Slashdot Mirror


G.I. Joe No Longer the Real American Hero?

Advocate123 writes "Clearly, Hollywood has forgotten the, 'Real American Hero.' G.I. Joe originally symbolized the American WWII soldier and a great generation. Now Hollywood celebrities are going to turn him into a international multicultural coed task force with no government affiliations. Isn't anything sacred to these people?"

15 of 548 comments (clear)

  1. GI = Government Issue by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    Ask anyone who's been in the military

  2. WAAAAAHH FOXNEWS WAAAAAAHHHH!!!! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Informative

    fucking whiny biotch

    1. Re:WAAAAAHH FOXNEWS WAAAAAAHHHH!!!! by Ticklemonster · · Score: 2, Informative

      Negative one, flamebait? That's one of the best posts I've seen here in ages. Directly to the point. That person ought to get a freaking award. The little bit of news that Fox broadcasts is right on the money, and non biased. It's the opinion shows that Fox broadcasts that make people on the left direct so much hatred towards Fox news. Funny thing is, it's not the news portion of Fox news that they are complaining about. So their complaints are basically nutty. America was built on the right to an opinion, why does the left try so hard to silence any opinion they don't agree with, then say that the right is unAmerican?

      --
      Karma: Bad is the liberal way of saying this guy won't drink the kool aid here on slash dot. I wear my Karma with pride
    2. Re:WAAAAAHH FOXNEWS WAAAAAAHHHH!!!! by Homr+Zodyssey · · Score: 2, Informative

      why does the left try so hard to silence any opinion they don't agree with, then say that the right is unAmerican? ...For the same reason that the right does.
  3. Re:Didn't it stand for... by Digital+Vomit · · Score: 2, Informative

    No, G.I. stands for Government Issue.

    --
    Modern copyright is theft of culture from everyone and it retards the progress of the useful arts and sciences.
  4. Re:It's about freaking time! by xs650 · · Score: 2, Informative

    "1. My understanding was that GI stood for General Infantry."

    It stands for Government Issue.

  5. Re:It's about freaking time! by eimerkopf · · Score: 2, Informative

    Apparently, GI originally stood for "Galvanized Iron" and was then later extended, based on the misunderstnading that it stood for "Government Issue." See the the current version of the wikipedia page and references therein.

  6. Re:Damn It! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    Yeah because western governments would never resort to violence against Greenpeace, right?

  7. Re:Damn It! by ricegf · · Score: 3, Informative

    "The Greatest Generation" did much more that just show up in the right place at the right time. It's easy to look back now and say how easy it was to make so many right decisions at such a critical time in history, but back then they struggled with overwhelming issues and yet managed to be united and purposeful - and therefore overcame.

    Among other accomplishments, they:

    • Fought and won a two front war against two powerful, highly immoral military dictatorships that not only sought to conquer the world (in reality, not Hollywood-ese) but to murder entire races and classes of people;
    • Rebuilt both defeated countries into modern economic, republican powers and allies (the allies helped, of course, but I'm drawing a distinction with the punative post-WWI "reparations" laws that proved so foolish);
    • Laid a working foundation for international dispute resolution (as opposed to the worthless League of Nations) that has survived to this day without become irrelevant (for the most part);
    • Generated a huge post-war economic boom that dramatically improved the quality of life for a large percentage of the population; and
    • Laid the foundations upon which the Cold War could be won without WWIII and (especially) the use of nuclear weapons.

    All in all, not a bad days work IMHO.

    (The "enormous debt habit" was not a product of The Greatest Generation, who were a uniformly thrifty and cash-based society except during WWII itself. See http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/fy2007/pdf/hi st.pdf (PDF file, starting pp 126) for the data - but national debt relative to GDP declined every year from 1946 (end of WWII) until 1981. The "enormous debt habit" was my generation, Bucky - show a little respect! :-/)

    I don't propose TGG were perfect by any means. Discrimination against certain classes of people were not eradicated (though they certainly didn't invent the concept!), although some of the worst abuses were indeed addressed (lynchings, for example, dropped out of popular acceptance, and the accomplishments of some Blacks were finally acknowledged and recognized, if only out of embarrassment for how much had gone unrecognized in the past). And the foundations for defeat were also laid, resulting most notably in the Vietnam war (where allied soldiers were required to bomb empty jungles lest we hurt any Russian advisors - idiots!).

    But compared to the moral confusion and lack of clear and unified purpose in the current generation, I think they did pretty darned good against overwhelming odds, and are worthy of the title bestowed by the popular media. YMMV, of course.

  8. Re:In other news.... by I(rispee_I(reme · · Score: 5, Informative

    G.I. Joe came in two flavors:

    1) Older, barbie-doll size toys, with clothes you could change and such. These are probably what the antediluvians at Fox News are witnessing the corruption of. This toy line was produced from 1942-1982. While this toy line was a success, it predated the tendency of toy manufacturers to sell a storyline with their products, which began in earnest with He-man and the Masters of the Universe, circa 1981. As such, this version of G.I. Joe had no villains to contend against until around 1976, when a line of alien invaders villains, called "Intruders" was introduced in a tacked-on fashion. Since almost no one knows about the Intruders, I submit that a "G.I. Joe vs. The Intruders from Space Movie" would be rather unpopular.

    Which leaves us with...

    2) A line of toys produced from 1982 until the present day, with a few pauses. This toy line, unlike the original, was based upon the marvel comic book, and utilized a wide array of science-fiction and fantasy devices, such as mad scientists (Dr. Mindbender), masked villains (Cobra and Destro), and even went so far as to integrate Robert E. Howard's myth of a prehuman, reptilian civilization in the animated movie.

    The second incarnation of G.I. Joe was inclusive by design (including both the token black and the token female in the original roster), and fought a war on terror that could never end, because Cobra was an undying hydra of a terrorist organization (sound familiar?)

    The multiculturalization of G.I. Joe that the article complains about actually took place over 20 years ago. Why were there no protests then? Perhaps because we were in the midst of a cold war, and people had something better to do than piss and moan about a toy line/cartoon/movie. Or perhaps because we as a culture realized that if we made certain classes of citizens feel unwelcome in our military, we would:

    a) Weaken the military.
    b) Look like the "unfree", "antidemocratic" culture we were nominally opposing.

    Just an idea. I rather lean towards the "better things to do" theory.

    I probably got some trivial detail re: G.I. Joe incorrect. I feel I can reliably depend upon the legions of their fandom to correct me. For the most part, though, the above information is accurate, and the linked-to article is a bunch of jingoist hysteria.

    Next week on slashdot: The global Zionist conspiracy forces Microsoft to keep its products closed-source!

  9. Really Old News, its been that way since 1966 by arthurpaliden · · Score: 2, Informative

    GIJoe has always been multi-national and multi-gender.

    In 1966's you could get the 12" G.I. Joe SOLDIERS OF THE WORLD SERIES which included:German, Japanees, Russian, British , Australian, Canadian and French

    In 1967 you could get the Action Nurse (Female)

    In 1967 he was also a race car driver and state trooper.

    In 1967 he was also a member of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police

  10. Sigh. by stonecypher · · Score: 2, Informative

    GI Joe was just the American branch of the Joes, has been since the 1970s. They're not dropping the Americanism, they're just aiming the camera higher up the tree. We got a dozen Joes (and Viper the matching villains) from other countries, including every eight year olds' favorite opponents, Storm Shadow and Snake Eyes. If you're going to be nationalistic about the history of a toy series, at least know the history of the toy series. (Indeed, in the 1980s cartoon block about the energy pyramids, several people comment that there aren't that many Americans on the group, and ask Duke why he's still calling them GIs.)

    If you think calling GI Joe an American is "sacred," you really need to read some books.

    --
    StoneCypher is Full of BS
  11. Re:be fair now.. by Scrameustache · · Score: 3, Informative

    Fortunately, if there are US christians who openly advocated violence against other countries in order to convert their population, they are not in positions of power. "President Bush said to all of us: 'I am driven with a mission from God'. God would tell me, 'George go and fight these terrorists in Afghanistan'. And I did. And then God would tell me 'George, go and end the tyranny in Iraq'. And I did."

    Mr Bush went on: "And now, again, I feel God's words coming to me, 'Go get the Palestinians their state and get the Israelis their security, and get peace in the Middle East'. And, by God, I'm gonna do it."

    Mr Bush, who became a born-again Christian at 40, is one of the most overtly religious leaders to occupy the White House, a fact which brings him much support in middle America.
    --

    You can't take the sky from me...

  12. Re:be fair now.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    They should be likewise contained. Fortunately, if there are US christians who openly advocated violence against other countries in order to convert their population, they are not in positions of power.

    "No, I don't know that atheists should be considered as citizens, nor should they be considered patriots. This is one nation under God."
    - George W. Bush

  13. Re:In other news.... by pimpimpim · · Score: 2, Informative
    Hmm, as a non-US-ian, I am not so much in favor of the right to carry arms, but since it is historically important to the US I won't discuss that now.

    What I do find interesting is that similar things are happening in Germany nowadays. The minister of interior Schüable got partially crippled 17 years ago when he was shot in an attack on him (he was then also minister of interior). Now, he is introducing a shitload of freedom-limiting laws, as you have read on slashdot this year (e.g. forbidding possession of 'hacking' tools). Strangely enough, he is actually in favor of the loosening of the right to carry arms, probably because he wants to carry arms himself, I have no real clue. For both your example as the current, one can say: for any political measure, fear should not be the reason behind it.

    --
    molmod.com - computing tips from a molecular modeling