Slashdot Mirror
VPN Solutions for Small/Medium Businesses?
artbeall asks: "I work for a small company and we are looking at various commercial VPN solutions, however many seem to be too expensive for us. I am interested in what solutions other small/medium size companies are using for their VPN. Of course, we want a SECURE system that is compatible with common network gear like Cisco as well as being able to run the VPN client on Linux, Solaris, and Windows. Does anyone have suggestions or ideas?"
Depending on what you mean by a 'small' company, I would look into using a Cisco PIX 506E. On CDW right now, they're ~$830. It sounds like it would meet all of your needs. I've used the PIX 506E for several smaller sites and it 'just works.'
-- "Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former." -A.Einstein
Why not use openvpn ? We run this on Linux, Openbsd and Windows.
Hey. We run a medium sized ISP out of wilmington, delaware and we have hads GREAT luck using IPCOP and Linksys BEFSX41 endpoints. The linksys routers are easy to setup and configure and they can be bought cheaply on ebay or any staples or compusa. IPCOP is completely linux based , The setup is more idiot proof then a windows install, and it has a web based admin which rivals standard stand-alone routers. Ipcop can run on tons of hardware configurations. We personally run it with 5 Network cards and it handles the VAST MAJORITY OUR OUR ROUTING needs. did i mention ipcop is free? Give it a try.
At work (~90 employees...I guess that would qualify as medium-sized??) we use a Cisco VPN 3000 Concentrator. It's been rock-solid for us for two years now, and I'd highly recommend it. If you want to go the VPN-client route, cisco has official clients for Mac, Windows and Linux, but the box is also compatible with the PPTP vpn clients that come with most modern operating systems and it's also fully IPsec compatible. So...for example, if you wanted to, you could set up a linux gateway at home that would connect to your work VPN and establish a LANLAN VPN link.
If this proves to be too expensive, you ought to look ag OpenVPN. It's quite stable at this point, and they have clients for Windows, Mac and Linux as well. You'll have to have some amount of knowledge of linux networking/firewalling to get it set up right, but there's plenty of documentation out there to guide you.
I've set up a PPTP VPN using a Ubuntu 5.10 server and PoPToP. All you need is to port forward the PPTP port to the set-up server.
Windows has the client native to the system. Linux can compile PPP and the PPTP client, and w/kernel 2.6.15+ you don't need to patch the kernel to get MPPE encrypton/compression. Solaris, alas, needs some patching. I googled this:
http://mcarpenter.free.fr/Dev/pptp.php
All works fairly well.
--
# Canmephians for a better Linux Kernel
$Stalag99{"URL"}="http://stalag99.net";
If you want good integration with windows (read: PPTP), and want to keep it on a nice cheap *nix box, try Poptop . Runs on most any *nix, entirely compatible with the builtin PPTP support in recent versions of windows. I've been running it for my own purposes (admittedly not on a "small business" scale, only one or two users) for years on a modest linux box and it hasnt given me any trouble connecting from WinXP or linux clients.
Go to openvpn.net. It's very straightforward to get a multiuser openvpn server up, using pre-shared keys or certificates. It's free, it's simple, it's multiplatform, and it's sufficiently secure for business purposes.
(However, if by "compatible with common network gear" you mean you need to host a VPN endpoint on a Cisco box, then OpenVPN probably won't work. If you can pass the connection through a firewall to a DMZ server, though, it should work fine.)
If you want a completely free solution, use OpenVPN hosted on an OpenBSD (or other free OS) firewall.
With reasonable men I will reason; with humane men I will plead; but to tyrants I will give no quarter. -- William Lloyd
Maybe I'm just an idiot, but OpenVPN was difficult to sort out in the beginning. There really needs to be a quick setup guide that'll get you running in under 10 minutes. If not that, then maybe a GUI solution that's better than what currently is in place, especially for Windows installations. If this was done, I can imagine that OpenVPN would gain much more wide acceptance.
I've heard people have much success with Linksys VPN routers. But Cisco VPNs will always be a sure bet.
Bollocks.
It works fine behind a NAT in either UDP or TCP mode. Have always worked. I run it for road warrior access for a 3rd year now after switching over from an IPSEC/PPTP solution.
If you use OpenVPN 2.0+ you can push options and manage everything from the server just like on a commercial VPN product. The only missing bit is the firewall management so you need to get a decent third party firewall.
A measly 320£ worth Via C3 running OpenVPN can deliver 200+ clients with an aggregate client bandwidth of 50MBit+. The comparable Cisco device is a higher end PIX or a 3000 series concentrator which costs 5 times that.
In addition to that with OpenVPN you can build a proper VPN infrastructure with failover, dynamic load balancing between tunnels, balancing between links, DDNS targets on either end, QoS to allow VOIP links in that, etc. With most IPSEC based solutions (including Cisco) you cannot get even close to that.
Baker's Law: Misery no longer loves company. Nowadays it insists on it
http://www.sigsegv.cx/
I have used IPCop for many, many months. With
the OpenVPN addon, it makes a sweet RoadWarrior
setup. The OpenVPN GUI is even easy enough for
our executives to use.
For us and our 30-something employees, it cost
us nothing to put IPCop online. It ran for a
year on a P-III/700mHz/256M Dell. We recently
upgraded the RAM to 768M so we could make better
use of the Squid cache.
You can get an IPCop server online with VPN in
under an hour. As long as you have a computer
in the spare parts closet, IPCop is far less
expensive than any other solution.
Matt
racoon is a very good Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP) and Internet Key Exchange (IKE) daemon. It is used to auto-negotiate keys for IPsec sessions.
/etc/passwd for authentication. This concentrator allows the Cisco VPN Client software to connect into the network for Road Warrior style access (also does much better with NAT traversal than tunnel-mode IPsec).
At work we have three VPN concentrators built using Linux and racoon. Two are configured as normal tunnel-mode concentrators, using fully-qualified usernames on the endpoints for authentication. One of these is for employees, the other is for customers. We are able to use any commodity VPN endpoint device which supports IKE identifiers (for example, Netgear FVS114).
We also have a third concentrator which is configured to use Xauth and
It's a pretty kick ass setup, actually. In particular, you don't have to have a Linux/BSD box or other PC at every endpoint location, just lil' IPsec-enabled gateways/routers (Netgear FVS114 is the best I've found so far, even other Netgears like FVS318 devices suck or are broken).
-=/\- Jizzbug -/\=-