Slashdot Mirror
Workable Fusion Starship Proposed
Adam Korbitz writes "A former colleague of Edward Teller — father of the hydrogen bomb — has published a new paper proposing a design for what could be the first practical fusion-powered spacecraft (PDF). As described at Centauri Dreams, the design has certain similarities to MagOrion, a 1990s-era proposal for a nuclear-powered spaceship with a magnetic sail and propelled by small-yield fission devices. The proposal's author also has links to the British Interplanetary Society's Project Daedalus, a 1970s proposal for an unmanned fusion-powered interstellar probe designed to reach 12% of the speed of light on its way to Barnard's Star."
a deuterium fusion bomb propulsion system is proposed where a thermonuclear detonation wave is ignited in a small cylindrical assembly of deuterium with a gigavolt-multimegampere proton beam,
that has to be right up there with back to the future. I mean, it has a frickin' gigavolt-multimegampere proton beam
See here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Orion_(nuclear_propulsion)
and here:
http://nextbigfuture.com/2008/12/micro-fusion-for-space-propulsion-and.html
If what you are proposing relies on technology already in use, or which could very likely be made usable during the next few years (i.e. technology which's basic scientific implications we understand, but just need a little time to figure some "engineering details"), then it's workable. If not, then most probably it's not.
I'm all for ideas like this but we won't be building things like this until we, as a planet, have a permanent manufacturing presence in space.
Moon colony, orbiting L5 colony, whatever it is it must be permanent and able to manufacture using locally sourced materials because building something like this from within the gravity well doesn't make economic sense.
"Bah!" - Dogbert
Edward Teller hired my Dad into the Physics department at UC Berkeley and I remember him as a gentleman - he was occasionally at our house. Once my parents had a costume party and Teller was provided with a bird costume - he did not want to wear the mask so he had these big white wings on. The SF Chronicle columnist Herb Caen ran a story the next day saying that Teller was dressed as the angel of peace. Until Teller died a few years ago, my Dad would occasionally travel to Berkeley to visit with him.
Actually it's too dense. At high speeds (significant fractions of lightspeed) a magnetic scoop acts like a very effective braking system in interstellar gas. A Bussard type ramscoop rocket could only be expected to reach about 0.12c even with highly efficient engines.
... Edward Teller, the self-described father of the hydrogen bomb.
Other people who worked on the project tend to disagree with that title.
This ain't rocket surgery.
Please read up on Relativity sometime. There are a number of decent resources on the subject.
As is, you've just lowered the IQ of everyone who read this post....
Specifically...
The time dilation effect on an object is irrelevant to an observer at its point or origin. It WILL reach its destination, unless it's aimed wrong, or hits something really hard.
No, there is no such speed as you propose in your second conjecture.
Time dilation is a wonderful thing. It helps to shorten trips from the point of view of the traveller. But it doesn't change the trip at all from the point of view of an observer back at the start point.
Unless, of course, you're carrying one end of a wormhole with you on the voyage. Still doesn't change the voyage from the point of view of the observer back home, but can have some interesting effects later (if, that is, you consider time travel interesting, of course).
"I do not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it"
From your post, you don't make it 100% clear, but I suspect your understanding of time dilation might not be 100% accurate.
Say the distance from Earth to another star is 1 light-year, and we manage to accelerate a probe to an average speed of 0.1*c (1/10th the speed of light). For the sake of our thought experiment, let's assume the probe comes back, too, for a total trip distance of 2 light-years.
On earth, 20 years will have passed--it's a simple, easy "distance = rate * time" kind of thing. No time dilation to consider.
If you placed a clock on the spaceship, though, you'd see some time dilation effects on the moving clock. It would have experienced less than 20 years' worth of time passing. So if your Earth-bound clock and your space clock were perfect, and you synced them up before the trip started, they would be out of sync when the ship got back.
Remember, in your own reference frame, you don't experience any time dilation. The fact that the ship is travelling fast doesn't make clocks on Earth run slower.
If this isn't clear, go read the Wikipedia article on time dilation, and read the part where it talks about muons decaying as they travel from the upper atmosphere to the surface of the Earth. That's the easiest example to understand, I think, as long as you get how radioactive decay operates.
Dude...you've got what appears to be about a 50px kinda round thing in a crater, and your first assumption is a man-made biosphere? Well, I've got about a hundred pictures of alien spacecraft for you to look at then....
Seriously though, different planets have vastly different conditions, so it's no surprise you don't see things like this on Earth. I'd say it's essentially a sand dune. There's a _lot_ of similar formations on Mars. In fact, there's a few more on the string of pictures that original is from:
http://ida.wr.usgs.gov/html/m15012/m1501228.html
There's one in the first image, there's some somewhat similar phenomenon in the second and third, there appears to be one in the fourth, two in the fifth, and part of one in the sixth.
Yeah, and what's worse, they can't even get acronyms right:
practical fusion-powered spacecraft (PDF).
That should be abbreviated as PFS or PFPS, not PDF.
Information theory is life. The rest is just the KL divergence.
If you read the proposal, you'll note that the proposed method of working in space seems to be that the rocket engine actually fires in two directions - first, it fires a very high energy plasma beam AT THE SPACESHIP, which, in the vacuum of space, turns the whole assembly into a Gigavolt capacitor. THEN the spaceship fires a GV proton beam back at the rocket. This proton beam then ignites a classic fission explosion (using Deuterium-Tritium), but "very small", and this DT explosion ignites a second, much more explosive Deuterium-only fusion explosion AWAY FROM THE SPACECRAFT. Repeat one million times per second, or as needed.
What could possibly go wrong?
If that's not exciting enough, the whole plasma/proton beam doesn't work on earth, so, hey, we use a disposable argon laser, which can generate a lot of power, but (sadly), is really inefficient. But wait, we can fix that! All you have to do is set off a small hexogene explosion around your rod of solid argon, and the laser will suddenly work at 80% efficiency. Oh, repeat that every microsecond or so.
Honestly though, if you can get past the insane energies involved, he's come up with a rather brilliant way to use readily available fuel (Deuterium, as opposed to Deuterium Tritium, which is hard to come by), and using a whole chain of events, make the process really efficient (i.e. you need a lot less mass to make all this work). And, since your main burn is fusion (which consumes the fission by-products), not a lot of radiation to speak of (oh, well, there are some pesky neutrons, but who doesn't like neutrons?)
Yes, absolutely. It has been proposed as a part of laser-boosted lightsail missions to other stars. A full sized collector scoop would work in interstellar gas, but you only need a relatively small magnet if you are plowing through solar wind (er... stellar wind, since it isn't Sol?). A superconducting cable spooled out of a probe and given a current could be used as a braking system to decelerate at a destination star. I recall seeing an estimate somewhere that the peak deceleration of a relativistic craft like this hitting the heliopause would be about 12g, not comfortable but very effective and cheap way to slow down. Magnetic sails have also been proposed as a way to accelerate in the first place, but in that case you are limited to speeds less than that of the solar wind itself, so it is more suited to in-system missions.