Slashdot Mirror


Pneumatic Tube Communication In Hospitals

blee37 sends along a writeup from the School of Medicine at Stanford University on their pneumatic tube delivery system, used for sending atoms not bits. Such systems are in use in hospitals nationwide; the 19th-century technology is enhancd by recent refinements in pneumatic braking. "Every day, 7,000 times a day, Stanford Hospital staff turn to pneumatic tubes, cutting-edge technology in the 19th century, for a transport network that the Internet and all the latest Silicon Valley wizardry can't match: A tubular system to transport a lab sample across the medical center in the blink of an eye."

36 of 350 comments (clear)

  1. Rollofle, you can't download a pizza either by Gothmolly · · Score: 4, Insightful

    So the point of this article is that physical tasks, like plumbing or carrying infected blood, can't be done electronically ?!?!

    --
    I want to delete my account but Slashdot doesn't allow it.
    1. Re:Rollofle, you can't download a pizza either by stfvon007 · · Score: 4, Funny

      Pizza hut is now suing customers that use the pizzamaker 3000 to download unauthorized copies of their pizzas through PneumaticPizzatorrents. papa johns and domino's are considering following suite. It is being shown that only 3% of all pizzas downloaded are legal public domain or open source pizzas.

      --
      All misspellings and grammatical errors in the above post are intentional and part of my artistic expression.
    2. Re:Rollofle, you can't download a pizza either by Discordantus · · Score: 5, Insightful

      The point of this article is that pneumatic tube networks are frelling cool, and they're old tech. To many persons of geeky persuasion (including me), this type of thing is fascinating.

    3. Re:Rollofle, you can't download a pizza either by itsthebin · · Score: 4, Informative

      Pneumatic Computation was use in early control rooms , with fully analog computation. Adders , Sumers , Square Root Extractors , PID controllers , switches.
      3 - 15 psi to represent 0 - 100 %

      when I did my Industrial Instrumentation Apprenticeship , pneumatics was a large part , and in some explosive enviroments it is still a preferred way to go.

      --
      ...I obey the laws of physics....
  2. Biggest problem with pneumatic tube communication by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

    The bandwidth sucks.

  3. Re:I guess the only question is... by More_Cowbell · · Score: 4, Informative

    I guess the only question is... why don't you take a look at TFA and get all your questions answered, instead of rushing here to try for a FP?

    --
    Experience teaches only the teachable. -AH
  4. Used in other places, too by AliasMarlowe · · Score: 4, Insightful

    The ultra-modern pharmacy in the local town also uses pneumatic delivery for prescription drugs. You present your prescription at the counter, and the attendant checks it, then keys in the appropriate codes on the terminal. The pills/potion/whatever arrives via pneumatic tube while the instructions & labels are being printed. This is faster then the previous method where the same attendant would have to walk off and fetch the prescription materials.

    Some banks also use pneumatic conveyance to send currency between the counters and the vault.

    --
    Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities. - Voltaire
    1. Re:Used in other places, too by FooAtWFU · · Score: 4, Informative
      New York City used to have pneumatic mail tubes. (They shut them down when it got to the point that adding mail trucks started to be cheaper than adding tubing. Never underestimate the bandwidth of a truck, magnetic tapes or paper.)

      Heck, the first New York City subway was pneumatic. (It was also very short, and short-lived.)

      --
      The World Wide Web is dying. Soon, we shall have only the Internet.
    2. Re:Used in other places, too by FooAtWFU · · Score: 5, Interesting

      Oh, and Roosevelt Island (in the river between Manhattan and Queens) has pneumatic garbage collection. It's the only place in the US besides Disneyworld to do that. Apparently it works somewhat-not-unlike a packet-switched network, periodically connecting garbage and recycling loads from different places to the appropriate suction via the same set of tubes.

      --
      The World Wide Web is dying. Soon, we shall have only the Internet.
    3. Re:Used in other places, too by alan_dershowitz · · Score: 5, Funny

      So what you're saying is that mail in NYC is a truck you put things on, not a series of tubes?

    4. Re:Used in other places, too by FatdogHaiku · · Score: 5, Funny

      Heck, the first New York City subway was pneumatic. (It was also very short, and short-lived.)

      Could that be because it sucked?

      --
      You have the right to remain sentient. If you give up the right to remain sentient, you will be elected to public office
    5. Re:Used in other places, too by canajin56 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      The Costco in my hometown uses pneumatic tubes to deliver money to the back room, from the registers. When there's too much cash in the drawer, you take the excess, stick it in a canister, it shoots off to be counted and put in the safe. I think if somebody breaks a large bill and you're low on change, the back room could also shoot you a canister of small bills to stock up with, but I've never seen that happen.

      --
      ASCII stupid question, get a stupid ANSI
    6. Re:Used in other places, too by dangitman · · Score: 4, Funny

      New York City does have a fascinating history of pneumatic transport projects. A particularly elaborate example is when New Yorkers were supplied with fresh burritos via pneumatic delivery.

      --
      ... and then they built the supercollider.
    7. Re:Used in other places, too by Sporkinum · · Score: 5, Interesting

      That is not unlike what I remember as a kid at a local department store. They didn't have cash registers, they had a table/desk with a tube endpoint on it. The clerk would take your check/money and a hand written bill and put it in the tube pod. It would shoot up to the 5 floor where the ladies handled the cash. After a short wait, a tube pod would come down with your receipt and any change you were due. It fascinated me and was always a treat to go there. It was also a treat because they had an elevator with dual doors and a guy that ran it.

      Now get off my lawn!

      --
      "He's lost in a 'floyd hole"
    8. Re:Used in other places, too by Kell+Bengal · · Score: 4, Funny

      That would be 'inappropriate suction'.

      --
      Scientists point out problems, engineers fix them
      altslashdot.org: The future of slashdot.
  5. This must have had the endorsement of.... by 8127972 · · Score: 4, Funny

    ... Sen. Ted Stevens.

    --
    This is my opinion. To make sure you don't steal it, it's covered by the DMCA.
    1. Re:This must have had the endorsement of.... by EdIII · · Score: 5, Interesting

      The funny thing to me is why people make fun of him at all. He is not an IT guy. In layman's terms a series of tubes is actually appropriate.

      You can look at a CAT5 cable and a fiber optic cable as being a tube, and information being droplets of water. All of the fiber running across the world is essentially a series of tubes and used to transport these droplets of information from one place to another.

      It is a little more complex than that of course. We have routers and switches which inspect those droplets of information and route them through other tubes, modify them, or just discard them which occurs at layers 2 and 3.

      I don't think it is unreasonable or stupid to liken layer 1 infrastructure to a series of tubes. It's a pretty easy abstraction to construct if you don't have an in-depth understanding of the technology.

    2. Re:This must have had the endorsement of.... by EdIII · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Who cares about the rest of the speech? I am only talking about the series of tubes comment. It's not the whole speech people make fun of, but just that comment.

      Appropriate grasp? Really? Series of tubes seems to me to be an appropriate grasp for a Senator. Unless you are saying that any Senator appointed to that subcommittee has to be an IT person.

      In fact, I would bet that an IT guy might even explain it that way to a Senator if they had asked.

      Instead of saying, "welll.. he is in a position of authority and you know he should like know all this stuff.." you might want to justify how series of tubes is an inappropriate and/or stupid abstraction of layer 1 communications worthy of ridicule.

      If you disagreed with the rest of his speech, just say you don't like the man's politics. Just don't try making fun of him for something that is really not able to made fun of in the first place.

    3. Re:This must have had the endorsement of.... by mr100percent · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Nah, why people make fun of him is when he said in a speech condemning Net Neutrality: "I just the other day got, an internet was sent by my staff at 10 o’clock in the morning on Friday and I just got it yesterday. Why? Because it got tangled up with all these things going on the internet commercially."

      Assuming he meant email, is network congestion so bad that it takes a weekend to send an email? More likely he doesn't know how to use a computer properly

  6. Re:Biggest problem with pneumatic tube communicati by 91degrees · · Score: 4, Interesting

    For that matter, how much information can you send if you load up a 16-Gb USB drive (or a few) and send them off in a tube?

    You have a last mile (or last metre) problem there though. Getting the data through the tube will take seconds. Minutes at most. 16GB through USB2 will take a few minutes even if you actually do get the maximum theoretical throughput.

  7. Re:Biggest problem with pneumatic tube communicati by noidentity · · Score: 5, Funny

    Biggest problem with pneumatic tube communication: The bandwidth sucks.

    How do you figure? How much information is coded in a blood sample, for instance, if you count all the DNA/RNA sequencing? For that matter, how much information can you send if you load up a 16-Gb USB drive (or a few) and send them off in a tube?

    No, the bandwidth here is just fine.

    There has never been a more appropriate time for this response: WHOOSH! (as the parcel goes by in the tube)

  8. Pneumatic tubes used to be big in the 19th century by Bender_ · · Score: 4, Informative

    Both Berlin and Paris had a networks with a total length of more than 400km.

    obvious link

  9. Re:Big supermarkets have them here. by mikael · · Score: 4, Informative

    Nearly all the department stores did that back in the 1950's/1960's . There were no electronic cash registers, and checkout staff weren't allowed to handle money. So the customer would place their payment along with a receipt signed by the checkout clerk into a capsule. This would be sent upstairs to be processed by an accountant who would send the change back down to the checkout clerk. Just like in the movie "Brazil".

    --
    Vintage computer adverts: http://www.vintageadbrowser.com/computers-and-software-ads
  10. Fluff piece, sorta by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 4, Insightful

    I found the article mildly interesting but the lack of details disappointing. They only mention things like switching points and waiting areas in passing. It would've been a great article if they'd talked about the specific tech - I know it's old tech, but most of us have had little to no exposure to it (I've been to banks that use it at their drive-through windows... that's about it). For example: there are switches; is there any sort of prioritization protocol, or are the switches simply for collision prevention?

    --
    #DeleteChrome
  11. Common in the UK, good way to loose an ear by AndyGasman · · Score: 5, Interesting

    They are pretty common in the UK, in all sort of industries.

    Tesco supermarket uses them in some stores for moving cash to tills, and they are widely used in Hospitals.

    There is one great, if slightly lengthy story that a friend tells, from when she was working in a hospital in Western Scotland a few years ago, I'll try to recount it best as I can.

    A patient who has Hepatitis and Epilepsy is admitted to the hospital, he had a fit, and his Dog bit his ear off while he was fitting. So he came to hospital with his ear in his pocket. He was treated in A&E (UK ER) and sent up to the surgical department. His Ear though was wrapped up and put in a tube, however before the doctor could tap in the destination, the pod whizzed off. The hepatitis positive ear was not found for several days (is this just a bit error rate?), as it was quiet a big hospital with a lot of tubes. It could have been worse, as the ear was not intended to be sown back on, but just photographed and incinerated. The doctor who put the ear in the pod was known as Stupid Dave before the incident, but I'm sure this didn't help him shake of the moniker. The worst thing is, most people just ask what happened to the dog.

    You don't get that with TCP/IP

  12. also functions as as hort range time machine by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    at the hospital at which I worked, you could select the origin station as the destination, and the tube system would dutifully take the carrier all the way around and back. so you could send yourself something, and receive it a few minutes later. I loved sending stuff to myself in the (near) future.

  13. Re:Big supermarkets have them here. by maxume · · Score: 4, Funny

    You stop letting them spend all day in the basement.

    --
    Nerd rage is the funniest rage.
  14. Re:Big supermarkets have them here. by I_am_Jack · · Score: 5, Informative

    Actually, the blower from a vacuum cleaner at a car wash would be more than enough to power a 100mm dia. (4" in the US, which is a standard tube size here for pneumatic tube systems) point-to-point line, and you could move the carrier several hundred meters with a payload up up to a half kilo. You could use ABS sewage line. The problem is how you would create bends and offsets. The smallest radius for a standard size carrier in a 100mm dia. tube is 60cm. Sealing the system is really not much of an issue. And if you use a piece of 70mm pipe, you'd need to wrap the outside with the fuzzy velcro strips at equadistant points to make your seal in order to allow the pressure/vacuum to propel the carrier. I used to sell the big systems to hospitals for a living.

  15. Re:I guess the only question is... by Discordantus · · Score: 4, Insightful

    (and no couriers available to fall back on)

    Luckily, they have plenty of *general purpose* organic units to fall back on, which, while less efficient than the tube network, can quickly transport the physical objects. Just because no one has "courier" in their job description, doesn't mean there are no available couriers.

  16. Re:Ding Ding by Vegeta99 · · Score: 5, Informative

    When I was in high school, I quite stereotypically worked at McDonald's. To this day, whenever I eat there, I can tell you EXACTLY what is happening in the kitchen. Someone really paid attention to make sure no function requiring human attention in that kitchen had the same sound.

    Sometimes, if some jerkoff called off and you were stuck back in the kitchen alone, it was MADDENING. You absolutely are more aware of a loud, high pitched beep than a voice telling you to do something

  17. Re:I guess the only question is... by shogun · · Score: 4, Funny

    actually some pneumatic tube systems have procedures for a stuck cylinder, by sending a second heavier cylinder, or by increasing the pressure to higher than normal levels, either way clearing the tube.

    as in Futurama: Governor lady said "I'm sending in more trains!"

  18. Anonymous Coward by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I used such tubes all day, every day, for several years, doing Neutron Activation Analysis. The samples were loaded three per tube, known as rabbits. They went into the slot, closed and blew down the outside wall of the building, underground, and then up into the core of our TRIGA reactor. There they got neutrons of various energies for anywhere from 0.05 to 2-3 seconds, and then they blasted back to me. Behind the shields I removed the samples and placed them at the gamma detectors--moving very fast. Counting gammas took anywhere from seconds to days, depending upon type and elements.

    We proved the existence of the Northern Hemisphere ozone depletion with 800 samples, and several of my graduates got PhDs. Another project showed trade routes extant through northern Italy at the construction of the Colliseum.

    Once in a while a rabbit would get stuck. A particularly hot one did, right at the corner of my lab. We timed that test so no one else was in the building, and it got so hot it wouldn't come back past the tube joint. If I hadn't known just where the 36" wrench was, the building could have been badly contaminated, and would've shut down, as in national news. I got it out without too much exposure, and was offered the job as building manager later.

    Another time a sample exploded while removing it from a rabbit, showering my nose with hot dust. I still get stray hairs growing there...

  19. Re:Would be interesting for home plumbing by scottv67 · · Score: 4, Funny

    > I've occasionally thought it would be interesting to use this kind of technology for home plumbing. For example, when you turn on your sink and ask for hot water, instead of having a continuous flow in a pipe from the hot water heater to the sink (which wastes a lot of energy), why not use a pneumatic tube system to deliver a packet of hot water to the sink?

    Are you fucking high?

    >Note that the same tubes could be used for delivering hot water an cold water, and taking away waste water? (You'd have separate containers, of course, for fresh water and waste water).

    Are you fucking high?

    >You could do cool things with a pneumatic packet-switched water network. For instance, it would be easy to add a storage tank and route shower waster water to the tank, and then from there to the toilets for flushing.

    Are you fucking high?

    >And I bet with some clever design, you could make it so the pneumatic tube system could double as a centralized vacuum system for house cleaning.

    Seriously, are you fucking high?

  20. Re:Would be interesting for home plumbing by mr_matticus · · Score: 4, Informative

    Why not? Possibly because of the following:

    1) The energy required to transport "packets" of hot water is many, many times greater than the losses through the hot water pipes.

    2) The cost of building such a system would exceed any logical benefit; adding a large-diameter pipe system would occupy considerable space and would require some (presumably mechanized) system for sorting, draining, and filling the containers (as well as isolating waste water containers from the others) in a space-consuming "sorting room".

    3) Each shower, sink, and drain in the building would require a large accumulation tank, since it would take multiple "packets" to flush a toilet, and storing enough hot water for even a brief shower would require many, many trips through the system. Any drain reservoir that filled faster than the system could empty it would back up into the sink/toilet/bathtub. The largest conceivable container to fit into a typical building could hold about a gallon of water and would be twice the size of the system used at banks--it certainly wouldn't fit inside a standard wall and would require a special breakout conduit.

    4) For home use, building a sufficiently complex system would simply be impossible--all water flow would stop while your "packets" were en route to other destinations. There is no conceivable way to build bypass structures and waiting areas sufficient to allow multiple taps to work simultaneously at an acceptable refill rate.

    5) Given the necessary locations for most of the accumulation tanks, you would need active pumps to run most faucets--the system would not function on water pressure alone as it does now. This adds cost, complexity, and new failure modes. Power outage? There goes the toilets.

    The whole idea is a Rube. If the relatively small losses in the hot water pipes concern you, build a home with insulated hot water pipes. Add a central vac if you like. The end result will be cheaper, more efficient, and 99% less insane.

  21. Re:Ding Ding by The+Wild+Norseman · · Score: 5, Funny

    To help alert employees to the arrival of containers, the system has more than three dozen different combinations of chiming tones.

    bing bing bong bong
    bing bing bong bong
    "Well, Theresa, aren't you going to get that?"
    "Hell no! That's Marty from accounting! He's been trying to contact me ever since he thought I was coming on to him at the Christmas party. As if!"
    "No, that's not Marty. Marty is bing bing bing bong and not bing bing bong bong. That's Bill in IT."
    "Are you sure? I thought Bill's was bing bong bong bing."
    "Nope. You might be confusing that with Jerry which is bong bing bong bingybong."
    "Okay, but only if you're sure."

    --
    "A government is a body of people usually -- notably -- ungoverned." -Shepherd Book
  22. Particularly relevant... by kmac06 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    *whoosh*