Slashdot Mirror


World Bank Under Cybersiege In "Unprecedented Crisis"

JagsLive sends in a Fox News report on large-scale and possibly ongoing security breaches at the World Bank. "The World Bank Group's computer network — one of the largest repositories of sensitive data about the economies of every nation — has been raided repeatedly by outsiders for more than a year, FOX News has learned. It is still not known how much information was stolen. But sources inside the bank confirm that servers in the institution's highly-restricted treasury unit were deeply penetrated with spy software last April. Invaders also had full access to the rest of the bank's network for nearly a month in June and July. In total, at least six major intrusions — two of them using the same group of IP addresses originating from China — have been detected at the World Bank since the summer of 2007, with the most recent breach occurring just last month. In a frantic midnight e-mail to colleagues, the bank's senior technology manager referred to the situation as an 'unprecedented crisis.' In fact, it may be the worst security breach ever at a global financial institution. And it has left bank officials scrambling to try to understand the nature of the year-long cyber-assault, while also trying to keep the news from leaking to the public." Update: 10/11 01:15 GMT by T : Massive spyware infestations might be good cause to reevaluate the TCO of non-Windows systems on the desktop.

37 of 377 comments (clear)

  1. This was bound to happen. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    These days financial institutions consider IT (and other) security as something that costs them money, without giving them any benefit.

    Will this wake them up?

    I hear the question "Can we afford"? when talking about security in IT shops. The question that I am coming back with is "Can we afford not to"?

    Just how many more banks machines are compromised? How about Federal and Local Government's machines and networks.

    If you had enough financial data somebody could cause an economic collapse - I wonder what it would look like.

    1. Re:This was bound to happen. by g0es · · Score: 5, Insightful

      These days financial institutions consider IT (and other) security as something that costs them money, without giving them any benefit.

      Will this wake them up?

      I hear the question "Can we afford"? when talking about security in IT shops. The question that I am coming back with is "Can we afford not to"?

      Just how many more banks machines are compromised? How about Federal and Local Government's machines and networks.

      If you had enough financial data somebody could cause an economic collapse - I wonder what it would look like.

      For most financial institutions their primary goal when it comes to information assurance is to pass audits. As you stated security is usually a cost center and they do what ever they can to keep that cost down. This generally means doing just enough work to make them compliant and as well all know, compliant != secure. I do not beleive these incidents will change anything unless the financial institutions are forced to a higher standard. I will continue to hope that they will see the light.

    2. Re:This was bound to happen. by wkk2 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Why wasn't all traffic limited to white listed addresses and that traffic limited to VPN connections using tamper resistant encryption hardware?

    3. Re:This was bound to happen. by ScrewMaster · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Because bankers are traditionally among the cheapest bastards on the planet. Rich people frequently are ... it's part of why they got to be rich in the first place. Furthermore, in the modern world the contents of a bank's hard drives are much more valuable than what's in their steel-lined vaults. I don't think they've fully come to grips with that, or they'd have spent more money on information security.

      --
      The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
    4. Re:This was bound to happen. by Skal+Tura · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Doesn't help if a whitelisted host is aswell infected. No single technique, or category of security is enough, it needs multi-tiered, multi-level security in cases such as this. All task specific.

      Furthermore, there shouldn't be a single "full access" account, except for "root", and anyone working on root access would need to be required to work as a team of 2 or 3 persons, all coming from separate divisions/offices/departments, no prior contact, randomly chosen. Why?

      Humans are always the weakest link in security, and if someone is being watched when working on a server maintenance, the second fellow could report such an incident. Offer an prize for bringing up if there's a suspicion, immediately bringing that server down, and even if it was a failed suspicion, there should be somekind of reward for just being suspicious.

      This data is too critical to let any single person to have access in privacy. every action taken on the server should be logged, and automatic heuristic analysis done on it. Aswell, for all data in and out, network or removable media. It is all doable, given the right persons to do it, it's even cost-effective.

      Automation is the key to cut costs.

      There's plenty of methods to do something with high security, given creatively, sane, suspicious people planning for all of it.

      My 2 cents.

    5. Re:This was bound to happen. by TubeSteak · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Furthermore, in the modern world the contents of a bank's hard drives are much more valuable than what's in their steel-lined vaults. I don't think they've fully come to grips with that, or they'd have spent more money on information security.

      Insurance companies act as private regulators in a 'free' market.

      Banks buy insurance for the contents of their vault, meaning their insurance company effectively dictates the minimum requirements for the bank's physical security. Higher cost security is balanced against lower insurance rates.

      Physical security is a mature field.
      Internet security is not and probably will not be for some time.

      --
      [Fuck Beta]
      o0t!
    6. Re:This was bound to happen. by bertok · · Score: 5, Interesting

      When I was studying computer science at university, I had read about all these fancy cryptographic techniques, and I imagined that banks were these encrypted, firewalled fortresses of IT security, monitored by the most competent, most vigilant administrators.

      I was very wrong.

      Let me tell you about my experience of IT security in banks.

      A couple of years ago, I was sent to one of Australians largest banks. I was there for a 1 week engagement to install the latest virus scanner software on some servers. It sounded like a great opportunity to have a look at some high-end systems and see how they were managed. So I turn up in the morning, and start unpacking my laptop, when the project manager warns me:

      "Don't plug your laptop into the network. We have to make sure you have the latest patches and AV first."

      I fully understood his position, of course, they couldn't just let some random guy plug some a laptop into the network. It was a bank after all, security matters. I was Wrong. He corrected me:

      "Oh no.. that's for your own protection! There's hundreds of viruses on this network, if you plug an unpatched machine into it, it'll be infected in seconds."

      I was stunned. He wasn't even joking. I did plug my laptop in (which was well patched), and ran Ethereal for a few minutes, during which time I saw several viruses attempting to hack my machine. It was incredible. I've never seen that kind of attack rate anywhere, and I've been to large, unfirewalled university networks and school networks.

      In fact, I didn't even really need to plug myself in. There was a WiFi connection available, with an easily recognisable SSID (the name of the bank). Of course, it was unencrypted, unsecured, and plugged directly into the desktop LAN.

      Next, I got a tour of the data center, which was an eye-popping experience in itself. The bank had recently invested in fancy new retina-scanning door locks. It looked like it was straight out of a James Bond movie. However, it was taking too long to program in every person who needed access into the system, so they had simply propped the door open with a bucket. The inside of the room was just as scary. I walked past DOS machines, Windows 95 "servers", and I saw at least one NT 3.x machine. This was in 2005.

      Eventually, I got around to planning the AV software upgrade. Except it wasn't. It was first-time-install, because the majority of their servers had no AV. The amount of work required to verify compatibility during for a the rollout was deemed too expensive, and I never did get to install the AV software. They did buy the licenses though, so it's entirely possible they installed it themselves. It's possible, but I wouldn't bet on it.

  2. Well . . . by arizwebfoot · · Score: 5, Funny

    while also trying to keep the news from leaking to the public

    Oops

    --
    Oh Well, Bad Karma and all . . .

    --
    Beer is proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy.
  3. so the chinese orchestrated the market meltdown by circletimessquare · · Score: 4, Funny

    previously, i thought the markets were melting down due to gay marriage

    perhaps this is the obvious run up to 2012 and the end of the mayan calendar

    paranoid schizophrenics, want to help me out here?

    --
    intellectual property law is philosophically incoherent. it is your moral duty to ignore it or sabotage it
  4. Funny the Email is referencing External webmail by phantomcircuit · · Score: 5, Informative

    Well of course I can't be certain but this appears to be ntohing more than a breach of their email system (encrypt your damn email people).

    From the leaked memo "MD and CIO has directed that all external Webmail accounts be disabled immediately for all staff who have not changed their passwords yet"

  5. Fox is like the National Enquirer by NobleSavage · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I'd really like to read about this from a source other than Fox news.

    1. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by eln · · Score: 5, Funny

      Hi.

      Apparently, the World Bank is under cybersiege in an "Unprecedented Crisis". Turns out they've been hacked repeatedly, apparently from China.

      I have a 5 digit Slashdot ID, so I think you can count on me being a reliable source. I got the information from a Slashdot story as well, so you can be pretty certain it's completely accurate.

    2. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by binaryspiral · · Score: 5, Funny

      I'd mod you up, but I read on Fox News that Slashdot was full of Chinese hackers.

    3. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by doomicon · · Score: 5, Funny

      To add more credibility, I concur with my fellow poster with my 4 digit ID.

      --

      Awesome!
    4. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by iplayfast · · Score: 5, Funny

      I'd mod YOU up but I heard that moderators were full of Chinese hackers.

      (oops did just say that out loud?)

    5. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by ScrewMaster · · Score: 5, Funny

      And I'd mode you up, but I heard that the moderators are Chinese hackers.

      Which would probably explain a lot.

      --
      The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
    6. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by ScrewMaster · · Score: 4, Funny

      Yes, well, all that 4 digit ID means is that you've wasted that much more of your life than I have.

      --
      The higher the technology, the sharper that two-edged sword.
    7. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by Electron · · Score: 5, Funny

      I'm just here to say these two young slashdotters have definitely seen the truth, though they still have a lot to learn from us 3 digit IDers.

    8. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by An+ominous+Cow+art · · Score: 4, Funny

      My id has only three distinct numbers, can I be an honorary 3-digiter?

    9. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by Greyfox · · Score: 5, Funny

      Ni hao! I has MOD POINTS for sale! +1 insightful 5 dowwah! Oh no, I posted in the article!

      --

      I'm trying to teach myself to set people on fire with my mind... Is it hot in here?

    10. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by Electron · · Score: 5, Funny

      I shall send word of you to the Council.

    11. Re:Fox is like the National Enquirer by keithjr · · Score: 5, Funny

      And I'd mod you up, but I don't have any mod points.

      They were stolen by Chinese hackers.

  6. Blaming the Chinese is useless by Progman3K · · Score: 4, Insightful

    First thing I would do is launch my attack from a compromised host in country X while being in country Y

    --
    I don't know the meaning of the word 'don't' - J
  7. reputable source? by Bearpaw · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Does anyone have a link to a story on this from a reputable news source?

  8. 0wn3d by modemboy · · Score: 5, Informative

    Damn, they got owned completely, 3 different times. Someone in their security department needs to get a clue. Somehow their offsite data store got accessed, then an IT consultant worker key logged them, and finally they got in again through a third party and escalated to admin rights.

    3 different attack vectors, all completely successful. That is just kinda pathetic...

    1. Re:0wn3d by IchNiSan · · Score: 4, Insightful

      OR, maybe the world bank just bought some "cisco" security devices. You know, the ones made in china?

  9. Dear World Bank by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    I hear you have an opening for a security expert...

    1. Re:Dear World Bank by Narnie · · Score: 5, Funny

      I know this one admin from SF that's a real whiz about network security. They even fired him for it.

      --
      greed@All_Evils:~#
  10. Re:I Hope They Destroy This Monster by grub · · Score: 5, Funny


    It is Satan's rectum, poised over the third-world.

    Best slashdot line in ages.

    --
    Trolling is a art,
  11. Security? by cdrguru · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Face it, no matter how secure a system is, if it is usable by humans it can be breached. Easily.

    There is anywhere from a 100 to 1000 hackers/crackers/slimeballs out there that are ready and willing to take on each and every system. Ones that claim to be "secure" are just a bigger target. There is no such thing as a completely "secure" system that is usable and accessible by ordinary humans. True security would require controlled physical access, multiple authenticating factors, and so on. None of this is going to happen for an accessible system usable by "ordinary humans".

    About all that is realistic is to minimize the damages. Face the fact that if you are a target you are going to lose. Try not to lose too much.

    Prosecution of the break-in? Forget it. It's the Internet. It is International. If it looks like it is coming from China, it could be real or it could be a proxy. There are no effective International laws that will assist in any sort of prosecution. There is no supra-national police force that will break down the door of the cracker and haul them away. Nothing is going to happen. Unless the guy is a complete idiot that brags about it.

  12. Re:Before anyone mods the parent down.... by Angostura · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Actually, I never assumed for a moment that the parent was a left wing nut. I assumed he was a right wing nut. There is a certain section of conservative opinion that believes any international multilateral body (I'm looking at you, U.N) is the spawn of satan.

  13. Urgent message to mods re: Satan's rectum by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It is Satan's rectum, poised over the third-world.

    Best slashdot line in ages.

    Please, please, please mod parent comment down. The last thing we need is for the phrase "It is Satan's rectum, poised over ..." to become a new Slashdot meme.

    I mean can you imagine:

    - an item about Linux and posts like "It is Satan's rectum, poised over capitalism";

    - an item about fascism and posts like "It is Satan's rectum, poised over our freedoms";

    - an item about the Cheney/Bush government and posts like "It is Satan's rectum, poised over privacy and the U.S. Constitution"

    - an item about a new Windows version and posts like "It is Satan's rectum, poised over the computer world";

    Yech! Please stop it before it starts!

  14. Re:Before anyone mods the parent down.... by flitty · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The World Bank and the IMF are infamous for requiring Countries to De-Nationalize resources, requiring that foreign Nationals can buy up once publicly owned companies, and turning social Democracies into lasse-faire capitalist countries in return for their "aid". See: Poland, Indonesia, Chili, Argentina, South America, etc. This usually causes real wages to fall, unemployment to increase, and the reduction of land ownership by locals.

    --
    Whether or not there is some sort of god, I'm not supposed to say/god is a word and the argument ends there-Smog
  15. Re:Before anyone mods the parent down.... by megamerican · · Score: 5, Informative

    That's not at all what actually happens. You should read John Perkins' book Confession of an Economic Hitman

    You can find interviews of him explaining it all over the internet. It has nothing to do with "lasse-faire" capitalism.

    The IMF/World Bank gives a country (normally with a valuable natural resource) a loan it knows it can't pay off to build infrastructure that benefits only a few big corporations, normally foreign. Once the country defaults, the banks get the country to sign over its infrastructure and natural resources to them and other corporations.

    That isn't capitalism of any form. It is legalized theft.

    --
    If you have something that you dont want anyone to know, maybe you shouldnt be doing it in the first place -Eric Schmidt
  16. What??? Where do you get that? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The world bank makes HUGE loans to entire nations and imposes draconian reform rules and regulations, requires real assets as collateral, usually the target nation's most valuable raw resources, and charges interest. If that ain't a bank of sorts, what is?

    1. Re:What??? Where do you get that? by lysergic.acid · · Score: 4, Interesting

      it's interesting that this is called the "World Bank" as if it's some kind of intergovernmental financial organization and has been given the power to dictate the domestic policies of entire nations. however, the World Bank operates without transparency, is not subject to public oversight, and its executive directors are not elected nor government appointed. it's technically a "non-profit" organization, but the reigns of power are held by industry heads who use it to advance their own financial interests, often at the cost of developing nations who have pretty much no say in the World Bank's decisions.

      it's scary how much power and influence the neo-cons have been able to acquire while completely bypassing the democratic process. it's no wonder more and more people are questioning the legitimacy of the World Bank as well as the IMF.

    2. Re:What??? Where do you get that? by TapeCutter · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "If that ain't a bank of sorts, what is?"

      1. An agency mandated to have a US citizen leading it, it's purpose is to hide the identity of predatory lenders who blackmail impoverished governments via their tresuries. Largely financed by the industrial/military complex to keep the oil flowing to the military/industrial complex.

      2. An agency that used the Bretton Woods system to rebuild western Europe, and has gone on to bring democracy, wealth and good govanance to much of S.America, S.E Asia, and Eastern Europe.

      I have heard "the road to hell is paved with good intentions" and suspect both definitions are correct at one time or another.

      --
      And did you exchange a walk on part in the war for a lead role in a cage? - Pink Floyd.