Slashdot Mirror
Judge Who Ordered Pirate Bay Censorship Found To Be Corrupt
TheGift73 writes "TorrentFreak reports that 'This week yet another court order was handed down in Europe with the aim of censoring The Pirate Bay. The ruling forbids the Dutch Pirate Party from not only running a direct proxy, but also telling people how to circumvent an earlier court ordered blockade. However, according to Pirate Party founder Rick Falkvinge, the judge in the case has a history of corruption relating to another file-sharing case he presided over in the Netherlands. The Court of The Hague in the Netherlands has been particularly busy this work with Pirate Bay-related cases.' Falkvinge wrote, '... not only was the plaintiff and judge personally and closely acquainted, the plaintiff in a controversial copyright monopoly case was running a commercial anti-piracy outfit together with the judge in the case. Money was involved. Commercial interest was involved. The judge was, as it appears from this brochure for the quite expensive course, getting money. Shortly after the case. In a directly related matter together with the plaintiff. That makes the judge not only corrupt, but textbook corrupt.'"
Why was the judge allowed to continue being a judge after being found corrupt? Judges, like police, should be held to a higher standard than the rest of us, not given a free pass because of their status.
Man, it's a good thing these Dutch guys aren't in the US, or else the FBI would storm their houses with swat teams under charges of conspiring with file sharers.
---
But then again, nothing says America like a getting bent over and fucked by an agency with your tax dollars.
Does this give the Dutch Pirate Party reasonable grounds to vacate the decision? (IANAL)
-A
Anyone who is willing to clamp down harshly on basic human freedoms has to be either corrupt or criminally insane. Either way they oughta be either in jail or in the Arkham asylum.
is ANYBODY suprised by this? really?
Shill for BREIN much?
Who are you calling Americans? The use of Europe is correct in the summary, TPB is being censored in many countries in said continent. Your use of Americans is a totum pro parte.
The story would have been more aptly named
"Rick Falkvinge believes judge to be corrupt".
"Kill 'em all and let Root sort 'em out"
Does someone really believe that "Shortly after the case." is a sentence? How about "in a directly related matter together with the plaintiff."?
He was also a Christian. And a Republican. And he had an evangelical TV programme.
Wait, wrong script.
If you desire to purchase a judicial outcome, you would instinctively lean toward a dishonest judge.
Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know.
Ernest Hemingway
those are allegations which haven't been proven.. Also we have to believe people who say they aren't making any money of piratebay even though we've got more than enough proof they certainly are making money off it.. It's just another smear campaign which both sides have used more than enough before.. If the judge really was corrupt, why is he still working? we have laws against stuff like that. And why haven't the lawyers of the defense filed any complains about that, if it was real than you certainly would if you are even a bad defence lawyer... next they'll claim the defence lawyers are corrupt for not putting up any defence..
Really, if every one pirates and downloads and copies and smokes pot at the same time, is it really so bad?
Lets cut the wages of these old gay fuckers back to $50k, and see how they do then.
Fight the power, protest, disobey, total chaos, and anarchy, screw ya all.
We the young people do what we like, STFU old people, it was the old peoples fault that we had WW1 and WW2, so thats proof enough that old people should never rule any countries or systems.
Liberty freedom are no1, not dicks in suits.
By your logic, since a restaurant is in the business of selling food, if it actually sold any food, it would reduce the demand for food and be hurting its own business.
In general, if you try to sell something, people want to see you can deliver. This is especially true in the anti-piracy business where there are a lot of shouters who claim they can protect your stuff but none that are able to deliver. thepiratebay.se is proof of that.
MMO Quests are like orgasms:
You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.
The BBC had a show about a lawyer in the days of slavery fighting for justice... except the justice of the day was something different. Is a judge and jury who believe slavery is the right normal and correct thing to do, ruling in favor of a slaver, corrupt? Often, society is split and the other side can seem to be malicious, insane, corrupt, just interested in their own goals, hypocrites and downright evil. But the other side thinks exactly the same of you. There are few people in the world who do "evil" thinking they are doing evil.
Even lawyers get themselves being able to sleep at night by telling themselves that "everyone has the right to a fair trial" means "I should do anything to get my client of regardless of the facts".
We are at a crossroad, once again, in western society. Copyright has always been changing when tech changed the world, it came into being because of new tech and it will change. But the powers that be want things to remain the same because to them, that is how it has always been and the new situation offers no benefits. Copyright as we know it now was NOT introduced to benefit artists but to protect publishers from the demands of artists to be payed. But over the years, things settled down, slowly and with many lawsuits and up-heaving all that again, that is not going to happen quietly.
The Pirate Bay is used by some artists to promote themselves, you can find artists claiming this themselves. But they don't fit in the traditional media worldview. Even today, most bands dream is to be discovered and to get a record deal... they might or might not have read about the lousy deal most bands who don't become the absolute top get but the dream is still there.
It will have to change, you can't stop tech. Content can be so easily distributed now it would like trying to ban book printing (which was tried for centuries over and over again) and is STILL being proposed right now in Germany by making it economically impossible to print the rantings of an pathetic german painter again. And do you think this stops his diseased followers? Hardly.
There are so many P2P methods and so many versions of each method that all this anti piratebay activity shows is just how silly it is to fight it. if nothing else, the only effect I have seen is that more and more people know that there are alternatives to paying for content. Google "thepiratebay mirror" and endless informative results that work perfectly.
Granted, Brein has openly stated that they know this to have no effect and that it is just so they can lay the foundation for more radical approaches. You didn't think they were going to give up did you?
But the genie is out of the bag. Not only does the public know about it, PRO-piracy is now enough to get you elected into government. Don't forget the green parties started much the same. The Dutch Socialist Party SP, started out as a protest party to far left of the labour party. They are now twice the size and tied for 1st/2nd place with the VVD (Corruption party).
And if the left wing parties don't change their tune (the trade union FNV is making itself a target of mockery for coming out in favor of copyright on behalve of its non-existant artist members) they will be replaced just as the older parties were replaced before them.
But while change is happening, the battles are nasty, ugly and seemingly without end. This is one of the battles. The outcome eventually is without doubt, you cannot put the cat back in the bag, but that doesn't mean there won't be a fight that must be fought. And if history has anything to say about it, blood will be shed.
MMO Quests are like orgasms:
You may solo them, I prefer them in a group.
In two day's time the Netherlands where playing the lead roll in three slashdot articles....
Now that is impressive IMHO!
rm -rf --no-preserve-root /
The BBC had a show about a lawyer in the days of slavery fighting for justice... except the justice of the day was something different. Is a judge and jury who believe slavery is the right normal and correct thing to do, ruling in favor of a slaver, corrupt? Often, society is split and the other side can seem to be malicious, insane, corrupt, just interested in their own goals, hypocrites and downright evil. But the other side thinks exactly the same of you. There are few people in the world who do "evil" thinking they are doing evil.
This has nothing to do with judge having a business relationship with the plaintiff. Especially in cases when the law says nothing directly applicable, and judge ends up making decisions based entirely on his opinions and intuition.
Contrary to the popular belief, there indeed is no God.
Why is /. discussing this unsubstantiated allegations? Just 'cause it's about "renegade" piracy? I have always supported Pirate Bay like web sites because of their will to stand up against big movie and record industries as they used unjust and illegal ways of dealing w/ piracy and NOT because I believe that piracy is right. This attempt by the Pirate Bay founder makes him seem desperate and thus week.
I do not support what Pirate Bay (and the likes) does, it IS stealing and it is a problem but, it must be dealt with in a way that does not violate our basic rights. Privacy is of utmost importance.
The cops who form a cooperative with the dealers to stop amateur competition?
Very good comment. Wish I could mod u up to 5
Corrupt politicians and senior police officers really need to be seen to be charged and swung in a noose.
Certainly not promoted.
While an offense can seem minor, I really feel its tip of iceberg. This case should see a career limited or terminated. Lying on a witness stand or planting evidence should be death.
Politicians not being honest with money matters...should face death.
In post Patriot Act America, the library books scan you.
ditto
"The ability to delude yourself may be an important survival tool" - Jane Wagner -
The world has been run by corporates and democracy is an illusion; against world tyranny, may God help the revolution; ameen.
Some /. discussions are better than others, but for this matter, I think this discussion provides much better insight.
This is the most elaborate troll post I've seen on /. in a long time. Too bad it's obvious with just a quick glance.
That makes the judge not only corrupt, but textbook corrupt.
Falkvinge, next time actually read a fucking textbook on the subject at hand before you claim that something is a textbook example. Words have meanings, particularly in legal settings. This sort of imprecision just damages your credibility.
:-)