Slashdot Mirror
Inside Apple's iPhone
DECS writes "Despite CNET's wild claims, Roughly Drafted is reporting that Apple's market position and recent performance show the company has the ability, capacity, and interest in shaking up the mobile phone industry. Something that service providers, manufacturers, and consumers desperately need."
Sounds cool, but it sounds like another fad. Just like the RAZR was a fad and just like the iPod was a fad, this will pass with time, and technically speaking, it will be a terrible product, but Apple's viral marketing schemes will somehow sell people on this idea.
I can't help but think of how Apple's iTunes cripples the MP3 industry by restricting use with proprietary formats. Maybe we'll see the same traits with the iPhone. I can see it now... only being able to make calls to other iPhones. Brilliant!
even Digg knows not to take this trash website seriously
..but TFA sports a case of roughly-drafted-itis in my opinion. While making a good point that Apple could do better and be more flexible in its approach than any of the old mobile dinosaurs, it could have been said in a much more compact way - without nice stock charts and raves about 'Apple doing better than any other tech company'
Most audio devices publish their S/N ratio, THD (at a given percentage), and a few other statistics. Most of these can't be measured without a somewhat destructive opening of the box. THD, for example, is measured directly on the board.
Also, most manufacturers (at least respectable ones) publish these numbers to show their devices don't sound like ass. Compare the iPod to the Gigabeat. Same song, same compression, same headphones. The iPod will sound worse, period.
Will it sound bad enough for you to care? That's up to you.
The truth of it is that style, over quality, is the driving market force for most of Apple's consumers. I'm not saying it's a bad thing (except for admittedly picky people like myself) but it IS a sign that the iMobile won't be a terribly high-powered device. It'll be all form.
/.)
If it's a GSM phone, it'll suffer the same poor audio quality, low data speeds, and structural penetration issues that all 900mHz phones suffer from. If it's a CDMA phone it'll HAVE to be sold through Verizon or Sprint directly, since those carriers' networks are locked on their end, no the phone's. If it's sold "unbranded" you'll lose half the market right away, especially the high-end users, the vast majority of which are on Verizon or Sprint, for the data options.
The RAZR is the perfect example of Style over Substance in the cellphone market. By all accounts, it's a terrible phone. It's wider than it should be, it has lousy battery life, it's fragile, has a terrible OS, delivers little to no advanced features, and cost (at launch) more than most PDA phones. But it was chique, and so it sold in droves. Remember when it was so absurdly cool to own an iPod? Now your grandmother's cat's litterbox has a dock, and came with a free nano.
Apple DOES sell form. When was the last time you heard anyone in an Apple store say "I want that one because it can do 1.4billion more calculations per second than the one over there in black" No, the prevailing sentiment is: It's cute. That's what sells Apple, and pretty much all that sells Apple to the VAST MAJORITY of their users. It isn't the software library, it isn't the 10 day return policy, it isn't "tested and reliable" hardware. That is the deciding factor for less than 1% of their customers (though admittedly those who should loudest and post most frequently on
I've wandered a bit into corporate culture and away from the impending iMobile. I apologize. But for the iMobile to reach the maximum number of consumers, it won't be a powerful product. It will flash Apple's minimalist design and carry a premium price point, because you're not just buying a cellphone, you're buying "cool".
Ultimately they're in the same boat as Google is now: Trying to "mandate cool" rather than putting out good products and letting people decide that they're cool. And that's a ship that sinks fast.
i refuse to read your post sir. ever heard of a html break? it's a less than, followed by B and R then a space and a forward slash and then a greater than symbol. if you don't know this, you are new here. congrats. but please learn that html is required in /. posts.
After 5 generations, Apple still haven't figured out how to put a plain old FM radio into their iPod. Wouldn't a phone be a much more complex proposition?
apple just sell expensive stuff for idiots who want to look good in front of their yuppie friends. it has been proven by this survey here.