Slashdot Mirror


Dolphins Can Sleep One-half of Their Brain At a Time Say Researchers

An anonymous reader writes "Looks like the evolution in multi-core computing is something nature has already figured out. Dolphins will sleep one core while the other remains vigilant, running background tasks necessary for survival. From the article: 'The scientists wrote: "From an anthropomorphic viewpoint, the ability of the dolphin to continuously monitor its environment for days without interruption seems extreme. However, the biological, sensory and cognitive ecology of these animals is relatively unique and demanding. If dolphins sleep like terrestrial animals, they might drown. If dolphins fail to maintain vigilance, they become susceptible to predation. As a result, the apparent 'extreme' capabilities these animals possess are likely to be quite normal, unspectacular, and necessary for survival from the dolphin's perspective."'"

32 of 139 comments (clear)

  1. why is this new? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This is known long ago... this is also an adaptation because dolphins breathing is not a reflex, so half the brain has to be always awake to remember breathing.

    1. Re:why is this new? by cvtan · · Score: 5, Funny

      Blonde listening to tape saying, "Inhale. Exhale. Inhale. Exhale..."

      --
      Sorry, but gray text on gray background is making my eyes bleed.
  2. Wrong headline by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    The news is that they can stay awake for 15 days at a time. Scientists have known for 30 years that dolphins can sleep with one hemisphere.

    1. Re:Wrong headline by Jstlook · · Score: 5, Insightful

      That isn't even what the article indicates. The article indicated that US Military tested a dolphin named Say for 15 days before a storm halted their experiment. The only other notable information in the article is that the dolphin achieved a 99% accuracy throughout the course of the experiments. That's better than your average (burger) flipper.

      --
      ---jstlook ---For that is the way of Elves, for they say both yes AND no, and mean every word of it. --- J.R.R.T.
    2. Re:Wrong headline by Mikkeles · · Score: 4, Funny

      Hell, that's better than your average software developer!

      --
      Great minds think alike; fools seldom differ.
    3. Re:Wrong headline by PopeRatzo · · Score: 3, Informative

      The news is that they can stay awake for 15 days at a time.

      BFD. Hell, Rick James used to do that twice a month.

      --
      You are welcome on my lawn.
  3. That's nothing by matunos · · Score: 3, Funny

    Republicans have been doing that for years.

    *rimshot*

    1. Re:That's nothing by marcle · · Score: 4, Funny

      Republicans, hell. I'm a hippie, and most of my brain is asleep most of the... What were we talking about?

  4. Already known? by Cronock · · Score: 2

    Hasn't this already been well known or quite some time?

    1. Re:Already known? by kwerle · · Score: 2

      Yeah. My first thought was "doesn't everyone know this already?"

      Here's a site with data sources in 1990 that explain this:
      http://www.dolphinear.com/data/dolphins.htm

      "news"

      Yeah.

  5. Evolution by girlintraining · · Score: 2, Interesting

    The real question is: Why is sleep needed in mammals in the first place? We've already found drugs that can keep a person going without sleep for weeks or months at a time, apparently without any significant reduction in cognitive ability or any significant change in neurological functioning. It's been investigated my the military for quite some time now.

    Evolution says the reason for sleep is that it improves a creature's ability to adapt... but what does sleep adapt us for? Why the downtime? Even here with mammals where never going to sleep is a survival necessity... nature kept it intact and instead segmented the brain so parts of it could sleep. Something about sleep is very, very important... but be damned if we can figure out what.

    --
    #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    1. Re:Evolution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

      We've already found drugs that can keep a person going without sleep for weeks or months at a time, apparently without any significant reduction in cognitive ability or any significant change in neurological functioning.

      Link please, otherwise I'm calling bogus. The official world record for going without sleep is 18 days.

      Look up 'Fatal Familial Insomnia' in which death follows (as best as anyone can tell) from lack of sleep.

    2. Re:Evolution by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Informative

      Those drugs can keep you alert for extended periods, but then you need an inordinate amount of recovery time for the missed sleep and performance never seems as good as normal. The increased uptime, as it were, isn't free. Yes, I've studied some brain chemistry with regards to drugs such as modafinil.

    3. Re:Evolution by JonySuede · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Memory consolidation , occurs more efficiently during sleep. That alone is worth it's evolutionary cost of sleep. Sure, Nature could have stumbled upon a memory consolidation scheme that do not involved sleep but it did not and evolutionary wise it seems that having a solid long term memory is more beneficial than not having to sleep. BTW if the drugs you talk about are orexin activator/recapture inhibitor/supressing enzyme inhibitor, only one: Orextin-A, is currently without know side effects. If those drugs you talked about do not act on the orexin transmitter up regulation, please tell me about them !

      --
      Jehovah be praised, Oracle was not selected
    4. Re:Evolution by Your.Master · · Score: 4, Insightful

      That doesn't explain why Dolphins didn't just turn sleep off, since they are warm and active throughout all time. Was it just so fundamental to the brain architecture that the segmenting was needed, or is sleep providing something else that dolphins still need?

    5. Re:Evolution by girlintraining · · Score: 3, Interesting

      That doesn't explain why Dolphins didn't just turn sleep off, since they are warm and active throughout all time. Was it just so fundamental to the brain architecture that the segmenting was needed, or is sleep providing something else that dolphins still need?

      Bingo. The one question that everybody missed, because they were too busy making jokes or talking about Dolphins to realize that this evolutionary development can shed a lot of light on our own. Don't mod this up, no siree, we like our science dumbed down and sprinkled in apple sauce here! deeeerp. :(

      --
      #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    6. Re:Evolution by guttentag · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Evolution says the reason for sleep is that it improves a creature's ability to adapt... but what does sleep adapt us for?

      Most creatures don't live long enough to have a need to adapt as an individual, but they adapt as a species over generations.

      Humans probably have the greatest need to adapt as individuals. Every day:

      • laws are changing. Today: Gay Marriage Legal! Tomorrow: Gay Marriage Illegal and Unconstitutional because the 40.46% of the electorate said so! Next Friday: Bingo at the Supreme Court!)
      • religions are changing. Today: Earth is the Center of the Universe and Stoning Pregnant Women for Sex Out of Wedlock is Good! Tomorrow: Earth Not the Center of the Universe and Abortion is Evil. Next Friday: Earth is the center of the Universe every third Thursday during certain seasons, check local listings or pastors for details.
      • food sources and taboos are changing. Today: steel cans lined with BPA keep your family's food fresh! Tomorrow: BPA in bottles bad, but we're OK with BPA in cans! Next Friday: FDA outlaws all estrogen-mimicking substances including Richard Simmons.
      • business and personal relationships are changing. Today: Great work, Invaluable Employee/Loving Wife! Tomorrow: You've been replaced by someone cheaper/someone cheaper! Next Friday: Special Rates at the Chapel of Love for Couples Marrying Each Other for the 3rd Time!
      • even the side of the street you may park on is changing on a regular basis.

      You have to be able to adapt because society ensures that someone is constantly moving your cheese, and in return for this, you as an individual get to live longer than wild animals do.

      One theory about why we need to sleep is that we need to filter out all the crap from the stuff we need to save. During REM sleep the neurons are subjected to spontaneous, chaotic activity, strengthening memories whose neuronal substrate is already sufficiently established, and disintegrating those that are weaker. Ever built a sandcastle by the water line at the beach? The walls that are not tightly packed get washed away when the water hits them, but the ones that are tightly packed survive and seem to actually be strengthened by the encounter. In a way, that's what REM sleep may do for our memories. Without that, it's all just an unstable jumble, and you can't adapt to all the crap in your life without the clarity to know what day it is or where the heck you're supposed to be.

    7. Re:Evolution by girlintraining · · Score: 4, Funny

      I don't know what gay marriage, the FDA, mail-order girlfriends, and violations of space-time causality, and sandcastles by the beach have to do with the importance of sleep... but I can say with a fair degree of certainty that having read your post, you are a case study in what happens when someone doesn't get any. Please man, go to bed. The internet, such as it is, will not want for a missed opportunity for you to post to slashdot.

      --
      #fuckbeta #iamslashdot #dicemustdie
    8. Re:Evolution by khallow · · Score: 2

      Sleep has no effect on "ability to adapt" at all.

      It just might. I find that I need more sleep when I enter a new situation or environment (for example, starting work at a new location or school, moving to a new place to live).

    9. Re:Evolution by El+Puerco+Loco · · Score: 2

      Yeah those drugs work great until suddenly everyone around you is a cop, and you can't get the ants out from under your skin.

    10. Re:Evolution by michelcolman · · Score: 2

      I've asked myself the same question, and one night the answer came to me in a dream.

      Too bad I forgot the dream so now I still don't know.

  6. we've known this for decades... by AcousticWolf · · Score: 2

    As a former dolphin researcher at the Kewalo Basin Marine Mammal Laboratory of the University of Hawaii I can say that we've known about split brain sleeping for at least three decades. I had always wanted to run an experiment looking for an acoustic equivalent to Rapid Eye Movement in dolphins. It could still be called REM sleep just substituting Eye with Echolocation. Since you really don't want to attach EKG leads to a swimming dolphin we'd have needed a set of directional hydrophones arrayed around the tank who's data would be correlated with the dolphin's head position as it swam. Perhaps this could be tackled now but back in the day it was beyond us.

  7. I have to tell my wife about this. by cvtan · · Score: 3, Funny

    Now when she asks why I don't listen to her, I can just explain that the half of my brain running the audio is shut down to conserve energy.

    --
    Sorry, but gray text on gray background is making my eyes bleed.
  8. So do birds. by Black+Parrot · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This is old "news". (Can we call it "olds"?)

    Supposedly when you see a row of birds standing on a cable, all the ones in the middle are asleep, and the two on the end have half a brain awake so that their outside eye is paying attention.

    More recent result is that even in humans, 'asleep' isn't a boolean proposition. Different parts of your brain may go to sleep at different times. Sometimes leads to "normal" sleepwalking, sometimes to horrid behavior because the impluse-suppression part is asleep and most of the rest isn't. See the overview article in a recent issue of Scientific American. (Current or previous issue, IIRC.)

    --
    Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
    1. Re:So do birds. by viperidaenz · · Score: 2

      +1 for "olds"

    2. Re:So do birds. by ledow · · Score: 3, Insightful

      And anyone who thinks that the brain is inherently capable of only doing one thing has never driven long-distance.

      Has *anybody* never had that experience where you are driving along thinking and then suddenly realise you've just navigated the past 20 miles, through traffic, round corners, through junctions, with gear-changes, etc. without remembering doing so?

      Your brain is more than capable of doing those tasks - and alerting you to problems just as quickly as when you're concentrating on the task - in the background without you knowing. (What scares me most about them is not the fact that it happens, but that I assume I stopped at red lights, followed traffic signs, didn't ram someone off the road, etc. and have to quickly recall events that I seem to have taken no conscious part in!)

      I've also had the (strange) privilege of knowing someone with multiple-personality-syndrome. This is extremely similar - one personality is at the fore but the others are there, in the background, observing events and doing things, just out of mind at that moment. In fact, in MPS, it's just a more pronounced version triggered by certain psychological problems (lots of abuse cases, lots of a very particular type of psychiatric therapy that seems to "trigger" MPS in vulnerable individuals - and is STILL practised in the one part of America where most MPS cases come from!).

      Your brain is not a single thing. It's a collection of billions of things, each with their own job. They group and work together but they also can separate off (otherwise you would have to "think" about how to move your arm rather than just passing it off to a group of brain cells that do that all day long) and even divide your consciousness in two in perfectly ordinary people with no mental health issues.

      And, like others have said, have you never had that thing late at night where you wake up because of an odd (and quiet) sound despite the fact that every other night you slept like a baby. How do you think that works? The brain is always awake, in some fashion, it's just a matter of whether it decides something is a threat or not (otherwise every predator would just wait until your were asleep because you'd be an easy target), and then "presses the emergency button" to get the rest operational very quickly.

      The dolphin thing is well-known. And any idiot with a cat knows that it doesn't really "sleep" for 18 hours a day, it's always aware and very, very rarely in an actual complete sleep (for the first time in 12 years, I manage to "scare" my cat the other day because it was completely, 100% asleep and didn't hear me come in, didn't feel me approach, until I stroked its fur - I actually thought it was dead, it was so deep in sleep).

      And every driver will tell you that they have driven on a kind of "automatic pilot" including some of the most complex observation, judgement, quick-reaction and motor skills that the average person will perform in a day, while they were thinking about what to have for dinner.

      Humans are animals. Animals have brains. Brains are a collection of groups of cells that, by their very nature, are inherently malleable, ever-changing and independent. It's no shock that dolphins can do this. What's more interesting is that humans seem to have lost the ability/need to do this so much.

  9. Re:Douglas Adams was right! by Black+Parrot · · Score: 2

    We are indeed inferior to dolphins, brain-wise. Makes you wonder what the mice can pull off!

    Depends on whether you're talking about Pinky or The Brain.

    --
    Sheesh, evil *and* a jerk. -- Jade
  10. Re:So basically... by LordLimecat · · Score: 2

    Whats really amazing is that, despite the claims that the right is the party of hate, it always seems to be the left calling us names.

    Stay classy slashdot.

  11. Re:So basically... by santax · · Score: 2

    It is not name-calling, it is pointing out facts. Huge difference there.

  12. Joke in there somewhere. by fox171171 · · Score: 4, Funny

    I'm pretty sure there's a joke in there somewhere.

    Only a half brain operating? I know people who...
    ...drive like that.
    ...talk like that.
    ...code like that.
    ...make decisions at Microsoft like that.
    ...decide to buy Apple products like that.

    and so on...

  13. Re:brain vs. body by the+biologist · · Score: 2

    Your body might suffer from your brain not sleeping, for instance when you drive into a wall, but there is nothing in particular the body needs sleep (different than rest) for. From the perspective of your body, you sleeping is just a reduction in the amount of talking your brain does. That said, the body can handle lots of things the brain can't. Some desert mammals (goats, in particular) can let their body heat up way past what would be fatal for their brains, while using some nifty plumbing to keep their brains cool enough to survive.

  14. Not news... by AliasMarlowe · · Score: 2

    This is known long ago... this is also an adaptation because dolphins breathing is not a reflex, so half the brain has to be always awake to remember breathing.

    In fact, here's a 2009 article in National Geographic on the exact same topic from 2009. It was not the first, either.

    --
    Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities. - Voltaire