German Court Rules Rapidshare Is Legal, But Must Adjust Content Policies

New submitter loosescrews writes "Online file locker Rapidshare is legal in Germany, but has to adjust its policy regarding infringing content, the Higher Regional Court in Hamburg has ruled. Rapidshare plans to appeal. Rapidshare was sued by the German copyright organization Gema which represents 64.000 copyright holders. After reading the verdict, both parties claim they are victorious."

Comments

So they left out the good part

[_0xd0ad]

It would have been nice if the summary had described the "adjustment" that Rapidshare is being required to make:

The copyright organisation had asked the court to order Rapidshare to scan files during the upload process, but the court took another approach, ruling that Rapidshare must actively monitor incoming links from external sites to the files it hosts and take down any illegal files thus identified.

I.e., if a warez site links to a Rapidshare file, then Rapidshare will deactivate the file.

Amusingly enough, Rapidshare already did this, which is why warez sites typically don't allow posting clickable links. Non-clickable link = you have to copy and paste = no HTTP referer = Rapidshare is none the wiser.

Re:So they left out the good part

[thegarbz]

Most sites I see rapidshare style linkage on uses anonymizer services to hide the referrer for exactly that reason.

No reason to make the link unclickable these days.

Re:"Both parties claim they are victorious"

[SydShamino]

As it happens, though, it was the lawyers for both parties talking. After that they went out together for caviar.