Microsoft Goes After "Career Pirates"

Stony Stevenson writes "Microsoft has filed 21 lawsuits in US Federal courts as part of an effort to stop those who continually pirate its software. The suits span 14 states and target people and businesses that have allegedly sold pirated copies of Microsoft software. Eight of the suits target companies that Microsoft refers to as 'repeat offender software pirates.' The eight firms had already been sued by Microsoft for selling counterfeit software."

Comments

good

[prockcore]

Really, that's who they should be going after. The people selling pirated software.

Re:good

[evilviper]

but this is like someone setting up a watch store that sells fake Rolexes.

The analogy isn't anywhere close... These aren't software stores that have boxes of counterfeit products on their shelves. These are COMPUTER HARDWARE stores, which just happen to bundle unlicensed copies of Windows with the hardware they sell.

I can assure you, there is a very small number of such companies, and they only get away with it because they are small enough that even Microsoft and law enforcement doesn't care enough to put any effort into closing them down.

Re:good

[Agent.Nihilist]

Microsoft's definition of pirated software is the same as Everyone else's. Illegally copied or counterfeited software and and software used outside of its license.

You have right of first sale for a Retail copy of windows. It can be installed an uninstalled from any number of machines as long as its only on one machine at a time.
You also have right of first sale for an OEM copy of windows. However it has to be used with the same system(usually defined as motherboard) as it was sold with/originally installed on. Yes it is a restriction but that is why it is sold at a discounted price.

Someone with a Technet subscription can get any operating system and a legal key for that operating system for a yearly licensing fee. The usage license for the software restricts it to use in a test environment only but that allows you access to thousands of dollars of software for a fraction of the cost.
If they start building and selling systems using those keys then thats piracy. If they use those keys in a production environment then thats piracy.

Remember that you can get a refund for the OEM copy of XP when you buy a computer prepackaged with it.

"There should be a good market for used copies of XP. Unfortunately, MS calls these genuine copies of the real thing "Pirated" and prohibits their sale."
To reiterate - you can resale a retail copy of XP by itself. You can sell a OEM copy as well but it is piracy to use it on any computer but the one it was originally installed on.

Re:So Copyright Infringement is Not Theft?

[uglyduckling]

Uh... I think you'll find that taking people's money for goods and then not providing them is, in fact, fraud and not theft. Theft is taking people's property without their permission with the intention to permanently deprive them of it.

Seeling on eBay

[jasonmanley]

This includes things as replacing your old XP software with Ubuntu and selling the disk, certificate, box and packaging on ebay Are you sure about this? Because I was once going to purchase some MS software from an auction site and decided to contact MS to check if it was legal. They replied that as long as the other guy had completely uninstalled it from his PC there would be no issues.

Re:Seeling on eBay

[mpe]

Its legal for Retail copies. However you can not use OEM copies on any other computer than the one it was originally installed on.

Only if a court has ruled that the "Retail"/"OEM" distinction actually ment anything. In Germany courts have ruled that there is no distinction. In the US courts have ruled that the doctrine of first sale is just as applicable to "promo" CDs as it is to "retail" ones.
Like many large corporations Microsoft tends to pretend that the law is something other than what it actually is.