Slashdot Mirror


Last NASA Spacewalk Marks End of Era

An anonymous reader writes "Astronauts embarked on the final space walk of the U.S. shuttle era at the International Space Station, where Atlantis is docked on the final mission of the 30-year U.S. program. Atlantis carries a year's worth of supplies — more than 3,600 kilograms — for the International Space Station. It will also bring up a system that will be used by Canada's Dextre robot to test a system for refuelling and repairing spacecraft and satellites in space."

51 of 80 comments (clear)

  1. End of an era, but... by Chonnawonga · · Score: 1

    Yes, this is the end of an era. It is worth noting, and we should have serious discussions about the future and direction of American space travel. But this is the last space shuttle spacewalk, not the last NASA spacewalk. Who approves these headlines, anyway?

    (NB: the headline comes from TFA, so don't blame /. completely.)

    1. Re:End of an era, but... by couchslug · · Score: 1

      "Who approves these headlines, anyway?"

      People trolling for page hits. If Fox News can do it, so can /.

      --
      "This post is an artistic work of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact."
    2. Re:End of an era, but... by camperdave · · Score: 1

      On the contrary. There has been a lot of science in the realm of microgravity biology, and material science. You can't do that sort of stuff on the Moon, or Mars. It's exactly the type of stuff we need to know if we're going to spend more than a fortnight in space.

      --
      When our name is on the back of your car, we're behind you all the way!
  2. It's our fault the program is over by PFactor · · Score: 1

    It's our fault our government spends more money on lawyers than on astronauts. I hope the end of the space shuttle program is a tipping point in how involved we are in changing how our government works.

    --
    Don't believe anything I say. I crash test crack pipes for a living.
    1. Re:It's our fault the program is over by Chrisq · · Score: 1

      It's our fault our government spends more money on lawyers than on astronauts.

      Well if it isn't your fault (collectively) then democracy has failed and the government is not acting in accordance with the will of the people.

    2. Re:It's our fault the program is over by PFactor · · Score: 2

      That's pretty much my point. I doubt many Americans WANT a huge department of justice/prison-filling-machine but many Americans continue to go with the status quo instead of demanding change. I'm of the opinion that our democracy is failing principally because the people won't get (and stay) engaged on matters of substance.

      --
      Don't believe anything I say. I crash test crack pipes for a living.
    3. Re:It's our fault the program is over by skids · · Score: 1

      I blame the people that go around spouting nonsense like "there's no difference between the major political parties" and other cynical non-witticisms. Or in other words, teabaggers.

    4. Re:It's our fault the program is over by Osgeld · · Score: 1

      Its also our fault that after 30 years we are still getting excited over a space walk, cause we let the program stagnate and not progress much if at all since 1978

    5. Re:It's our fault the program is over by Osgeld · · Score: 1

      and its been proven that most do not care about the space program so be careful for what you wish for

    6. Re:It's our fault the program is over by hairyfeet · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Ya know, that takes some mega sized brass balls to say that when Obama is the pres. How's that Hope & Change thing working out? Oh yeah he Hopes you don't notice the only Change is from an R to a D on the door. I mean this administration actually has the gall to claim the president has the right to assassinate Americans on American soil with NO oversight or trial, and this is irrevocable under "war powers". Dubya didn't have the balls to do that, even Nixon didn't have balls that large!

      Sadly my friend the late great Bill Hicks nailed it more than 20 years ago "Well I believe the puppet on the left shares MY beliefs, well i think the puppet on the right has my interests at heart...hey wait a minute there is one guy controlling both puppets!". Time and time again We, The People have made ourselves heard only to be ignored. We want our borders fixed, we want the wars to end, we want Medicaid/care and aid to the poor left alone, we want taxes to increase on the top 5% and we want companies to stop being rewarded with taxpayer money to close factories and send them overseas like GE did recently. But all you get is two sides to the same coin, and thanks to Citizens United this will only get worse. If you believe either side gives a shit about the American people I have a nice bridge to offer, it goes to nowhere so there is no wear and tear!

      As for TFA I hate to be the one to say it, but good riddance to the shuttle, it is only sad we don't have a replacement that should have been built in 1995. The shuttle was a failure from the start, its original mission statement was for a "space truck" that would allow both the military and NASA to share expenses, to allow cheaper and larger loads into space, and to allow fast turnaround. It failed to live up to that statement which is why the military has been using the Delta V.

      I would argue the only reason it has hung on this long is Sen Porkus and Congressman Kickbackus were using it to "bring jobs to the area!" which is why there was nearly 20 states working on shuttle parts and why congress pushed for reusing shuttle parts when it made no sense on Orion. Both sides of the aisle have long since quit giving a shit if they hurt this nation as long as it suits their personal goals and spreading the shuttle parts like a shotgun blast across the country helped them show they were bringing home that bacon.

      So goodbye shuttle, you did much good work despite failing your original goals and I'm only sorry you weren't put out to pasture years ago and something more practical brought up in your place. maybe we'll have the Delta Vs man rated, hell maybe we should just buy some Soyuz off of Russia. Either way the shuttle should have been in a museum years ago and I hope the astronauts get down safely for this their final ride.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    7. Re:It's our fault the program is over by Anrego · · Score: 1

      No one has the money, and very few people share your mysterious enthusiasm for tin cans in orbit.

      I think a few people do, but yeah, not enough for an industry .. unless they can bring down the price and risk by a lot. Personally I don't care about space at all... but there are definitely a few people who would spend at least as much as they would on a 2 week cruise just for the experience of, as you said, staying in a tin.

      I do forsee the private sector exploiting the resources of space at some point. Mining asteroids/other planets .. turning the moon into a waste dump.. whatever.

      No one cared then, no one's cared in 15 years. FIFTEEN YEARS and NOT A SINGLE BOLT in space.

      Indeed. I think it still needs some government support to get the tech up to where a private company could take over. The gap between "what we have to do" and "zomg enormous profits!!!" is still too large.

    8. Re:It's our fault the program is over by 0123456 · · Score: 1

      No one cared then, no one's cared in 15 years. FIFTEEN YEARS and NOT A SINGLE BOLT in space.

      Indeed. For example, Bigelow Aerospace don't have two private space station modules orbiting the planet right now for long-term testing (at least I believe both are still in orbit). There's a big market for space tourism, but not at current prices... and a gap between current prices and viable prices that's hard to cross without spending lots of money on R&D without an immediate market.

      But to me the more important question is: if we can put a man on the moon, why can't Slashdot build a web forum that doesn't suck?

    9. Re:It's our fault the program is over by BJ_Covert_Action · · Score: 1
      I don't disagree with anything you are saying, but I wanted to correct this part:

      It failed to live up to that statement which is why the military has been using the Delta V.

      There is no such thing as a Delta V. There is a Delta IV, and an Atlas V, and the military uses both.

      I just don't want new readers/non-space-enthusiasts to get confused over a typo.

    10. Re:It's our fault the program is over by blueturffan · · Score: 3, Funny

      Delta-v has always been an important part of space travel.

    11. Re:It's our fault the program is over by hairyfeet · · Score: 1

      Great another koolaid drinker. Instead of giving citations to back up his beliefs he can ONLY throw insults. You have a president that has broken EVER major campaign pledge since taking office, gitmo, the two wars (added a third, yay for the military industrial complex! They'll be getting extra hookers this Xmas pal!) warrantless wiretapping, do you think this kind of major flip flop was just because he ate some bad cheese? he got a big fat fucking check dude, don't delude yourself. he said "How much money? Really?" and your vote was flushed down the toilet.

      So lets see your proof pal, back that mouth up. I can literally wallpaper this place with link after link after link showing major graft and corruption by those at the very top, from a certain SCOTUS wife taking big fat checks to those on the president's job advisory panel getting bailouts to send the jobs overseas. So back that mouth up C6gunner, lets see the links. Because that is what happens when one has truth on their side, they can provide citations all day long.

      BTW just FYI the late great Bill Hicks wrote that more than 25 YEARS ago and the man has been dead two decades now. How sad is it that if anything his words are more true today than they ever were? I'd like to end by quoting another late great man, George Carlin: "You know why they call it the American Dream? Because you have to be asleep to believe in it" and no truer words were spoken.

      --
      ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
    12. Re:It's our fault the program is over by c6gunner · · Score: 1

      Oh boy. The woo is strong with this one.

      If I could find a single clear, rational question in your entire rant, I'd try to answer. I'd probably be wasting my time, but I'd give it a shot. However, much like your idol, you seem to be mixing together dozens of incidents and topics as if they were part or some grand conspiracy, and then spewing it out in one giant heap of vitriol.

      I like Hicks, I like Carlin, and I don't particularly like Obama, but I can honestly say that you, my friend, are nuttier than squirrel shit. Try taking your medication, thinking for a while about what it is you want to ask or say, and then writing a clear and concise comment which can be parsed without first needing to smoke a half-dozen joints. If you manage that, I'll do my best to respond. Otherwise, don't expect to be taken seriously.

    13. Re:It's our fault the program is over by c6gunner · · Score: 1

      Yea, I didn't actually expect you to take me up on a perfectly reasonable offer. Thanks for the confirmation. Take care.

    14. Re:It's our fault the program is over by blueturffan · · Score: 2

      Please try reading before responding next time. And to whoever modded this guy up, the same goes for you.

      To paraphrase Robert J. Hanlon, "Never ascribe to ignorance that which is adequately explained by tomfoolery".

      In the words of that noted philosopher Foghorn Leghorn, "That's a joke, son. A flag waver. You're built too low. The fast ones go over your head. Ya got a hole in your glove. I keep pitchin' 'em and you keep missin' 'em. Ya gotta keep your eye on the ball. Eye. Ball. I almost had a gag, son. Joke, that is."

    15. Re:It's our fault the program is over by BJ_Covert_Action · · Score: 1

      And that's the beauty of pure-text responses: without any inflection, it becomes very hard to distinguish humor from downright naivete. Still, good one.

  3. Re:Last cup of coffee? by Medevilae · · Score: 1

    Doesn't stop the headline from reading 'LAST NASA SPACEWALK!!!'

  4. Last shuttle defecation coming up by elrous0 · · Score: 1

    Soon the toilet will flush on the Space Shuttle for the last time. The end of an era.

    --
    SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    1. Re:Last shuttle defecation coming up by rbrausse · · Score: 2

      no flushing - the thing is air flow driven :)

    2. Re:Last shuttle defecation coming up by Bill_the_Engineer · · Score: 2

      Brings a whole new meaning to Whooosh. ;)

      --
      These comments are my own and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of my employer or colleagues...
    3. Re:Last shuttle defecation coming up by Eevee · · Score: 2

      Okay then, it will be the last time the shit hits the fan on the shuttle...

  5. Agreed by gr8_phk · · Score: 1

    You beat me to it. The last launch, the last docking, the last poop taken on the shuttle. Each of these (except the poop) has been hyped as the last thing or the end. Actually, the end should be when it lands, but then they'll bring it up again when it reaches its final resting place in a museum. I'd be glad to see it go, if only they had something better :-) Shame on NASA for not advancing human space vehicle design in 35 years. Lets flush this thing and move on.

    1. Re:Agreed by Talderas · · Score: 1

      The problem with the last poop is that you aren't going to necessarily know if it's the last poop on the shuttle until all the astronauts strap in for reentry.

      --
      "Lack of speed can be overcome. In the worst case by patience." --Znork
    2. Re:Agreed by rnaiguy · · Score: 2

      Actually, until they get off on the ground. Shit happens...

    3. Re:Agreed by 0123456 · · Score: 1

      Actually, until they get off on the ground. Shit happens...

      If I was part of the cleanup crew I'd take a dump in there after they get off just so I could tell my grandkids I was the last one to do so.

    4. Re:Agreed by shadowfaxcrx · · Score: 1

      It certainly wasn't for lack of trying on NASA's part. They can't advance anything without approval from the government, and the government keeps jerking them around. "Build a new shuttle! Wait cancel that. OK, start it up again, but you gotta start it from scratch - Build a new new shuttle! Nope, stop, don't do that, go to Mars! Wait, go back to the moon! Wait, no, go to an asteroid. And Mars. Maybe." And I'll bet that the next election will bring new marching orders for NASA that will require to, once again, scrap everything they've worked on so far and start working on something else.

      NASA has had several design processes for the next generation shuttle, and Congress/POTUS keep scrapping the programs.

      (btw Slashdot, isn't a >4 minute flood control a bit. . excessive?)

      --
      "I disagree with you" does not equal "flamebait."
  6. just to be clear by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

    i think that headline might be misleading. just want to be clear: this is not the last ISS spacewalk. The ISS has an airlock and can perform spacewalks with not shuttle support. (In fact, this spacewalk was actually carried out by ISS crewmembers and not shuttle crewmembers). This is, however, the last spacewalk while the shuttle is docked. Others will not have the extra shuttle assets to lean on.

  7. Re:Last cup of coffee? by PhilHibbs · · Score: 1

    Yes, I'm looking forward to the last of the "Last" articles now. I'm gutted that the shuttle era is over, especially as it won't be visible from the UK in its orbit (I was secretly hoping for a delay so I could see it go overhead one last time).

  8. ISS suits? why is this the "last spacewalk" by Danathar · · Score: 1

    Ok. It's ISS crew. Are they not using their own suits? Or did they go over to the shuttle, use their suits and go out their airlock. And if so WHY?

  9. More than the end of the shuttle program. by wcrowe · · Score: 2, Interesting

    End of an era? Yes. But the era that has ended is not just the shuttle program. It is the end of the U.S. Space program. The United States will never be prominent in space again.

    --
    Proverbs 21:19
    1. Re:More than the end of the shuttle program. by dunezone · · Score: 1

      Wrong, they got there quicker with the German engineers.

    2. Re:More than the end of the shuttle program. by egamma · · Score: 1

      End of an era? Yes. But the era that has ended is not just the shuttle program. It is the end of the U.S. Space program. The United States will never be prominent in space again.

      And we'll never need more than 640k of RAM.

    3. Re:More than the end of the shuttle program. by couchslug · · Score: 2

      The sky is falling. We must continue legacy systems so we can be trapped by them. The Soviet Union never sleeps. If it doesn't put humans in space it isn't science. If the US doesn't fund most space efforts humanity won't benefit from them.

      Did I miss anything?

      --
      "This post is an artistic work of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact."
    4. Re:More than the end of the shuttle program. by bkmoore · · Score: 2, Informative

      Robert Goddard independently invented liquid-fueled rockets before Werner von Braun. The problem for Dr. Goddard was that the U.S. in the 1930s was in the middle of a great depression and wasn't ruled over by a maniacal dictator bent on ruling half the world. Dr. Goddard had to finance his research from private donations. Werner von Braun on the other hand, had the backing of the Nazi government and the German Army. It's no wonder that von Braun built bigger, better rockets than Dr. Goddard.

      To say that the Americans were just a bunch of idiots who needed German help to get anything off the ground is just plain wrong. In 1945, the Germans were further along than the Americans. The German scientists who came over to America helped speed up the space program, but they weren't the only ones who made contributions. The same can be said about the Russian space program. The Russians had some German engineers and some V-2 rockets, but the R-7 rocket which launched Sputnik was developed by Russian engineers.

    5. Re:More than the end of the shuttle program. by BJ_Covert_Action · · Score: 1

      The United States will never be prominent in space again.

      You show me one other country that has probes exploring the outer planets or landers exploring the inner planets. Go ahead and show me. I'll wait right here.

      Yeah, the U.S. may be retiring a flying 30 year old POS brick that has more potential failure modes than a God damned boat made of Swiss cheese. But how, exactly, that leads to the U.S. failing to be prominent in space when the U.S. is the only country investing in actual space exploration (and not just dicking around in LEO) is completely and utterly beyond me.

  10. Re:Deregulate ... by Anrego · · Score: 1

    Maybe you can pay for it by getting an extremely dangerous but very high paying job working a mining operation on the moon ;p

    Seriously though... this is what I see being the ultimate outcome of the private sector in space. Tourism will be there, probably first, but eventually the focus will shift towards exploiting the resources that are out there.

    I can totally see a company form up that takes nuclear waste (and other waste) and hurls it into the sun.

    Is all this a good thing or a bad thing... I really don't know!

  11. Another Misleading Head line. by Nexusone1984 · · Score: 1

    It's not the Last NASA space walk... It's the last space walk from the Space Shuttle..... I expect better from CmdTaco....

    1. Re:Another Misleading Head line. by gstoddart · · Score: 1

      It's not the Last NASA space walk... It's the last space walk from the Space Shuttle..... I expect better from CmdTaco....

      Well, it's the last NASA space walk until they design and build an entirely new launch platform. That's, what, a decade or so away? And, if they lose the political will to do it, possibly even longer.

      Once they decommission those shuttles, the US has no capacity to put people into space short of renting it from the Russians (or possibly the Chinese).

      It may not be the case that NASA will never again do a space walk, but it's going to be a hell of a long time.

      --
      Lost at C:>. Found at C.
    2. Re:Another Misleading Head line. by Gravatron · · Score: 1

      COTS would like a word with you. Space X says they can put a man into space in 2-3 years, and they aren't the only company aiming for that.

  12. Re:Last cup of coffee? by gr8_phk · · Score: 1

    How is it the last space walk? I mean, it could be, but it's not like NASA is planning on never sending humans into space again-- they're just not using shuttles anymore. It may be awhile, but we'll certainly see more NASA astronauts in space, probably using rockets.

    Read it carefully. It's the last space walk of the shuttle era. The ISS guys will probably be space walking again next month - it just won't be during the shuttle era then. So this one is really a big yawn.

  13. Re:Deregulate ... by nitehawk214 · · Score: 1

    I can totally see a company form up that takes nuclear waste (and other waste) and hurls it into the sun.

    Not if you know anything about orbital mechanics.

    Anything launched from Earth is in Earth's orbit of the sun. Which means unless your rocket is astoundingly powerful, it is going to keep crossing Earth's orbit over and over to get a gravity assist to slingshot it to the sun. Look at the orbit for MESSENGER, and that diddnt even go all the way to the sun.

    Besides with as much uranium as coal power puts into the atmosphere it probably doesn't matter.

    --
    I'm a good cook. I'm a fantastic eater. - Steven Brust
  14. freefall much..?? by xTantrum · · Score: 1

    u.s. space shuttle era is ending AND they are about to default on thier debt and plunge deeper into a global financial crisis. Wow, end of the United States empire? I think we may be seeing it.

    --
    $action = empty(PHP) ? backToC() : unset(PHP) ; "when the concrete cases are understood, the abstractions are readily
    1. Re:freefall much..?? by 0123456 · · Score: 1

      I suspect that the US will still be around and still be more relevant than you long after you're dead and dust, Tantrum.

      People were saying that about the British Empire in the 1930s.

  15. Re:Deregulate ... by 0123456 · · Score: 1

    Which means unless your rocket is astoundingly powerful, it is going to keep crossing Earth's orbit over and over to get a gravity assist to slingshot it to the sun.

    Uh, no. The only remotely viable plans I've seen for shuttle-based waste disposal (if launching nuclear waste on a shuttle could ever be considered viable) were based around rotary launchers that would cancel out most of the orbital velocity and drop it into the sun.

    Using a rocket would be silly when you can use some solar panels, an electric motor and a few bits of spinning metal.

  16. Decline and Fall by ThatsNotPudding · · Score: 1

    of the American Empire. Towards the end, I think Rome also used all it's money on armies defending rotting, ignored infrastructure.

  17. Part of a larger trend by Animats · · Score: 1

    Although space gets most of the attention, arctic and ocean exploration is way down, too. In the 1960s, there was talk of "undersea cities' and "cities under the ice". A few small underwater habitats were even built. The only one still operating, at Key West, is being used as a hotel for divers. No manned submarine has been down in the Marianas Trench since Trieste, in the 1960s.

    That field, too, has been taken over by robots.

  18. 30 Years.. by kryliss · · Score: 1

    30 years of Space Shuttle.... 30 years of Donkey Kong..... Conicidence? I think NOT!!

    --
    --- If the bible proves the existence of God, then Superman comics prove the existence of Superman.
  19. Last poop on the shuttle? by Crock23A · · Score: 1

    Will there be a headline about the last time someone takes a dump in a space shuttle? We get it.... the program is over.