leave room for bands who legitimately work at what they do. If you love a band, you buy the album and listen to the other songs. If you like one song 'cause it's catchy or whatever, there is no reason to purchase the album which kills bad albums. Survival of the fittest. Darwinism in the music industry.

    14. Re:Hmmmm by cobras2 · · Score: 1

      >Get him playing sport instead. He'll be healthier, he'll concentrate better at his schoolwork, he'll develop more social skills.

      That's err... totally debatable. How is it healthier if you keep getting a broken bone every couple of days, and end up having to retire at thirty because you've got so many aches and pains?

      >If he wants to play computer games then fine, if he wants to buy games with his own money then let him, but don't indoctrinate him into it.

      Quite. But, same goes for football.. I think there's been plenty of people already who made thei kids play football or soccer or baseball or wrestling or whatever, when the kid never wanted to.

      Besides.. it's not like you can't play computer *and* play some kind of sports - even if you're only playing the sport in order to exercise. Which is probably better for you than playing it professionaly anyway.

      --
      Early bird may get the worm.. but the second mouse gets the cheese.
  2. Aww by pnevin · · Score: 5, Funny

    In no time at all, he'll be bagging your favourite childhood games as being unplayable crap.

    Kids grow up so fast these days, don't they?

    1. Re:Aww by rf0 · · Score: 1

      This is why I refuse to go back and play those games I've got happy memeories of as a kid on the Spectrum. I used to love Jet Pac but being older now I can't help but things i would just look back at it and think how dull or boring it is as I've changed (prehaps for the worse in some cases)

      I'd much rather just keep the memories

  3. Yeah, if you don't... by Luigi30 · · Score: 2, Funny

    ...je'll act like this

    --
    503 Sig Unavailable

    The Signature could not be accessed. Please try again later or contact the administrator
  4. Having fun is *NOT* evil by Dark_Link2135 · · Score: 0, Insightful

    Ok, seriously - why do people treat gaming as some sort of an addiction in most all cases? Anything can become an addiction if it is taken to unhealthy or unproductive levels. Everyone *NEEDS* entertainment. Having fun isn't some sort of sin, unless you are neglecting family/work and other responsibilities. In that case, it *is* an uncontrollable addiction. You can't spend every hour of your life exclusively focusing on just your work/family. Just a thought I had when i caught this article. People think, and even gamers themselves think there is something wrong with them for enjoying video games - but this is no different than someone whose favorite pasttime is playing piano, or watching movies, or playing chess. It's a different form of entertainment, and like all entertainment *CAN* be taken to unhealthy levels - but in most cases it is not.

    --
    "Potpourii doesn't taste as good as it smells." - Dark_Link2135
  5. Goddamit son. by sharopolis · · Score: 5, Funny

    Daddy can I got outside and play? No! You'll stay in the house and play videogames! Why can't you spend all day cooped up in your room like normal kids?

  6. Time issues? by hackwrench · · Score: 1

    I don't get the whole "I'm getting old thing" and I don't think it's just because I'm 29, though I suppose it does help that I watch anime shows like Tenchi Muyo! and Crest of the Stars that have people that are chronologically old but physically young. Oh and watching Doctor Who growing up didn't hurt either.

    1. Re:Time issues? by superpulpsicle · · Score: 1

      I am positive if I "ever" reach 90 years old, I'll still be playing video games. And if I do any traveling, I'll bring at least a handheld system.

  7. it's not indoctrination by inu_maru · · Score: 1

    It's called spending "quality time".

    --
    Mu
    1. Re:it's not indoctrination by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's called spending "quality time".
      You can forget the "quality" bit. This is Slashdot; we don't understand how those words fit together. No one understands you.

      I'd rather:
      It's called spending "time-showing-my-kids-how-adults-waste-even-more-t ime-posting-on-Slashdot-than-playing-their-games-e ver-did".
      You see, "quality" never comes into it. ;-)

  8. My Son and Games by under_score · · Score: 5, Interesting

    We're homeschooling. Educational games play a part of that. We have games from the "Reader Rabbit" series as well as a few other one-offs such as "Physicus" which is a cool physics simulator/tutorial/game and "Rosetta Stone" for Arabic and Chinese. However, much as he doesn't mind these, they are not what gets him really interested. He's been a Civ player for over a year... and he's only seven and a half. Right now he loves CivIV. He is starting to learn the difference between strategy and tactics, learning about planning, and of course, learning some things about history from the game itself. However, we have found that we need to put tight limits on his time playing. Currently, he plays CivIV only on weekends, and only in the time he has available when we're not doing other things (visiting, groceries, etc.). We have had some struggles with obsessive game-playing and we are trying to moderate that, but given that I myself go through periods of intense game playing (and so does my wife), we have to balance that with our own example. When we first got CivIV, we didn't do much else except eat for about three days... I truly hope that this is not a problem. I haven't seen anything conclusive about this and we do have a balance with visiting, regular academic work, and my son is an avid reader as well. I'm not worried, but like with television or other forms of entertainment, I don't think that children are able to set their own boundaries very well. It's important as parents to do that both verbally and by example. For those interested, my wife keeps an extensive web site about homeschooling and some other things.

  9. Burnout Revenge? by Gogo0 · · Score: 2, Funny

    What kind of father is this guy?

    When the fruit of my loins is unleashed upon the world, I am ready to raise him properly.
    That means starting him out with Donkey Kong, Pac-Man, Burgertime, and all the classics. He will move up to the NES, SNES, Genesis, and along up the generations as he gets older. Of course, Number Muncher and other classic educational games will be on tap, too.
    Start a kid off with current-gen stuff will only produce another graphics-obsessed drone that will shun anything that isnt 3D and is too soft to handle the occasional hard game that is released by brave studios (FZeroGX, Ninja Gaiden, etc).

    Off-topic:
    And when he isnt playing the classics, he will be watching Transformers, Thundercats, the original TMNT, and all the other great cartoons that were on when I was a kid. It worries me that kids are growing up these days watching YuGiOh GX and other drivel CN and the other networks are putting out. Sleep in on saturday, kids. We can watch some cartoons on DVD when you get up.

    1. Re:Burnout Revenge? by ezratrumpet · · Score: 1

      You forget the Root of Roots, the Game of Games, the Big Bang of the Gaming Universe, the day that the Great Gamer looked down into geekdom and said....."Let there be....PONG."

    2. Re:Burnout Revenge? by Gogo0 · · Score: 1

      If only I had it =[

      Even though I dont have Pong, the kid will grow up in a way that he can see it or something like it and consider that he may have fun playing it. I would bet that any kid starting with Burnout Revenge would rather wash dishes than try Pong.

    3. Re:Burnout Revenge? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      go and get the transformers or thundercats dvds now. i guarantee that they are unbearble.

      be sure to get the transformers movie also. beware of dancing australian garbage bots...

    4. Re:Burnout Revenge? by Gogo0 · · Score: 1

      They arent that bad, and stuff like TMNT is actually pretty good barring the sometimes mixed up voices and occasional silly episode.
      And while they may not be all that perfect, theyre still a ton better than what is on tv now. Also, I enjoyed them when I was a kid, so chances are my kid will enjoy them too =]

    5. Re:Burnout Revenge? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I assure you, it really is that bad. I was surprised when I saw the DVDs. You should go get Beast Wars or Gargoyles instead.

    6. Re:Burnout Revenge? by heinousjay · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Maybe there's something you don't realize about children - they have no taste at all. Pretty much everything kids are into, be it food, movies, music, or whatever, is sheer crap.

      The worst part? This holds true for you, too. All those things you remember as awesome from your childhood are just as crappy as what's out there now. Even worse, actually, because the production values are better today.

      --
      Slashdot - where whining about luck is the new way to make the world you want.
    7. Re:Burnout Revenge? by Joe123456 · · Score: 0

      Also have him play pinball to as well and some of the old dos games.

    8. Re:Burnout Revenge? by GospelHead821 · · Score: 1

      Which is it? Do children have no taste or do they only like crap (poor taste?) I'd argue you were correct in stating that children have no taste. They'll latch on to anything billed as entertainment. I agree, looking back at my own childhood, I watched a lot of terrible programs. On the other hand, having watched episodes of Darkwing Duck and Gargoyles as an adult, I still find them enjoyable and worthwhile.

      --
      Virtue finds and chooses the mean.
      Aristotle, Ethica Nichomachea
    9. Re:Burnout Revenge? by hal2814 · · Score: 1

      My daughter is starting to get to the age where she is taking an interest in video games. DK, Pac, and Burget Time are all good games, but so is Super Monkey Ball. Monkey ball is her favorite game and Ms. Pac is a close second. Interestingly enough, she's not a fan of Marble Madness (which goes hand-in-hand with Monkey Ball in my book). Instead of forcing your kid to follow the same path you did as a kid, why not let them choose their own games (as long as they are appropriate for kids)? I think you'll be surprised at how much kids pay attention to gameplay. I've noticed that a lot of kids today are not impressed so much by graphics and 3D capabilities. Such things have been ubiquitous in their lifetime.

      I think this next generation of gamers is going to be a good lot because the run of the mill graphics upgrades will cease to impress them. Sex and violence (which is filling in for graphics to some extent nowadays in a lot of games) can only go so far. Sometime in my childrens' lifetimes, game developers will have to conectrate on gameplay again because that will be all that's left.

      You're looking back at the greatness of yesteryear while ignoring a lot of the crap. Have you seen the Thunderats recently? I LOVED that show as a kid, but watching episodes now I can see that it's a pretty poorly made show with a thin plot and an awful lot of preaching (usually while the character is staring straight at the viewer). There are some shows I refuse to watch now because of what it would do to my image of them ("Benji, Zax and the Alien Prince," "He-Man," "Captain N," etc).

    10. Re:Burnout Revenge? by sesshomaru · · Score: 1
      Preaching, oh, I know what you mean:

      Ancient spirits of evil, transform this decaying form, to MUMM-RA, THE EVERLIVING! mulrhahaha!

      Yeah, he was kind of preachy.

      --
      "MIT betrayed all of its basic principles."
    11. Re:Burnout Revenge? by hal2814 · · Score: 1

      Actually, I was thinking of the "lessons" they beat over your head. Like when something is stolen and Tigra looks right and the camera and says something along the lines of "And STEALING is wrong." It happens a lot and I never really noticed it as a kid.

    12. Re:Burnout Revenge? by ezratrumpet · · Score: 1

      True enough - it's like going back to playing Dune on an old 486 after Starcraft, or Warcraft, or a hundred other games. However - there's also a sense of classicism in playing Pong (or Pac-Man, or whatever), even on a emulator of some kind. I wonder if a hundred years from now, young hackers will have to learn to create a version of Pong (or whatever) in almost the same way literature students read Antigone, or Jack London, or John Steinbeck. The point is NOT that it's the greatest Literature (or Game) of the Modern Era; the point is that the Modern Era is rooted in its past, and that past, be it Pong or 'Of Mice and Men,' is worth remembering and reliving to some extent.

  10. "Too?" by Guppy06 · · Score: 2, Insightful

    "so that someday he too can struggle in the decision between food and maintaining his subscription to World of Warcraft."

    "Too?" As in you think about whether to buy food or WoW? And you have a son to feed?

    Look, we get enough flak from Jack Thompson types as it is, why don't you do us all a favor and call child services now before your face is plastered on TV news.

    1. Re:"Too?" by Fried-Psitalon · · Score: 1

      I have to admit that this stunned me as well. I'm a gamer - heck, I've even managed to make a pretty good second living consulting for a game company - but I don't have to battle between that and FOOD. I don't even have to battle between that and my girlfriend. REAL LIFE COMES FIRST. That's the lesson gamers (myself included) need to pass on to their children. Love your hobbies. Love your passions... and don't let them overcome you. Everything in life in moderation; gaming isn't anything special. It's the newest, greatest thing. Get exercise and your back, wrists and eyes won't hurt when you game for a long time. Spend time with the spouse and he/she'll surprise you with food/drink/backrubs while you're at the keys. Work hard at your job and you'll make friends and get promotions that allow you to live more comfortably and have a better machine(s) to game on. A mature, intelligent gamer should pass on that lesson to their child - like any hobby, it is best enjoyed when you know everything that SHOULD be taken care of already IS.

      --
      The ability to communicate well does not directly correspond to the ability to communicate intelligently.
  11. Humour. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Humour.

  12. As the father of an another gaming 4 year old . . by Rowan_u · · Score: 1

    Elijah is four years old; his computer sits directly in-between mama and papa's computer in the living room. He games for 2-3 hours every day; his favorites being Novadex Rocket, MoonBase Commander, Incredible Machine, Homeworld 2, Don Pachi (Mame), Takumi Fighters, Unreal 2k4, and Google image search + Photoshop. Elijah's gaming habits were definitely something we thought long and hard over, but eventually we decided to give him access to almost everything we play and do on computers. Keeping him from playing things like Unreal Tournament (gibs off) is going to hurt him more in the long run, by virtue of him feeling left out of what his papa and mama are doing. I remember being horribly scared as a kid, by not being allowed to play Starflight 2, and I don't want to pass that kind of thing on to Elijah. I knew I was smart enough to play Starflight, and so does Elijah. We even include him (for a couple hours) in LAN parties, so he gets an idea of the social aspects of gaming.

    I think the most important thing you can do with raising kids into a gaming world, is make sure you're participating with them. Both through multiplayer and simply by being in the same room with them and seeing the kind of experience they're getting from the game. I'd much rather have Elijah experiencing an interaction with his PC than watch his brain draining away into the occasional spurts of drivel that air between the commercials on TV. Also important are the interests that he gains through gaming that help him learn about the computer itself. For instance, Unreal Tournament leads to Unreal Editor, which leads to lessons on 3d modeling, textures, and lighting (he now tries to spot CG while watching TV shows.) Or Novadex Rocket, which leads to all kind of interest in the physical world, including the way blocks tumble off each other, or how the human body can move.

    I like how you mention Civ4, as I feel that about the worst thing you can do for your kid is buy them "educational" software, which is often underdeveloped crap. I do work for the Boys and Girls club, so I know all about educational software. We also plan to Home School Elijah when he gets to that age and we are starting early in that respect. Games that are professionally made to be both fun and educational (like civ4) are your best bet. And you'd be surprised what unintentional learning happens even when playing something as non-educational as Unreal Tournament.

    --
    only one everything