Slashdot Mirror
Former Nurse Charged With Aiding Suicides Via Web
mernil writes "A former US nurse has been charged with two counts of aiding suicides on the Internet, US officials say. William Melchert-Dinkel, 47, is accused of encouraging the suicides of Mark Drybrough from Coventry, UK, in 2005 and Canada's Nadia Kajouji in 2008. Melchert-Dinkel, from Minnesota, allegedly posed as a female nurse, instructing people in suicide chatrooms how to take their lives. He reportedly admitted helping five or fewer people kill themselves. Some legal experts say it could be difficult to prosecute Melchert-Dinkel under a rarely used law because he allegedly only encouraged the victims to kill themselves, without physically helping them to take their lives."
Except that's not what happened, this guy pretended to be a woman, made fake suicide pacts and actually pressured people to go through with them.
Yes, this guy is pretty sick. From the summary I thought this was about assisted suicide of the terminally ill. The article makes it clear it was encouragement of depressed, but physically healthy, people to commit suicide.
The law is supposed to define what being a dick means so you can be punished for it. I think I heard of a similar case (probably in another country) where someone got arrested for encouraging suicide. It counts as psychological assault and conspiracy to murder I think.
Justice is the sheep getting arrested while an impartial judge declares the vote void.
From here:
Words fail me, really.
It's sad that people are being prosecuted for being dicks rather than for breaking actual laws. Mob justice acts with an arbitrary and inconsistent hand, and has no place under the rule of law.
He pretended to be a female nurse in order to instruct others on how to commit suicide.
To clarify, the issue is not that he pretended to be female, but rather that he pretended to be a nurse (although if anyone relied on him being a female for the purpose of committing suicide, it in fact could be an issue).
I'm fairly certain that fraud, especially in the context of pretending to have medical training, is in fact a crime based on actual laws.
Meanwhile, he has been charged with two counts of assisting suicide, not convicted by mob justice (for example, being hanged in a tree without a court hearing). He has a chance to prove that he did nothing wrong, or to be convicted of a crime that has been committed, specifically because of rule of law. Your implication that charging someone with a crime based on valid allegations (in this case, based on the fact that the accused admits to having helped people commit suicide) should be seen as mob justice is patently absurd.
I think suicide actually goes beyond humans, and is a very natural thing. Not an animal expert but I suspect depression is an natural animal instinct that evolved to benefit the greater good of the species to deal with situations such as over population, injury, inability to adapt, or other conditions that make the individual useless and of no or negative benefit to the species.
Of course you don't see squirrels putting guns to their heads because they don't need to. In nature if an animal were to become depressed, it would just use less energy defending itself from its natural predators, not feed itself sufficiently, or something like that and eventually *chomp* no more critter.
So yes, if humans want to reduce suicide they should focus on detecting and treating depression, being sure to involve friends, relatives, and making sure the individual had a sufficient purpose in the world.