What To Do When a Megacorp Wants To Buy You?
Anonymous Entrepreneur writes "I run a small technology startup company; so small that our offices are still located in a room in my home. We are just some young friends, fresh from college, and we haven't started having regular sales, as 99% of our time is invested in development. A large corporation has just approached us, trying to persuade us to sell our company. The money is fair enough, and the employment conditions would seem excellent, since they would enable us to manage good-sized motivated teams, but we are very emotionally attached to our development and we place great importance to being independent. We founded our company because we didn't want to follow rules. We wanted to be the ones who make the rules instead. Money really doesn't mean much to us as long as we can do whatever we want while excelling at our passions. We feel that by accepting the offer, we couldn't achieve the maximum of our potential, and one of us joked that if we get in contact with the corporate environment and accept their money, we risk becoming lazy. Another member is more pragmatic, saying that accepting some money now is better than waiting for the development to go gold, even though all of us agree that if we finished our thing, we'd earn more than what the corporation has offered us. We would be very interested to know your thoughts and viewpoints, especially if you have ever faced a similar dilemma."
You have given us nothing to go on here as far as your business case, so I'll be brief:
Money really doesn't mean much to us as long as we can do whatever we want [...]
The first you will learn about money is that it lets you do exactly that. Make sure it's enough that in case things don't work out with Megacorp, you can get back to doing whatever it is you enjoy.
If the money's good, take the money. You can always start another business but you can't always find someone willing to pay you for your current one.
Remember: you don't have to be the next Google. It only takes a few million to retire and to *anything you want to do.*
Moderating "-1, Disagree" is simple censorship. Have the guts to post your opinion.
When a company wants to buy you, it means you are competitors otherwise and they want to stop you or otherwise control your future.
Make it clear what their expected terms are to be and whether or not you will be forced into a non-compete situation. They will bring you on as an employee as part of the agreement and at that point "all your IP are belong to us." You stand to lose plenty. And let's be clear on this -- they will hire you, but that is NO guarantee that they won't turn right around and fire you leaving you with no options for "starting up again" or working for another company doing anything similar -- remember that "non-compete" thing they required you to sign?
They have a PLAN. Make no mistake about it. They have thought this through. You should give this no less thought. Get them to disclose their ENTIRE plan to you at once including their intent to terminate you leaving you high and dry. (Of course they will never say that, but you can get them to state that they never had any such intention AND that in the event they feel they need to in the future that you have a golden parachute and get it in writing.)
If your primary interest is autonomy/creativity, then it really comes down to what they are actually trying to buy. If they are buying your company to get your product(s); then sell, sell, sell. The more money you have, the easier it will be for you to pursue whatever projects/new startups/etc. you feel like doing in the future.
If they are buying your company to get you, then the situation is less clear. If a condition of the buy is you working for the man for a fair while, then you might not want to do that.
Take the money if it's anything reasonable. You then have some resources to enable you to work on things that make you feel more free.
But seriously, take the money while the offer is there.
Given that you've started this in the first place, you're almost certainly going to become unhappy with the new corporate environment sooner or later, which means that you're going to come back to this again. The real questions are:
I'd certainly lean towards not taking the offer.
Game! - Where the stick is mightier than the sword!
I've done a lot of startups, and every one of them failed -- and four out of five times, it wasn't for lack of technical excellence.
Getting sales, marketing, and operational execution right is both critical and very difficult. If the buyout offers you enough money you'll be in a better position next time you want to go start your own company -- think very, very hard about accepting the deal.
Make sure the cash is enough you won't need a job for a year or two at least, above and beyond what you just want to blow right now. You should be prepared that in less than six months, you won't want to work there and arrange your finances accordingly.
.. and now the investor owns all rights to the product so other than the originator having a high-paying job for a couple of years he got ... zip.
Personally, I would work out some kind of ongoing royalty situation in addition to the buy out just in case it takes off. Stock options are useless unless it is already a public company and you can exercise them within 6 months.
A friend of mine had a great idea. Got some investors, created a company to develop the hardware and software, started getting customers. Then the economy went south, the investor got scared, and no more money. So no more company.
Oh
I rarely read replies, it's my opinion and if you thought about your opinion a little more, I'm OK with that.
You're asking this on Slashdot rather than seeking professional help, so that tells us something immediately. Sell out to the big company now, ride it as long as you can and leave when it's no longer fun. You don't have the business know-how to run this company on your own and have it survive.
Tired of being "punished" by the Slashdot $rtbl since 2002. I'm now over at http://soylentnews.org/ .
If you want to do *exactly this* for the rest of your life, say no.
But if you're like most entrepreneurs I know, that's not the case. It's likely that you could take the money, and pursue a new idea, developing another company, new employees, etc... and having some extra money in the bank will make all that a LOT easier.
As somebody who has done a few startups now, I can assure you that money matters. Because more money means you can chase bigger ideas with less pressure.
Agree with cduffy. If they are offering you "car" or "downpayment on a small house" amounts, then you may wish to consider going it alone. But if they are offering you F U money, then think very hard about it. Many best technologies don't succeed, and almost as often, the founders donot get much of it because of dilution or getting forced out by the board or any other number of reasons. If you are looking at over $1M or so going to you, then think very hard about passing it up. Even if the money is less, having experience making and selling a company is a huge gold star to any VC or angel investor for your next company. By the way, if you are really serious, get better advice than /. Talk to VCs, your clients and your advisors or mentors.
Well, you know, someone (I think John Steinbeck) said that a man never asks for advice unless he's already made up his mind.
Not to mention, if the Mega-Corp likes the idea, they'll find a way to implement it whether or not you are helping them. You may be in the right, but if they want they can get the product cranked out faster and with more developed distribution channels and contacts. More importantly, they can throw more and better experienced lawyers at defending themselves than you can throw at them.
I'll never make that mistake again, reading the experts' opinions. - Feynman
I was in the same situation about 10 years ago (yeah, pre-1.0-burst) so I think I have some insight for you...
First, this is a business question you are asking in a techie forum, bad idea. You are running a business, possibly selling a business, go get yourself some business advisers, at a minimum that means an accountant and a lawyer who know (or at least "get") your industry, and preferably some people who have sold companies in your industry, extra points if they sold to the same megacorp and aren't involved with megacorp any more (they can tell you how it all went, but if they're still there, there's a conflict).
Second, and read carefully: TAKE THE MONEY. There's an old expression: No one ever went broke making a profit.
Caveat: after taxes it should be more money than you'd make in 10 years of working the same "job" at average pay. (e.g. if you're an engineer who could easily pull in $125k/yr, make sure you're landing at least $1.25mm cash after taxes, don't take an all-stock deal - bubbles burst) You need enough money to be able to screw around for a few years if megacorp really does turn you lazy.
BUT don't get sucked into a long term contract working for megacorp. A year or two is ok, and if you're stuck with an earnout, make sure you really can see your company meeting those numbers. After a year you could be itching to leave the megacorp lifestyle (no company is perfect) and its best to know you can part on good terms, pick up and travel for a few months, then start your next awesome company.
Third, can I repeat #1? Find a better place than slashdot to get this sort of advice. If you're really strapped, try your college's career center network, or SCORE (.org)
Actually, sufficient money is exactly what can buy you independence.
If you aren't beholden to anyone or any company for making a living, you can do pretty much as you please as long as its legal.
(Not getting into how enough money will actually often buy you legal leeway too at times.)
Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.........
Here are the arguments you made in favor of selling:
The money is fair enough, and the employment conditions would seem excellent, since they would enable us to manage good-sized motivated teams,
Here are the ones you made against selling:
but we are very emotionally attached to our development and we place great importance to being independent. We founded our company because we didn't want to follow rules. We wanted to be the ones who make the rules instead. Money really doesn't mean much to us as long as we can do whatever we want while excelling at our passions. We feel that by accepting the offer, we couldn't achieve the maximum of our potential, and one of us joked that if we get in contact with the corporate environment and accept their money, we risk becoming lazy.
Judging by both the quality and quantity of the arguments in both scenarios, it is pretty clear that you really don't want to sell, and are just pondering the benefits of selling rather than seriously considering it. I can understand this kind of dilemma, but it sounds like you really just want someone to convince you that selling is good or bad rather than actually asking about it. You either want someone to go into a detailed rational response in favor of selling, or a simple emotional one against it.
I say do what you think is right for you and your company, rather than listening to a bunch of random Internet users.
Most important: Decide quickly. Also important: Try to put as little emotion into the process as possible. When you have made your decision, consider the following:
If you decide in favor, make certain the process moves as quickly as possible. Make sure you have put in place -- before taking each and every step -- provisions for backing out (at no cost to you). At the slightest sign of foot-dragging, stop the process and pull out. Decide from the beginning what your triggers will be for backing out. Then stick to the plan.
Being bought out is time-consuming. Think of it as a huge distraction to your business. A huge distraction could be the only thing Magacorp wants to "buy". If they're earnest, they'll understand and appreciate caution as well as haste. (Time is money.)
If you decide against, let Magacorp know immediately. Then get back to work, pronto. Looking back, second thoughts and re-negotiations are distractions, too. Let Megacorp know that your decision is final.
Good luck!
The purpose of a company is to make money. The purpose of a hobby is to have fun and experience personal fulfillment. You need to decide which your organization is.
If it is a company, then you need to decide which path will make the company make more money. But, without knowing the numbers, it sounds to me like a big lump sum now plus jobs from Megacorp, Inc., will probably pay better than hoping that whatever it is that you're developing will someday be a viable product.
And if it is a hobby, then generally, I'd say don't sell. But there may a be reason to. Megacorp, Inc. might be able and willing to supply the development teams that you as an individual and a couple of friends cannot. In this case, by selling out, you could enable your product to be on the market that much sooner.
There are certain core ingredients typically required for success:
* Marketing -- finding out if there is a need for a product, creating requirements for a new products based on emerging needs in a market
* Sales -- getting the word out, building relationships and closing deals
* Distribution -- fulfilling orders, positioning goods for easy access and generally getting products into the hands of your customers
* Support -- keeping the brand alive in your customer's mind, keeping the relationship positive and creating secondary opportunities to, say, up-sell or repeat-sell
* Accounting -- getting paid for all of the above, keeping current with accounts payable (esp. taxes) and paying employees and shareholders
* Product Development -- (the easy part) research, design, testing and documentation
* Production -- parts procurement, assembly, verification, bundling and shipping (on time and under budget)
* Human Resources, Legal and Staff -- people named "Peter"
Does you company have all of these in place? If it's missing even two or three components, you may be headed for real trouble. If Megacorp can fill in some of the blanks, consider being bough out a real win-win!
... let me tell you that going from a company of 30 to a company of 140,030 is still quite a shock, and the purchase went through nearly 18 months ago.
if you decide to go down this path, make sure that:
1) you have definite set dates for _EVERY_ part of the transition, _especially_ for 401(k)s, health insurance, etc. these dates must be part of the terms of the contract with seriously stiff penalties.
2) take a long, hard look at all your groups' bumps and warts. if you're like my group, you have several excellent tech leads and no project managers. make sure that your potential purchaser can either fix or drastically improve all of your failings.
there's a lot more, but for me the biggest items are those 2.
Yes there are! Being happy. Healthy. Fulfilled. Having an interesting life. Loving and being loved.
Being rich isn't a prerequisite for any of them - and it doesn't bring any of them on its own.
You may be ambassador to England or France. You may like to gamble, you might like to dance. You might be the heavy weight champion of the world. You might be a socialite with a long string of pearls, but you're gonna have to serve somebody. Yes indeed, you're gonna have to serve somebody. Well it may be the devil, or it may be the lord, but you're gonna have to serve somebody.
-- Bob Dylan
I'm gonna need a spec.
The economy is disintegrating, take the money now. You can always give it back later if you feel bad about it.
Let me repeat, the 20th century is over. The dot-com boom is long over. The bubble economy is over. Serious economists are predicting deflation. Sell out while you can. Take the money and let them deal with the problems that will happen if the economy does tank and the market for your currently-popular product goes away.
Let me sum it all up in one three letter word: AOL. Ten years ago, people thought that their stock price was going to continue to grow so big that it would eclipse the entire Time magazine: Warner Bros. studio conglomerate. Now they're just the lingering bad smell of a fart. Can you imagine how bad Steve Case would feel now if he didn't sell out for billions back then when he was more popular than Elvis? AOL is nothing now, but he still has...ALL...THOSE...BILLIONS...OF...DOLLARS.
Sell out now, fool. Why are you even asking us such a silly question? If you sell out and the business is good, you'll still be a company god and get even more money through your stock options and bonuses. If the start-up tanks, you'll still have all the money and you can walk away with none of the problems. Think of your kids. No kids yet? Well then sell out, find a beautiful wife or two and go make a dozen. and don't forget the pre-nup.
At some point you need a sales conduit if it's like most products. Developing that will take more people and cash.
THe standard VC process is to give you almost but not quite enough cash to bring the device to fruition but not enough to market it and keep your salaries going while you wait for it to catch fire. Then at that point it's round 2 for cash raising: and this is when you find you need a lot of cash and it's gonna cost you most of your company. Oh and there's one more thing...they'll want you to appoint a director of their choice to watch their money. THis is when you are screwed.
So unless this thing can market it self you gotta know what your path to raising capital is before you decide if you'd rather go corporate.
Some drink at the fountain of knowledge. Others just gargle.
...if there isn't, or it's quite reasonable, take the money, fulfil the contract, then take the money and go and do the same thing again, but even better next time now you have the capital to avoid cutting (any/as many) corners. Rinse and repeat.
Worked for a former boss/colleague of my acquaintance! Thrice!
That's what poor people like to tell themselves, but it's not really true -- rich people are, in the aggregate, happier than poor people. Being rich doesn't make you happy per se, but it can sure help you avoid a lot of the things that make you unhappy. And there's no reason to believe that being rich makes any of that happy-generating life events more difficult or less likely.
Not really - how much money you have is an important variable in the equation of how much time and resources you have to do the other things that you consider important. He didn't say that it was the most important, just that it's up there. Anyone who has to work 2 or 3 jobs just to keep their family surviving would probably agree that money is very important. It's only those who make enough that they don't have to worry about money that consider it unimportant.
which is totally what she said
This is good advice.
I had a startup 10 years ago with a similar situation and a head full of ideals. We passed over two such opportunities.
With experience, we now know that was a mistake.
Developing a product and making real money is 100 x harder than anyone realises, no matter how talented you are.
If you take a good chunk of money now, it will set you up and free you to explore bigger and better things. Plus, the big corporate may teach you a valuable business lesson or two.
Consider that to make $100k clear cash, your company would have to sell c. $1M of product taking into account staff costs, taxes, cost of sale, legal fees, etc.
Work out how long it would take you right now to generate $1M revenue and that is how much time $100k cash would save you.
Believe me, if you can save 2-5 year's of grind, do it. Anything can happen to your product including total failure in the Market. So if someone's willing to put a value on it now, cash in.
As a startup you have no idea how hard it is to turn great code into hard cash. Take the cash now and get where you want to be quicker.
P.S. just because you work with suits doesn't mean you have to become one. But it's surprising how some business methodology can bring order to creative chaos.
Having worked as a guidance counsellor, social worker, and community organizer, I can state with absolute 100% certainty and authority that this statement is entirely bullshit.