Slashdot Mirror
Cloned Sniffer Dogs Begin Training
H0D_G writes "The Australian Broadcasting Corporation reports that the world's first cloned sniffer dogs have begun their training in South Korea. The dogs, cloned from a successful golden retriever sniffer dog, were the result of a $320,000 AUD project."
In Soviet South Korea, you sniff dogs!
Great minds think alike; fools seldom differ.
Ask not what you can do for your country. Ask what your country did to you
training a sniffer dog means serving lightly sauted with a side order of rice and vegetables.
Do not try to read the dupe, thats impossible. Instead, only try to realize the truth
What truth?
There is no dupe
The only problem I see with using cloned animals for a task like this, is that they will only ever be so good. Assuming the genetic make-up and training is the same for all these dogs, and that they have a proficiency of X, then you will never get a dog that is better than X (by some margin). If you use selective breeding to try and produce better and better dogs with each generation, you could end up with a better product in the end.
Anthropic principle: We see the universe the way it is because if it were different we would not be here to see it.
Why would you do this? I don't understand.
Maybe my information is out of date, but last I checked cloning of mammals is still a massively expensive process with a stupidly high failure rate (95%+ of embryos fail to develop into live young). Even when the cloned embryos develop to adulthood there are usually significant defects. What effect these defects might have on the animal in later life, or what problems might arise if these clones breed with normal dogs are both still largely unknown.
So why do this? It seems a ridiculously expensive, unreliable and dangerous way to try and go about breeding better dogs for a pretty trivial purpose. This technology is being mass marketed before it's even close to being ready for prime time.
Good dog!
This sounds like a hoax. The idea is impractical, not particularly beneficial, and expensive. Clon-aid, anyone?
Write your own Choose Your Own Adventure. http://www.freegameengines.org/gamebook-engine/
The BBC reported them as cloned Labrador Retrievers, rather than cloned Golden Retrievers.
Consider it practice; and as they say practice makes perfect. As they continue to clone and train the dogs they are sure to learn a great deal about the process. Greater understanding combined with advances in other areas (like genetic manipulation) could potentially lead to the development of a (pardon the phrase); super sniffer. Not to mention that any lesson learned would probably be transferable to the development of any other specialized dog (or other animal).
Now I will not judge if this is good or bad, but I reckon the age of Designed Animals is probably inevitable and not too far away.
The Long Now Foundation
4) you're nitpicking a point that the rest of us understand quite well, but you're too ignorant and intellectually deficient to get.
I'm guaranteeing it's #4.
Tastes like chicken!
That is all.
"They will report for duty in June after completing a second round of training," Customs spokesman Lee Ho told AFP. Emphasis added. So, basically, these clones have undergone at least one round of training, with results good enough that they are confident the animals will pass the second set and be deployed, and causing the project manager to say that they were easier to train than "ordinary" dogs.
Sure, you can say the jury is out until they have fully trained the dogs, deployed them, and examined their service records after several years. Or gone through the process with many batches of cloned sniffers. Nevertheless as a preliminary statement the claim that the clones are easier to train is not fundamentally without merit, after all who would be better able to judge the ease with which dogs are trained than the trainers?
If the project manager is exaggerating for the sake of his project, that's a different thing, but it's not like they don't know anything about these dogs.
The enemies of Democracy are
Wow, that's about as intelligent as your homepage.
The original dog started acting strangely and had to be put down after sniffing his own ass on the cloned dog.
It must have been something you assimilated. . . .
. . . does it bark when it smells suspicious traffic on the wire?
One CPU cycle wasted on digital restrictions management is ONE TOO MANY.
This is my brother Toppy. This is my other brother Toppy. This...
(Of course naming a puppy "Toppy" for "tomorrow's puppy" doesn't make sense at all. As anyone who has ever gotten a puppy knows, today's puppy is tomorrow's DOG.)
The dogs, cloned from a successful golden retriever sniffer dog, were the result of a $320,000 AUD project."
It would be cheaper to go to a shelter and pay $50-70 per dog and train them. Even if only 1 out of 10 get through the training, it's under a grand for the dogs, and however much for human pay to train them. Or, if they are so inclined breed a good bitch and male and train the puppies.
If I cloned my last dog (rott/lab mix) who sadly passed away 2-22-08 at age 12, there's no guarantee that I would get the same dog with the same qualities/personality.