Slashdot Mirror


Forging a Head: The Upside of Scientific Hoaxes

An anonymous reader writes "In a very funny piece over at Science Careers (published by the journal Science), scientist-comedian Adam Ruben suggests that a lot of good can come from a well-intentioned hoax. 'Hoaxes have infiltrated science for centuries,' Ruben writes, 'from fake fossils (Piltdown Man, archaeoraptor, Calaveras skull) to fake medical conditions (cello scrotum, the disappearing blonde gene) to fake animals (Ompax spatuloides, Pacific Northwest tree octopus, Labradoodle).' In contrast to fraud, Ruben argues, such hoaxes do a great service to science by illustrating 'failures of our most important tool: our skepticism.'"

3 of 201 comments (clear)

  1. Re:I did not evolve from an ape.... by maxwell+demon · · Score: 5, Funny

    So I get you are still an ape? Fortunately I evolved away from that. :-)

    --
    The Tao of math: The numbers you can count are not the real numbers.
  2. Re:Fake Dogs?!? by ShakaUVM · · Score: 5, Funny

    Labradoodles are both real, *and* a blasphemous abomination before the Lord.

    Seriously. Labs and Poodles should never be in the same room together, let alone mated. They're the most disgustingly horrific dog to have ever been successfully bred this side of Lovecraft's fecund imagination.

  3. Re:I did not evolve from an ape.... by mangu · · Score: 5, Insightful

    There is more evidence in Creationism - as well as it making more sense.

    But if we take Bronze Age myths as evidence, then there's much more evidence for theories other than Judeo-Christian creationism. There are hundreds, thousands of different creationist myths out there.

    If you think an old book is evidence enough you have to consider all other old books as equally valid, don't you?