Slashdot Mirror


New Star Wars TV Series Confirmed

merauder writes to tell us BBC News is reporting that the new Star Wars TV series is set to run at least 100 episodes. From the article: "The series will be set between episodes three and four of the film saga. It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up that remains a mystery to most film-goers. McCallum said there would be 'a whole bunch of new characters' and the series would be 'much more dramatic and darker.'"

112 of 489 comments (clear)

  1. A New Hope by eldavojohn · · Score: 5, Interesting

    In my youth (prior to eighth grade), I read every Star Wars book out there. I think it was half way through the Young Jedi Academy series when I lost interest (Episode One was the final nail on the coffin of my fondness for Star Wars).

    Now breathe and get everything out of your system about me being a nerd without a life. I was, in fact, a farmboy without a permit or vehicle ... although I'm prepared for some colorful replies in response to this post.

    Kevin J. Anderson & Timothy Zahn could write a story. In their books, they expanded on what Lucas first saw. I read everything and loved the rich histories and futures laid out in the books for characters in the Star Wars universe. Sadly, none of these characters were in the new movies. None of the Jedi were cloned. Everything alluded to in the Thrawn (Zahn) Trilogy was omitted from episodes one through three. There was no talk of Spaarti cloning cylinders or Joruus C'Boath being cloned from Jorus C'Boath.

    Why? Because although these books were licensed by Lucas, they were not official parts of the story. These works became known as the Star Wars Expanded Universe meaning characters not in the movies. This material expands and continues the stories told in the films, taking place anywhere from 4,968 years before The Phantom Menace to about 130 years after Return of the Jedi. In fact, some of the works (like the Dark Empire comics and Zahn's Trilogy) conflict directly with other works.

    Don't be deceived, some of these works (like Children of the Jedi by Barbara Hambly) sucked. But I heavily suggest the Thrawn and Jedi Academy Trilogy if you want to read some of the better stories from the Expanded Universe.

    I would like to say that I remain optimistic about what Lucas can still do with the Star Wars Universe. I believe that he has made mistakes in giving himself supreme veto power over what is shown or added in the movies and I think this attitude has ruined Star Wars for me somewhat. I wish that Lucas would open his mind to other ideas as some of these books have proven that there are other people out there capable of helping Lucas create story lines. I shudder to think that he might attempt to write all 100 episodes without the help of coauthors. It has been my experience that television shows with multiple authors are less likely to grow old. I also hope that Lucas has finally realized that his fans don't want hilarious/annoying Jar Jar Binks but instead want the drama and emotion of Episodes Three and Five.

    Episode One left me disinterested. Star Wars Galaxies left me angry. Hopefully this series will win me back although I think a lot of us will have a hard time adapting to the new actors in old parts. I hope a large part of Luke's Youth is omitted as I cannot think of one young child actor I have liked.

    --
    My work here is dung.
    1. Re:A New Hope by DorkusMasterus · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I agree with this wholeheartedly. What do people NOT like right now about the franchise: Lucas' tinkering. With this show, he's going to probably have little if nothing to do with the daily content. I'm excited about this. I loved the books, especially the stuff with Thrawn, and while I know this is not the same time period plot-wise, it would be cool to see something along that same thematic idea. I'm excited for this and would give it a shot. (And NO, I'm not a fanboy. I like star wars, but have never dressed up as one, never owned a lightsaber (even the plastic toy ones), and don't even own all the films. I just like good fiction, and a lot of the "expanded universe" took the best things about the early films and gave them more and new life.

    2. Re:A New Hope by Mayhem178 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      I've been in your shoes. At home I have well over 100 Star Wars novels sitting on my bookshelf, and not one of them is unread (save for Republic Commando: Triple Zero, which just came out). The Expanded Universe is, for the most part, a wonderful continuation of the Star Wars saga, with a few inconsistencies or downright blunders (*cough* Planet of Twilight *cough*). The SW:EU has seen some of the most talented sci-fi writers of our age. And I can't think of any character I like better than Grand Admiral Thrawn.

      I do hope this TV series will live up to the ongoing story and be just as enjoyable as the books have been for me. I pray that they will heed the prior works of the authors and beware of glaring inconsistencies (one of which I intend to keep an eye on being young Han Solo).

      --

      "You will pay for your lack of vision..." - Emperor Palpatine to Ray Charles

    3. Re:A New Hope by AlterTick · · Score: 5, Insightful
      I hope a large part of Luke's Youth is omitted as I cannot think of one young child actor I have liked.

      Indeed. Not only that, but the true story arc of the Luke character can't really even begin until Ep4. Too much of the character's development in ANH starts with the premise of Luke as an inexperienced farmboy. To have him do anything beyond shooting womp rats with his T-16 or wasting time at Tashi Station with his friends would bugger the existing canon. Not that I'd put it past Lucas to do just that...

      --
      Conclusion: the Empire squashes the Federation like a bug. Accept it.
    4. Re:A New Hope by Venyce · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Timothy Zahn wrote some excellent Star Wars, I agree. I'm a little amazed that anyone could read something like the Jedi Academy series and find them to be anything better than grade D trash. They had to have Michael Stackpole (of X-Wing / Rouge Squadron books) come in and basically re-write it so it was partially believeable.

      The Dark Empire comics where relativly OK, as comics go. However they were trash compared to the good books. Most of the writers had to spend a lot of time ignoring the "Reborn Emperor, and Luke goes to the dark side blah blah. It was shit, but it had to be considered 'canon' for the sake of expanded universe books.

      Now we have the New Jedi Order books. I read 2 or 3 and that was the end. Just too cheesey. Other than Zahn, Stackpole, and a couple of others (whoever adaped Episode 3 and the guy who wrote Shadows of the Empire) I ignore Star Wars books now.

      Stackpole was right when he wrote his main character telling Luke that you can't take a guy who blows up a whole star system and say he's a great Jedi Knight. Good ole Kevin J. invented the super-weapon of the week club. The Deathstar 3, the Sun blaster who whatever that little twit jedi character he wrote used to blow up a star. It was just lame.

      And don't even get me started on the "Wonder Twins" saving the day through any number of books before they were even 12 years old. All of our main characters from the 1st triligy are standing around like assholes, so the kids can do it all.

      No thanks. Star Wars has become questionable. I approach anything writen or done for the screen with skepticism.

      On a good note, look around on the internet and see if you can find "Stuff". A piece of Star Wars fan fiction that was written to try and fix all the dumb shit various authers had done to the story after Zahn's books. It's very well written and pretty funny to boot.

      --
      Venyce

      remove all references to 007 to email me
    5. Re:A New Hope by Klivian · · Score: 3, Insightful

      >Kevin J. Anderson & Timothy Zahn could write a story. Agree 50%, but not with the Kevin J. Anderson bit. I would rather have Michael A. Stackpole work with Timothy Zahn, he is better than Anderson. They are the best writers that has worked on the Star Wars novels, their respective works are in a class above all the others. And they already have experience working thogether in the Star Wars universe. The 'Side Trip' story from Tales From the Empire, are one of the best short stories in the series.

    6. Re:A New Hope by leenoble_uk · · Score: 4, Funny

      Maybe Luke will lose his memory just before the droids arrive. That'd make it work.

    7. Re:A New Hope by MyNameIsEarl · · Score: 5, Funny

      Didn't you know that Obi Wan's lightsaber also acts as one of those doohickeys from Men in Black and can erase memories.

    8. Re:A New Hope by BTWR · · Score: 4, Insightful
      A young luke Skywalker reminds me of a young indiana jones. That series wasn't that interesting either.

      Yes, but the key difference is that a young Indiana Jones DOES have adventures (and is proven directly by Last Crusade's prologue). GP's idea is that a young Luke Skywalker is not supposed to have any jedi-like adventures, or anything having to do with the Force.

    9. Re:A New Hope by RzUpAnmsCwrds · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Why? Because although these books were licensed by Lucas, they were not official parts of the story.

      Actually, most EU content is considered cannon, unless it disagrees with the films or other Lucas-produced works. Indeed, much of the content used in the prequels came from the EU.

    10. Re:A New Hope by im_thatoneguy · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I shudder to think that he might attempt to write all 100 episodes without the help of coauthors.

      I think we're probably safe on this. I don't know anyone who would be willing to write 4,000 pages of screenplay on the same story. The volume of work required demands a team.

    11. Re:A New Hope by daeley · · Score: 4, Funny

      Didn't you know that Obi Wan's lightsaber also acts as one of those doohickeys from Men in Black and can erase memories.

      From the neck up. ;)

      --
      I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhauser gate.
  2. snark of the day :) by B3ryllium · · Score: 2, Funny

    Great! It should be about as interesting as Enterprise's first season. Yay!

    1. Re:snark of the day :) by flyingsquid · · Score: 4, Funny

      I think I speak for geeks everywhere when I say that I just can't wait to see a younger, whinier Luke Skywalker.

    2. Re:snark of the day :) by Golias · · Score: 4, Funny

      Heh.

      It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up that remains a mystery to most film-goers.

      Great. At last! 100 episodes of a farm boy fixing vaporators, shopping for power converters, and shooting at womp rats for cheap thrills.

      And you just know that every last goddamn character that had anything to do with the ultimate destiny of the Empire will pass through Luke's parcel of desert before the series run is over. I've got ten bucks that says we see Fett before season 1 is over.

      --

      Information wants to be anthropomorphized.

    3. Re:snark of the day :) by kniLnamiJ-neB · · Score: 3, Insightful

      What's he going to learn? He could barely pull his saber to cut himself free of the Wampa at the beginning of Empire. This is supposed to be before ANH, when he barely even knew that Old Ben lived out in the desert.

      Nah, this is just Lucas proving that he could mold a pile of dog crap into a sculpture of Darth Vader and people would kill each other to own it.

      And yes, sadly enough, I will probably watch it.

      --
      Windows isn't the answer... it's the question. NO is the answer!
    4. Re:snark of the day :) by hunterx11 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Really, in the last episode of Enterprise they should have sorted the whole mess out by going back in time and killing Berman.

      --
      English is easier said than done.
    5. Re:snark of the day :) by whitehatlurker · · Score: 2, Insightful
      What I don't get: 100 episodes of Star Wars?!

      Firefly cancelled after one season (okay before the end of the first season)
      Babylon 5 struggled each and every season to get renewed
      Farscape killed off before its time
      Enterprise got killed off as it started getting reasonable (the last episodes were shot when they knew they were dead, and it showed)
      And don't get me started on Birds of Prey

      Why would this series run that long?! (Yes, I know - it's the hype that surrounds a new series and all, but really - 100 episodes. Maybe they expect that Jar-Jar will be a big draw. Tune in next week to Meesa Binks get incinerated ... )

      Preparing to be slaughtered by the Sith/Jedi moderators, I don my blindfold and light my cigarette ;-)

      --
      .. paranoid crackpot leftover from the days of Amiga.
    6. Re:snark of the day :) by fatboy · · Score: 4, Funny

      The moment I knew that Enterprise jumped the shark was the Ferengi episode, whom the federation had never seen before. Right. I call bullcrap.

      Hey, I knew it jumped the shark from the beginning. There's singing in the theme song. This is Star Trek, THERE IS NO *SINGING* in Star Trek theme songs! (Even if lyrics have been written for it, you don't *SING* them on TV.)

      --
      --fatboy
    7. Re:snark of the day :) by captjc · · Score: 2, Funny

      What I want to see:

      Owen: I want you to clean these droids before supper.

      Luke: But I wanted to go the the Toshi station and pick up some power converters.

      a brief pause,
      SLAP


      Owen: If your gonna whine like a bitch, I'm gonna slap you like one. Your Father was an obnoxious little bastard too.

      --
      Slow Down Cowboy! It's been 1 hour, 47 minutes since you last successfully posted a comment
    8. Re:snark of the day :) by iphayd · · Score: 4, Funny

      Of course, this is going to be a sitcom, detailing the wacky adventures of Owen, Beru, Luke, and that crazy hermit Ben. Be ready for these episodes:

      - Luke visits the cantina. Hilarity ensues.
      - Luke buys drugs from the Jawas. Hilarity ensues.
      - Luke goes through puberty. Hilarity ensues.
      - Owen and Beru go out of town, Luke has a party. Hilarity ensues.
      - Luke finds a lightsaber at Ben's, pretends it a sword. Meaningful life lesson ensues.
      - Luke gets a girlfriend. He then wakes from his drug-induced dream.
      - Luke and family go to Hoth on vacation. Luke licks cold weather maintenance droid. Hilarity ensues.
      - Luke questions his sexuality. Steals Ben's Lightsaber again.

      Of course, these are not all of the episodes planned, but they will account for most of the 100 episodes, due to slight retelling of the same story, with the same jokes, over and over again.

    9. Re:snark of the day :) by 1u3hr · · Score: 2, Funny
      Umm, does that mean it's like an ABC after-school special? Or maybe like Dawson's Creek with more sand? Smallville with stormtroopers?

      It'll be The Dukes of Tattooine with a flying General Lee. Boss Jabba Hogg, Uncle Jesse Kenobi...

    10. Re:snark of the day :) by ErroneousBee · · Score: 2, Funny

      Tune in next week to Meesa Binks get incinerated ... )

      Ive seen some scripts for the New ST Series, and the whole series is constructed around the idea that Jar Jar gets stuck in a time bubble. Every episode starts with him arriving on Tatooine, and ends with his death, then the time bubble collapses and hes alive and well and about to die in the next eposode.

      One particularly touching script had him run over by a speeder in the opening sequence, with the rest of the episode charting his slow painful progress dragging his broken body across the street to safety, being repeatedly hit and stepped upon by passing traffic. He makes it to the sidewalk, only to be crushed when something falls from the back of a speeder.

      I think the series is going to be a great success.

      --
      **TODO** Steal someone elses sig.
  3. Mysterious Future by kevin_conaway · · Score: 5, Funny

    Would a slashdot subscriber please look into the "mysterious future" to make sure that this won't get rolled back like Futurama?

    Ah well, I never watched Star Trek anyway.

    1. Re:Mysterious Future by minginqunt · · Score: 4, Funny

      I predict that six episodes in, we'll be marching on the Lucas Ranch and Jar Jar Hater Re-education Centre, waving burning sticks demanding this atrocity be pulled from our screens for the sake of humanity, trying to fight our way through legions of brainwashed Lucasites dressed in Ewok suits brainwashed and tooled up with chainsaws disguised as Light Sabres to protect The Bearded One from the angry marching Hordes.

      As George Lucas climbs into his reproduction ATAT and shouts out the order to charge, "Yousa People Gonna Die! Dangah Ewoks" will be the last words YOU'LL EVER HEAR.

      This will come to pass.

    2. Re:Mysterious Future by greysky · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Fox will have first dibs at the rights to air the seires, and we all know what fox does with scifi series in the post-x-files world. The series will be aired versus the superbowl, or some other mega-draw, the episodes will be run out of order, and they will not even bother airing the pilot. It will be cancelled by the time the sixth episode airs, and all the fanboys out there will start a "save starwars tv" website, asking for donations to privately fund the production of more episodes. Rich Macullum will write to the fans on his blog thanking them for their dedication and support. And it will all be covered here on slashdot...

    3. Re:Mysterious Future by gnarlin · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I, for one, find peoples lack of faith disturbing.

      --
      A bad analogy is like a leaky screwdriver.
  4. Oh noes by voice_of_all_reason · · Score: 5, Funny

    McCallum said there would be 'a whole bunch of new characters'

    Meesa cries a bit at that ominous remark

  5. only if by tubbtubb · · Score: 5, Funny


    I'm not going to watch it, unless Han shoots a new bounty hunter (first) at the opening of every single episode.

    Only that will atone for Lucas's past sins.

    1. Re:only if by Matimus · · Score: 5, Funny
      I'm not going to watch it, unless Han shoots a new bounty hunter (first) at the opening of every single episode. Only that will atone for Lucas's past sins.

      Only if by "New" you mean an infant he suspects might one day become a bounty hunter in addition to it being a different infant every week. In fact, I won't watch unless that is the plot for the entire series. They can call it "Star Wars: Han Solo Baby Bounty Hunter Hunter Chronicles".

      --
      GENERATION 25: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and add 1 to the generation. Social exper
  6. The wrong 20 years. by Tackhead · · Score: 4, Funny
    Show me the 20 years of Anakin Skywalker between Episode III and IV. Show me the 20 years of Luke Skywalker following Episode VI. But this...

    > It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up that remains a mystery to most film-goers.

    Ah, I see - the years when Luke started out as a whiny, snot-nosed kid to, umm...

    Well, I guess there's nothing to see here, I'll move along.

    1. Re:The wrong 20 years. by Fhqwhgadss · · Score: 2, Funny

      But what, pray tell, could be darker and more dramatic about Vader's life than 20 years moisture farming on Tattooine?

      --
      How does a 7-person democracy cut a pie? Into 4 pieces.
    2. Re:The wrong 20 years. by teal_ · · Score: 2, Interesting
      No, there will be plenty of Jedi... fugitives who escaped order 66, and Vader will be hunting them down. In the book "Dark Lord Rising", which takes place immediately after episode iii, one of the main characters is a Jedi named Roan Shryne. The book starts off with him leading a campaign on Murkhana with a battallion of clones when all of a sudden his clones turn on him and he barely escapes. He ends up with a group of smugglers, evading Vader and his legions (also with him are a couple of padawans whose masters have been killed.) He is looking for other surviving Jedi, and makes his way to Kashyykk (the wookiee homeworld) to look for Yoda, but gets trapped there by Vader and ultimately we see Vader's power... as well as the empire's military dictatorship and its atrocities, as they pretty much commit genocide on the wookiees with only a few escaping... like Chewbacca.

      Meanwhile, we see the rise of the empire with the new regional governors taking control of the sovereign systems (such as Governor Tarkin.)

      This series has HUGE potential, and I can't wait. I too had a problem with episode I, it left me very cold, but after seeing episodes II and III, and how they tie it all up, I love it now, I have learned to just ignore Jar Jar, and believe it or not, I don't even mind him any more, he serves a pretty important purpose in the actual story (though we could have done without a few of his lines that made us all cringe.) In the end, amazingly, I find that I enjoy watching the prequels even more than the OT!!! (blasphemy, I know, and I'm one of those pathetic geeks who can answer just about any obscure star wars trivial pursuit question, from the OT!)

      So, to sum up, I think the series will feature:
      • Senator Organa and the rise of an underground resistance... the rebel alliance
      • The rise of the military dictatorship and Governor Tarkin -> Gran Moff Tarkin
      • Darth Vader the emperor's enforcer, flushing out the fugitive Jedi and reigning in defiant star systems
      • Jedi fugitives looking for other surviving Jedi
      • Chewbacca, his species having been all but extinct, getting into the smuggling game... perhaps we'll see him hook up with Han and Lando? Maybe we'll find out what Han did to Lando that Chewy reminded him about on the way to Bespin, where Han said "that was a long time ago, I'm sure he's forgotten all about that", and how the millenium falcon changed hands
      • There will be no Yoda, no Obi-Wan, no Luke. They're all gone, in hiding, or growing up on some back-water planet. This isn't going to be like young Indiana Jones where we see Luke's adventures growing up. It's clear that he has a very dull life as a moisture farmer on Tatooine and wants to leave. This series won't be about him at all.
      • Leia might be seen here and there just as Bail Organa's daughter but she won't be doing anything. Maybe we'll see how she gets to be a senator at age 20 though. But Alderaan seems to be an off mix of a monarchy and a democracy, Senator Organa is called "your majesty" by captain Antilles, so maybe Leia just gets appointed as a successor in the (powerless) imperial senate.
      • And, I hope, this all gets seen through the eyes of our favourite droids, the prissy protocol droid C-3PO and the heroic astromech droid R2-D2. A Kurosawa device... telling the story through the eyes of two insignificant characters who are just there, pretty cool. Refer to Kurosawa's Hidden Fortress


      Now, about the issue of episodes 7-9, no, that I do not want to see. This whole saga is really all about Anakin Skywalker's rise, fall, and rendemption. After he dies, it makes no sense to continue.

      Sit back, enjoy, let yourself go. Don't be jaded. Relax. It's fun. Don't be ashamed to enjoy.
  7. Could've picked a better setting by voice_of_all_reason · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up that remains a mystery to most film-goers

    I thought the whole point of the opening on Tattooine was that Luke was bored to tears on his home planet, and that his whole life up until this point was a choice between tendin' to the vaporators and picking up power converters at Tosche Station.

    That said, if he hated his life enough to consider signing up for the Imperial military, why would it be of any interest at all to us?

    1. Re:Could've picked a better setting by Moby+Cock · · Score: 2, Funny

      But we'll be able to watch Luke bulls-eye womprats in his T-16. Plus more epic and grand adventures!

    2. Re:Could've picked a better setting by mcc · · Score: 5, Interesting

      That said, if he hated his life enough to consider signing up for the Imperial military, why would it be of any interest at all to us?

      The answer is obvious and, unfortunately, terrible. They're almost certainly going to pack luke's early life with exciting star-flung adventures, cameos of star wars characters, and a constant use of the force powers he supposedly didn't know he had. By the time the series ends, whatever suspension of disbelief the once-powerful opening scenes of A New Hope originally conjured will have been totally destroyed by the knowlege that Luke Skywalker is in fact just as experienced and battle-hardened as any character from Sailor Moon.

      An alternate possibility is that when they say "the 20 years luke skywalker was growing up", they don't mean luke will be the focus of the series-- they just mean that is the period over which the series will take place. That is, perhaps the action will all follow Bail Organa, Mon Mothma et al, who have exciting and dangerous space adventures while Luke Skywalker is repainting the grain silo. This would make for an interesting and believable series-- and putting Leia through complex and traumatic adventures (while Luke sits at home and watches the news dispatches depicting the Empire's party line propaganda version of those same adventures) would be totally consistent with what we see in the movies. But I do not consider this likely to happen. Over 100 episodes, the temptation of somehow dragging Luke in every other plot will be too great to resist.

      Oh-- and expect a long and drawn-out plot arc in which Obi-Wan takes increasingly dangerous journeys into the underworld in a desperate attempt to make the last three clumsy minutes of dialogue in Return of the Sith seem dramatic and important instead of just being a hastily composed plot band-aid. Expect Luke to feature in these semifrequently, although he supposedly had never met Old Ben before the beginning of A New Hope.

    3. Re:Could've picked a better setting by Tetris+Ling · · Score: 5, Informative

      Actually, the movie implies that Luke has met Obi-Wan. After all, Luke quickly recognizes the name "Kenobi" when he hears it, and knows where his house is. Luke is just unaware of the connection between Kenobi and his father and all that.

      I don't mean to imply that this makes the show's concept any better. Just trying to keep our facts straight.

    4. Re:Could've picked a better setting by Guppy06 · · Score: 3, Funny

      "Luke Skywalker is in fact just as experienced and battle-hardened as any character from Sailor Moon."

      Mark Hamil in a girls' high school uniform?

    5. Re:Could've picked a better setting by MORTAR_COMBAT! · · Score: 2, Insightful

      actually, mark hamill turned into a pretty accomplished voice actor. he even had live-action roles in SeaQuest and in cut-scenes for the video game series Wing Commander. sure, his career has not followed the same trajectory as harrison ford's, but considering his horrible car crash, i think he's done quite well for himself. a long, happy marriage, 3 kids, plenty of regular work. we should all be so lucky.

      --
      MORTAR COMBAT!
    6. Re:Could've picked a better setting by Blackforge · · Score: 2, Funny

      I do have mod points right now, but there's no selection for "-666 Points Burn in Hell you dirty bastard!"

      Mark Hamil, uniform... EEP! While he's strutting his stuff like Britney Spears ;)

      BAHAHAHAHA!

  8. I Can't Wait by BRock97 · · Score: 4, Funny

    You thought moisture farming was fun and exciting before, wait until you see it in HD! Plus, I can't wait to see a permiere for the new season of the O.C. during the last five minutes of a Star Wars television episode!

    --

    Bryan R.
    The price of freedom is eternal vigilance, or $12.50 as seen on eBay.....
  9. New Characters? by magicsquid · · Score: 4, Interesting

    It will be interesting to see if they create the new characters with the ultimate eye towards plot development or whether they are simply created in order to sell merchandise.

    Given Lucas' focus in the last 5 years, I'd guess merchandising.

    --


    "Chances of RHIC-induced Armageddon are exceedingly rare, but... you never know." - MIT Physicist Bob Jaffe
  10. i thought by stoolpigeon · · Score: 4, Insightful

    luke just hung out on his uncle's farm. if he actually did anything interesting, that would fly in the face of everything he says and does in ep 4.

    --
    It's hard to believe that's how Micronians are made. Why don't we see it right now by having you both kiss one another?
    1. Re:i thought by AeroIllini · · Score: 4, Insightful

      if he actually did anything interesting, that would fly in the face of everything he says and does in ep 4.

      Like George Lucas has ever given a damn about continuity. Didn't Yoda mention that he taught Obi-Wan? How does Vader not recognize R2-D2 and C3P0?

      Lucas doesn't care about the story. He puts in familiar characters just so you'll say, "Hey! I recognize him!" and go buy the action figure. If you thought any further than that about it, you're out of Lucas's league. This TV show will be no different.

      --
      For security, the MD5 hash of this message and sig is 09f911029d74e35bd84156c5635688c0.
    2. Re:i thought by viking099 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "How does Vader not recognize R2-D2 and C3P0?"

      Do you recognise the Lego blocks you played with as a child? Or maybe the Apple IIe you might have used around 20 years ago? How about the little "robot in a kit" you might have assembled back then?

      What about the vacuum cleaner your mom used when you were 10? The hammer your dad might have used?

      No? Why not? Oh, because they were beneath the level of attention you gave other, more important, things. The Star Wars world is FULL of such things. In ANH there are like 3 or 4 protocol droids shuffling around in Princess Leia's ship, and I'm sure it's the same with R2 units.

      Just because important things happened to people while some "things" are around doesn't necessarily mean that they'll be remembered decades later. Not even the contexts were the same.

      Lucas is guilty of a lot of stuff when it comes to plot holes, retconning storylines, and dumb editing, but this one is always trotted out as a prime example of his hubris, when to me it's just another statement of the ubiquitous nature of robotic assistants in his world.

      There is no reason for Vader to remember R2D2 or C3P0, because they're just tools, despite their personalities or presence during important events.

  11. Re:Why? by Stiletto · · Score: 3, Insightful


    Star Wars stopped being "art" when the first Star Wars Happy Meal was sold.

  12. Heh by Moby+Cock · · Score: 4, Funny

    I feel A New Pessimism about the story that leads to A New Hope.

  13. Least interesting part? by irc.goatse.cx+troll · · Score: 4, Interesting

    It seems like a silly timeframe for a star wars show. Jedis when theyre hiding, luke when he doesn't know anything about the force, dark side ruling without any serious opposition.. The way they described it makes it sound like there won't even be any light sabers.

    Seems like theyre trying to clone the success of Smallville, except Superman found out his powers on his own-- Luke didn't know about them until taught.

    Attack of the clones, indeed.

    --
    Pain lasts, kid. Its how you know you're alive. Sometimes I think this growing up thing is just pain management-TheMaxx
    1. Re:Least interesting part? by bckrispi · · Score: 4, Interesting
      It seems like a silly timeframe for a star wars show. Jedis when theyre hiding, luke when he doesn't know anything about the force, dark side ruling without any serious opposition.. The way they described it makes it sound like there won't even be any light sabers. Silly timeframe? The 20 years between RotS & ANH are arguably the *darkest* period in the whole saga. There are plenty of interesting plot threads that can be covered:
      1. The subjugation & enslavement of resistant worlds by the Empire
      2. Vader "hunting down and destroying" any Jedi who survived Order 66
      3. Bail Organa & Mon Mothma stirring the seeds of rebellion.
      4. Obi-wan's early relationship with Luke and Uncle Owen. We know from ANH that there is history between these characters.
      5. Palpatine consolidating his power away from the Imperial Senate to his hand-picked regional governors.
      --
      Xenon, where's my money? -Borno
  14. 60 Second Version by ndansmith · · Score: 3, Funny


    "But I was going to [location] to pick up some [items]!"
    </whine>
    ad nauseum

  15. 100 episodes... of... by ChePibe · · Score: 3, Insightful

    of... what exactly?

    20 years of Luke growing up? Call me crazy, but Episode IV points to Luke's childhood being quite boring, comparatively. It sounds as if he raced a lot, argued with his parents, and generally did "kid stuff" with little to no understanding of precisely what the force was and only the ocassional trip beyond the confines of his farm to spice things up. His caretakers obviously were not on the run to avoid detection, as he was dropped off at the same place he grew up and left in Episode IV.

    I think this will turn quickly into Lucas's "Smallville" and, as such, fail to connect with "true" fans.

    1. Re:100 episodes... of... by garethwi · · Score: 2, Funny

      Perhaps it will be Malcolm in the Middle of Tatooine

  16. Great idea! by Locke2005 · · Score: 4, Funny

    The long, slow, painful death of Jar-Jar should make for a great first season... but what are they going to do for the second season?

    --
    I've abandoned my search for truth; now I'm just looking for some useful delusions.
  17. They should have done this sooner! by Pitr · · Score: 3, Funny

    Will Wheaton is too old to play the part now! ;)

    --

    --Not to be worried, Pitr fix.
  18. MONEY MONEY MONEY MONEY!!!! by autopr0n · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Each episode of the new starwars movies was supposed to be 'darker' then the last, and each one was ridiculous.

    Still, if it means that someone else will be doing the directing, it will have to be an improvement.

    --
    autopr0n is like, down and stuff.
  19. It has a lot to live up to by blibbler · · Score: 4, Funny

    Everyone remembers how wonderful the previous starwars TV shows have been. I hope this lives up to the brilliance of "droids", and the Christmas special. I would like to see a "Luke in the Middle" sitcom style... except without any brothers... perhaps they could adopt a jawa.
    later on, it could morph into a "the OC" style show, set in Mos Eisley... "the ME"

  20. Sounds like they're following the wrong Skywalker by Channard · · Score: 3, Interesting

    'Dark Lord: The Rise of Darth Vader' shows that there's still plenty of mileage in Vader's post ROTS and pre-New Hope years. Hunting down rogue Jedi, dealing with the rebel resistance etc - more fun than Luke Skywalker's life would be.

  21. I Have a Bad Feeling About This... by malikvlc · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up that remains a mystery to most film-goers.

    I am confused - just HOW much of a mystery could his life have been? Growing up on the moisture farm, rise early to avoid the heat, dust off the droids, whine to Uncle Ben, lots of sand on Tattoine...

    Lucas should not milk this cow any longer, prequels are not his strength! I'd root for something that picked up twenty years after Ep VI, the books are full of the political intrigue and scandal Lucas adored so much for Ep's I, II, and III...

    Ok, maybe even that would suck.

    --
    Try not. Do... or do not. There is no try. ~Yoda
  22. Han better be in there somewhere... by mobiux · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Like a side story, just bringing him into the story.

    That type of character is what was missing from #1-3.

    People aren't just good or bad, some people walk the line between the two.

  23. much more dramatic and darker by Expert+Determination · · Score: 2, Funny

    Does that mean that even more people will have their hands amputated? What does Lucas have against hands anyway?

    --
    "The White House is not an intelligence-gathering agency," -- Scott McClellan, Whitehouse spokesman.
  24. Skywalker story is already told by Cy+Sperling · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I wish they would just leave the entire storyline of the movies out of it. The universe he has created is so textured and interesting- why do we need to see Young Skywalker? Can't we just go to a new world and witness all new characters struggle with life under the Empire? More forced connections to the films just makes the narrative clumsy and self concious. Let's see an action series about a rebel resistance group, or the exploits of a Han Solo type anti-hero/outlaw (Oh wait, that was Firefly).

  25. Worst. Idea. Ever. by Lave · · Score: 5, Insightful
    It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up [on a farm, doing nothing, with no powers]

    Rather than post and post, about why this is a fucking stupid idea. Lets just all post the words:

    Worst. Idea. Ever.

    And mod each other +5 insightful.

    --
    http://skeptobot.blogspot.com/ - A site for the Renaissance man and woman
    1. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by smidget2k4 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Worst. Idea. Ever.

    2. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by Laserwulf · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Worst. Idea. Ever.

      --
      "Make cyberlove, not cyberwar!" -Khaed(544779)
    3. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by AdamHaun · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Worst. Idea. Ever

      --
      Visit the
    4. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by nicolasmendo · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Worst. Idea. Ever.

    5. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by Kingrames · · Score: 5, Insightful


      Free. Karma. Points.

      --
      If you can read this, I forgot to post anonymously.
    6. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by Tezkah · · Score: 5, Funny

      Honk if you love Jes....er.... Worst. Idea. Ever.

    7. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by yivi · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Worst. Idea. Ever.

    8. Re:Worst. Idea. Ever. by Makarakalax · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Hopefully you'll lose your karma in meta-moderation.

  26. Kurosawa by corporatemutantninja · · Score: 2, Interesting
    I've been thinking for years that Lucas should do a Star Wars version of the Yusagi Yojimbo story. It got retold as a Clint Eastwood Western (For A Few Dollars More), so why not as Sci Fi? Lone Jedi on a remote mining colony, two alien races in conflict, light saber vs. blaster. "My mistake, make that 4 cryogenic suspension tubes."


    A TV Series would be a perfect opportunity for this idea.

    --
    Actually, I was trying to be Insightful, not Funny.
  27. I'd rather have 100 TV episodes of 'Serenity' by ironduke-particle · · Score: 2, Interesting

    ... and I'm not the only one, see paragraph 6: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2006/03/15/star_wars_ tv_spin_off/

  28. It's simple by sterno · · Score: 5, Interesting

    If Lucas mostly keeps his hands off of this it will be good. Lucas is really good when it comes to the big picture view of the Star Wars universe. He did a fantastic job of creating this rich world with all kinds of potential. But if you look at the output from his work, the more involved he is with the movie, the more it sucks, generally speaking.

    What is the best Star Wars movie of all time? Empire Strikes Back, the one he had the least involvement in. Lucas is bad at writing and directing. He really struggles to bring any sense of emotion to the characters. Whenever you see emotion it feels like Soap Opera camp. You look at the stilted dialogue of Padme and Anakin in Episode 2 and 3 and it's just painful.

    So I believe that if Lucas is willing to keep his hands mostly off of this project and let it become it's own thing it stands a chance of not sucking. But it does fascinate me how things have come full circle. Star Wars set a bar and Battlestar Galactica came out shortly after trying to meet that bar and failing quite specatcularly. Now Star Wars comes to television and we have a very high bar set by Battlestar Galactica for what a sci-fi television show can be. Can Star Wars hold up? Probably not, but there's always hope I guess :)

    --
    This sig has been temporarily disconnected or is no longer in service
    1. Re:It's simple by qeveren · · Score: 2, Informative

      The only thing the new Battlestar Galactica has done is made me wish every last character would suffer a horrible, horrible, slow, agonizing death. All of them. oO;

      --
      Don't just stand there, get that other dog!
    2. Re:It's simple by skam240 · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Even without Lucas they're going to have a hard time making this both interesting and true to the starwars story line. Luke is pretty much some country bumpkin living on a farm in his youth. He doesnt ever leave the planet, he's ignorant of city life in episode 4 so he probably won't be going to cities and running into the native crime lords that much, he won't know anything about or be learning the force and the character wont really develope at all given that luke starts off episode 4 as a winey, naive kid. That pretty much just leaves the sand people. A hundred episodes of fighting sand people sounds pretty terrible. Sure there's a few other bits you can throw in there (like him developing his piloting skills through the canyons) but I just don't see how there's all that much good material to go with here.

      --
      I ignore Anonymous Coward posts. If you want to discuss something, that's awesome. Log in.
    3. Re:It's simple by WCityMike · · Score: 4, Funny

      Lucas is bad at writing and directing. He really struggles to bring any sense of emotion to the characters. Whenever you see emotion it feels like Soap Opera camp.

      "Oh, Ani, hold me! Hold me like you did at the lake on Naboo!"

      Indeed.

    4. Re:It's simple by gnarlin · · Score: 2, Funny

      Oh, Ani, use the force again!

      --
      A bad analogy is like a leaky screwdriver.
  29. Lucas "image" by wolfponddelta · · Score: 3, Funny

    If the photo accompanying the BBC article is any clue, Lucas is working hard to transform himself so he can guest star as Jabba in the series.

  30. Uh-oh by Reducer2001 · · Score: 4, Funny

    I have a bad feeling about this.

    --
    When you get to hell -- tell 'em Itchy sent ya!
  31. Why choose Luke? There is another... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Why not track the story of how Leah became a key player in the Alliance. More on her and her family on Alderan would be more entertaining than anything about Luke.

    Or Grand Moff Tarkan and the construction of the Death Star.

    Or Han Solo and Chewey smuggling and fighting bounty hunters, or AS bounty hunters. Throw in a little Lando. Works every time...

    Or Boba Fett's adventures as a bounty hunter, and perhaps an akward relationship with Vader.

    Or the further slauter of Jedi by Darth Vader. Have him track down Jedi and kick the crap out of them. Show him get more and more evil. This can be be supplimented with yoda training a few of the better Jedi that are fugitive.

    Any of this is better than tracking Luke or Obi-Wan. Putting Luke into forced adventures on Tatooine will really ruin the whole story, it doesn't fit well with A New Hope.

  32. new show by spartacus_prime · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Hmm...somehow, I think this is going to end up very similar to "Smallville." Luke had no knowledge of his abilities before Obi-Wan Kenobi told him. Although there is a plethora of non-canonical information on what exactly happened before Episode 4, is it really going to keep Star Wars fans entertained? I have my doubts, I'd rather see a show about Leia's childhood, or perhaps a show dealing with both.

    --
    If you can read this, it means that I bothered to log in.
  33. Uhg... by Cyno01 · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Luke is the last character we wanna see as an adolescent. C'mon, he was a farmer on a desert planet, snore. Even leia would be more interesting. Her dad was a senetor in the imperial senate. And anyone whos read the illustrated starwars universe knows how kickass alderran is. The character that me, and im sure everyone else would like to see grow up between epIII and IV... Boba Fett. C'mon, his father gets killed in front of him, thats gonna make for an extra angsty teen. From kid to the biggest badass in the universe. Now that would be a cool show. Not Dawsons Creek with landspeeders and Jawas like this is gonna be.

    --
    "Sic Semper Tyrannosaurus Rex."
  34. Artistic license with story... by catdevnull · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I wonder if there will be an "amnesia" plot device that has made the E4 Luke forget all the "Young Indiana Jones" mis-adventures set for this series? I mean wamp rats and moisture farming on a desert planet would make such an interesting show and all, but they're gonna have to punch it up and figure out a way to tie into "A New Hope."

    Maybe Lucas can just finally move on to another universe outside of Star Wars now that he's milked it dry.

    --

    I might know what I'm talkin' about, but then again, this is Slashdot...
  35. Not just Star Wars - Trek too by DG · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I was in a similar boat, but with Trek instead of Wars. Bought and read every single paperback that came out, starting with Blish's novelizations of the TV eps, then moving to Alan Dean Foster's novelizations of the animated series, then all the other paperbacks up to about #100 or so, when I finally gave up.

    Some of these, especially later ones, sucked really REALLY hard. But there were some landmark books in this series with some solid writing and adult tones and themes.

    FASA latched on to some of this material for their Trek-based role playing game, but Paramount explicitly ignored it when they did Next Gen... and it was around that time that the quality of the writing did an absolute nose-dive and they became downright juvenile.

    Shortly thereafter, I "grew out" of Trek, and with a couple of exceptions (a few Next Gen eps, and most of DS9) the quality of the work being produced validated that decision.

    Somewhere I've got a big box full of Trek paperbacks. I wonder what they'd fetch on EBay?

    DG

    --
    Want to learn about race cars? Read my Book
    1. Re:Not just Star Wars - Trek too by TacNuke · · Score: 2, Funny

      "Somewhere I've got a big box full of Trek paperbacks. I wonder what they'd fetch on EBay?"
       
        200 quatloos

      --
      I am not a number. I am a free man!
  36. 100 episodes, eh? by Rob+T+Firefly · · Score: 3, Funny

    I predict that by the time episode 100 premieres, Lucas will have already re-released heavily re-edited "Special Editions" of episodes 1-47.

  37. i'd rather see... by rhesuspieces00 · · Score: 2, Funny

    jar jar binks die at the beginning of every episode, where by the beginning, i mean everything before the closing credits. each week, we are shown new and creative ways for jar jar to die slowly and painfully. For the first episode, I propose the use of any combination of at least 4 of the following: chain saws with dull rusty teeth, bolt cutters, horse syringes, ewoks, various acids and bases, hot molten stuff, pixie cups, and/or freddy kreuger.

    In the second season, they kill George Lucas.

  38. Follow Han, not Luke by Pfhorrest · · Score: 5, Interesting

    That's something I'd be far more interested to see. The history of Han Solo leading up to ANH. Luke, as has been said everywhere, was a boring farm boy on a backwater planet. Han Solo was a riotous space cowboy smuggling for the Fetts. His story would be far more interesting.

    Besides, Han is about the only character from the original trilogy whose ancestry/history/whatever aren't talked about in the prequels already...

    --
    -Forrest Cameranesi, Geek of all Trades
    "I am Sam. Sam I am. I do not like trolls, flames, or spam."
    1. Re:Follow Han, not Luke by freeweed · · Score: 4, Funny

      We called that series 'Firefly'.

      You're right, it rocked.

      --
      Endless arguments over trivial contradictions in books written by ignorant savages to explain thunder in the dark.
  39. For all you nay sayers by Testicon · · Score: 2, Informative
  40. Lucas rape the classic trilogy? No way, dude!! by elrous0 · · Score: 3, Interesting
    Just look at how faithful his "special edition" versions of the film were to the originals as evidence of how much he loves and respects the original canon.

    -Eric

    --
    SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    1. Re:Lucas rape the classic trilogy? No way, dude!! by pilkul · · Score: 2, Insightful

      I'm not sure why anyone expects Lucas to worship the original canon. I mean, he made it. There's no reason why he should respect it if he believes he can do better now. (He can't, but that's not my point.)

  41. whoops! by Pfhorrest · · Score: 2, Funny

    Ack... revoke my geek card and s/Fetts/Hutts. Gah.

    --
    -Forrest Cameranesi, Geek of all Trades
    "I am Sam. Sam I am. I do not like trolls, flames, or spam."
  42. Fanboy alert! by MMaestro · · Score: 2, Insightful
    However, despite the fact that they predate episodes 1 2 and 3, they have many glaring inconsistencies.

    Timothy Zahn came first, and wrote that part of Vader's history, and Lucas screwed it up.

    Oh yeah, George Lucas really screwed things up by not having Anakin in his 20~30's when Episode 1 came around. Timothy Zahn is a great storyteller, but in terms of timeline continuity, you can't fault George Lucas for overriding Timothy Zahn.

    Pre-Episode 1, 2 and 3 stories + Anakin != Blame George Lucas

    Seriously, the guy places his stories PRIOR to Episodes 1, 2 and 3 and you blame George Lucas for the inconsistancies? Timothy Zahn flat-out screwed up in using Darth Vader in his stories. Anyone who watched the original Episodes 4, 5 and 6 knew Episodes 1, 2 and 3 would simply be 'how it all started' stories. (Where did the Emperor came from? What happened to the Jedis? Where did the stormtroopers come from? How is Darth Vader Luke's father? Etc.)

  43. A Book for a Simp in the Field by eldavojohn · · Score: 2, Interesting
    Good ole Kevin J. invented the super-weapon of the week club. The Deathstar 3, the Sun blaster who whatever that little twit jedi character he wrote used to blow up a star. It was just lame.
    Yeah, I sure did enjoy it when I was an grade school farm hand. I liked the part where stuff 'sploded! I didn't have the luxery of owning the movies but I had seen them and the books were freely available at the library.

    You (and a number of other posters) seem to be highly critical of my grade school interests. Isn't it amazing that low grade science fiction is entertaining to someone who has to geld piglets and pick rock? Hell, Kilgore Trout would have satisfied me then. Now I read James Joyce, Herman Hesse or any number of various real authors. That's not to say I fail to recognize my roots in reading.

    Do I feel like a smarter person now? Do I reject reading and liking Star Wars paperbacks on the grounds that they're literary trash? Not at all. I remember them. I remember liking them. And I always will. Laugh and jeer all you want, I'll defend Anderson because he gave me something to enjoy as a kid.

    Call me crazy but I'll also always find the original Tetris to be more sacred than any religious work due to the amount of time I invested in stacking bricks. It was like ... virtual hay bailing ... with rockets! Far out!

    So go ahead and trounce Kevin J. Anderson and Stephen King and Michael Chrichton and a number of other authors I read in grade school. I'm not really concerned about what literary snobs have to say about them. I don't care if you think Madeline L'Engle, Ray Bradbury, Brian Jacques or Laura Ingals Wilder suck as authors, I still love them--even though I've met people here and there that have a good time picking them apart and laughing at their simple plot lines.
    --
    My work here is dung.
    1. Re:A Book for a Simp in the Field by kcarlin · · Score: 2, Interesting

      Actually, you make a good list there. Michael Crichton's Andromeda Strain, both the novel and the movie, combined a tight A-novel/A-movie sensibility with science fiction without completely losing the audience the way the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey did, helping science fiction overcome its B-Movie reputation in the mass culture. (Planet of the Apes and Omega Man were fine adventure vehicles for Charlton Heston, but Andromeda Strain was relevant in a more immediate way.)

      Stephen King is a good enough writer to have convinced me to read Salem's Lot and the Shining long after I had lost interest in genre horror and fantasy, his realism was top-notch in Salem's Lot. His long suffering at the hands of screen adapters reputedly ended with the Stand, so perhaps I'll watch that some day.

      L'Engle and Bradbury and Heinlein were the best of their day. "Great Works" is a game for academics trying to bring what they consider best forward, and it changes radically and routinely. In High School we read Moby Dick, the Scarlet Letter, and the Moon is a Harsh Mistress. The pantheon of literature changes some each year, but it is a messy and perverse process, not to be mistaken for a mechanism for personal validation. Every year something abominable slips in and something core and critical is lost. Literary fashion and clothing fashion both enjoy heights and valleys. In the 1950's, only a handful of academic specialists had spent any time on the Romantics for about a hundred years, their opus of incomplete works, their subversive hedonism in life and on page, the classicism/paganism. And fantasy was routinely disguised or passed off as science fiction to avoid giving offense to religious elements, with a fraction of the titles released per year that we see now. Suddenly pot, LSD, Stranger in a Strange Land, Lord of the Rings, were front and center and the Romantics were suddenly campus favorites.

      Whenever you look at anyone's pantheon, ask the following:

      1. Who picked the works? There is always an agenda. Take the Bible, take Catcher in the Rye, take Bug Jack Barron, take the Satanic Verses, why were these things included or excluded? What would you include or exclude?

      2. What viewpoint do they represent? Are they trying to sell me something unsavory? (I have met too many narcissistic ideologues that cheerfully hijack a course to bully students into echoing a bankrupt position to achieve a passing grade. I believe in giving everyone a hearing, but forced conversions are Muhammed's folly, and the notion that the curriculum planned is of no import compared to their unapproved and uncataloged replacement requires some examination. A good literature teacher will draw out student debate on a literary position, and only reluctantly put a position forward themselves and only when the discussion has gone horribly wrong.)

      3. What other competing pantheons are out there? What does Berkeley do? What does the University of Chicago do? What about Hitler, Stalin, Mao? What about C. S. Lewis, Maya Angelou, or Victor Davis Hanson? Do they align more closely with my core beliefs? Most people actually do have core beliefs, and any pantheon that is aggressively or subversively in opposition to those beliefs will find opposition in the engaged reader.

      4. Most of all, people should read what they enjoy. I enjoy comic books and I have translated Chaucer hundreds of lines of Chaucer orally for a class as easily and accurately as one might read a passage from a Star Wars novelization. I have enjoyed treatments of Beowulf by John Gardner, Crichton, and Niven/Pournelle/Barnes. If you have acquaintances too rude and narcissistic to be polite on matters of literary conviction, you might want to consider changing friends. Some people you meet in life will be Hitlerites or Stalinists or Jihadists or Maoists, and it won't always be obvious which is which off the bat.

      Before I concern myself with whether someone validates me in some ar

      --
      Free Adam Smith! (Or best offer.)
  44. Biggs & Luke Duke of Hazzard by Loether · · Score: 3, Funny

    It'll be like the Dukes of Hazzard... In Space. Luke & Biggs Duke. I can almost hear the song. Just the good old boys never meanin no harm... They steal Uncle Owen's land speeder and always get in trouble with the local dim witted imperials. Those crazy kids. Tuskan Raiders/Jawas/Hutts/Wamprats loads of fun for the whole family. How many times will the Blue Milk gag work? I started of in sarcastic mode now I'm looking forward to seeing it. oh well...

    --
    TODO create witty sig.
  45. Product Placement by MrSteveSD · · Score: 2, Funny

    Darth Vader: "I see you have constructed a new lightsaber." Luke: "That's right. And I power it with new Duracell Ultra-Life Batteries." Darth Vader: "I see. wwwwhoooor poooooow" Luke: "You sound a bit congested. Why don't you try new Lemon-Flavor Beecham's Flu Powder?" Darth Vader: "I will, but later my son. Now I must text the Emperor on my new Blackberry 7100r." etc etc

  46. There was a good Star Wars TV series by wickedj · · Score: 3, Informative

    It's called Clone Wars and was animated by Genndy Tartovsky. Mace Windu and Yoda were badass. Even Anakin was cool. Yeah, here's hoping Lucas will give control to someone as talented as Tartovsky.

  47. Smallville Tatooine Graffiti County by YHZ_MadMonk_CAN · · Score: 4, Funny

    Great, we're going to see Berman try to recreate what people think is American teen culture (The OC, Fast'n'Furious, Clerks) on Tatooine using Luke Skywalker instead of Superman.

    Watch Luke drag race his tricked-out Accura Skyhopper in Beggar's Canyon.

    Watch Luke not get any at the Lookoff.

    Watch Luke pine about the girl he never gets (who looks mysteriously like his sister) while some girl (probably a strong-willed red head) pines about Luke.

    Watch Luke avoid disaster after disaster while the mysterious Imperial Governor's son lurks around and insists he and Luke are best friends.

    I was going to say that Luke would battle giant carnivorous beavers but I don't think he's going to even get that close to getting any.

  48. Hear that sound? by scoser · · Score: 2, Funny

    That is the sound of my childhood crying out as it is abused again and again.

  49. Synopsis of the first few episodes. by Mogomra · · Score: 2, Funny

    They also released a synopsis of the first few episodes:

    1 - Luke helps out on the farm, collecting moisture for the harvest.
    2 - Luke helps out on the farm, collecting moisture for the harvest.
    3 - Luke helps out on the farm, collecting moisture for the harvest.
    4 - Luke helps out on the farm, fixing the family landspeeder.
    5 - Treadwell goes on a rampage, and Luke and Owen have to put him down.

    Sounds like gallons of fun.

  50. Re:I'm tired of everyone bashing Jar Jar!! by Vinnie_333 · · Score: 2, Funny

    Jar Jar: "Ooo, Meesa horny! Whe'r da white woman at!"

    --

    "We shall party like the Greeks of old! You know the ones I mean." - HedonismBot
  51. Drama by pete-classic · · Score: 4, Funny
    It would cover the 20 years in the life of Luke Skywalker growing up that remains a mystery to most film-goers.

    McCallum said there would be "a whole bunch of new characters" and the series would be "much more dramatic and darker".


    It seems only natural that the adolescent antics of a farm boy would be darker and more dramatic than his subsequent struggle to free the galaxy from the tyrannical grip of his father and an evil wizard.

    (I want to drown George Lucas in Rick McCallum's blood.)

    -Peter
  52. Zahn, Stackpole. And others. by demonbug · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Stackpole was pretty good (the X-Wing/Rogue Squadron series is the best Star Wars I've read aside from Zahn), I tried reading one of Anderson's books and it was pretty bad. Zahn's are definitely the best of the Star Wars books by far (and his other books are pretty damn good, too - try the Conquerors series, or Icarus Hunt). I remember when Heir to the Empire came out, it was just awesome - it was the first non-Lucas Star Wars book out there (that I'm aware of) and it was very well written. Zahn has consistently lived up to it, alhtough I have to say his latest book in the Star Wars universe wasn't nearly as good. Outbound Flight just felt rushed, and a littel bit stilted - but part of that might be due to Zahn trying more to fit in with episodes I-III. The parts where Zahn stays with his own characters (Thrawn, etc.) are much better than the parts where he includes Ben and Anakin et al.
    That said, it is still a hell of a lot better than most of the Star Wars crap that is out there now. The whole "expanded universe" thing is really, really lame - if there was ever a case of "Too many cooks ruins the soup", it is Star Wars (at least the books - the movies, strangely enough, seem to exhibit the reverse).

    On a somewhat related note, Give Me Another Tie Fighter (or X-Wing - I loved those games)!

  53. Close second by SuperKendall · · Score: 2

    Actually I am not sure if Empire is better, or Clone Wars season 2 - really a whole movie by itself, and a damn good one.

    One of them is a close second to the other, at any rate.

    That the Clone Wars project was so good is further proof of your statemnent that Star Wars TV will be pretty successful if Lucas backs away from it a bit.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  54. Mmmm, stirred seeds and mixed metaphors... by Hamster+Lover · · Score: 4, Funny

    Bail Organa & Mon Mothma stirring the seeds of rebellion.

    Man, using metaphors is not rocket surgery.

  55. "More dramatic and darker"? B.S. by stlhawkeye · · Score: 2, Insightful
    McCallum said there would be 'a whole bunch of new characters' and the series would be 'much more dramatic and darker.'"

    Yeah, whatever. When the prequels were in the queue, this is what they said about them. They'd be more dramatic. Darker. Lucas was even going to pitch the familiar theme music and do something different. It all sounded wonderfully original and artistic until somebody said, "George, nobody wants that. People want the same score, the same movies all over again." So George, 20 years older and basically living off the technology royalties from ILM, having not written anything worth watching (note that Indiana Jones is basically a really awful movie that is saved by an enchanting combination of a fun score, the kinetic influence of Spielberg, and chemistry among the actors), writes Episode 1. I don't want to rehash the myriad complaints about Star Wars, but Episodes 1-3 were supposed to be "much darker". Well, the watered-down scene where Anakin kills the Tusken raiders elicited a yawn from me. I still get uneasy watching the scene of Han Solo of being tortured for no reason other than the Empire delights in torture. "They never even asked me any questions." Yeah, they do'nt care, they just enjoy inflicting pain and suffering. Then Lando walks through the corridors of his city arguing with Vader with the sounds of Solo screaming in inhumane pain behind him ... that's dark. Nothing about Anakin's fall from grace was dark. It barely even made sense, nor did Padme's perplexing passion for him. The films were written by a guy in his 60's who has clearly forgotten whatever he once knew about the passionate love of youth.

    So now they're going to make a "darker" TV series. Well, bullshit. Sorry. Their last attempt at "darker" gave us the slapstick antics of Jar Jar Binks flopping around a virtual soundstage and spouting sentence fragments and stepping in crap and tripping over shit and basically irritating the hell out of everybody.

    There's also a tendancy among bad writers to assume that "dark = deep". If I'm really depressing and dark and morbid and whatever, it means I'm deep and insightful and consumed by the pain that wracks our world in shuddering convulsions, blah blah. This misattribution of insight to misery is probably what fuels the Goth kids. Easy to sit around hating the world and thinking you're above it all simply because you're unhappy. Anyway, when I read, "this is goign to be dark" I hear, "weighty subject matter is going to substitute for insightful writing."

    But I'm cynical.

    --
    "I have never won a debate with an ignorant person." -Ali ibn Abi Talib
  56. Worse. Idea. by TeatimeofSoul · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Actually, I can think of an even worse idea: 101 episodes.

  57. People, it's not an action series! by TCQuad · · Score: 2, Funny

    Too much of the character's development in ANH starts with the premise of Luke as an inexperienced farmboy.

    There won't be any conflict... The series will just be "Little House on the Tatooine Prairie".

  58. But.. by Makarakalax · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Isn't that missing the point that vadar built C3PO? I'd recognise everything I ever built. Even if I built it from a kit that half a million other kids used. There's always a scratch or badly done part that I'll recall a story about or something.