Slashdot Mirror


State Secrets Defense Rejected In Wiretapping Case

knifeyspooney writes in with an Ars Technica report that a federal judge has issued a strong rebuke to government lawyers attempting to invoke the "state secrets" defense to quash a lawsuit over warrantless wiretapping. This is not the high-profile case the EFF is bringing against the NSA; instead the case is being pursued by an Islamic charity that knows it had been wiretapped. "At times, a note of irritation crept into [Judge] Walker's even, judicial language. At one point, he described the government's argument as 'without merit,' and characterized another as 'circular.' He also seemed impatient with the Justice Department's refusal to provide any classified documents addressing Al Haramain's specific claims for review in chambers. 'It appears... that defendants believe they can prevent the court from taking any action under 1806(f) by simply declining to act,' wrote Walker."

7 of 269 comments (clear)

  1. Consider the litigant by Gothmolly · · Score: -1, Troll

    If it was a bunch of hippies (EFF) the judge would have told them to go screw, but because its a MUSLIM group, the court is kissing their butts.

    Farce.

    --
    I want to delete my account but Slashdot doesn't allow it.
  2. This Is Aslo Going To Be Fun +1, Seditious by Anonymous Coward · · Score: -1, Troll

    When the Gitmo detainees file suit in U.S. federal court for
    damages against BushCo.

    Let the ulcerations begin !

    Yours In Communism,
    Kilgore Trout

  3. Gnome users come from... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    An abandoned warehouse in San Francisco, kitted up as for a rave, electronica playing at 15db louder than "my ears are bleeding and I'm developing an aneurism" volumes and the windows all painted over black so that the strobe and spotlights and lasers can be seen better. Computers, mainly made of whatever stuff has been exchanged for crack or scavenged from dumpsters behind dot-bombs, are scattered around on whatever furniture is available, which also consists of whatever stuff has been exchanged for crack or scavenged from dumpsters behind dot-bombs. There's no break area, but you may be able to bum a beer (or more likely something harder) off of one of the developers hanging around, and they will probably be too jacked up on X, coke, acid, heroin, ether or all of the above to notice that you've taken anything.

    Development strategies are generally determined by whatever light show happens to be going on at the moment, when one of the developers will leap up and scream "I WANT IT TO LOOK JUST LIKE THAT" and then straight-arm his laptop against the wall in an hallucinogenic frenzy before vomiting copiously, passing out and falling face-down in the middle of the dance floor. There's no whiteboard, so developers diagram things out in the puddles of spilt beer, urine and vomit on the floor.

    At the end of the day - whenever that is since an equal number of programmers will be passed out at any given time - or really whenever someone happens to think of it (which is rarely), someone might type "make" on some machine somewhere, with mixed results. Generally nothing happens, so he/she shrugs his/her shoulders and wanders off to look for someone who might have more pink/black-striped pills. Once in a great while, generally in the unpleasant time between the come-down from the last thing they took and before whatever it was they took just now comes on fully, someone will tar up a bunch of random files and post it on a website someplace it as the next GNOME release, usually with a reference to some kind of monkey.

    GNOME developers rarely live past 25 and prefer "alternative" art - generally stuff made of feces that's "too edgy" for most people to "understand" or "like." Core GNOME developers are heavy Ketamine users. The bodies of GNOME developers can often be found in dumpsters or floating face-down in any sufficiently large body of water.

  4. And I'd trust Bush more.,. by tjstork · · Score: -1, Troll

    I'd trust Bush with them more, any day of the week. That's the whole point. I would argue this point with many conservatives. Sure, we know that Bush is only going to go after a bunch of muzzies and illegal aliens but you know that if Dems get the same powers, they are coming after us, just like they always have, but with much more power. The only compromise that is reasonable is a limited government.

    --
    This is my sig.
  5. IT would almost be funny... by tjstork · · Score: 0, Troll

    If the liberals of this country made it possible for Islam to spread and then take over the USA, then watch all of their progress evaporate as women are disenfranchised, then kicked out of their jobs, abortion is banned, homosexuals are stoned, writers are jailed, directors shot, dancers raped, just like, well, every other country where Islam has taken over.

    --
    This is my sig.
  6. Fucking judge is a terroristic asshole. by cryptodan · · Score: -1, Troll

    What a fucking dumbass judge. You fucking terroristic asshole. You do not have a need to know so you shouldn't be granted access to classified documents what a fucking ignorant son of a bitch.

  7. Re:Is this the "charity" in question? by MrNaz · · Score: 0, Troll

    What, have you been asleep since Sept 10, 2001?

    --
    I hate printers.