Slashdot Mirror


Sore Thumbs and Texting

Ant writes "ABC News reports that text messaging, once seen as a way to send a short message without running up the expense of a cellular telephone/cell phone call, has become so popular that it poses its own public health problem: sore thumbs. This comes from a survey and warning put out by Virgin Mobile, one of the largest cellular service providers in Great Britain. Virgin reports that 93 million text messages are sent every day in the United Kingdom (U.K.). One estimate for the United States (U.S.), whose population is five times as large, is 700 million text messages a year. "

14 of 170 comments (clear)

  1. First litigation? Someone else to blame? by us7892 · · Score: 3, Informative

    Has anyone sued the phone maker, text message service, or anyone else they can think of getting money from? Seems like that's the next story we'll see following all thse people with sore thumbs who need someone other than themselves to blame.

    It's just a poll, actually. So they have sore thumbs...big deal.

  2. What? by hal2814 · · Score: 4, Informative

    "once seen as a way to send a short message without running up the expense of a cellular telephone/cell phone call"

    My text messages cost 10 cents per message. I'd have to talk for over 2 minutes to cost more than a text message and I can sure relay more information in that two minutes than most can in a text message and even get feedback during that time. Text messages have their uses but being cheaper isn't one of them. Besides, I thought the point of text messages was to annoy others trying to watch a movie in a movie theater.

    1. Re:What? by GoddessOfDeath · · Score: 3, Informative

      In New Zealand text messages cost 20 cents, and one minute of calling costs (off peak) 49 cents or (on peak) $1.29. You must live in one of the lucky countries where calling is cheaper than texting. Plus there are many plans which give huge numbers of "free" texts, and not many "free" minutes.

    2. Re:What? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      That's incredible... when I was with T-Mobile USA and using the phone much, I had a $40/month plan that gave 1000 minutes plus free nights/weekends. Add $20/month for unlimited GPRS data (internet). And SMS still cost more per message unless I bought some SMS package. But, since nobody uses them much, I never saw the point. Chicken and egg.

      This is also with no roaming and no long-distance anywhere in the US, for $0.04 per minute. The cost for overages was higher, something like $0.20 per minute as I recall, but the name of the game is to choose the appropriate service tier for your usage and not go over too much. I eventually downgraded my subscription because the next cheaper tier plus overage charges was less on average than the $40/month when I stopped using the mobile for multi-hour conference calls.

      The idea of $1 per minute for voice is what I consider an incredible rip-off even for international roaming, and which leads me to get pre-paid SIMs when I travel overseas. I will note, a pre-paid US SIM costs about $0.35 per minute until you use it a lot and the tarrif changes a little bit in your favor. The post-paid accounts are much more affordable for frequent use, however.

      The other side of this nobody outside the US seems to understand why we pay for incoming air-time. This is because a land-line phone making a "local" call to a cell phone (same area code and exchange numbers) would not be metered and it is the mobile user who pays for the privelege of using the wireless network. Similarly, a long-distance land line call to the mobile number does not get charged more than calling a land line in the same area/exchange. The cost for mobility goes to the mobile user, which seems fair to us.

  3. This just in... by B00yah · · Score: 2, Informative

    waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

    seriously. That's like complaining about your legs hurting after walking 200ft, because you usually just do laps from the fridge to the couch. You can avoid soreness in your thumbs the same way you avoid soreness everywhere else: stretch your muscles (try shadow thumb wrestling), repetition, and don't go till it hurts. You know when you're getting near that point, just stop there.

    IANAPFE (I am not a physical fitness expert), but I do play a lot of video games, A LOT of video games, and between that and the literally hundreds of thousands of characters I type on a daily basis for work, I've learned how to deal with digit soreness.

  4. Umm, did someone forget about... by benjjj · · Score: 2, Informative

    video game controllers? Sorry, but there's no way texting is as rough on the thumbs as bingeing on Gran Turismo. maybe for a few 1337 texters who text a couple hundred wpm, but they need to stop with the "texting = public health crisis" line. there's no way it's true.

  5. Maybe it's just me, but... by RodgerTheGreat · · Score: 2, Informative
    I'm really trying to figure out how "sore thumbs" counts as a "public health problem".

    By my definition, a health problem is something that you need medication or a doctor's appointment for. If your thumbs hurt you, taking a break from texting is all you really need. An alternative would be to try holding the phone in your hand a different way- after all, a repetitive strain injury is a repetitive strain injury.

    --
    I'm a signature virus. Copy me to your signature so I can replicate, and introduce your own mutations so I can evolve.
  6. I personally don't like texting by bobcat7677 · · Score: 2, Informative

    While it certainly has it's uses. It does seem over-used.

    Pros for me:
    -Have my computer send me alerts.
    -Send a quick e-mail to someone from the road.
    -Send a short message to someone discreetly in a location where talking on the phone would be rude/inappropriate.
    -Get a message through to someone when the reception is there but not good enough to have a conversation.

    Cons for me:
    -Almost have driven off the road on various occasions while trying to punch in a message or read a message. Way more dangerous then just talking.
    -Time consuming to communicate the simplist of concepts.
    -Sore thumbs
    -U.S. carrier pricing on text messages makes it not make much sense economically.
    -Additional way of being in-personal in your communication with other human beings.
    -Short messages can be easilly mis-interpreted. Have gotten several people mad at me for no reason just because they took a brief text message the wrong way.

  7. Re:Arghh bad use of statistics by wisdom_brewing · · Score: 3, Informative

    well, 93 million a day. i apologise for being petty.

    texting (sending an sms message) is much more popular in the UK and europe in general than it is in the states, mainly because initially the infrastructure was terrible, a very large proportion of messages were lost when sending abroad or to other networks, this has been resolved but people in general do not have the same sense of trust in the technology as they do in other countries.

    imagine that in your first year of emailing more than half of your emails did not get through. this is looking through the eyes of a consumer, say you sent your first email in '98 and it didnt go through, what would you think of email? you might avoid it for a while, the same seems to have happened with sms in the states.

    i agree entirely with your point as to the misleading figures, its appalling that someone would write that, especially considering the fact that it could be much more dramatic with the US population sending 700 million a year and the uk upwards of 30 BILLION.

    and another point, virgin is nowhere near being a leading UK mobile phone company, the big four are 02, Vodafone, Orange and T-Mobile, with 3 doing a very good job of catching up (3 is an exclusively 3g network, i am not sure who they are owned by).

  8. Who's mind thinks that? by Vellmont · · Score: 2, Informative

    I was able to read those two sentences and know what they meant. "per year" and "per day" are clearly different time period. If you really didn't understand on first read I think you need to slow down a bit, rather than just plowing through the summary and (apparently) reading only every other word. The article is very clear, it's your comprehension that's the problem here.

    --
    AccountKiller
    1. Re:Who's mind thinks that? by prodangle · · Score: 2, Informative
      I'm grateful for the GP post pointing this out. I mis-read the article too. Most people don't read a single word at a time -- the important word year can be easily missed, Just as it's common to skip over over repeated words, such as the the. Whilst the summary is factually correct, it is written in a misleading way.

      For more ways of bending the truth, check out Darrell Huff's How to Lie With Statistics.

  9. This is why I always roll my eyes by Tim+C · · Score: 2, Informative

    everytime I read a comment here bemoaning how many useless features mobile phones have "that nobody use".

    Based on these statistics, people in the UK send roughly 50 times as many text messages each year as people in the US. Factoring in the relative population sizes, on average we send 250 times as many SMSs as you guys do.

    You might not use those "useless features" on your phones, but we most certainly do. Entire message boards exist solely to compare the picture quality and associated features of the various camera phones, which is a serious deciding factor for some people when buying a new phone...

  10. Re:Arghh bad use of statistics by Brushfireb · · Score: 2, Informative

    NOt only that, the statistics are WRONG.

    4 billion text messages per month are sent in the US. This is according to the Mobile Messaging Alliance, a industry group of carriers. www.mma.com

    Maybe they ment 700 Million per year for Virgin? Thats about right.

  11. US vs Europe by Wellerite · · Score: 2, Informative

    As the statistics say (not very clearly), texting is far more popular in the UK (and I would assume Europe, too) than the US. Cue lots of americans saying it's expensive and crap and don't understand why it's so popular.

    Reason is that texting is cheap and universal in Europe (inc. the UK) because of the GSM network prevalent there, plus all sorts of organisations jumping onto the texting bandwagon to encourage people to text more.