Slashdot Mirror


Judge Creates Own Da Vinci Code

xmedar writes "The BBC is reporting that the judge who presided over the recent Da Vinci Code plagiarism case used steganography to embed his own code in the judgment using italic text in random places throughout the text. The full text of the code reads 'smithcodeJaeiextostpsacgreamqwfkadpmqz' if you want to have a go at cracking it." From the article: "Although he would not be drawn on his code and its meaning, Mr Justice Smith said he would probably confirm it if someone cracked it, which was 'not a difficult thing to do'. In March, he presided over a High Court case brought by authors Michael Baigent and Richard Leigh, who claimed Dan Brown plagiarized their own historical book for The Da Vinci Code."

35 of 463 comments (clear)

  1. It's not ROT13 by griffjon · · Score: 5, Funny

    Which only turns it into "nrvrkgbfgcfnpternzdjsxnqczdm"

    I checked double, triple and even quadruple ROT13, too! No luck!! ;)

    --
    Returned Peace Corps IT Volunteer
  2. Coolest Judge Ever? by propellerhead_prime · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Anybody who puts that kind of stuff in their formal documents is clearly too cool to be a judge. Anybody know where you can find info on what the italicized letters are?

    1. Re:Coolest Judge Ever? by propellerhead_prime · · Score: 5, Funny

      Actually, if you RTFA you would see that what's in the summary doesn't match the summary. So I see your 'Fucking retard' comment and raise you with 'stop being a total dumbass'

    2. Re:Coolest Judge Ever? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      Then tell us which one he's making fun of.

      Sorry, didn't mean to end a sentence with a prepostition.

      Then tell us which one he's making fun of, asshole.

    3. Re:Coolest Judge Ever? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      So I see your 'Fucking retard' comment and raise you with 'stop being a total dumbass'

      Woah. This is getting too rich for me. I fold...

  3. Smithy Code? by Whiney+Mac+Fanboy · · Score: 5, Funny
    The line in the summary "The full text of the code reads 'smithcodeJaeiextostpsacgreamqwfkadpmqz' if you want to have a go at cracking it." seems to be contradicted by the linked article
    Italicised letters in the first few pages spell out "Smithy Code", while the following pages also contain marked out letters.
    I would not have a go at cracking what's in the slashdot summary (if it's missing one letter who know's what else is wrong)

    Offtopic: For those unsure about whether Dan Brown is a fool or a genius, I offer a quote from Digital Fortress:
    "We've got a five-tier level of defense," Jabba explained. "A primary Bastion Host, two sets of packet filtersfor FTP and X-eleven, a tunnel block, and finally a PEM-based authorization window right off the Truffle project. The outside shield that's disappearing represents the exposed host.It's practically gone. Within the hour, all five shields will follow. After that, the world pours in. Every byte of NSA data becomes public domain.
    You cannot make this stuff up :-)
    --
    There are shills on slashdot. Apparently, I'm one of them.
    1. Re:Smithy Code? by fatduck · · Score: 4, Funny

      While the five-tier defense system of the NSA computer network is well-publicized, few people know about the hidden "sixth tier" of defense run by the sysadmin superman "The Plague" It is comprised mainly of an overwhelming number of "garbage files" to muddle even the most leet hax0r. It seems quite unlikely that anyone will ever hack the Gibson.

      --
      Making you think you're crazy is a billion dollar industry.
    2. Re:Smithy Code? by KE1LR · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Too bad the book sucked, though.

          Dan Brown uses basically the same plot outline for each of the three books of his that I've read. (Da Vinci Code, Angels and Demons and Digital Fortress). Here it is in a nutshell:

          Egghead professor-type gets sucked into something Really Important To the World (tm) with the help of a very intelligent woman who happens to be an expert in the Really Important Thing (tm) but STILL needs him to explain everything to her anyway. While they try to make it to the end of the book they are pursued by a merciless killer who wants to bump them off before they discover the Big Secret (tm). Did I forget anything?

    3. Re:Smithy Code? by gEvil+(beta) · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Dan Brown uses basically the same plot outline for each of the three books of his that I've read.

      Makes one wonder why you keep on reading his books if they're all the same...

      --
      This guy's the limit!
    4. Re:Smithy Code? by phong3d · · Score: 4, Funny
      Oh, come on, name me one major hollywood movie with more realistic IT in it.

      The First Wives Club. At one point in the movie, one of the characters is in her husband's office. She opens up a document in Microsoft Word and saves it to a disk.

    5. Re:Smithy Code? by Fred_A · · Score: 4, Funny

      It's because those crafty marketing people at the editing house keep changing the book covers.

      --

      May contain traces of nut.
      Made from the freshest electrons.
    6. Re:Smithy Code? by JWW · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Theres anothr movie that people have failed to mention that I think gets some aspects of IT better that any of these mentioned so far, and that would be.

      Office Space

      It certainly nails the office politics aspect of IT ;-).

    7. Re:Smithy Code? by Minwee · · Score: 5, Funny
      At one point in the movie, one of the characters is in her husband's office. She opens up a document in Microsoft Word and saves it to a disk.

      Oh, come on. When is the last time you saw a Microsoft Word document that was small enough to fit on a floppy?

    8. Re:Smithy Code? by good+soldier+svejk · · Score: 4, Interesting
      I'd be curious to see how shows like ER or House actually compare to real medicine.
      I can't comment overall, but on ER I have seen a couple of very realistic portrayals of medical technologies with which I am experienced. On one episode the doctor with the limp described an ongoing beating heart valve replacement using the Cohn Cardiac Stabalizer. She even credited Bill Cohn at Beth Israel in Boston with its development. In the background they showed the procedure on the monitor. The footage was Dr. Cohn's own from a procedure he performed. He also does his own editing. The others were passing references to medline and paperchase online medical reference searches.
      --
      It is cowardly, and a betrayal of whatever it means to be a Jew, to act as a white man

      -James Baldwin
    9. Re: Smithy Code? by Sheriff+Fatman · · Score: 5, Funny

      That's your standard Linux distro ought to include the mystical "tawgo" command. Anyone who can actually keep up with the command-line will get the joke, and it'll look just like ordinary movie computer fluff to everyone else...

      [root@fortress]$ cd /home/dr.evil/
      [root@fortress]$ tawgo "PREPARING TO COPY SECRET FILES..."
      [root@fortress]$ cp -Rf * /mnt/floppy
      [root@fortress]$ tawgo "SECRET FILES COPIED"

      [root@fortress]$ tawgo --help

      tawgo: Tell Audience What's Going On

      Usage: tawgo [option] MESSAGE

      Displays MESSAGE in big bright coloured letters, probably in some sort of futuristic animated dialog box.

      -a --animation Show cheesy animation
      -w --warning Use yellow & black warning stripes
      -s --self-destruct Initiate fake countdown sequence
      -v --voice Reads MESSAGE in a Female Computer Voice

      Use -v -s if you need Female Computer Voice counting down the seconds to our hero's impending destruction.

      [root@fortress]$ tawgo "INITIATING SATELLITE ALIGNMENT"
      [root@fortress]$ /usr/sbin/comsatctl -a --lat=324.3 --lon=213.4
      [root@fortress]$ tawgo "SATELLITE ALIGNED."
      [root@fortress]$ tawgo "BEGINNING FIRING SEQUENCE"
      [root@fortress]$ /usr/sbin/comsatctl --target 01 -n

      It'd save them a fortune on getting media companies to hack up fake OS screens in Flash as well...

      --
      -- Open Source: It's mad, but you don't have to work here to help.
  4. It's "Smithy code" by Creosote · · Score: 4, Informative

    The first boldface italicized letters actually spell out "Smithy code"; you can see the 'y' in section A.1.3 of the ruling (PDF).

  5. I've solved it... by dsginter · · Score: 5, Funny
    The output is as follows:
    All your case are belong to us!
    --
    More
    1. Re:I've solved it... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      Or take off every 'Wig'...

  6. Re:Sorry by chill · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I'm sorry, but a Judge should not be playing games in a judgement. If I were the plantiff or prosecutor, I'd be pissed the he might not be taking the case seriously.

    The plaintiff's premise for suing was "Dan Brown wrote about the same stuff we wrote about" followed by their lawyer's logic of "Dan Brown is rich" and "this pays better than the lottery". They deserve not to be taken seriously.

    --
    Learning HOW to think is more important than learning WHAT to think.
  7. Re:too much time on their hands? by Hedgethorn · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This isn't unheard of in the legal world. I don't have any references at hand, but my brother-in-law (who is presently in law school) has shown me several creative decisions like this: a judge who included hundreds of movie titles in his decision, decisions in rhyming verse, etc.

  8. Re:too much time on their hands? by OzPeter · · Score: 5, Funny

    Yes, but funding doesn't always help you in the legal process. What we need is smarter people who can read betwen the lines and check out what is really being said. Why don't people realise that lack of intelligence is what the problem is actually about>

    --
    I am Slashdot. Are you Slashdot as well?
  9. Dan Brown, Artiste! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    A telephone is ringing in the darkness -- a tinny, unfamiliar ring. I fumble for the bedside lamp and turn it on. Squinting at my surroundings I see a plush Renaissance bedroom with exquisite Louis IX furniture, hand-frescoed walls, and a mahogany four-poster bed with a person in it, who is me, Dan Brown, the master storyteller and a bestselling author whose talent for dialogue and depth of characterization exceed even Tom Clancy at his finest. The jacquard bathrobe hanging on the bedpost bears the monogram: HOTEL RITZ PARIS.

    Where the hell am I?

    The cobwebs in my head blow away, like candles in the wind. Oh, that's right, I am in my New England bedroom recovering from a trip to the world renowned city of Paris, where I attended a lecture given by world renowned Harvard religious symbologist Robert Langdon, who gave me an idea for a novel about religious symbology. On my bedside table I see Umberto Eco's Foucault's Pendulum ... It's really difficult to read. How I wish someone would write a dumbed-down version!

    Hello?

    I pick up the phone. "Monsieur?", says the voice. "Sir, an important man is here to see you, s'il vous plait?" I wish Juanita would stop putting on a French accent. "A very important man," she pressed. That could only be my friend, Sir Leigh Teabing, the Royal Historian and Ambassador-Plenipotentiary to the Exchequer. He was awarded a knightency by Queen Elizabeth the II for his amazing volume on the House of Percy, in which he revealed for the first time the ninth earl's involvement in a Rosicrucian-Illuminati-Masonic conspiracy to do, er, something or other.

    "Good evening, old fruit!," he exclaimed as he shimmered in, his monocle popping out. "I say, how the devil are you, old bean? Lawks-a-mercy, had a spot of bother getting up the apples and pears, don't you know! Good lord, is that settee kosher or wot? Must 'ave a knees-up round the old Joanna, eh!" (Did I not already tell you my research skills are second to none?: I based this dialogue on The Code of the Woosters, a useful compendium of contemporary slang). His manservant, Rémy Legaludec, stood by, menacingly. I don't trust him. Rémy, I mean, not Sir Teabing, who is as straight as a piece of string.

    But who was the femme fatale (fatal woman) accompanying him? She looked familiar, like a beautiful Jacques Saunière, world renowned curator of the Louvre (the Louvre), the world renowned art museum in Paris. "Ah, 'alo, 'alo, monsieur (Mister), my name is Sophie Neveu," she said in flawless English, "I studied at the Royal Holloway." There is a sadness about her, as if she were about to find out her grandfather had been shot by a psychotic albino assassin working for Opus Dei -- hey, it happens -- but on the outside she smiles enigmatically, like Amon L'Isa.

    Sophie took off her glasses, the ones that made her look like the renowned French government cryptographer she was. "My God," I said, "you're beautiful." "Thank you," she said, tossing her mane of thick burgundy hair playfully. Her playfulness disguised the haunting memory of witnessing her beloved grandfather participating in a bizarre sex ritual, but I wasn't to know that, though I thought I'd mention it now to keep the narrative tension at fever pitch. See, that's what good writing is all about.

    Sir Teabing was also a sight for sore eyes. I wanted to pick his brains about an idea I'd had for a new bestselling book. "Sir Teabing," I said to the Royal British Knight of the Realm, "I'd like to pick your brains about an idea I've had for a new bestselling book."

    "O, Jubilate!," Sir Teabing said. "Fire away!, as we used to say on the hunting-fields of Eton College, the world renowned school for the British upper-crust."

    "From my researches at the Institute of Historical Review, and with the help of world renowned scholar David Irving, I've discovered the existence of a secret cabal -- known as 'Jews' -- which controls the destiny of the world through its factotum, an entity called 'Israel' that worship

  10. I got it! by jpellino · · Score: 5, Funny

    d-r-i-n-k-m-o-r-e-o-v-a-l-t-i-n-e !

    --
    "Win treats sysadmins better than users. Mac treats users better than sysadmins. Linux treats everyone like sysadmins."
  11. One Question by Billosaur · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Can we get this guy on the US Supreme Court? It's gotten way too stuffy for my test. Mr Justice Peter Smith might just bring some much-needed humanity to court deliberations.

    --
    GetOuttaMySpace - The Anti-Social Network
  12. Re:too much time on their hands? by Foobar+of+Borg · · Score: 4, Funny

    Although, speaking of severe, horrific,ubiquitous legal forums, it remains to be seen which of the two well funded legal teams has enough capital to really win this case through successful legal obfuscation.

  13. I knocked something together... by beady · · Score: 5, Informative

    To grab single italicized letters from the document.
    As far as I can see the letter list is:

    smithycodeJaeiextostgpsacgreamqwfkadpmqzviMi

    1. Re:I knocked something together... by lamplighter · · Score: 5, Informative

      Yes, I've gone through it pretty carefully and been unable to find more single italicized letters than

      smithycodeJaeiextostgpsacgreamqwfkadpmqzv

      And these are the paragraph numbers and words I found them in, for those who wish to look at the original ruling and confirm:

      1 Claimant(s)
      2 clai(m)ant
      3 (i)s (t)hat ... (h)is ... realit(y)
      4 (c)ynicism
      5 f(o)r
      6 prece(d)ed
      7 T(e)mplar
      8 New (J)ersey ... (a)ble
      9 res(e)arch
      11 th(i)s ... techniqu(e)s
      13 e(x)tinguished
      14 (t)echnical
      16 st(o)ry ... wa(s)
      18 (t)he
      19 somethin(g)
      20 grou(p)s
      21 u(s)ed
      23 w(a)s
      25 do(c)uments ... bein(g) ... e(r)adicated
      26 elsewh(e)re
      27 Templ(a)rs
      29 Clai(m)ants ... se(q)uence
      30 (w)ith
      31 o(f)
      34 (k)ey
      35 Plant(a)rd
      37 intro(d)uced
      38 manuscri(p)ts
      40 ulti(m)ately
      42 (q)uestions
      43 embla(z)oned ... pre(v)alent

      This could be just a substitution cipher, in which Mr. Justice Smith has contrived to make the first ten characters "smithycode." The lack of spaces between words, though, makes it tough for me to decipher -- though I'm sure there are people out there better at deciphering than I.

  14. It IS ROT13!!! by Descalzo · · Score: 5, Funny

    That's fhqwhgads' brother.

    --
    I cried real tears when Li Mu Bai died.
  15. A Codesmith Exists by digitaldc · · Score: 4, Interesting

    smithcodeJaeiextostpsacgreamqwfkadpmqz

    Reverse the first part to get 'codesmith' and take away the word 'a' & 'exists' from the next few letters
    This leaves you with 'Jaeotpcgream' which you will use later.
    Take letters on the keyboard next to 'qwfkadpmqz' to get 'asriseonas' which is then combined with 'Jaeotpcgream' to form 'jaeotpcgreamasriseonas'
    You take out the words 'to raise a scam' then throw away the rest of the letters.

    These words are then rearranged to form the sentence:
    'A codesmith exists to raise a scam.'

    --
    He who knows best knows how little he knows. - Thomas Jefferson
    1. Re:A Codesmith Exists by Just+Some+Guy · · Score: 5, Funny
      Take letters on the keyboard next to 'qwfkadpmqz' to get 'asriseonas' which is then combined with 'Jaeotpcgream' to form 'jaeotpcgreamasriseonas'

      ...which is clearly an anagram for "masons jar epic ogre at sea", referring to their role in overthrowing the British empire through a series of clever but obscure naval battles.

      --
      Dewey, what part of this looks like authorities should be involved?
  16. Re:More Clues by tddoog · · Score: 5, Funny
    What an asshole.

    The judge, who is 53 and lists some of his hobbies as reading military history and the sinking of the Titanic,...

    I just can't respect a person who sinks cruise liners and kills thousands as a hobby.

    That seems more like work to me:)

  17. Partial Decryption by Kinthelt · · Score: 4, Funny

    Well, using "SMITHCODE" as the key to a Vigenere cipher, I managed to get a partial decryption:

    ISALQRAPPXGSJZPQNIYKXRTBBJMH

    As you can plainly see, the first three words are: "Is All Crap"

    --

    "Evil will always triumph over good, because good is dumb." - Dark Helmet (Spaceballs)

  18. Re:too much time on their hands? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting
    Some famous cases: Justice Eakin in Pennsylvania (who was taken to task for his doggerel on delict); Judge Buchmeyer in the Northern District of Texas, who issued a musical decision in a forum selection dispute involving country music singer LeAnn Rimes; Judge Alex Kozinski famously used tons of movie titles in U.S. v. Syufy Ent. 903 F.2d 659 (9th Cir. 1990) ... actually, there's quite a few amusingly-written decisions and opinions out there. One of the perogatives of being a judge.

    Of course, there are good arguments against levity in court proceedings, but I can say that these cases have made the lives of countless law students at least slightly more pleasant.

    A particular favorite is the wrongful appropriation case of Zim v. Western Publishing Co., 573 F.2d 1318 (5th Cir. 1978), which begins -- for no particular reason that I can discern -- in a mock King James style:

    In the beginning, Zim created the concept of the Golden Guides. For the earth was dark and ignorance filled the void. And Zim said, let there be enlightenment and there was enlightenment. In the Golden Guides, Zim created the heavens (STARS) (SKY OBSERVER'S GUIDE) and the earth. (MINERALS) (ROCKS and MINERALS) (GEOLOGY).

    Then there rose up in Western a new Vice-President who knew not Zim. And there was strife and discord, anger and frustration, between them for the Golden Guides were not being published or revised in their appointed seasons. And it came to pass that Zim and Western covenanted a new covenant, calling it a Settlement Agreement. But there was no peace in the land. Verily, they came with their counselors of law into the district court for judgment and sued there upon their covenants.

    My guess is some law clerk won fifty bucks for getting Irving Loeb Goldberg (a great judge and perhaps even a great jurist) to do this.
  19. Re:You've missed the point by elvum · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This is the UK. We can tell the difference between bias and humour over here.

  20. Clue? by darthservo · · Score: 4, Interesting
    I have set out at some length what in my opinion is an overall analysis of HBHG [The Holy Blood and the Holy Grail]. I have done that and will do the same further in this judgment in respect of DVC [The Da Vinci Code] because that is essential in my view to deciding this case. The paragraph ended: "The key to solving the conundrum posed by this judgment is in reading HBHG and DVC."

    I don't know if this is useful or helpful, but I noticed that the character sequence past smith(y)code has the same number of characters from the phrase to abbreviate both books:

    Jaeiextostpsacgreamqwfkadpmqz

    HolyBloodHolyGrai lDaVinciCode

    --

    Prove it.