Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

When Does Gore Get In the Way of Gameplay?

Posted by Soulskill on from the when-i-need-to-break-out-the-windex dept.

Wired is running a story inspired by the level of gore in the recent Wolverine game that wonders: how much is too much? It mentions a study we discussed in February which indicated that violence tended to interest gamers less than other characteristics. "... the longer you play a 'twitch' action game, the less you notice the cultural content — the gushing blood, the shrieks of agony. You're too busy focusing on the gameplay. I noticed this with Wolverine. For the first hour, I found the deranged bloodshed both shocking and exciting; it made me feel like I 'was' Logan, the grunting, killing-machine character from Marvel Comics' X-Men universe. But as I became more expert, the cultural shell of the game boiled away. In a sort of staring-into-the-cascading-numbers-of-the-Matrix way, I found myself looking past the visible aspects of the game and savoring the underlying, invisible mechanics of play. ... The game became pure physics and algorithms: Vectors, speed and collision detection. The gore had become mostly irrelevant."

3 of 141 comments (clear)

  1. can't you turn Gore off? by mcfatboy93 · · Score: 5, Funny

    I hated an inconvenient truth. all i want him to do is shut up.

    but really in most violent video games can't you turn the blood and gore off?

    --
    Its not my fault, someone put a wall in my way.
  2. Gore is semi-irrelevent but still has a place... by Pvt_Ryan · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Gore is pretty much irrelevent however I do think it has a place. For example I like the Hitman series. In the 1st one there was bullet holes/decals on the bodies I liked this as it allowed me to see where I hit as opposed to yes i hit or no i missed. I was rather annoyed at the future hitman installments removing this, for me it was all about the perfect head shot in the 1st one, right between the eyes.

    I did think the manhunt series was boring mainly due to the limited number of death animations and the excessive gore.

    I do prefer games that have some gore over those that have none, for example when a rpg shell blows someone to pieces it is more realistic than them just falling over. It's all about the realism the game creates the more realistic the more I enjoy the game (assuming the gameplay is there).

  3. Gore is Necessary by Psyborgue · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Without it, a game comes off as a cartoon. I don't notice it so much when it's there and have never found it a bother, but when it's not there, it's noticeable. If you shoot somebody in the head with a shotgun and they just fall down without a drop of blood, something is wrong. It's just plain not realistic.