Slashdot Mirror


Fructose As Culprit In the Obesity Epidemic

drewtheman writes "According to an interview with Dr. Robert Lustig, Professor of Pediatric Endocrinology from the University of California, San Francisco, fructose, once touted as diabetic-friendly because it doesn't raise insulin levels directly, could be a major culprit for the obesity epidemic, high blood pressure, and elevated blood levels of LDL in Americans and others worldwide as they adopt American-style diets. Fructose comprises 50% of table sugar and up to 90% of high-fructose corn syrup, both ingredients found in copious quantity in most American prepared foods."

12 of 821 comments (clear)

  1. Isn't that at obvious? by janrinok · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Excessive quantities of anything is not good for the diet. It has been known for decades that high quantities of carbohydrates can cause weight increase. The confusion here is linking fructose as being good for diabetics (yes, and it still is in reasonable quantities) and excessive consumption of fructose leading to obesity.

    --
    Have a look at soylentnews.org for a different view
  2. Re:from the "no shit" dept. by Optikschmoptik · · Score: 5, Insightful

    How long have nutritionists been telling us this?

    At least as long as Fat Land has been out, but probably a bit longer than that. The story of American obesity is the story of American corn subsidies, which is therefore the story of high-fructose corn syrup and omnipresent, cheaper-than-water soda; and the story of vending machines and fast-food restaurants, 'family-style' Applebee's-like chains that exist solely to help burn off the excess corn stock by selling almost nothing but corn and its byproducts.

    Don't tell the presidential candidates though, they have to win in Iowa!

  3. Well maybe... by gowen · · Score: 5, Insightful

    But the smart money is still on "Burgers".

    / and no concept of portion control.

    --
    Athletic Scholarships to universities make as much sense as academic scholarships to sports teams.
  4. And in other news......... by axia777 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Pie is tasty and the sky will be blue tomorrow. No shit fructose is bad for us. It is pure simple sugars. The only fructose that IS good for humans is the fruit kind. And that is not simple sugar. Don't drink Soda Pop and always check the labels for High Fructose Corn Syrup. It is says it has it, don't buy it. That shit should be illegalized in most foods.

  5. um no by eneville · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I hate articles like this. The reader should not be blaming a single food as a CAUSE for obesity. The cause is that the consumer should not be eating large quantities of anything. Personally if anything is to blame then its the consumer for not getting off their ass and actually preparing food, going for a bike ride, or doing some running. Simple exercise like washing up has now been replaced with a dish washer, we mow lawns with electric/petrol mowers, and we don't even write letters by hand either, soon voice recognition will replace keyboard work. When will the world learn that as physical creatures we depend on a good, fresh diet and plenty of exercise.

  6. Re:from the "no shit" dept. by Optikschmoptik · · Score: 4, Insightful

    No, while "fast-food" style serving may contribute to creating bad habits, the main culprit is still what people eat

    First of all, you walked about 6 times the distance that might be considered the maximum for an American before getting into a car and driving :) . But yeah, of course, it's what is in the vending machines that counts. Next time you're in the States, see if you can buy something from a vending machine without some type of corn or corn-syrup or corn-byproduct as a major ingredient (sometimes it's even in 'diet' products, which have their own set of health threats). I won't say it's impossible, but it's not easy either. The stuff is cheap as dirt to produce, and has long been known to be extremely efficient for conversion and storage as fat.

    Fast-food in the States is essentially cheap food. It's there because its corn-syrup ingredients are so cheap to produce and easy to maintain and transport (bonus: it doubles as a preservative). Most of this vending-machine / fast-food / suburban-feed-bag (TGIFriday's et al.) industry is built around this cheapness and ease. They are symptoms. I would guess that vending machines in Japan are the result of a different economic cause.

  7. Re:from the "no shit" dept. by superdude72 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The Japanese meal you describe sounds somewhat healthier than the American fast food diet of:

    Two beef patties slathered with carbohydrate-rich condiments sandwiched between carbohydrate-rich bread, served with a side of carbohydrate-rich french fries and a 32 oz. cup of high fructose corn syrup. All super-sized because the marginal cost of the ingredients is so low, it is profitable for the restaurants to offer extra portions for a premium.

    The innocuous-seeming bun, even, is so loaded with refined carbohydrates that you might as well be eating your hamburger in the middle of a donut sliced in half.

  8. Re:Thank ADM, Cargill and their lobbyists. by TubeSteak · · Score: 5, Insightful

    But the GP is right too. You don't HAVE to buy pre-processed foods. 95% of the crap sold in grocery stores just isn't good for you. You can buy the ingredients and make it yourself like your mother may have done.
    For poor people, even the ingredients that they can afford tend to be shit. High in fats, sugars and/or salt. Low quality meat and pre-processed canned/boxed foods are also much cheaper than fresh ingredients.

    Not to mention that some people's mothers are busy working two or more jobs and don't have time for anything besides a McDonalds quality dinner.

    http://foodstampchallenge.typepad.com/
    Voluntarily eating at/below the poverty level will change your perspective.
    --
    [Fuck Beta]
    o0t!
  9. Personal Experience by 605dave · · Score: 4, Insightful

    A few years ago I became aware of HFCS, and was amazed at how pervasive it is. With the birth of my son I needed to lose weight, and was starting to really be aware of what I ate. I changed two things about my lifestyle. I eliminated almost all HFCS (mostly sodas), and started exercising more regularly. I lost 60 pounds, and have kept it off. I don't know about any of the scientific arguments, but my experience tells me HFCS has a big role to play in out society's weight issues. There are other factors, including exercise which I mentioned. But if you want to get creeped out, go to a convenience store and try to find something without corn syrup in some form. Perhaps the weight loss can party be credited to the fact that I eat better foods and drink more water by avoiding HFCS. But the bottom line is this. For me, getting rid of HFCS either caused me to lose weight directly, or forced me to eat healthier by avoiding it.

    --
    Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a difficult battle. - Plato
  10. Re:Thank ADM, Cargill and their lobbyists. by Gabrill · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Sorry, but the less expensive arguement doesn't hold water. Homecooked food is faster than any restaurant food, but it's certainly not cheaper than boxed meals. Better, yes. Not cheaper.

    --
    Always going forward, 'cause we can't find reverse.
  11. Misplaced priorities by FranTaylor · · Score: 4, Insightful

    It's funny with people: you threaten to take away their donuts and their soda, and they get all riled up, but you take away their civil liberties, and they don't seem to care very much.

  12. Re:Nasty aftertaste by Eli+Gottlieb · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Most people who smugly criticize America from abroad are European. If they angrily criticize America for what it did to their country, they're from South America or the Middle East. If they laugh at how much money they make off stupid Americans, they're from Asia.

    The one exception is that Britons seem to have some understanding that their food is scarcely better than ours.