Court Finds Part of Copyright Act Unconstitutional

I Don't Believe in Imaginary Property writes "A US District Court in the Southern District of California has found the Copyright Remedy Clarification Act to be unconstitutional. That act is what removes the sovereign immunity for infringement that state workers have in their official capacity, something many argued would jeopardize universities with liability for faculty infringement, not to mention other state agencies. In a rather dense legal ruling (PDF), the Court found that the Clarification Act was not a valid exercise of congressional power under the 14th Amendment. For those of you who have absolutely no idea what I just said, I recommend either being glad that a small piece of copyright law may soon bite the dust, or hoping that NYCL will explain this better."

Comments

Re:Not a good thing?

[ScrewMaster]

The way I read this (and I'm a lawyer) through official action, a state can now, willy-nilly, appropriate intellectual property with immunity.

Yeah, that doesn't sound good at all, although it's one of those things that may cost them more in the long run.

Besides, the military has been doing that forever. My father worked on a number of major contracts for the Navy and Air Force back in the sixties, and anything they decided they liked and wanted to have built cheaper elsewhere they would just stamp "CLASSIFIED".

Once that was done, the original manufacturer/designer/inventor was basically screwed out of his rights (patents, copyrights, whatever) and couldn't even take it to court. After that happened to Dad a couple of times, he made damn sure that the patent apps and design specs left out crucial elements such that they'd eventually have to come back and buy it from his company. That, or invest a whole lot of time and money figuring out what he hadn't told them. They deserved it though: the Navy severely shafted his company on a number of contracts. Just outright stole years of work, and put them out on open bid ("classified", yeah, right.) Sleazy, and not what most people would expect from the service. A used car salesman, sure, but not from the world's most powerful military.