Slashdot Mirror


Buzz Aldrin's Roadmap to Mars

FleaPlus writes "Former astronaut (and MIT astronautics grad) Buzz Aldrin has an article in last months Popular Mechanics in which he describes a plan for manned Mars missions. Aldrin's plan proposes using a Cycler spacecraft permanently orbiting between Earth and Mars. This would have a shielded habitat and rotation-induced gravity, and would take just 5 months to reach Mars. Smaller vehicles would take astronauts to and from the Cycler. Aldrin claims the plan is less costly and more sustainable than NASA's current plans."

59 comments

  1. Cheaper? The space industry begs to differ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Buzz's plan may be cheaper than the NASA's current plan, but pass on his plan to NASA and the space industry and they'll inflate the price tag like he cannot believe.

    Still, the Congress might buy it.

    (sorry for a troll...)

  2. MMMMM, orbital donut. by Panascooter · · Score: 5, Funny

    Not only is he an MIT grad with a doctorate, he's got a moon crater named after him, and he has flown into space with Homer Simpson. With credentials like that I don't know how anyone could doubt his wisdom.

    1. Re:MMMMM, orbital donut. by oh_bugger · · Score: 2, Funny

      His last mission was a failure though, he never did find out if ants could be trained to sort tiny screws in space.

      --
      Go home and shave your giant head of smell with your bad self
    2. Re:MMMMM, orbital donut. by Megane · · Score: 1
      and he has flown into space with Homer Simpson.

      Yeah, and so did Inanimate Carbon Rod, who was the star of the mission. You don't hear people saying "In Buzz We Trust", do you?

      --
      #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
  3. Buzz Aldrin by mkavanagh2 · · Score: 1, Funny

    Is fucking better than you.

    This is true.

    1. Re:Buzz Aldrin by jcr · · Score: 2, Funny

      He has a girlfriend at his age? Good for him!

      -jcr

      --
      The only title of honor that a tyrant can grant is "Enemy of the State."
    2. Re:Buzz Aldrin by idkk · · Score: 1

      Girlfriend? Anyone on the FIRST moon landing trip can have anything he d*mn well wants! And good luck to him!

      --
      Ian D. K. Kelly

      idkk Consultancy Ltd.

      "Quality through Thought"

  4. One hell of a guy. by Paperweight · · Score: 5, Informative
    1. Re:One hell of a guy. by Big+Nothing · · Score: 3, Insightful

      "Has this guy lived or what?"

      WARNING: Clicking on the link in parent post is bound to result in severe depression and feelings of inadequacy!

      --
      SIG: TAKE OFF EVERY 'CAPTAIN'!!
    2. Re:One hell of a guy. by Dr.+Eggman · · Score: 1

      Wait, so his mother's maiden {last} name is Moon!? Talk about coincidences

      --
      Demented But Determined.
    3. Re:One hell of a guy. by Elvis+Parsley · · Score: 1

      That bodes well for any children Veronica Mars might have.

    4. Re:One hell of a guy. by 955301 · · Score: 1

      Yeah, he even defended his experiences with a swift left hook. Some conspiracy theorist named Bart Sibrel called him a liar and a coward to his face once and got an appropriate response.

      --
      You are checking your backups, aren't you?
  5. i hereby by Mahou · · Score: 0, Redundant

    i hereby nominate myself to help test this facility when it is done being constructed and time how long it takes to go to mars using this plan

    --
    if i'm not immortal, what's the point of living?
    ...te?
  6. Re:Has the slashcode changed? by interiot · · Score: 4, Informative

    Before this feature, articles like this would simply never appear on the main page unless users configured their homepage to include all articles from the section (in this case "Science"). Now, these non-front-page articles get a small footprint at least.

  7. Research paper on Aldrin's work by FleaPlus · · Score: 4, Informative

    I dug around a little and found the following abstract detailing an older version of Buzz Aldrin's work. Unfortunately, I can't seem to find a free link to the actual paper...

    Evolutionary space transportation plan for Mars cycling concepts
    Aldrin, Buzz; Byrnes, Dennis; Jones, Ron; Davis, Hubert
    AIAA Space 2001 Conference and Exposition

    A promising new human Mars exploration approach based on the use of an Earth-Mars Cycling Interplanetary Transportation System is described. In this approach, a cycling vehicle acts as a permanently emplaced transportation element that continuously cycles between the Earth and Mars using gravity assist with minimal course adjustment on each cycle eliminating the need to repeat the large and expensive injection propellant requirement of traditionally conceived Mars vehicles and missions. With the implementation of a two Cycler system, one Cycler would always be going to Mars while the other is returning to Earth. When in the vicinity of the Earth or Mars, the Cyclers release or are intercepted by smaller aerobraking "taxis" that ferry people and supplies to and from the surface. Alternatively, in the Semi-Cycler Concept, the Cycler vehicles themselves would use aerobraking and gravity assist to orbit about the Earth or Mars for a period before returning. In this way, unmanned cargo flights to Mars could use the minimum energy, long trip time trajectories while crewed flights could use the shorter flight time, longer stay time options. Both concepts are addressed in the paper, and the results of preliminary flight mechanics analyses are presented. In addition, a transportation plan is presented based upon a logical extension of existing space assets augmented by new vehicles providing a reusable transportation capability.


  8. Former? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Once an astronaut, always an astronaut.

  9. So...... by mofomojo · · Score: 2, Funny

    .... when do we get to blow zombies' heads off from Hell?

    Soon, rite?

    >:D

    1. Re:So...... by Elitist_Phoenix · · Score: 1

      Yeah I bet to be able to get the moonraker

      --
      "I'm going to f***ing bury that guy, I have done it before, and I will do it again. I'm going to f***ing kill Google"
  10. Plans... by Elitist_Phoenix · · Score: 4, Funny

    Seems like this guy came out up with his plans only after NASA released theirs. Story of his life, always second.

    --
    "I'm going to f***ing bury that guy, I have done it before, and I will do it again. I'm going to f***ing kill Google"
  11. According to his timeline... by frog23 · · Score: 1

    ... he has already been on the moon (or in that studio for that matter) in 1960. I knew it. They just wanted to trick the commies into that "race to the moon" and at a point where the Russians are so close to really be first, they publish those recordings. What a cover up!

  12. Think Big by MichaelSmith · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Without the ISS there would be no space tourism. You need to have a destination to sell before you get customers. A flight to Mars could be done with something like an extended apollo program, with similar non-reusable hardware, but you can't make money off that.

    If money is not being made the US taxpayers will have to pay for the whole thing and I really can't see that happening in this day and age.

    But wealthy people would pay for a cruise on the continous shuttle system Buzz is proposing. I think it is the right way to go.

    And good on him for punching Bart Sibrel

    1. Re:Think Big by Oldsmobile · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I think NASA should just cut all the manned missions and concentrate on space probes. Much more information for the buck.

      However, I do think going to mars would be worth doing, IF they got smart about it (and yes, I realize they need the ISS for learning how to go to mars, but the ISS isn't designed to be a precursor to a mars mission). The "one way" idea I thought was worth exploring, put some risk into it, that risk might be worth taking. You know, the one where they send one rocket a year with more and more equipment, but no return fuel, only equipment later to manufacture their own return fuel and hopefully a permanent mars base.

      NASA is overly concerned with human life and the propaganda fall out of losing astronauts to be an effective exploration organization. Fireman and racecardrivers take risks in daily life, I'm sure they would find plenty of skilled volunteers for a one way mission.

      --
      Some say he is made with ascii, others that he is eyeballed daily by millions. All we know is, he is known as the Sig
  13. Did anyone else think... by meringuoid · · Score: 1, Offtopic
    ... that this was going to be a sequel to Buzz Aldrin's Race into Space?

    Damn was that game ever hard. The intelligence agencies were bloody useless, as well... I once played a two-player game against myself, running both sides with equal incompetence, and the KGB were assuring me that the Americans were about to orbit a minishuttle - I'd barely even got Gemini spaceworthy :)

    --
    Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    1. Re:Did anyone else think... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Just wondered about this game, how to prolong the session after one has landed on the moon ....

      there are those shiny crafts capable of reaching jupiter without you ever having a chance to use them in this funny unfair game :/

  14. Yes but ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    It only works if we find water on the moon and water on mars. Doesn't that mean this plan is science fiction? Or should billions be invested on a maybe?

    1. Re:Yes but ... by Dr.+Eggman · · Score: 1

      Did the Columbus set out on a 'maybe' we'll find a shorter path to India by going around the other way? Sure, and look what he re-found: An island off a huge uncharted mainland continent chock full of resources and indigenous peoples to exploit!

      --
      Demented But Determined.
    2. Re:Yes but ... by meringuoid · · Score: 1
      It only works if we find water on the moon and water on mars. Doesn't that mean this plan is science fiction? Or should billions be invested on a maybe?

      Clementine indicated that there may be water ice on the moon; however, this was not confirmed by the later impact of Lunar Prospector, so further investigation will be needed. Mars Express indicated that there is very probably water on Mars - in the polar icecaps, and in subsurface permafrost.

      Before constructing a manned infrastructure that relies on these supplies, we'd need to confirm their availability by dedicated robot probe, but there's certainly good reason to think that the water is there.

      --
      Real Daleks don't climb stairs - they level the building.
    3. Re:Yes but ... by Mr.+Slippery · · Score: 2, Insightful
      Did the Columbus set out on a 'maybe' we'll find a shorter path to India by going around the other way?

      Columbus is quite possibly the luckiest fsck-up in history. He completely miscalculated the size of the Earth (never mind that the ancient Greeks had managed to get it right) and would have starved if he hadn't blundered into the Americas. And yet, despite this, and despite not being the first person to "find" this land mass (the American "Indians", the Vikings, and the Chinese all having been there first), despite kidnapping and enslaving natives, he gets remembered as some kind of a hero of exploration.

      We ought to use more genuine heroes for comparison when advocating space exploration.

      --
      Tom Swiss | the infamous tms | my blog
      You cannot wash away blood with blood
    4. Re:Yes but ... by Billosaur · · Score: 2, Informative
      Clementine indicated that there may be water ice on the moon; however, this was not confirmed by the later impact of Lunar Prospector, so further investigation will be needed. Mars Express indicated that there is very probably water on Mars - in the polar icecaps, and in subsurface permafrost.

      And water is one of many simple, universal compounds. Even thought there are no great heaping pools of it on the Moon and Mars, it's bound up by chemical activity in the minerals there. It can be cracked out easily enough through heating. And if a spacecraft uses fuel cells, they'll be able to carry significant quantities of hydrogen and oxygen aboard their ship as propellant, atmosphere, and fuel to produce electricity and water. Water isn't really the biggest challenge; dealing with the radiation that lashes the Martian surface is a bigger challenge.

      --
      GetOuttaMySpace - The Anti-Social Network
    5. Re:Yes but ... by Dr.+Eggman · · Score: 1

      Ok, ok. How about Hotu Matua who lead (according to island legend) the Polynesian people to discover the lush ripe Easter Island. Err, wait no. They also exploited that land. In fact they did so so much they all but killed the ecosystem and near wiped themselves out. Hmm, maybe we'd be better off if we just stayed home... exploration doesn't seem to end well with us.

      --
      Demented But Determined.
    6. Re:Yes but ... by ArsonSmith · · Score: 1

      Nobody seems to have the courage of Columbus any more. In his time he put forth a half thought idea that sailing west he may end up in the east. Sold it got the ships and sailed off on little more than a hope that he was right.

      Today, we can see Mars. We can send probes there. We have it mapped. We calculate that we could get there by doing this, that, and the other, and we sould need $x to do it. Then decided that because we know we could do it there really is no reason.

      That is why Columbus is considered a Hero and the first Mars explorers, while hero's none the less, will get much less noterity. Except perhaps for the Mars colonies once established. Call it stupidity or courage, which ever you like. But with great risk comes great reward.

      --
      Paying taxes to buy civilization is like paying a hooker to buy love.
    7. Re:Yes but ... by Karma+Farmer · · Score: 2, Informative

      Nobody seems to have the courage of Columbus any more. In his time he put forth a half thought idea that sailing west he may end up in the east.

      Well, everyone at the time was pretty much certain world was round, and that if you sailed west far enough you would end up in the east. That wasn't new or revolutionary, it was commonly accepted knowledge.

      The interesting thing Columbus did was convince some brain addled religous zealots to agree with his half-thought maths about the size of the world. There's probably something to be said about a stupid man's spectacular failure being more impressive than a smart man's prudent inaction. There's also something to be said for not starving to death in the middle of the ocean.

    8. Re:Yes but ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "But with great risk comes great reward."

      Do you think so?

      Suiciders would be greatly rewarded, wouldn't they?

  15. Buzz has accomplished 3 things in his life by Ellis+D.+Tripp · · Score: 2, Funny

    that I always wanted to do:

    Fly into space.

    Walk on the Moon.

    Punch Bart Sibrel in the face. :)

    --
    Remember "News for Nerds, Stuff that Matters"? Help make it a reality again! http://soylentnews.org
    1. Re:Buzz has accomplished 3 things in his life by RCSInfo · · Score: 1

      http://www.csicop.org/articles/20021018-aldrin/

      Link to video for anyone who didn't get the above post. Or for anyone who wants to see it again.

  16. Mars belongs to China? by Dr.+Eggman · · Score: 2, Insightful

    This is a dangerous time for NASA. People are getting older there (as if they weren't before) But is the US education system producing enough people to fill the void and meet tomorrow's challenges? Will we make it to mars in less than 18 yrs as many are predicting or will the red planet be claimed by a rising red star?

    --
    Demented But Determined.
    1. Re:Mars belongs to China? by ArsonSmith · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Education is not given it is taken. If someone is smart and able to be the chronic over achiever that is typically hired by the NASA space program you'll be able to get all that is needed out of even the worst education system. Sure an education system may if it's good make a mediocre person better but it wont make a retard smart or if it's bad, a genius dumb. Of course 97% of the people in the US are mediocre and that is why a good school system and education is important.

      --
      Paying taxes to buy civilization is like paying a hooker to buy love.
    2. Re:Mars belongs to China? by ArsonSmith · · Score: 1

      Sorry mister AC, you were just dumb to begin with. But if you find comfort in blaming the school system for your own inadequacies then far be it from me to refuse you that pleasure.

      --
      Paying taxes to buy civilization is like paying a hooker to buy love.
    3. Re:Mars belongs to China? by imperious_rex · · Score: 1

      I honestly don't know about China's future in space. But if the quality of the young people at JPL are an indication, then I feel confidence and pride in our future space exploration capability. The only real limits are financial and political, NOT in talent or imagination. NASA may have its problems, but we can be proud of the fact that NASA has almost single-handedly expanded mankind's knowledge of the solar system to an incalculable degree.

    4. Re:Mars belongs to China? by ChrisGilliard · · Score: 1

      Sure an education system may if it's good make a mediocre person better but it wont make a retard smart or if it's bad, a genius dumb.

      I have to disagree with you on this. There was just a thread on geniuses don't grow in a vaccum. It's very important that we have a good education system. Imagine if we had _NO_ education system whatsoever. We would be a lot like some of the poorer nations in Africa. How many geniuses do you know from Ethiopia? See my point?

      --
      No Sigs!
    5. Re:Mars belongs to China? by ArsonSmith · · Score: 1

      A bad education system is still better than no education system. If you read the article it was about access to information and standing on the shoulders of others. It still showed people who were basically loaners but studied hard and set out to get the information they wanted. Few genius are given the information they need.

      --
      Paying taxes to buy civilization is like paying a hooker to buy love.
  17. Re:Has the slashcode changed? by Megane · · Score: 1

    Yes, they used to say stuff like "17 more" under the section. And then a few weeks ago, it got stuck and Games was on "17 more" for two weeks. Last week they fix it, and now this. It's an interesting change, at least. Under the old way, I would never have seen this article because I wouldn't have bothered to click on the "Science" topic. Mostly because "Science" wasn't in my "Sections" list on the left side of the page.

    --
    #naabhaprzrag, #sverubfr-000, #agi-fcbafberq, negvpyr[pynff*=' negvpyr-ary-'] { qvfcynl: abar !vzcbegnag; }
  18. Read TFA and... by foniksonik · · Score: 3, Interesting

    There seem to be a lot of 'extra' expenses that his plan depends upon.... like a permanent base on the moon, a permanent fuel depot and manufacturing plant on Mars (already in place) not to mention that he calls for two Cycler type ships not one... plus the multiple CEVs to actually realize the goal of sustainability. There's more but I'll let you read it yourself.

    It's a nice plan but do I see a plan that's cheaper? Hell no, If the goal is to GET to Mars.

    If the goal is to create an interplanetary transit system then sure, this is definitely the way to go.

    --
    A fool throws a stone into a well and a thousand sages can not remove it.
  19. Buzz's Sci-Fi Books by The_Doughboy · · Score: 2

    I've always loved Buzz, he actually wrote about this stuff in his Sci-Fi book Encounter With Tiber. In it he also wrote about the "Big Can" method of building the space station, ie. build the Space Station out of the spent fuel tanks. I think he also had space stations at Lagrange points.

  20. Carefull, they're ruffled! by Andy+Gardner · · Score: 1
    Lets hope nobody smuggles a bag of chips aboard.

    Especially ruffled ones!

  21. What's with the parenthetical? by Guppy06 · · Score: 1

    "Former astronaut (and MIT astronautics grad)"

    He's been to the fucking moon!, the second one to set foot on it! Who cares what school he's gone to? I mean, just as a ballpark estimate, I'd say 2-3 orders of magnitude more people have graduated MIT with said degree than ever walked on the moon. What is the submitter, an MIT alumn?

    1. Re:What's with the parenthetical? by FleaPlus · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Who cares what school he's gone to?

      I think it's rather relevant that he has an astronautics doctorate from MIT when the submission is about a plan for spacecraft which exploit interplanetary transport orbits.

  22. Re:Has the slashcode changed? by Damek · · Score: 1

    I would avoid talking about footprints, especially "small" ones, around Buzz Aldrin if I were you...

  23. The Moon: A Ridiculous Liberal Myth by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    It amazes me that so many allegedly "educated" people have fallen so quickly and so hard for a fraudulent fabrication of such laughable proportions. The very idea that a gigantic ball of rock happens to orbit our planet, showing itself in neat, four-week cycles -- with the same side facing us all the time -- is ludicrous. Furthermore, it is an insult to common sense and a damnable affront to intellectual honesty and integrity. That people actually believe it is evidence that the liberals have wrested the last vestiges of control of our public school system from decent, God-fearing Americans (as if any further evidence was needed! Daddy's Roommate? God Almighty!)

    Documentaries such as Enemy of the State have accurately portrayed the elaborate, byzantine network of surveillance satellites that the liberals have sent into space to spy on law-abiding Americans. Equipped with technology developed by Handgun Control, Inc., these satellites have the ability to detect firearms from hundreds of kilometers up. That's right, neighbors .. the next time you're out in the backyard exercising your Second Amendment rights, the liberals will see it! These satellites are sensitive enough to tell the difference between a Colt .45 and a .38 Special! And when they detect you with a firearm, their computers cross-reference the address to figure out your name, and then an enormous database housed at Berkeley is updated with information about you.

    Of course, this all works fine during the day, but what about at night? Even the liberals can't control the rotation of the Earth to prevent nightfall from setting in (only Joshua was able to ask for that particular favor!) That's where the "moon" comes in. Powered by nuclear reactors, the "moon" is nothing more than an enormous balloon, emitting trillions of candlepower of gun-revealing light. Piloted by key members of the liberal community, the "moon" is strategically moved across the country, pointing out those who dare to make use of their God-given rights at night!

    Yes, I know this probably sounds paranoid and preposterous, but consider this. Despite what the revisionist historians tell you, there is no mention of the "moon" anywhere in literature or historical documents -- anywhere -- before 1950. That is when it was initially launched. When President Josef Kennedy, at the State of the Union address, proclaimed "We choose to go to the moon", he may as well have said "We choose to go to the weather balloon." The subsequent faking of a "moon" landing on national TV was the first step in a long history of the erosion of our constitutional rights by leftists in this country. No longer can we hide from our government when the sun goes down.

    1. Re:The Moon: A Ridiculous Liberal Myth by HardCase · · Score: 1

      Well, that certainly puts my mind at rest.

    2. Re:The Moon: A Ridiculous Liberal Myth by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Isn't this a FOX News transcript? Quit plagiarizing!

  24. Mars missions by White+Yeti · · Score: 2, Informative

    I saw this referred to in the Encyclopedia Astronautica (no images). There's also a section that lists the "leading" proposed manned Mars missions.

  25. Not a donut, a potato! by Nambu · · Score: 1
    This sounds familiar...

    The CRIST Sol orbiters, or Cargo and Resources In-System Transports were huge ships shaped like a hollow potato and designed to be able to move huge amounts of material between Earth and Mars with low cost and, theoretically, low maintenance. The system was simple. The CRIST was put into orbit around SOL on the plane of the ecliptic. Built with a powerful solar sail, the CRIST could change its orbit easily to pass by the Earth or Mars. On a flyby, materials could be loaded or offloaded...

    The design of the CRIST was innovative and useful, but it was not low-maintenance... Each time that a CRIST broke down, the result was famine on Mars... ...the coming of a Martian conflict was inevitable.

    (Ironically, the Pfhor invasion pre-empted that massacre with another.)

  26. The biography leaves out a very important detail. by Jerk+City+Troll · · Score: 1

    He also has a little-known career in boxing. Truly an American icon.