Tetris Clones Pulled From Android Market

sbrubblesman writes "The Tetris Company, LLC has notified Google to remove all Tetris clones from Android Market. I am one of the developers of FallingBlocks, a game with the same gameplay concepts as Tetris. I have received an email warning that my game was suspended from Android Market due to a violation of the Developer Content Policy. When I received the email, I already imagined that it had something to do with it being a Tetris clone, but besides having the same gameplay as Tetris, which I believe cannot be copyrighted, the game uses its own name, graphics and sounds. There's no reference to 'Tetris' in our game. I have emailed Google asking what is the reason for the application removal. Google promptly answered that The Tetris Company, LLC notified them under the DMCA (PDF) to remove various Tetris clones from Android Market. My app was removed together with 35 other Tetris clones. I checked online at various sources, and all of them say that there's no copyright on gameplay. There could be some sort of patent. But even if they had one, it would last 20 years, so it would have been over in 2005. It's a shame that The Tetris Company, LLC uses its power to stop developers from creating good and free games for Android users. Without resources for a legal fight, our application and many others will cease to exist, even knowing that they are legit. Users will be forced to buy the paid, official version, which is worse than many of the ones available for free on the market. Users from other countries, such as Brazil in my case, won't even be able to play the official Tetris, since Google Checkout doesn't exist in Brazil; you can't buy paid applications from Android Market in these countries."

Comments

shame

[jDeepbeep]

Falling Blocks is a nice little game. It's on my phone right now, so here's hoping that Google won't 'pull an Amazon' and vanish it off the device.

How about replying?

[Issarlk]

Doen't the DMCA allow you to just send a "No I don't infringue on the copyright" back to Google and have your app not taken down?

Re:How about replying?

[ICLKennyG]

This is one of the biggest problem with the DMCA. You have given all the power to the big conglomerates without making them risk anything in return. They just indiscriminately fire C&D letters like shotgun blasts and use them to anti-competitive effect. The only thing Tetris has is their trademark claim and a prevention on decompiling/copying their code or graphics in an exact manner. Feist We need a broader application of Assessment Technologies.

I'd be less critical of the DMCA if they had a penalty, $10,000 plus costs, for reckless or malicious take-down notices. You wouldn't get companies sending 25,000+ a day for 2 seconds of their content used in a fair use manner. This is what scares me so much about the MPEG 7.

Re:How about replying?

[Interoperable]

I think that Google might well restore the app if a counter-claim was filed. They work hard to avoid being painted as a big evil corporation and in this case, there's no risk to them if the counter-claim is filed, in fact, there's less risk. All the risk would be assumed by the developer of Falling Blocks, who would have to hope that the EFF would supply lawyers in the event of a law suit.

Could be worse..

[draxil]

Of course with Android you always have the option of getting software from sources other than the main sanctioned market. Unlike a certain other smartphone OS I could mention.

Instead of Whining, Create Something Original

[RobotRunAmok]

I'm always amused by how the same geek crowd that will rip a film-maker or author to shreds over re-hashing some common plot device will support to the death a software developer demonstrating the same lack of unoriginality.

"Falling Blocks!" The guy made a Tetris clone and called it "Falling Blocks!"

Where's the pride?

Re:Instead of Whining, Create Something Original

[loshwomp]

I'm always amused by how the same geek crowd that will rip a film-maker or author to shreds over re-hashing some common plot device will support to the death a software developer demonstrating the same lack of unoriginality.

Citation, please. I've seen nothing to indicate that this is the same geek.

And anyway, no one shuts down the big movie company when they make a re-hash movie.

Re:Instead of Whining, Create Something Original

[moonbender]

By the same argument, developers ought to be ashamed for writing a Chess game (or crafting a real one, for that matter -- it's been done before, man!). Tetris is a staple game, it's a shame that the name is trademarked, and it's downright preposterous to send out notices to take down the clones which don't infringe on the trademark.

The comparison the books and movies is flawed: I don't watch the same movie two evenings in a row, and I might now want to watch two extremely similar movies in terms of characters and plot on two evenings in a row. Playing a game of skill such as Tetris five times in a row isn't such a problem though. The two are at opposite ends of the interactivity scale, with plot-heavy games in the middle.

Re:Instead of Whining, Create Something Original

[delinear]

Complaining about someone's lack of originality while supporting their right to be unoriginal aren't mutually exclusive.

Re:All in all..

[c-reus]

For me this seems fairly similar to claiming that Doom, Quake and a number of other FPS games should not exist because they're clones of Wolf3D.

Re:Old news?

[TheCRAIGGERS]

Do you work for The Tetris Company?

This is horrible advice and underlines everything (ok, maybe not everything) that is wrong with the DMCA. The company is being an unlawful bully and bowing to their pressure is not going to help anything.