Slashdot Mirror


Japanese Scientist Creates Meat Substitute From Sewage

An anonymous reader writes "Hold on to your hamburgers — Japanese scientist Mitsyuki Ikeda at the Environmental Assessment Center in Okayama has invented an artificial meat substitute made from human feces. The unseemly meal is made by extracting protein and lipids from 'sewage mud.' The lipids are then combined with a reaction enhancer and whipped into 'meat' in an exploder. Ikeda makes the 'meat' more palatable by adding things like soy protein."

50 of 417 comments (clear)

  1. um... by enderjsv · · Score: 2

    Disgusting. I'd rather eat soylent green.

    1. Re:um... by msauve · · Score: 5, Funny

      Well, this is simply soylent brown.

      --
      "National Security is the chief cause of national insecurity." - Celine's First Law
    2. Re:um... by couchslug · · Score: 3, Insightful

      "Disgusting. I'd rather eat soylent green."

      With this technology you can eat soylent green. Again, and again, and again.

      --
      "This post is an artistic work of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact."
    3. Re:um... by Oligonicella · · Score: 2

      Yes. Yes, it is.

    4. Re:um... by syousef · · Score: 3, Insightful

      It's not all that much more disgusting than fast food as is.

      Okay either your fast food is a lot worse than what it is like here, or you have no sense of taste or smell. The fast food might not be good for you, but it shouldn't be so bad as to make you ill the way poo does, and it is designed to be appetizing despite being bad for you.

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
    5. Re:um... by Darinbob · · Score: 2

      "Soylent Brown is digested people!"

  2. Harro, Shitty Wok by jnpcl · · Score: 3, Funny

    Try dericious shitty meat!

    1. Re:Harro, Shitty Wok by jameskojiro · · Score: 2, Funny

      That's Lacist!

      --
      Tsukasa: All I really want, is to be left alone...
    2. Re:Harro, Shitty Wok by LoRdTAW · · Score: 2

      One order shitty beef and one order shitty chicken

  3. Re:"soylent green is people" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    Soylent Brown is Poop-le!

    Sorry, it was too easy.

  4. someone will eat it by v1 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    We're always seeing people eating strange things, whether it be fish that may or may not be lethal, to tasties like cow brains and pig testicles, this will be no different. There will be some that will eat it. If nothing else, ship it to people that would much prefer turdburgers to starvation. But the start will probably just be people eating it for the shock/novelty value.

    The scientist says his goal is to make it the same price as regular meat... I think they're going to have to go a little better than that, make it cheaper. If you can drop the cost per calorie/nutrient down to at least that of say, grain, it'd be an ideal foodsource for places that need food relief. Right now they don't see meat because of cost - grain is still their cheapest alternative. This would be a lot higher in protein, so if they could at least match the cost, that'd be a hit.

    --
    I work for the Department of Redundancy Department.
    1. Re:someone will eat it by Nethemas+the+Great · · Score: 2

      If this can be made palatable I suspect there will be some interest at NASA. For any kind of long duration missions this would make for a pretty handy food stuff supplement much like how they're now recycling urine.

      --
      Two of my imaginary friends reproduced once ... with negative results.
    2. Re:someone will eat it by JDeane · · Score: 3, Informative

      I stole this from Wikipedia shhh don't tell them.

      "Allura Red AC is one of many High Production Volume Chemicals.

      Red AC was originally manufactured from coal tar, but is now mostly made from petroleum. Despite the popular misconception, Allura Red AC is not derived from any insect, unlike the food colouring carmine, which is derived from the female cochineal insect."

    3. Re:someone will eat it by syousef · · Score: 3, Funny

      Scientist's Advertisement on Google, "EAT SHIT" or wait.. "Check This Shit Out!". OK, someone had to say this.

      I'll [bet] that scientist wants to charge as much as a T-bone or Prime Chuck! He's in this shit up to his knees for what, notoriety?

      Waiter!!! There's a fly in my excrement!

      --
      These posts express my own personal views, not those of my employer
    4. Re:someone will eat it by Larryish · · Score: 5, Funny

      Wow.

      Starving masses in Africa eating our bourgeois American white-people feces.

      That would be a total PR shit storm.

    5. Re:someone will eat it by RussR42 · · Score: 2

      Perhaps instead they will get their shit together and feed themselves. (couldn't help it, sorry!)

    6. Re:someone will eat it by 10101001+10101001 · · Score: 2

      We're always seeing people eating strange things, whether it be fish that may or may not be lethal, to tasties like cow brains and pig testicles, this will be no different.

      Well, you do realize that seeds/beans are plant ovum, right? And that fragrant gift of flowers to your loved one is a great way for them to inhale tons of plant sperm/sniffing a plant's vulva. Then there's mushrooms, which have tons of spores which are basically baby mushrooms. And there's things like cheese which are the product of an enzyme from either mammal stomachs, proteases, or apparently some vegetarian-friendly sources. Alcohol is the waste of yeast. Etc.

      I'm not saying I'd be gun-ho about eat pig testicles, but that's more a psychological/cultural thing than a particularly sensical one. After all, no one really bats an eye about eating plant testicles. :/

      --
      Eurohacker European paranoia, gun rights, and h
  5. Re:Mmmm by Forty+Two+Tenfold · · Score: 2, Informative

    Doubleplusgood this. Did you know I don't think there's a single piece of meat in this stew? Looks like meat. Tastes like meat. Isn't meat at all. Doubleplusgood!

    — George Orwell, 1984.

    --
    Upward mobility is a slippery slope - the higher you climb the more you show your ass.
  6. Another option by dawning · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Another solution to the global food crisis is to stop having massive freakin steaming piles of babies. (*Gives various religious doctrines a condemning glare*).. Further developing the pwned world would probably go a long way too.. If everyone can afford an xbox, they'll be too busy getting killed playing Halo to go reproduce. AHh, forget it, let's just chow down on some shit-jerky and "go to town"..

    1. Re:Another option by Dracos · · Score: 2

      All the places to which Spain and Portugal brought the Catholic dogma against contraception certainly do have a reproduction problem, although they can't see it that way.

    2. Re:Another option by Volante3192 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Another solution to the global food crisis is to stop having massive freakin steaming piles of babies.

      Or, just a modest proposal here, have more babies.

    3. Re:Another option by DerekLyons · · Score: 2

      Another solution to the global food crisis is to stop having massive freakin steaming piles of babies. (*Gives various religious doctrines a condemning glare*)..

      The problem of course, is that most religious doctrines don't say "go out and have piles of babies". In fact, off hand, I can't think of a single one.
       

      Further developing the pwned world would probably go a long way too.. If everyone can afford an xbox, they'll be too busy getting killed playing Halo to go reproduce.

      That birthrates in the developed world started dropping long before the introduction of electronic entertainment suggests a flaw in your argument.
       
      In fact, birthrates primarily vary with two simple factors - education and women's rights. You might want to get yourself some of the former.

    4. Re:Another option by voidphoenix · · Score: 2

      The problem of course, is that most religious doctrines don't say "go out and have piles of babies". In fact, off hand, I can't think of a single one.

      Genesis 1:28

      In fact, birthrates primarily vary with two simple factors - education and women's rights. You might want to get yourself some of the former.

      Both are vigorously and often brutally suppressed by various Christian denominations, Roman Catholicism in particular, and in stricter interpretations of Islam, such as the Taliban. You might want to get yourself some of the former, neh?

  7. Breath Mints Win! by dawning · · Score: 4, Funny

    The breath mint industry probably paid for this research.

  8. Choices, choices by Iron+Chef+Unix · · Score: 3, Insightful

    From the video: "Once the research is complete and it's put on the market we'll probably be able to price it at roughly the same level as normal meat." Hmm, should I buy the ribeye or the extruded soy-supplemented feces meat? At the same price, the choice is so difficult....

    --
    Like puzzle games? Warehouse51 for iOS
  9. The Yes men proposed this years ago ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZP_nNemsNT8
    They even suggested a pipe line between the US and developping countries, to convey the "food".
    They only thing they failed to predict was the state of the US economy, which may require to operate the pipeline in reverse.

  10. This is a huge deal for space travel by Tropico · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Recycling nutrients for space travel is essential. Astronauts already drink water that is extracting from human urine. Extracting proteins and lipids from human waste could be just as important.

    1. Re:This is a huge deal for space travel by Culture20 · · Score: 2

      Beat me to it. This is the obvious benefit. I doubt it will ever be the marketing coup that "astronaut ice cream" was, though.

      This could be "astronaut soft serve"

    2. Re:This is a huge deal for space travel by DarthVain · · Score: 2

      Astronaut 1: "And you thought drinking your own recycled pee was bad... Ha!"

  11. Only in Japan by l0ungeb0y · · Score: 2

    Once I think I've gotten used to the weirdness that comes out of Japan -- they go and top themselves.
    I suppose they'll be coming out with Tentacle and Used Panty flavored Shit-Meat® in short order

  12. I call bullshit... by mswhippingboy · · Score: 2
    I don't buy it (and believe me I won't!).
    There are lots of strange things that can be made edible (snails, bugs, pond-scum, dogs, cats, etc).
    Why choose what is probably the most disgusting choice, excrement? And if you have to choose excrement, why does it have to be "human" excrement?

    TFA even shows the scientist with a bag labelled "shit burgers"! This sounds totally like an attempt at simply getting some hits on You Tube.

    --
    Sometimes the light at the end of the tunnel is the headlight of an oncoming train.
  13. You got trolled by freefrag · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Googling the researcher's name and his institution only brings up this story. Looks like you someone successfully trolled slashdot.

    1. Re:You got trolled by carlzum · · Score: 2

      Mitsuyuki Ikeda is referenced in countless articles and papers about education and sustainability organizations. The organization and project seem consistent with his other work. I'd like to believe it's not true, but it's really not a hoax.

    2. Re:You got trolled by adolf · · Score: 2

      It's not a troll -- it's just old news.

      The WTO did a presentation on this very subject several years ago.

    3. Re:You got trolled by torgis · · Score: 2

      Your google skills are weak.... how ever, what surprised me was that this was done in 1993, which means the news are 18 years old!

      Still an acceptable timeframe to be posted on slashdot as "news" though.

  14. Big deal... by Trailer+Park+Boy · · Score: 2

    McDonalds has been doing this for years.

  15. So who did they pressure into testing it? by bmo · · Score: 3, Insightful

    This reminds me so much of elementary school recess.

    "I'll give you my snack if you eat a bug, Timmy"
    "No, I don't want to"
    "What are you a wuss? It's just a bug"
    (kids start chanting)
    "Eat a bug!"
    "Eat a bug!"
    "EAT A BUG!"

    Timmy eats the bug.

    Timmy is still known as "that kid that ate the bug" at the 50'th anniversary high school reunion.

    --
    BMO

  16. Re:The possibilities are fantastic by jameskojiro · · Score: 2

    No not really, they still need electricity to run the processes, there is no such thing as a free lunch, even if you eat your own shit.

    --
    Tsukasa: All I really want, is to be left alone...
  17. Now just apply the inverse function by smoothnorman · · Score: 2

    It was some years ago now, but i want everyone to know that i (*me*) devised a method for the reverse process. I'm still seeking my patent on the methodology.

  18. Re:Mmmm by lewoot · · Score: 3, Funny

    I wonder if consuming cayenne pepper beforehand will give the product a southwestern flair. Or if like... eating ginger and lemongrass will give it a pan-Asian spin. etc.

  19. If ever an article... by roc97007 · · Score: 2

    ...didn't need a video...

    --
    Oliver's law of assumed responsibility: If you're seen fixing it, you will be blamed for breaking it.
  20. Re:Mmmm by fyngyrz · · Score: 5, Funny

    Oh, they're going to run into real trouble here, McDonald's has a patent on this.

    --
    I've fallen off your lawn, and I can't get up.
  21. 2 points to ponder by Bazar · · Score: 2

    A few things to consider

    1. The price of meat is more expensive in Japan then most countries. So saying they'll get the costs down that of japanese meat isn't really a draw card for most other western/american nations.

    2. Compleating the food cycle? I thought we got mad-cow disease because we did this very thing with cows. We reduced the food chain and had cows eating cows, Rather then having intermedate agents inbetween.

    Now we want to mimic that efficency with humans eating human shit...

    --
    To avoid criticism; Say nothing, Do nothing, Be nothing.
  22. Re:Mmmm by bughunter · · Score: 2

    Now they can revive the "I'd Hit It!" campaign.

    All they need to do is add an 'S'...

    --
    I can see the fnords!
  23. Re:It is so much simpler than that by another_twilight · · Score: 2
    I have heard this argument, in various forms, many times.

    Let's posit your idealised government with idealised economics. Let's also posit a perfectly efficient distribution method, let's move most cities off the arable land they sit on and into less 'useful' regions. Now we can support an even greater population.

    Which we will proceed to reach and then attempt to exceed as we have done every other time the constraints on food have been lifted.

    Until we consciously and deliberately manage our populations, then we are going to keep seeing 'food crises'. Increasing the food supply, food distribution or even quality of food is not going to change that.

    If you want to solve the global food crisis, adopt socialistic policies

    Don't get me wrong, I tend towards the socialist end of the spectrum politically and philosophically, but if you _really_ want to solve the food crises, activate for increased levels of education (this has a high correlation with lowered birth rates) and against social and cultural mores that put a premium on multiple children and/or reject contraception.

  24. Re:"soylent green is people" by LordoftheLemmings · · Score: 2

    Funny you should say that because I was thinking, if this becomes popular and I become a cannibal, does that make everyone who eats food made from my crap a cannibal too?

  25. Re:Nothing Good Can Come From This by tragedy · · Score: 2

    Another market, although admittedly not a big one, could be the space industry. Reprocessing of human waste directly into food has definite applications in long manned space missions. If you had a moon base, for example, this kind of technology could be used to increase the time between resupply missions and potentially could save hundreds of millions of dollars. Not to mention that it might give the moon base occupants some real incentive to get extraterrestrial food gardens up and running as fast as possible.

  26. Old/Fake news? 2009, 2007 and mention of 1993 by w0mprat · · Score: 2

    This is apparently an story that has resurface around the web. Only this time it's gotten more attention. Googling with various date range and looking for "Environmental Assessment Center, Okayama, Japan" - "Mitsuyuki Ikeda" gets the same story popping up all the way back to a L.A. Times article dated 1993, and shows an enormous absence fact checking since.

    " 2007 Sep 27, 2007 - The Environmental Assessment Center in Okayama Japan announced in October that it had manufactured an experimental sausage by adding soybean protein and steak flavoring tosewage solids from TokyoSewage isnt really such a dangerous and dirty thing said a spokesman However he did not ... From News of the Weird | News of the Weird | Chicago Reader - Related web pages www.chicagoreader.com/chicago/news-of-the ... "

    Check this http://www.google.com/search?q=Environmental+Assessment+Center,+Okayama,+Japan&hl=en&biw=1062&bih=543&prmd=ivns&sa=X&ei=OoD5TbWtNcTTiALGx9DnBA&ved=0CDgQpQI&tbm=&tbs=tl:1,tlul:1990,tluh:2010

    http://www.greenkampong.com/food/scientists-makes-meat-from-poo/
    http://forum.prisonplanet.com/index.php?topic=119734.0 (2009)
    http://absolutelyfobulous.com/2009/09/03/ooey-gooey-poop-burger/ (1993!!!!)
    "Dec 30, 1993 - In October the Environmental Assessment Center in Okayama Japan announced that it had managed to make a sausage out of recycled Tokyo sewage by adding soybean protein and beef flavoring The company does not plan to market the product commercially however citing the main ..."

    So it is a genuine news story? Not sure, but smells very fake. Although both the alleged researcher and the organisation do have other mentions on the internet, only the organisation seems to be genuine.

    --
    After logging in slashdot still does not take you back to the page you were on. It's been that way for 20 years.
  27. Re:Mmmm by Warhawke · · Score: 2

    To be fair, McDonald's is one of the few only FFRs/QSRs to use 100% real beef in their burgers. A close friend of mine with Celiac disease tests off the charts with her gluten reaction, and McDonald's beef is the only fast food beef she can tolerate.

    I still laughed, though. +1

  28. Re:"soylent green is people" by blair1q · · Score: 2

    Uh-huh. And the stripper really likes you.