Slashdot Mirror


Russian Media Link Moscow Bombing With Modern Warfare 2 Scene

An anonymous reader tips news that following the airport bombing in Moscow earlier this week, the Russia media is linking the attack to a scene from Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 in which a number of civilians were gunned down inside an airport. "Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 has become a shocking reality ... with so many people seemingly downloading, playing or watching this game, you have to consider whether or not anybody actually thought this game could so closely resemble reality,' said a Russia Today news presenter in the report. It also included comments from US terrorism expert Walid Phares, who said it was possible that computer games might influence the strategies employed by terrorists. Phares, who is director of Future Terrorism Project at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, said: 'The issue is we need to know if terrorists or extremists are using these videos or DVDs or games to basically apply the model.' 'I think those who have been radicalized already – that is supposed in this case jihadists, Al-Qaeda or other kind – they look at the games and say these games will serve them to train.'" As we discussed when the game came out, Activision edited out the controversial scene from the Russian version. Violent video games have been taking a similar beating in the US after the shooting in Arizona earlier this month.

17 of 91 comments (clear)

  1. Must surely be correct by RogueyWon · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The Russian media must clearly be correct. Nobody ever attacked an airport before.

    This is a strong contender for "lowest point in the history of journalism about video games". At the very least, it's tied with the whole MS Flight Sim and 9/11 "controversy". It's hard to see it as anything but an insult to those who died or were injured in the incident.

    1. Re:Must surely be correct by noidentity · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Games might affect the exact target of these extremists, but they are not the cause of their extremism. It's their extremism that is leads them to kill innocent people. I can't help but think of water precipitating in the atmosphere. "It's that grain of dust that caused that drop to precipitate! If it hadn't been for that grain of dust, this drop wouldn't have precipitated somewhere else."

      Seems like their blame on games is like when there's a bully that nobody wants to deal with, so their anger towards him is directed at other things. Like if the bully threatens to beat someone up if anyone goes near the soda machines, you blame the kid who went near the soda machines for causing someone to get beat up, because you're too cowardly to confront the bully.

    2. Re:Must surely be correct by rainmouse · · Score: 2, Insightful

      This is a strong contender for "lowest point in the history of journalism about video games". At the very least, it's tied with the whole MS Flight Sim and 9/11 "controversy". It's hard to see it as anything but an insult to those who died or were injured in the incident.

      You are right, there is no evidence other than reasonably close timing, but to be honest part of me feels they deserve some of the heat by using such dubious methods purely for hype and marketing purposes. Though I must stress I am completely against censorship, the fact that Activision would add content that is pretty much guaranteed to cause worldwide damage to the gaming industry for free marketing and thus a quick extra few points on the profit margins is frankly far more offensive than the actual content in the game itself.

    3. Re:Must surely be correct by Feinu · · Score: 3, Funny

      At the very least, it's tied with the whole MS Flight Sim and 9/11 "controversy"

      Not even close. Comparing the realism between flight sim games and MW2 is ludicrous - with some additional hardware you could start approximating the experience of flying a plane. Hardly compares to holding down 'W', waving your mouse around and clicking bullets into unarmed civilians.

      Additionally, there is no bomb in the "No Russian" mission of MW2, while it's entirely possible to fly jets into the World Trade Center in pre-9/11 flight sims. I once did it with a Cessna in Flight Simulator 95, which resulted in "This program has performed an illegal operation and will be shut down" moments after the crash.

    4. Re:Must surely be correct by silanea · · Score: 2

      What is the alternative? Not to shock people? Hell, literature would be a rather poor subject if authors had followed that reasoning. Yes, the airport scene is crass. Yes, I can understand that it is controversial to many people. Still it is a work of fiction. Nothing more. Fiction serves to entertain, and there was a time it also was intended to educate. And I do see MW2 in this tradition. It has the player face probably the biggest dilemma of them all: Does the end justify the means?

      We see exactly this question asked right now across European media - though admittedly in a much less dire context, thank goodness - with the investigation into British PC Mark Kennedy's conduct. How far may the "good" go to fight the "bad"? May they break laws? If yes, which ones? May they violate ethical or moral conventions? MW2 may have chosen the most drastic scenario imaginable - killing those that you are supposed to protect - but the underlying issue is the same. Here in Germany just a while ago a law was snubbed by the supreme court that would have permitted the armed forces to shoot down hijacked passenger planes if they were being used as weapons akin to 9/11. So I really do not see why the game causes such a shit storm. Reality is far, far more grim.

      --
      Rudolf Hess edited Mein Kampf. He was the very first grammar nazi.
    5. Re:Must surely be correct by Coren22 · · Score: 2

      From that section of the article:

      Jack Thompson said about the controversy, "The guy who shot his mouth off about it had no idea what the Hell he was talking about. This contrived controversy is absolutely ridiculous."

      Holy crap, Jack Thompson defending video games? Is the world coming to an end? Oo, I think I just saw a pig fly by.

      --
      APK likes to ask for responses to the same things over and over. Maybe he just likes the responses?
  2. This has been obvious for quite a while by Maxo-Texas · · Score: 2

    Any security barrier creates a clot of people which becomes a target.

    You can protect the planes for the most part, but people are tougher.

    --
    She was like chocolate when she drank... semi-sweet at first and then increasingly bitter.
  3. Highly connected. by cgenman · · Score: 5, Informative

    For the record, in Modern Warfare 2, the terrorists are a group of people who gun down people in the middle of an airport with automatic guns. In real life, this guy blew himself up outside the terminal.

    Obviously, very similar.

    1. Re:Highly connected. by alvinrod · · Score: 2

      It's really sad that this is the best scapegoat they could drag out; but, because the majority of the population hasn't played the game, it'll fly.

  4. What we all already know... by sysusr · · Score: 2

    Games have never been the problem. The number of shootings, bombings etc in a country doesn't grow proportionally to the number of people exposed to violent video games. They grow based on the culture of the country in which they occur in. The US has a particularly high number (overall and per capita), but countries with similar living conditions have almost none.

    Russia has always had a problem with terrorists and various ethnic groups. Anyone blaming a game for something like this is desperately grasping for straws and hits.

    --
    \x72\x6D\x20\x2D\x72\x66
  5. To quote the text message receved from a friend... by dohzer · · Score: 2

    "Russian airport bombed. Looks so much like MW2"

    That's exactly what he sent a few hours after it happened.

  6. just like MW2 by dnaumov · · Score: 2

    So:

    The attack wasn't really a suicide bomber, it was 5 gunmen?
    One of the gunmen was actually an american?
    The atack was carried out to the music of Hans Zimmer?

    Just like MW2, alright...

    1. Re:just like MW2 by noidentity · · Score: 2

      The atack was carried out to the music of Hans Zimmer?

      You know, you've got me thinking about him. He's done the music for dozens of movies that involve violence. I think Mr. Zimmer should take some of the blame for terrorism.

  7. Blame the video games by sltd · · Score: 5, Funny

    Blaming video games for this type of violence is like blaming spoons for making Rosie O'Donnell fat.

  8. Re:Training sim? by RogueyWon · · Score: 4, Funny

    If I was engaged in fighting a war, or a counter-insurgency operation, then I know one thing. There is nothing I would love more than for my enemy to be using the Call of Duty games as training sims. Just think of all the fantastic lessons they could learn from them:

    - Don't worry about taking a few bullets. As long as you can duck behind cover, you'll be perfectly fine in 5 seconds or so.

    - Charging through an artillery barrage, mine-field or other incredibly dangerous intensely dangerous situation is absolutely fine, provided you can work out the precise sequence of steps that the developers wanted you to take. There'll be convenient cover every 10 paces or so.

    - Enemy soldiers will employ a combination of two cunning tactics. Some of them will run straight towards you, firing sporadically. Others will hide behind a piece of cover, which they will stick their heads above at predictable 3 second intervals. Don't worry too much about numbers; you should be able to take down a dozen or so at a time.

    - If all else fails, hole up on a hill against overwhelming waves of enemies. It might get sticky for a while, but after 5 minutes or so, stirring music will play and reinforcements will arrive to save you.

  9. Shut up by aaaaaaargh! · · Score: 2

    In my humble opinion, people working on projects called "Future Terrorism Project" at research institutes with names like "the Foundation for Defense of Democracies" should just shut up. I mean, really, shut up!

  10. And I blame mario... by hipp5 · · Score: 2

    for my high consumption of 'shrooms.