Slashdot Mirror
Microsoft Denies It Built Backdoor Into Windows 7
CWmike writes "Microsoft has denied that it has built a backdoor into Windows 7, a concern that surfaced yesterday after a senior National Security Agency (NSA) official testified before Congress that the agency had worked on the operating system. 'Microsoft has not and will not put "backdoors" into Windows,' a company spokeswoman said, reacting to a Computerworld story Wednesday. On Monday, Richard Schaeffer, the NSA's information assurance director, told the Senate's Subcommittee on Terrorism and Homeland Security that the agency had partnered with the developer during the creation of Windows 7 'to enhance Microsoft's operating system security guide.' Thursday's categorical denial by Microsoft was accompanied by further explanation of exactly how the NSA participated in the making of Windows 7. 'The work being discussed here is purely in conjunction with our Security Compliance Management Toolkit,' said the spokeswoman. The company rolled out the Windows 7 version of the toolkit late last month, shortly after it officially launched the operating system."
At least, not intentionally.
Why do people think that the back door is in Win7?
The NSA put the backdoor in the Intel compiler, that's a much better place to put a backdoor or more accurately spread a backdoor
Odds are the NSA is privy to whatever the current exploits are for windows operating systems anyways. I wouldn't be surprised if they had staff working on breaking into Windows machines if for nothing else than attacks on targets outside the US.
"It's for the RIAA."
Warning: this article may contain humor, sarcasm, parody, and perhaps even irony. Read at your own risk.
The NSA did SELinux (for Linux...) so I don't think it's unreasonable to think they might have helped MS on security issues without doing anything nasty.
This is true. However, I plan to register microsoftrapedandkilledandembeddedinwindows7ayounggirlin2009.com because they haven't denied that they have not.
Please, they have microphones in my clothes, on the desk, in the walls, the fly buzzing by your mouth is their robot!!! Meet me by the dumpster out back around 5pm, come alone.
Unfortunately I have a bad habit of reading things aloud when I read them and by the time I was finished the fly was gone and the man sitting across from me was dead. The government doctor that rushed in the room and gave him pentobarbital in an attempt to revive him said it was due to an aneurysm caused by a robotic fly which he says he sees a lot of so it's nothing for me to look into.
I guess there's no story here after all.
My work here is dung.
NSA: "We wrote a guide and a separate tool to help in enterprise security management"
ComputerWorld: "OMG NSA TROJANED WINDOWS 7"
NSA: "WTF? We made a document and stand-alone download..."
ComputerWorld: "CONSPIRACY!"
NSA: "Uh, we work with linux too you know... SELinux...?"
ComputerWorld: "FRONTPAGE HEADLINE NEWS! WINDOWS 7 BACKDOOR EXISTS!"
Slashdot: "ZOMG! NSA MADE A WINDOWS 7 BACKDOOR!"
and Windows 7 was my idea.
Despite many years’ warnings that Microsoft regards security as a marketing problem and has only ever done the absolute minimum it can get away with, millions of users who click on any rubbish they see in the hope of pictures of female tennis stars having wardrobe malfunctions still fail to believe that taking Windows out on the Internet is like standing bent over in the street in downtown Gomorrah, naked, arse greased up and carrying a flashing neon sign saying “COME AND GET IT.”
Microsoft cannot believe people have not applied the patch for the problems, just because they keep trying to use Windows Genuine Advantage to break legally-bought systems. “Don’t they trust us?” asked marketing marketer Steve Ballmer.
Millions of smug Mac users and the four hundred smug Linux users pointed and laughed, having long given up trying to convince their Windows-using friends to see sense. “There’s a reason the Unix system on Mac OS X is called Darwin,” said appallingly smug Mac user Arty Phagge.
“It can’t be stupid if everyone else runs it,” said Windows user Joe Beleaguered, who had lost all his email, business files, MP3s and porn again. “Macs cost more than Windows PCs.”
“Yes,” said Phagge. “Yes, they do.”
Ubuntu Linux developer Hiram Nerdboy frantically tried to get our attention about something or other, but we can’t say we care.
http://rocknerd.co.uk
Why would Microsoft build a back door into Win7, when the front door is so wide open?
Take Nobody's Word For It.
and it wouldn't work with the "Home" version of Windows, since nothing special ever does.
To say it more clearly, the allegation is that NSA put the back door in, microsoft didnt deny it. They are using political speak to make is sound like nobody put back doors in.
An think about it, what self respecting intelligence agency wouldnt want a back door in windows. Their job is to collect intelligence, and windows is almost everywhere and handles lots of information.
It might sound paranoid to say windows is bugged by the NSA, but it totally ignorance to suggest they wouldnt want to bug it.
Never believe something until it is officially denied. :o)
What the "we're able to shut down your computer if we suspect you may not have an authorized version of our software" backdoor isn't enough of a backdoor for them?
You are welcome on my lawn.
The developers should designate one person for compromise testing. It's his job to try to get compromises to the kernel. He will submit a patch to a random developer every 6 months, the developer submits the patch, and if it is missed and gets included in the main tree it triggers a more widespread code audit. Offer a $1000 reward to anyone finding the offending or more dangerous backdoor.
This should keep the developers on their toes and give us some confidence that the code IS being audited properly.
.
An think about it, what self respecting intelligence agency wouldnt want a back door in windows. Their job is to collect intelligence, and windows is almost everywhere and handles lots of information.
It might sound paranoid to say windows is bugged by the NSA, but it totally ignorance to suggest they wouldnt want to bug it.
You are overlooking the fact that intelligence agencies are, also, usually tasked with preventing (as much as possible) foreign countries from collecting intelligence about the U.S. government. If Windows has a back door that the NSA can use, how would they prevent foreign intelligence agencies from using it? It is a well understood fact that any security vulnerability that is introduced will be discovered by those with nefarious goals (the NSA would not view their own goals as nefarious, but they would consider the goals of many foreign intelligence agents to be nefarious).
The truth is that all men having power ought to be mistrusted. James Madison
Seriously, you're absolutely correct. The NSA has every incentive to improve the security of Windows, not compromise it. They did the same for Linux, where you can see the changes they made. In the past, they've made suggestions for improvements to encryption algorithms that academic researchers later realized had a sound mathematical basis. The NSA is as much about strengthening computer systems as they are compromising them. Hell, if in a particular situation they want to compromise the security of a system, all they usually have to do is ask (see: AT&T et. al.).
The thing is, they know that important information they want to be kept secret is going to exist on Windows machines. On Linux machines. On [x] machine that isn't necessarily controlled directly by the NSA.
And even outside such "National Security" secrets... The NSA may want to listen in on your phone calls, but it doesn't help them at all for every Tom, Dick, and Sally to have their credit card information stolen, their bank acccounts phished and plundered, and so on.
The enemies of Democracy are