Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Comcast and Net Speed Tests

Posted by kdawson on from the mystery-but-in-a-good-way dept.

JimDaGeek writes "I recently moved to Columbia, SC where I have Time Warner as my cable ISP and pay for an 8 Mbps connection and have been very happy with the service, speed, and reliability. In contrast I have heard bad things about Comcast. So now that I am up in the Philadelphia PA area visiting my parents, I decided to test out the speed and reliability using the Speakeasy speed test. The results surprised me. Here are the reported download speeds in Kbps: New York, 18,946; Washington, 15,821; Atlanta, 11,257; Chicago, 10,042; San Francisco, 4,230. What is going on? I know my father is not paying for a 10+ Mbps connection. Is Comcast giving priority to popular speed-test sites?" From Comcast's site, in the Philadelphia area they seem to offer download speeds of 6 or 8 Mbps, with an option for a "PowerBoost" to 12 Mbps on large files. This wouldn't explain the results JimDaGeek got of almost 19 Mbps down.

Update: 07/10 12:07 GMT by KD : A friend in Massachusetts had a tree fall on his house. The Comcast guy who reconnected the lines told him that they are boosting the line speed to 20 Mbps down / 2 Mbps up in certain areas to be more competitive with Verizon FiOS.

5 of 290 comments (clear)

  1. SpeedTest.net by ragnarok · · Score: 5, Informative

    The Speakeasy speed test is just a re-branded version of speedtest.net. They have a lot more test locations to choose from there.

    --
    Search first, ask questions later.
    1. Re:SpeedTest.net by Lumpy · · Score: 5, Informative

      and it's a worthless test.

      One big transfer != bandwidth capabilities.

      Give me 100-500 smaller files with smaller ACK going back. that gives you a real test that will show latency and jitter.

      also check many different ports. Port 80 get's priority. Ports above 8000 get lower priority. Ports for Voip are screwed with hard.

      --
      Do not look at laser with remaining good eye.
  2. Download a linux distro by Raleel · · Score: 4, Informative

    Someone above mentioned using jigdo to get all of debian, but even using wget to get a full dvd or cd set of some distro will provide you with a good data point. That's been my standard test for quite a few years now.

    --
    -- Who is the bigger fool? The fool or the fool who follows him? --
  3. 20 Meg Cable Modems Practical Since 1999. by Dave+Burstein · · Score: 5, Informative
    19 megabits on an unloaded cable modem node is quite practical, especially for brief speed tests.The U.S. cable modem architecture is based around nodes that share 35 megabits or so downstream. RCN even sells a 20 megabit service, which David Reed buys and reports gives him the promised 20 megabits most of the time. In practice, most nodes run with 5-10 megabits typical load, as only a fraction of the time multiple users on one node simultaneously download megabits and fill the pipe. Statistical multiplexing (sharing) works much better than people expect on cable modem networks, especially on well managed nets that split nodes and otherwise expand capacity when needed because a node gets frequently congested.

    Comcast and cable suppliers are working on several techniques to allow customers to get more than the 6 or 8 meg typically allocated, while not causing undue congestion. "Speed burst" technology tests the network load, and if uncongested temporarily raises the speed of an individual modem making a fast download for a brief period. While that's marketed as "doubling" speeds to 12 and 16 megabits, bursts to 20 and 25 megabits are also practical.

    The new technologies require upgraded equipment and are typically being tested first and then rolled out market by market. So it would be no surprise if a subscriber in Philadelphia (Comcast's home town) is benefiting from a test or early deployment of faster speeds than Comcast customers elsewhere.

    100 megabit+ (shared) cable modems are being deployed in Japan, Quebec, and France, bonding 3 or 4 35 megabit channels for higher speeds. These are early "DOCSIS 3.0" products, unlikely to be widely deployed in the U.S. until 2009. Comcast's CEO, Brian Roberts, demonstrated 100 megabits at the cable show in Las Vegas this spring, and will probably test widely in 2008 and go into deployment (especially where Verizon is building FIOS) the following year. DOCSIS 3.0 requires a new cable modem unit, however, so this customer is unlikely to be an early tester.

    That doesn't explain why the test to San Francisco only ran at 4 megabits, which could be explained by node congestion a few minutes later, inferior Comcast backbone connections to Speakeasy's host in San Francisco, or other circumstances. For more details on coming faster cable modems, google DOCSIS 3.0.

    Dave Burstein

    Editor, DSL Prime

  4. REAL BANDWITH TEST by logik3x · · Score: 5, Informative

    http://miranda.ctd.anl.gov:7123/ Can't stand seeing people using speedtest.net, MOD THIS UP!