Slashdot Mirror


CMU Professor Randy Pausch's 'Last Lecture'

This is a bit of an unusual story for Slashdot- it's the "Last Lecture" of a professor at CMU who is terminally ill. His early research in VR has benefited everyone and even if you have never heard of Randy Pausch I think this is worth your time. It's a 2 hour long wmv filled with insight, laughs and wisdom from a man who has really done some amazing work. I've been watching it all morning and I think it would really be worth your time if you can spare it to listen to what he has to say. From virtual reality to education to stuffed animals and childhood dreams, there's a lot here worth your time. Thanks drew for the link. Update: 09/21 15:44 GMT by Z : The link is already a little shakey, so you might want to turn to this cut up YouTube version of the talk instead.

93 comments

  1. Moving.. by kraemate · · Score: 5, Insightful

    I havent seen the lecture, but the story in some Pittsburgh newspaper (sorry, dont have the link - it appeared on reddit yesterday) is really moving. Amazing, so 'close' to death but still in such good spirits. Sad that i came to know of such a great spirit when i know i wont be hearing more from/about him. Sad indeed.

    1. Re:Moving.. by kraemate · · Score: 5, Informative

      Here is the good article describing the lecture, for those who cannot download the lecture itself.
      http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/07262/818671-85.stm

    2. Re:Moving.. by Seumas · · Score: 1, Troll

      It's too bad we put ridiculous priorities on things. Imagine what we could cure, probably including his terminal illness, if we only had a trillion dollars to spare on research.

      Gee, if only there were some place we could find a trillion dollars in the last four or five years of the budget that was wasted and could have been better spent improving the world.

      Hmm.

      Can't think of any place, whatsoever.

    3. Re:Moving.. by Mindwarp · · Score: 5, Informative

      To be honest you're probably not going to find a cure for Pancreatic cancer any time soon, even with a trillion dollars thrown at it. The problems with this form of cancer are:

      1) It's in the endocrine system, meaning it has easy access to a lot of other vital organs that the cancer can spread to,
      2) The pancreas is vital to survival (it produces insulin, as well as a host of pancreatic enzymes that the body needs to be able to process food and regulate metabolism) so you can't just chop the whole thing out if it becomes cancerous
      3) It's nestled in the middle of a complex set of nerves, arteries and veins meaning that it's extremely difficult, and often impossible, to perform surgical or radiation treatments,
      4) Screening programs often don't work, as the cancer is completely capable of developing without showing up in any blood tests,
      5) This is the real kicker - the early symptoms of PC are identical to a host of other minor illnesses such as gallstones, back ache, indigestion or acid reflux. By the time the symptoms have become serious enough for the patient to go to the doctor with them, and by the time the doctor has ruled out all the simpler ailments the symptoms point to, it's almost always too late. That's why this disease has a 5 year mortality rate of 98% and a 1 year mortality rate of over 75%, along with being the U.S.'s most fatal cancer.

      Even if we could implement an accurate and early-detection screening programme, the cancer is so aggressive that we really need a paradigm shift away from current radiation and chemotherapy treatments. It's not so much that we're lacking money in researching into new forms of treatment as it is we're lacking the knowledge necessary to advance in these areas right now. There are plenty of well funded people working to solve the problems of cancer - right now we're waiting for one of them to have the 'eureka!' moment.

      --
      The gift of death metal does not smile on the good looking.
    4. Re:Moving.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      War on Poverty? Never Ending Welfare?

    5. Re:Moving.. by Relic+of+the+Future · · Score: 1
      Seeing his lecture (the live link was spread around among CMU graduates), it seems to me that, even before his diagnosis, Pausch lived every day as if it could be his last.

      I think that's perhaps the main reason why, despite his situation, he's in as good spirits as he is.

      --
      Those who fail to understand communication protocols, are doomed to repeat them over port 80.
    6. Re:Moving.. by sjdude · · Score: 1

      It is not often in life that someone tells you important things, and when they do, you should listen. What Randy Pausch has to say in this 'last lecture' is important. He is, in fact, teaching us to the very end.

    7. Re:Moving.. by HuguesT · · Score: 2, Informative

      The problem is that cancer is not *a* disease. All cancers are different, have different causes, and are even sometime heterogeneous within one single patient, meaning some cancer cells will respond well to a kind of treatment, but not others. It only takes one surviving cancer cell to restart the whole thing. The odds of beating this soon are slim.

  2. Worth it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    I'm just not sure that it's worth my time.

    1. Re:Worth it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I watched the entire video and it was okay. Certainly not what I expected. I wanted some deep philosophical insights into life and death but he mostly talked about his career and realizing his childhood dreams.

    2. Re:Worth it? by syphax · · Score: 1, Funny


      It would clearly interfere with your valuable ./ commenting time.

      --
      Simple Unexpected Concrete Credible Emotional Stories
  3. He made an impact on my life. by readin · · Score: 1, Interesting

    He was the man who introduced me to Doom.

    --
    I often don't like the choices people make, but I like the fact that people make choices. That's why I'm a conservative.
    1. Re:He made an impact on my life. by viega · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Haha, me too (I was one of Randy's students back when he was at UVa). I didn't get too into Doom, but when the Quake test code came out, many of us spent pretty much every waking hour playing, for several months. In the meantime, we were supposed to be working on an Alice deliverable for SIGGRAPH. I think the turning point for my entire life was a few months before SIGGRAPH, when Randy called a couple of us out for being too much play and not enough work. I went cold turkey, and didn't pick up another video game for 10 years. I firmly believe if he hadn't done that, I'd have accomplished very little professionally, and would be holding down a crappy 9-5 mid-level programming job while thinking forward to what I was going to play on my XBox 360 on any given night. To this day, I can't really get much enjoyment out of a video game, but I think that's a good thing! Randy definitely taught me to pick a prize and keep my eye on it. He used to like to tell me, "John, you're a strong rocket with no fins," that I would never get to the moon and would come crashing back to earth if I didn't focus. I didn't like it at the time, but I needed to hear it. I think about that advice all the time, and it is just as relevant to me today. Randy has always attracted amazing talent and amazing people. The people in that lab were the greatest group of people I ever worked with in many respects. I'm proud they're my friends, and I'm thankful to Randy for providing the environment and putting us together.

    2. Re:He made an impact on my life. by ari_b · · Score: 1

      Randy has had a similar effect for me in the almost-15 years since I first enrolled in one of his classes at UVa. Some of the lessons didn't sink in at first (my fault, not his!), but over time I realized how rare Randy was and how fortunate I was to have met such a teacher and mentor. Nowadays, one of my most valuable tools for any major decision (and even some of the small ones) is to ask myself, "Would I be embarrassed to tell Randy about this?".

      Not many people make you want to live up to their standard. Even fewer have the desire and ability to teach us how. Randy has given all of us a great gift.

    3. Re:He made an impact on my life. by 6Yankee · · Score: 1

      Would that all of us could live to read something so moving about ourselves, to know we made a difference.

  4. Saw him on GMA this morning by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    He's awesome. Sad, though, that fate turned this way for him. I hope I can take it in that much stride when my time comes.

    1. Re:Saw him on GMA this morning by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Have you seen Ingmar Bergman's film The Seventh Seal ? It's got some good lessons about how to stop fearing death. Of course, this guy isn't just accepting death, he's keeping good humor to the very end, which is more than most people are capable of.

  5. Slashdot stories by flynt · · Score: 5, Insightful

    This is actually the type of story I love to see on Slashdot. A nice break from yet another "YRO" stuff.

  6. Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by antifoidulus · · Score: 3, Insightful

    because they are worried that anything over 10 minutes is probably a copyright violation....they should at least create some mechanism whereby material that provably doesn't violate copyrights could have more than 10 minutes alloted to it....how you would prove it is another issue entirely, but I would imagine they could implement some type of peer review system.

    1. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by Ian+Lamont · · Score: 1

      What about storage costs? Those data centers ain't cheap ...

    2. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

      You can find the full version on Google Video.

    3. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by kebes · · Score: 2, Insightful

      they should at least create some mechanism whereby material that provably doesn't violate copyrights could have more than 10 minutes alloted to it....
      YouTube evidently is able to serve up videos past the 10-minute limit. The official Google channel and the Google Talks channel have plenty of long videos. So, at least for those trusted channels the limit doesn't exist. I'm not sure if there is any way to get YouTube to trust your channel.

      how you would prove it is another issue entirely, but I would imagine they could implement some type of peer review system.
      Frankly the 10-minute limit is a small impediment to copyright infringement. People just split the work into multiple pieces (numbered "1/9" to "9/9" or whatever), and it's quite easy for a YouTube viewer to simply queue up all the pieces to play one after the other. So, really, what's the point of the 10-minute restriction?

      One thing I can say is that community flagging isn't the answer. You can currently flag content on YouTube, but the fact is that a large portion of the community wants the copyrighted content on YouTube, and thus won't actively participate in flagging it as infringing (or conversely will actively flag infringing content as "okay")... not to speak of the fact that the viewer has no way of knowing whether permission was given for a particular posting. Some TV shows have YouTube channels where they post material, but how is a viewer supposed to tell the difference between sanctioned channels and unsanctioned ones?
    4. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by Biffer4810 · · Score: 1

      Sorry, but you're incorrect (if a single counter-example proves such).

      My favorite channel on youtube has plenty of videos over 10 minutes. (http://www.youtube.com/viperkeeper) This is not meant as any sort of plug, I have no relationship with the director of this channel, other than being a fan.

      --
      -.-- -.-- --..
      One fish / Two fish / Red fish / Blue fish
      ShyaOS - Think Differently!
    5. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by Biffer4810 · · Score: 1

      I guess what I really wanted to point out in my original post is that I think it's a storage limit, rather than a time limit to avoid something so abstract as violating copyright...

      --
      -.-- -.-- --..
      One fish / Two fish / Red fish / Blue fish
      ShyaOS - Think Differently!
    6. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by kebes · · Score: 1

      I guess what I really wanted to point out in my original post is that I think it's a storage limit, rather than a time limit to avoid something so abstract as violating copyright...
      But a per-video limit doesn't make much difference to storage space if they allow you to upload an unlimited number of videos. Anyways, according to the official YouTube blog, the reason is indeed copyright concerns:

      we're constantly trying to balance the rights of copyright owners with the rights of our users. We poked around the system a bit and found that these longer videos were more likely to be copyrighted videos from tv shows and movies than the shorter videos posted.
      The blog post also explains how to become "trusted" so that you can go past the 10-minute limit:

      However, we also recognize that there are legit content creators out there who may have videos over 10 mins, so we've created a Premium Content Program for those of you with professional-produced videos.
      So, basically, if you are a "big player," YouTube will waive the 10-minute restriction. If you are a small, independent YouTube user, you are stuck with the 10-minute restriction. And the official reason is copyright concerns.
    7. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by Biffer4810 · · Score: 1

      I appreciate the research. The director I referenced had approximately 50 videos with thousands of views before any of them crossed 10 minutes. The pieces fit!

      --
      -.-- -.-- --..
      One fish / Two fish / Red fish / Blue fish
      ShyaOS - Think Differently!
    8. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by pilgrim23 · · Score: 1

      I miss the days of a avi mpg or mov YOU COULD DOWNLOAD and play instead of horrid bad codec rendered streamed dreck cut to heck. Oh yes I cna get usilt which allow me to download the dreck but WHY? I will wait till someome finally archives the real thing and

      --
      - Minutus cantorum, minutus balorum, minutus carborata descendum pantorum.
    9. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by Obiwan+Kenobi · · Score: 1

      This is not necessarily true. I have a video series for Magic the Gathering (youtube.com/mrorangeguy) and I am not a "big player" in the least. I began like everyone else, in the 10min limit. Then I begged and pleaded and bugged the hell out of them until I became a Director. This was about a year ago now.

      They've since changed the policy and the methods by which you become a Director, so this may be moot. However, I know I'm just a guy making videos with the tools he has and no corporate backing. I also read where they let those who they had already allowed 10+ minutes to keep this access when they changed said policy (To which I'm grateful, of course).

      Either way, they let people pass the limit when they show effort and ask. That's my experience, anyway.

    10. Re:Sad that youtube forces this stuff to be cut up by antdude · · Score: 1

      It could be on other video hosting site like Google Video (no limit I think). YouTube does offer no time length limit if you're a subscriber.

      --
      Ant(Dude) @ Quality Foraged Links (AQFL.net) & The Ant Farm (antfarm.ma.cx / antfarm.home.dhs.org).
  7. Amazing Lecture - Dare to Dream by NiMSiM · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It was an amazing lecture. If you dare to dream and dare to follow through, then he's the man to emulate.

    1. Re:Amazing Lecture - Dare to Dream by alyawn · · Score: 0, Redundant

      Agreed.

  8. Is there a torrent available? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I know all the links are streaming, but if anyone has a solid copy of it could you start up a torrent for the rest of /.?

    1. Re:Is there a torrent available? by Hatta · · Score: 2, Informative

      http://www.mininova.org/tor/900739

      Try that. I hope it's ok, I didn't have a chance to preview the wmv, no graphics on that machine.

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    2. Re:Is there a torrent available? by Hatta · · Score: 1

      I may have mangled the .wmv a bit. It's in an avi container but the data is wmv. mplayer should be able to play it.

      --
      Give me Classic Slashdot or give me death!
    3. Re:Is there a torrent available? by jeffbax · · Score: 1

      Or you can use the google video link, which is the full lecture not broken up.

      Randy's Last Lecture

    4. Re:Is there a torrent available? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Something missing there... I downloaded the original from mms://wms.andrew.cmu.edu/001/pausch.wmv and it was 252 MB. Your torrent file is way too small.

  9. Time management talk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Interesting

    It's kind of off-topic, but I read some inspirational lecture slides by Randy Pausch about time management a little while ago. In light of his illness, I guess there's two ways to take it: Perhaps time management isn't that important in the end, or perhaps the limited amount of time each of us may have makes it even more important.

    (Or, I suppose, the stress related to worrying about time management may affect your health...)

    1. Re:Time management talk by Alzheimers · · Score: 1

      How ironic, procrastinating from doing something else by reading a Time Management seminar.

    2. Re:Time management talk by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes... but at least it's better than writing a Slashdot comment about it. ;)

      Or a comment about a such a comment. :(

  10. The kind of news you don't want to hear... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Interesting

    This sucks.

    He was one of my classmates when I was going to graduate school in the CMU CS department (back then, it was "just" a department, not a school). He was a nice guy (and a bit of a clown).

    I hadn't kept in touch, so this is the first I've heard about the cancer. (And with three young children ...)

    Here's hoping he's among the "15% - 20%" for whom the pallative care actually extends life, and that his quality of life will be (as) good (as it can be).

  11. Great Professor by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    He was my professor at the University of Virginia, where he was befiore CMU, for an engineering course on Useability and Interfaces. His teaching style and enthusiasm really made a lasting impact. This is sad news indeed, he will be sorely missed.

    1. Re:Great Professor by viega · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Ah, yes, who could forget Randy taking out his frustrations with a VCR by smashing it with a sledge hammer on the first day of class? I definitely credit Randy and that class for getting me to prioritize the end users above almost everybody else.

  12. Re:What would you do? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Funny

    The word "more" in your post wasn't necessary.

  13. What can one say... by blind+biker · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This was the most valuable lecture I've ever attended. And it's the kind of lecture I can talk about with my girlfriend, with my friends, and with anyone I care about. It's the stuff of life.

    This man has lived an amazing life, and no doubt, this gives him the courage and the peace of mind to leave in such a graceful way, in an ultimate act of generosity. "Take a piece of me" he said somewhere at the beginning, when inviting people in the audience to take away his stuffed animals. And I feel I received a piece of him, even though I am thousands of kilometers away from this great person.

    If you want your children to persevere in their lives and reach their dreams, show them this lecture (I saw the videos on YouTube), and talk about it with them.

    --
    "The agriculture ministry is not in charge of Gundam" - Japanese ministry official.
  14. Time management is (probably) for the birds by Man+On+Pink+Corner · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Perhaps time management isn't that important in the end, or perhaps the limited amount of time each of us may have makes it even more important.

    Yeah, that's the question I had when I read through his PowerPoint slides yesterday morning, after the WSJ video came up in the course of my daily hour of mindless Fark surfing.

    Pausch's methods are great for people who value a highly-regimented life, or who require the same to accomplish anything at all. There are people like that, and maybe he's one of them, but he overgeneralizes to a criminal extent, IMHO. Most of the worthwhile things I've accomplished can trace their beginnings to sitting around daydreaming and doing not much of anything, or looking for an excuse to put something else off. Hell, I wouldn't have seen his video and slides in the first place if I hadn't been killing time surfing the Web, right?

    Ultimately, I spent half an hour watching the slides, and then went back to finish my daily list of unimportant links on Fark. I'll admit I was a little unsettled by one of the suggestions he raises ("Write your own eulogy. What do you want it to say?") because frankly, I don't know if people would find enough interesting things about me to even bother attending my funeral, and of course that bugs me. Everybody wants to leave a meaningful legacy, right? But ultimately, living by what you want your eulogist to say is just another way of living according to other people's standards. I finally managed to refute Pausch's dictums by imagining myself trying to persuade a Zen Buddhist practitioner to follow them.

    You have to go your own way in life, and if you're lucky, you'll have the chance to determine how you die as well. If I were in Prof. Pausch's shoes, I'd like to think I'd wrap things up on my own terms, with a .38 Mannlicher and a one-way ticket to Washington, D.C. Consequently, my eulogy would depend entirely on how I behaved during the last five minutes of my life. Why should anyone be all that concerned about what people have to say about my Fark and Slashdot habits?

    1. Re:Time management is (probably) for the birds by Tyler+Durden · · Score: 3, Interesting
      I finally managed to refute Pausch's dictums by imagining myself trying to persuade a Zen Buddhist practitioner to follow them.

      Actually Zen Buddhist monks live very strict, regimented, structured lives. Espcially those in Japan. They would consider anybody with a tendency to daydream or procrastinate as failing to live "in the moment". One great quote I remember hearing goes, "Don't do nothing. Do nothing." One monk from the non-fiction book "Ambivalent Zen" would pay any bills he received as soon as he received them so that he could better keep his mind clear.

      That said, I'd have a hard hard time changing my own daydreaming, procrastinating ways.

      --
      Happy people make bad consumers.
  15. Do NOT mod up GP! by perkr · · Score: 1

    GP video is the stupid Rick Rolled video.

  16. I am delighted - this is superb by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I so wish this "face" of the US was more visible outside the country instead of what Washington presently does. If the lessons here could be learned (as encore, read "the 8th habit") the nation would actually again represent leadership and I still believe that is possible.

    Let this talk be the inspiration.

  17. Met when @ UVA by sleight · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I had the pleasure of taking Randy's first course on "User Interfaces" back in 92 or 93. How many courses have you heard of where the professor begins the first class by assailing the poor UIs of clock radios and VCRs only to immediately smash them Gallagher style in front of a classroom of undergrads. Randy was one of three truly inspirational teachers that I had the pleasure of studying under during my entire formal education. I still retain and use much of the knowledge that I learned from him.

    Godspeed Randy.

  18. What do you think life and death is all about? by HarryCaul · · Score: 1


    It's what you do with what you got, and that's what he's about.

  19. watch it, learn from it by six11 · · Score: 3, Informative

    I was in the 10th row, or so. The talk was given in the biggest auditorium on campus, with overflow locations in other big rooms watching it onscreen. I have to say that this really was one of the most moving, intense moments I've ever experienced. This was compounded by the sense that it was being shared with thousands of other people laughing, thinking, and occasionally crying together. At the close of his talk he received a standing ovation that did not even begin to wane after what seemed like ten minutes, until Randy Bryant (in my opinion somewhat rudely) brought it to an end. For that hour, all of CMU was on the same page. In the days since then I've had conversations with several people who were there, and my sense is that people will remember the talk and Randy Pausch's message for the rest of their lives. I know I will. Especially since he's a nerdy smartass just like me.

    1. Re:watch it, learn from it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I watched the video, and it showed an amazingly obnoxious, pompous, opportunist man. Don't fall for the slogan that "this was his last talk" - that doesn't make it better. Bunch of "wise" slogans piled up.

  20. this is a lot more relevant than... by technoCon · · Score: 1

    I think this is a very pertinent slashdot topic. The fellow in question is a Computer Science prof. If he were a humanities prof, I'd feel less so. Sure, the story is a tear-jerker and contemplating the imminent demise of someone who's a nice guy is a downer.

    But I'd rather see this story on slashdot than something political. And I've seen far too much political bull on slashdot. If you wear a t-shirt that says Rush is Right or Impeach Cheney First, there's a 50% chance you'll end up nattering on about stuff that may be life-and-death stuff (yeah sure) but it won't be "news for nerds, stuff that matters." Right now, I'm wearing a t-shirt with Maxwell's equations on the back. And if yours says, Code Poet, we'll probably end up nattering on about stuff the poly sci types find boring.

    Dr. Pausch is an accomplished technologist and as a technologist I'll appreciate his views on career and personal goals. I'm also a cancer survivor and I hope he''ll do the impossible and beat the disease.

  21. Sorry for the guy but.. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    As usual the submitter went into overdrive: "His early research in VR has benefited everyone", uh,
    'Everyone'??

    I'd really like that people would avoid such kind of vain hyperbole..

  22. Fair play by memoriesofgreen · · Score: 0

    Good luck to the guy. I've just read the story, and all I can say is that I am immensely impressed. Such sang froid is a sight to behold. My heart goes out to this guy and his family.

    --
    in the long run, we're all dead anyway.
  23. He's in the Guinness World Records by javalizard · · Score: 2, Informative

    He is... under the label biggest dick and largest ego.

    His ego is, I swear to God, bigger than that of Steve Jobs, really, no joke. When I was in school at CMU he required an Interview (uppercase I) to get into his class. What kind of professor tells undergrads that they don't deserve to have "an educational experience" in 3d, VR, game technology, etc?

    I sumbitted. I didn't want to because i wholey disagreed with his philosophy of education. His class seemed interesting enough that i let it go. The interview went something like this:

    Me: Hello, Professor. Your class sounds very interesting and I'd like to take it.
    Randy: Hi. So your a white upper class yuppy student who thinks they deserves whatever they want. {sarcasm}Greeeeeaaaat.{/sarcasm} What aspect of my class are you interested in?

    I swear on the holy bible it was the first thing out of his mouth! He still admitted me to his class... I emailed him back saying i wasn't going to take it.

    Even though he was a complete ass-hole to me I still respect _some_ of the work he's done. One exception is this, I did a technology review of Alice at one point. It was not impressive coming from an experience of writing a 3d game engine and scripting system. He really does think he's "THE BIG SHIT" when in fact he is just "a shit."

    That is just my experience with him. Has anyone else met the guy?

    Dear Randy,
    I'm sorry to hear about your condition. No one deserves it. My positive thoughts tonight are with you. May you live a painless and pleasant life that remains. Also, could you not be a prick to those around you?
    javalizard

    1. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

      His ego is, I swear to God, bigger than that of Steve Jobs, really, no joke. When I was in school at CMU he required an Interview (uppercase I) to get into his class. What kind of professor tells undergrads that they don't deserve to have "an educational experience" in 3d, VR, game technology, etc?

      That's nothing. When I was at CMU, I was seated next to him at a dinner and he practically required an audition for me to keep the seat. And it wasn't even his dinner. It was honoring someone infinitely more gracious. He is a bizarre egomaniac who does like to make everything be about him. I don't think most nerds are equipped for it, so I think it often has a jarring, sometimes positive, impact.
    2. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by blahplusplus · · Score: 1

      "What kind of professor tells undergrads that they don't deserve to have "an educational experience" in 3d, VR, game technology, etc?"

      In my opinion he's right on the mark, I think he wanted to filter out weak students wouldn't survive in industry. Plus if I was in his position I wouldn't want students who are simply not interested in the work. Too many teachers have to deal with dumbing down their classes to the lowest common denominator. Not that I disagree that it can be hard or that maybe he's an idiot.

      But if I were him I'd probably do the same thing.

    3. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by javalizard · · Score: 1

      Yes it makes sense... Filters ARE needed for classes. But that's why they have required classes for a class. He took it to a completely new uncalled for level.

    4. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by DrRotwang · · Score: 1

      I agree completely. I was in one of his classes at CMU as well. I'm not happy to see anyone get a disease, but man, if I had to make a list of people who have to leave planet earth, Randy Pausch would be in the top 100. Egomaniacal self-centered narcissist that lied to, and about, his students. He's all show, all marketing, all glitz.

    5. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by spads · · Score: 1

      Though I cannot detract from some valid and very compelling things he said, ultimately I think he is a very interesting study in the modern academic culture. For one thing, he's got folks on one side saying he's brilliant, and on the other hand he said he blew his GREs. I have noticed that it isn't always the deserving who win in that game. The culture is self-serving, and likes to retain the ones who basically make them feel good. Honestly, I have to include the drive to increase women and minorities in IT in that camp as well.

      I appreciate hearing from the other side on this one. He has a definite animal magnetism, though the conflagratory ego is undeniable. Also, that brick wall metaphor he likes so much is interesting. (Kind of like ./'s moderation system!) Reminds me of Charles Bukowski's point about a culture who believes in hiding Easter eggs so you have to search for them. There is always more to the picture than meets the eye. Thanks... (& Cmdr Taco)

      --
      Bukowski said it. I believe it. That settles it.
    6. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by Rude-Boy · · Score: 1

      I love how even when you tell the story you come off as the self important jerk. Hilarious.

      Just because he required an interview for his course doesn't make him a jerk, it just means he wants people in the class who really want to be there. Similarly with his comment to you, I think he was looking for a little more then "I want to take it" as a reason for getting in.

    7. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by javalizard · · Score: 1

      Yup, Hilarious. All that talk of being greater than thou! WOW. Indeed.

      Requiring an interviewing for his course doesn't make him jerk. I just believe he doesn't understand pedagogy. Who would want to take a class whose professor, they believed, didn't understand the principles of undergraduate education?
      Alas, who says that kind of thing within the first 30 seconds of meeting someone? That's being a jerk.
      Have you ever been in an interview? You need to start somewhere. "I'm really excited to be here", "This job looks really interesting", etc. You don't start a _conversation_ with "Hello, I am qualified for this position because of this list of things... abcdef." That's not a conversation.

      Confusing these things make an ass out of me and you.

    8. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by Rakishi · · Score: 1

      Required classes are BS, trust me I should know as I easily met requirements despite not having what it takes (lazy and very intelligent). Just because you KNOW something doesn't mean you have the passion to take up to another level (so to say). For some classes dedication is a lot more important than knowledge. If you need to be in lab 40 hours a week for a class it doesn't matter how well you did beforehand if you don't have the will power to actually be in lab 40 hours a week.

    9. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by Rakishi · · Score: 1

      What kind of professor tells undergrads that they don't deserve to have "an educational experience" in 3d, VR, game technology, etc? The type who actually wants to provide a good experience to those who do get in. If it's a heavily team based class than a single fuck up can ruin it for half the class.
    10. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by Rakishi · · Score: 1

      There is more to life than passing some test and your intelligence doesn't matter as much as you think it does. In every single field who you know matters a whole lot more than anything else. Getting to know those people and knowing how to use them is a skill in itself. Likewise your intelligence is worthless if you can't work hard but also work smart, take advantage of your time in other words.

      Anyway he seems to have the ability to manage and drive people, something people utterly lacking them seem to enjoy dismissing. Someone with those skills are worth a lot more to a group than some socially inept geek.

    11. Re:He's in the Guinness World Records by greenspots · · Score: 1

      Any fool can criticize, condemn, and complain, and most fools do. ~Benjamin Franklin javalizard, I hope your family reads your comment here; they will be so proud - NOT!!

  24. best teacher I ever had by cknudsen · · Score: 2, Insightful

    I had Randy Pausch for an undergrad CS class at UVA in either 88 or 89.... so that was either his first or second year teaching there. Without a doubt, he was the best teacher I had in all four years. I can only imagine that he got even better after almost 20 years of practice. He truly engaged the students. I've been in the software business for 17 years now, and I continue to enjoy it today. I have to think he's partly the reason I ended up there (since I was in the EE program).

    --
    http://www.k5n.us
  25. Watched it all by rjamestaylor · · Score: 1

    And just want to say: thank you.

    --
    -- @rjamestaylor on Ello
  26. This guy is amazing. Reminds me of. . . by Fantastic+Lad · · Score: 2, Insightful
    I just watched the video via youtube, and was happily impressed. Randy carries his light and encourages others to do so, and thus makes ripples which go on to affect the world in very positive ways. He reminds me of Joseph Campbell ("Follow your Bliss") and Ray Bradbury ("Live on the edge of your hysteria") in this regard.

    Those two gents made a huge impact upon me when I was growing through high school, and all I had access to were a few recordings and videos of them speaking, but the philosophies they broadcast were powerful enough to change me forever.

    Teachers of this caliber are golden.

    The very best thing you can do for the world is to Live Your Light. --Just doing so and encouraging others to do so changes the world in ways which are not immediately obvious, but it is enough to win the war against the dark side.


    -FL

  27. Hardly the time for your bitter little rant by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The man's dying. A lot of people, myself included, respect him no end and will miss him greatly. So why don't you just hold your tongue, little man. Maybe after he's dead and buried you can tell the world all about his faults, failures, and the personal hurt he caused you. Maybe he had a few, no-one's perfect. But your pettiness says a lot more about you than it dooes about Pausch.

    Who's done more for the world, Randy Pausch or javalizard? Whose life do I value more? Pretty obvious, isn't it. Learn some respect for your betters. And if you can't do that, at least show some fucking discretion.

    1. Re:Hardly the time for your bitter little rant by javalizard · · Score: 1

      Excuse me. No life is any more valuable than any other. Just ask the Dalai Lama. The bum down the street is just as human as George Bush or John Kerry. All deserve to be treated with immense value.

      I'm sorry you don't know my accomplishments but maybe you should hold your tongue until you know what I've done in the world, not that what one has done makes one valuable. Have you seen Fight club? "You are not your job. You are not the money in your bank account. You are not the car you drive. You are not how much money is in your wallet. You are not your fucking khakis."

      Anyway, death is not a reason to silence discussion. He has done a lot of things including some of the ass hole things he's done to me and many others. Discussing the total of who he is is more respectful than just putting him high on a pedestal (which he did on his own and doesn't need any more help with). You need to see him as a whole person, not just as what he's done. His accomlishments don't make up for, in my perspective, that he was an ugly person.

      I do wish him health and long life. No on deserves what he's going through.

    2. Re:Hardly the time for your bitter little rant by ediron2 · · Score: 1

      heh, and while you're at it, JL, you might try a bit of the same egocentric and bizarre mathematics:

      Hmm... who has done more for (in decreasing order: the universe, all life, humanity, my family, my country, my region, my town, my neighborhood)? javalizard or Anonymous Coward... um...

      'nuff said.

  28. What no Suntan vs p53 by pg--az · · Score: 1

    Yes, I viewed the whole video, and specifically noticed his remark, something like please don't come up to me with 'herbal remedies' etc. Which is maybe too bad, because it might not be coincidental that he's at CMU which is fairly North, and perhaps he also uses sunscreen, might even be a religious sunscreen user. You saw it coming - MY religion can be found by Googling (( Holick p53 tumor ))- what if he "got religion" and vowed to spend his final days on the beach, and experienced a miraculous recovery ? Of course this is a very serious cancer, but that's all the more reason to dismiss skin-cancer as a potential side-effect of my folk remedy - I am not a doctor.

  29. Re:Speaking of wastes... by Seumas · · Score: 1

    Wanting my taxes to go toward potentially extending or saving the lives of people who contribute a great deal to science, society and culture is "political spew"? Are you insane?! (You're clearly a coward, but that isn't the question here).

    Our resources are spent on so many destructive processes that dwarf the amount spent on constructive ones. How can you possibly watch so many people suffer or die prematurely -- especially when you see what kind of people and personalities they are like you have been able to here -- and have anything but contempt for a society that places curing such ailments anywhere but in the top three priorities?

  30. I am in awe of this man by barzok · · Score: 1
    I've only had a chance to read his "cancer update page" but I am in awe. His spirits are amazingly high and he's living life to the fullest as long. I couldn't read it at work as I read the following and nearly lost it (my wife & I have a 9 month old)

    And tomorrow Dylan & I are taking a 3 day "Dylan and Daddy trip" to Florida to do a dolphin swim and see Mickey Mouse!
    Reminds me so much of that episode of The Simpsons when Homer thought he was dying. But with actual feelings. Gets one thinking what they'll do if faced with the same situation.