Slashdot Mirror
Friday's Big Swings, Mostly Down, Illustrate Bitcoin Value Volatility
An anonymous reader writes "As cool as Bitcoin is, it looks like it lost 1/3 of its value in the last 24 hours. Lots of big sells, complaints of liquidity, and pissed off nerds." The linked article goes on to explain that the value rose again, so the aggregate loss was considerably less. The author also helps defuse claims that Bitcoin is untraceable or otherwise especially well suited to nefarious activities.
I think it is weird and irrational that we should let our lives be determined by a totally imaginary thing, this "value," where all wants and needs are collapsed into one measure, "value" and its accumulation. Now if you ask me, I will stick to real value like dollars which is the natural measure of Man and all his works, not some silly thing on the internet that is really just an electron representing some fucked-up historically determined concept for which millions starve and a few prosper.
UNITE with the Campaign for a Free Internet because today, our future begins with tomorrow!
I keep waiting for someone to jump out and shout "April Fool!"
Yes, yes, all currency is imaginary. But there's imaginary and frigging deluded.
The gst of the article is "Bitcoin is important. It's just like real money. See, it even has a market like real money, but the problems of the market aren't too bad." Despite the Slashdot headlne mentioning the volatility, the article goes out of its way to say to say that the problems aren't all that bad and goes on to emphasize how much it is like real money. It then goes for four sections (out of five total) explaining exactly what Bitcoin is, why people might want to have it, how it's being attacked for no fault of its own, and how some people don't like it but it's just paranoia.
It's a disguised ad It's like having an article whose headline says that a popular diet doesn't always work, then reading the text and finding that the reason it doesn't work is because it's too natural and some people refuse to obey the diet because they don't like natural things. Then followed by paragraphs of details about the diet, where to buy a book about it, and complaining about how the media doesn't like the diet.
Look at the Bitcoin price chart . This is a price-only 90 day chart. The site normally displays the price on top of the volume, which obfuscates the trend. Displayed in this form, the chart just screams "bubble".
Yesterday's drop takes the price back to where it was on June 6. Which is twice the price of June 1. Which is twice the price of May 1. Which is three times the price of April 4. Yesterday just happened to be the first big drop.
Patterns like that in something that doesn't generate revenue are usually associated with "High Yield Investment Programs" and Ponzi scams. One wonders how many Bitcoins the people behind this bought early.
Someone just cashed out a large deposit of bitcoins, and these nerds and bitcoin miners just got played. 3 months ago, this thing was less than $1. Now it was $30? lolz Someone made some good money, and waited for there to be enough liquidity for them to be able to cash out and raped the order book. This is a classic accumulation/distribution (a.k.a pump and dump) pattern where a few buyers suck in a multitude of retail fools by slowing raising the price through accumulation, and then once retail fervor hits, they dump it and get out. It's so stereotypical, it's a cliche, and I guess bitcoin just fell for it as well. I only wish I could short this thing, it's going back to below $1.
Update: The main "BitCoin exchange", Mt. Gox, gives no information about the business entity behind the exchange, not even an address. The site has only "Tibanne Co. Ltd. (Japan)", which is an ISP in Tokyo.
Mt. Gox is a depository institution - you have to deposit BitCoins to sell them, and after the trade, you now have credit in some currency with Mt. Gox. Then you have to get the money out of Mt. Gox. The withdrawal process is slow. Also, on one forum, there's the comment from a Mt. Gox staffer (?) "If we have a lot of LR activity (like, about now), withdraws will be put on hold and executed later (ie. the next day) in the order they were received." That just screams "Ponzi scheme". They're an exchange; if they're honest, they should never have a cash flow problem.
The more I look at the BitCoin financial infrastructure, the more it looks like the High Yield Investment Program scams. Multiple offshore entities, withdrawal limits, unexpected delays in payouts, anonymous businesses. HYIP schemes are notable for being difficult to cash out of. They have to be, because they're Ponzi schemes.