Slashdot Mirror


Water From Wind

ghostcorps recommends a writeup in The Australian by columnist Phillip Adams about a new windmill design that extracts water from air. The article gives few details of how it works, because patent protection is not yet in place, but what is revealed sounds promising. "[Max] Whisson's design has many blades, each as aerodynamic as an aircraft wing, and each employing 'lift' to get the device spinning... They don't face into the wind like a conventional windmill; they're arranged vertically, within an elegant column, and take the wind from any direction... The secret of Max's design is how his windmills, whirring away in the merest hint of a wind, cool the air as it passes by... With three or four of Max's magical machines on hills at our farm we could fill the tanks and troughs, and weather the drought. One small Whisson windmill on the roof of a suburban house could keep your taps flowing. Biggies on office buildings, whoppers on skyscrapers, could give independence from the city's water supply. And plonk a few hundred in marginal outback land — specifically to water tree-lots — and you could start to improve local rainfall."

17 of 411 comments (clear)

  1. Interested.... by SQLGuru · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Things I would like to know:

    1. Does this design perform better than other windmill designs (for generation).
    2. What will this do to the atmospheric conditions?
    3. If everyone has one....will it no longer rain?

    Layne

    1. Re:Interested.... by UbuntuDupe · · Score: 4, Informative

      Disclaimer: just my guesses:

      1. Does this design perform better than other windmill designs (for generation).

      No; conventional windmills have long been designed to extract the maximum amount of mechanical work from the air. This new windmill is not designed to do that, and works the same in any wind direction.

      2. What will this do to the atmospheric conditions?

      Small decrease in humidity.

      3. If everyone has one....will it no longer rain?

      It will still rain. The windmills couldn't possibly collect all evaporating air in a short radius. Even if they did, clouds call still blow in from over oceans and lakes.

    2. Re:Interested.... by spun · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Things I would like to know:

      Phillip Adams, this guy Max Whisson is your longtime friend. You give no details about how his device works, yet you ask for people to invest money with him. Is this a scam? You say you already have investors, yet you haven't managed to get a patent on this device yet, and so you need to keep the details secret. Why should we think this is anythign but a scam?

      --
      - None can love freedom heartily, but good men; the rest love not freedom, but license. -- John Milton
    3. Re:Interested.... by Chris+Mattern · · Score: 4, Funny

      > Why should we think this is anythign but a scam?

      So, what you're trying to say is:

      [Morbo]
      "Windmills do not work that way!"
      [/Morbo]

      Chris Mattern

    4. Re:Interested.... by general_re · · Score: 5, Funny

      I would also like to know how this works. Any speculations here?
      I understand these moisture vaporators are similar to binary load-lifters. Get the right droid to program them, and you're good to go.
      --
      ABSURDITY, n.: A statement or belief manifestly inconsistent with one's own opinion.
    5. Re:Interested.... by pizzaman100 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Whoo-hoo-hoo, look who knows so much. It just so happens that your air here is only MOSTLY dry. There's a big difference between mostly dry and all dry. Mostly dry is slightly wet. -Magical Max

    6. Re:Interested.... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I do not believe this is a scam - roughly 15 years ago or so a bunch of guys and me built a couple of scale models of vertical mills with aerofoil blades generating lift, the mill both faced windward in whatever direction the wind decided to come from as well as spun faster than a bat out of hell to put it mildly, quite a lot faster than the windspeed if built correctly is quite possible - These mills will basically blaze away!!!

      Unfortunately we never got around to putting any form of electricity generation equipment or water/warmpumps rotor concept onto them as we planned (maelstroems/turbolence in the water to extract the potential energy)

        - We have for years been putting off finishing the half built full size mill parked in the basement, maybe it's time to find the right bearings that can take the correct angle of pressure etc. and slam that hunk of junk together and start generating some $$$ from the savings as well as doing something right for the environment.

      And the neat thing is that we have independent witnesses from several countries who can back us up regarding what we built and the principles involved so there will be no patent BS to stop us from doing whatever we'd like with our concept.

      So No - I do not for one second believe this might be a scam, but I hope the guy simply decides to share his idea freely as his earnings will be far higher than mere money when the chips fall. Heck he could surely make quite some cash if he spoke to the right people - no need for patents - just get production started - If the concept is as revulutionizing as the article mentions then the need will far exceed production capabilities anyway - plenty to take from.

      He could in life as well as later be remembered as a pioneer - And if the concept is realized as a stroke of genious - people might just listen to the next thing he might hatch.

      Just my two cents...

    7. Re:Interested.... by Lord_Dweomer · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I'm guessing that it is more of a constant trickle. Doubt it would generate much electricity.

      IANAEE (I am not an electrical engineer) but if this thing can generate water, AND wind power...wouldn't it be a self-powered fuel cell? The process of separating the hydrogen could be powered by the wind-generated electricity it would seem. I'd love for someone with much more understanding of the physics behind this to tear apart my idea but this thing sounds damned useful. Not sure how small it could be made and still maintain its effectiveness but imagine giving a portable version of this to sailors. If you could create drinking water and electricity from this while floating on the ocean that would be a real life saver.

      --
      Buy Steampunk Clothing Online!
  2. Dune by RAMMS+EIN · · Score: 4, Funny

    Wow. Reminds me of the Windtraps from Frank Herbert's Dune.

    Next thing you know, we'll be harvesting spice.

    --
    Please correct me if I got my facts wrong.
  3. Free Dry Land! by nbannerman · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Excellent, so now anyone living near, but not in a city can enjoy a barren landscape when the rain no longer falls.

    Alright, sarcasm aside, surely there are bound to be some less-than-good effects on the surrounding enviroment if large amounts of water are 'sucked' out of the atmosphere prematurely?

  4. Hmmn, implied refrigeration by davecb · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Anything that creates lift creates a lower pressure, which in turn refrigerates, and eventually induces condensation.

    A Mere Matter of Programming to model an aerodynamic shape that maximizes condensation and captures the resulting droplets.

    --dave

    --
    davecb@spamcop.net
  5. it's a competition by macadamia_harold · · Score: 5, Funny

    [Max] Whisson's design has many blades, each as aerodynamic as an aircraft wing,

    Yeah, but you know Schick is just going to add one more blade and totally steal his marketshare.

  6. Re:Something doesn't add up... by Marxist+Hacker+42 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    So, condensing water from the air to water trees, from which some of the water will transpire back to the atmosphere, might improve local rainfall? Is that like the "lose money on every sale, but we make it up in volume" line? :)

    No, it's more that this windmill does what trees in a rainforest are already doing. Israel noticed this some time ago, and spent most of the 1960s and 1970s on something similar, though theirs was based on water pumped out of salinated lakes and the Medditeranian, and placed in desalination tanks. The fresh water was used for tree farms, that created more rainfall by cooling the air.

    Therefore, the windmill in this situation is just a placeholder for what the trees will do anyway once they're mature enough.

    --
    SJW: a person who perceives an injustice, and while correcting it, commits a greater injustice.
  7. Where's the need come from? by Lazerf4rt · · Score: 4, Funny

    Does this country face a more urgent issue? Will the world have a greater problem? While we watch our dams dry, our rivers die, our lakes and groundwater disappear...

    Forgive me for being unaware of this impending catatrophe, but is there really an urgent issue? Is this mainly happening in Australia? I thought floods were going to be the next big problem, due to global warming.

    What should I be bracing myself for? Floods or droughts? I need to know what I should panic about. Thanks.

  8. Stop smoking crack naysayers by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Compare the volume of air that any good-sized unit can draw moisture from (and assuming 100% efficiency which is BS) to the total volume of air passing across the area. That's like saying too many windmills will stop the wind blowing. Stop smoking crack.

  9. Re:Hand out the Moisturizer by Dachannien · · Score: 4, Funny

    Around here, we have a novel system for collecting moisture from the air in the dead of winter.

    We have a widespread system of asphalt-covered concrete which collect the copious moisture, extracted from the nearby lake due to atmospheric pressure differentials, in the form of a thick residue. We then dissolve large amounts of highly soluble compounds into this residue to prevent it from freezing solid, and then the mixture is processed by repeatedly compressing it under several hundred pounds of weight.

    We use the resulting product to support both the automobile and landscaping industries, by using it to rust out car underbodies and kill treelawn grass.

  10. Re:But why not? by putaro · · Score: 4, Funny

    Well, the best would be more of a turbine like arrangement, but then the shit would really hit the fan.