Software-Defined Radio For $11

Malvineous writes "Don't have $1500 to drop on a USRP? A Linux kernel developer has discovered that a Realtek digital TV tuner chip has an undocumented mode that turns it into a software-defined radio, with a frequency range of 64-1700MHz. The going rate for one of these USB devices can be as low as US$11. If you're unfamiliar with software-defined radio and have 20 minutes to spare, Balint Seeber has a great video introduction."

Comments

Re:Too long

[bmo]

Software defined radio has the government worried and paralyzed. The government is used to individually regulating the frequencies and power levels and signal characteristics of each kind of radio-using device. An AM/FM radio specifically does not pick up police or cell phone frequencies, and things like CBs and walkie-talkies and cellphones and baby monitors all have specific power levels and specific frequencies they can broadcast on, and they only broadcast in specific radio formats. And those limits are hard-baked into the devices by their exact circuitry. Software defined radio throws that entire idea out the window. A software defined radio is going to have some inherent power limit based on the exact hardware, and some minimum and maximum frequency range based on the hardware, but generally it can handle a very broad range from low frequency bands to high frequency bands, and they can send/detect absolutely any radio format over that entire range, and they can do it at full power. There's no way to regulate "don't detect police/cell frequencies", and no way to regulate "don't broadcast FM on what is supposed to be an AM band", and there is no way to regulate different power levels on different bands. Once you sell a software defined radio, the end user can load in any software they want.

Anyone with the technical knowledge can do any of these tasks in hardware, for not a lot of money. There are entire libraries of books and technical articles on how to broadcast/receive on any band, even "forbidden" ones like 800MHz cellular. I remember an article in Popular Communications for a down-converter you could build to listen to 800MHz back in the early 90s that simply screwed into the BNC of your scanner in line with the antenna.

BFD.

>implying it's somehow illegal to listen to bands outside of AM/FM

What the hell are you talking about? Beyond the Cellular legislation, any and all bands are open for reception. It's your right to intercept radio waves on whatever spectrum and you don't need a license to do so. You only need a license to transmit on licensed spectrum.

>cannot regulate power levels and bands

As if they weren't able to regulate for the past 80 years?

Protip: If you are transmitting 1kw, and transmitting in a band you shouldn't be in, it won't be the feds who track you down, it will be the licensed operators who will find you and turn your ass in to the feds and they'll be happy to do so.

The only reason why Joe Trucker doesn't get turned in with his 1kw linear on CB is because he's a moving target. Anyone else sitting in his basement throwing shitty harmonics up and down the bands can be found.

Also, software defined radios are not amplifiers. You are conflating one technology with another.

The amount of wrong in your post is staggering.

--
BMO

Re:Too long

[Anonymous Coward]

What the hell are you talking about?

1) The hard bit of any radio, especially important for transmission, is low noise band filtering, precise tuning and mixing to convert to/from AF. This all involves a lot of careful analog design and cannot be replaced by the S of SDR. Sure, the oscillator can use DDS, but that's not going to be done by wasting your computer's CPU cycles and it wouldn't make any difference anyway;

2) For analog modes, it's arguably easier to build a circuit than write decoding software. For digital modes, you're either running software on your desktop/laptop or you're running software on the radio's CPU. The only relevant questions are a) whether the modulation is documented - the answer is usually "yes" except for military; b) the keys for any encryption are available to you - if not, being able to implement an SDR makes not a hoot of difference;

3) Yes, you can do some fine DSP with a modern CPU but only an idiot thinks this is a substitute for a good antenna and (per 1) front-end.

SDR is the e-m equivalent of the "winmodem" in dial-up days: yes, you have the opportunity for a lot more versatility, but only by creating something dumb and offloading the work to a less power-efficient general purpose computer which may or may not have something better to do.

Re:Too long

[girlintraining]

The only reason why Joe Trucker doesn't get turned in with his 1kw linear on CB is because he's a moving target

Actually, it's because the government just doesn't give a sh*t about CB radio frequencies. But given that it uses an incredibly simple modulation scheme, it can easily be traced and tracked in realtime. All you need to catch "Joe Trucker" is three antennas spaced one wavelength or more apart and you can get a fix on their position. They may be a moving target, but they're moving along a fixed path: The road. Find a guy heading northwest in the same direction as the highway and you just hop on the road a few exits up and join the flow of traffic. He'll talk again, and when he does... oh look, it's the guy 50 feet in front of you in the left lane... *flips on lights* Goodbye 1kW transmitter, goodbye trucker.

Be more concerned about frequency hopping mobile devices that use a PRNG to communicate with another device over a range of frequencies and encoding techniques... That requires a LOT more equipment to sort out where the signal is coming from. Actually, that's pretty much what the military does... o_o