Slashdot Mirror


Spinal Fluid Chemical Levels Linked To Suicidal Behavior

An anonymous reader writes "For the first time, researchers have found that a chemical in the brain called glutamate is linked to suicidal behavior. While previous research and drugs have targeted serotonin to fight severe depression, this study shows that more attention should be paid to this chemical."

48 of 85 comments (clear)

  1. Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by Futurepower(R) · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Medical Daily is not a reliable source, in my opinion. Is the publication paying for so many links to it? Does the owner of Slashdot, Dice Holdings, have a financial relationship with Medical Daily?

    1. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by BeanThere · · Score: 3, Informative

      TFA contains a direct link to the original article in the journal Neuropsychopharmacology FFS, can we advance to the next stage of logical fallacies now ..

    2. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by ColdWetDog · · Score: 5, Informative

      OK then, it's Bush's fault....

      The original FA (in the journal) has a reasonable abstract:

      The NMDA-receptor antagonist ketamine has proven efficient in reducing symptoms of suicidality, although the mechanisms explaining this effect have not been detailed in psychiatric patients. Recent evidence points towards a low-grade inflammation in brains of suicide victims. Inflammation leads to production of quinolinic acid (QUIN) and kynurenic acid (KYNA), an agonist and antagonist of the glutamatergic N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor, respectively. We here measured QUIN and KYNA in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of 64 medication-free suicide attempters and 36 controls, using gas chromatography mass spectrometry and high-performance liquid chromatography. We assessed the patients clinically using the Suicide Intent Scale and the Montgomery-Åsberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). We found that QUIN, but not KYNA, was significantly elevated in the CSF of suicide attempters (p less than 0.001). As predicted, the increase in QUIN was associated with higher levels of CSF interleukin-6. Moreover, QUIN levels correlated with the total scores on Suicide Intent Scale. There was a significant decrease of QUIN in patients who came for follow-up lumbar punctures within 6 months after the suicide attempt. In summary, we here present clinical evidence of increased QUIN in the CSF of suicide attempters. An increased QUIN/KYNA quotient speaks in favor of an overall NMDA-receptor stimulation. The correlation between QUIN and the Suicide Intent Scale indicates that changes in glutamatergic neurotransmission could be specifically linked to suicidality. Our findings have important implications for the detection and specific treatment of suicidal patients, and might explain the observed remedial effects of ketamine.

      TL;DR - Suicidally depressed patients seem to have a low level inflammatory process going on. They measure two compounds (out of many) in spinal fluid samples of depressed and control patients that are part of the inflammatory pathway are related to the turnover of glutamate, an amino acid felt to be a neurotransmitter (first link the TFS, a nice short explanation). The glutamate agonist levels were higher in suicidal patients, the glutamate antagonist not.

      Potentially a method of quantitating level of suicideality which is a very problematic issue (witness the recent shootings in Connecticut). Very early data. Manuscript submitted but not accepted. At the level of interesting but don't run down to the local Szechuan restaurant and OD on MSG. Oh, and leave the ketamine to the vets.

      --
      Faster! Faster! Faster would be better!
    3. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by ColdWetDog · · Score: 4, Funny

      Forgot to add:

      Do Not Taunt Happy Fun Ball.

      --
      Faster! Faster! Faster would be better!
    4. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by The_mad_linguist · · Score: 5, Funny

      glutamate, an amino acid felt to be a neurotransmitter

      Felt to be a neurotransmitter in the same way that hemoglobin is felt to be important to your circulatory system.

    5. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by jkflying · · Score: 1

      Mr Hoppy!

      --
      Help I am stuck in a signature factory!
    6. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by Charliemopps · · Score: 1

      Speaking of which, are suicide rates lower in Japan? According to my buddies wife, who lived there for a while, it's actually hard to find regular salt because almost everyone uses MSG exclusively. I also use MSG almost exclusively instead of table salt. Not because it tastes better or anything, I just like to freak people out when I cook for them and they want to know what I put in it. As soon as I whip out the MSG their eyes get big "I thought that was poisonous!!!" lol

      FYI: MSG + Onion powder + fresh ground white and black pepper mixed in with ground beef is the ultimate recipe for burgers.

    7. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by Charliemopps · · Score: 1

      Answered my own question:
      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_in_Japan
      Looks like MSG wont do you any good. But if anything will get you out of your funk and keep you from offing yourself, my burger recipe is it.

    8. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by number6x · · Score: 2

      re-read the article. The people who attempted suicide had higher levels of glutamate:

      The research indicated that the patients who had attempted suicide had quinolinic levels that were twice as high as the controls had. That indicated that their glutamate levels were far higher than that of healthy people. The patients who had reported having the strongest desire to kill themselves also had the highest levels of quinolinic acid.

      So you should keep those burgers away from depressed people with easy access to knives. From the look of the article you linked to, It might do the Japanese some good to cut down as well.

    9. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by AsmCoder8088 · · Score: 1

      I thought the article said that the suicidal patients had *higher* levels of glutamate, not lower. So wouldn't the extra glutamate from MSG intake make you more suicidal? In any case, it's like they say, all things in moderation.

    10. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by Genda · · Score: 1

      So are we saying that Japanese ritual suicide may in fact just be the result of a seasoning selection??? Hhhhmmmm, DEATH BY UMAMI!!!!

    11. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by uninformedLuddite · · Score: 1

      Oh, and leave the ketamine to the vets.

      Soldiers have all the fun

      --
      The new right fascists are bilingual. They speak English and Bullshit.
    12. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by Panruru · · Score: 1

      Thanks for the tip! I will try this tomorrow.

      --
      "All statements are true in some sense, false in some sense, and meaningless in another sense."
    13. Re:Suggestion: Stop linking to Medical Daily. by SourceFrog · · Score: 1

      True story, I was once given a stern lecture on the dangers of MSG's by a colleague while he sat smoking a cigarette. No trace of irony in his voice. That said, MSG's probably really aren't very good for you.

      --
      My other UID is three digits.
  2. And the antidote: by Opportunist · · Score: 3, Funny

    Special K.

    "No, officer, I'm not abusing drugs, I'm suicidal"

    --
    We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
    1. Re:And the antidote: by demonlapin · · Score: 2

      It is one hell of an antidepressant. Really.

    2. Re:And the antidote: by Opportunist · · Score: 1

      I know a few more that kick in really well. Oddly, none of them make it into prescription drugs.

      The mad tinfoil hatter in me claims it's because it's much more profitable to keep selling pills that don't work and tell people that they "need a while to work".

      --
      We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
    3. Re:And the antidote: by Opportunist · · Score: 1

      I don't know whether "suggesting" the (ab)use of illegal drugs is illegal in some country, so I just link to the US National Center for Biotechnology Information.

      --
      We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
  3. Glutamate by Canjo · · Score: 5, Informative

    Glutamate is one of the major neurotransmitters, involved in almost everything the brain does. Reading this summary is kind of like reading "Scientists have discovered that a mysterious substance called 'blood' is involved in heart disease...."

    1. Re:Glutamate by oodaloop · · Score: 4, Funny

      It also overlooked the obvious correlation of suicide with dihydrogen monoxide. Not only has every person who committed suicide ingested this chemical, some even commit suicide by inhaling it!

      --
      Tic-Tac-Toe, Global Thermonuclear War, and relationships all have the same winning move.
    2. Re:Glutamate by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      High blood pressure does lead to heart disease, like high brain activity leads to depression.

    3. Re:Glutamate by Opportunist · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Yeah, I can see how thinking too hard can lead to depression in this world.

      --
      We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
    4. Re:Glutamate by TeslaBoy · · Score: 2

      Indeed. Glutamate is THE MAIN neurotransmitter used by the brain. Drugs targetting glutamate transmission are very common, but because it is so fundamental to brain function, drug effects are very non-specific (wake up, fall asleep, or highly toxic). Medical Daily is clear not a reputable source.

    5. Re:Glutamate by sjames · · Score: 1

      Alas, that's about the state of neuropharmacology. The whole serotonin SSRI anti-depressant thing is at about the same level (and probably wrong).

    6. Re:Glutamate by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Thinking too hard and getting absolutely nowhere, with no horizon of actually getting somewhere.

      Anecdotally, I've noticed that people who don't like thining hard, and don't care if they get anywhere, are the happiest people out there. And because of the preconditions, you won't find them on Slashdot.

    7. Re:Glutamate by Divebus · · Score: 1

      Ha! I always kept a jug full of liquid labeled "dihydrogen monoxide cleaning fluid" in my fridge. Nobody ever touched it but they sure asked about it.

      --

      Most of the stuff on /. won't survive first contact with facts.
    8. Re:Glutamate by girlinatrainingbra · · Score: 1

      Or it would be like saying that "electrons have been found to play a critical role in the transmission of signals in CPUs. It's a true statement, but the neurotransmitters are used in a huge variety of circuits and not limited to just one subset of neurons that subserve just one set of functions.

    9. Re:Glutamate by AthanasiusKircher · · Score: 1

      It's even worse than that -- although glutamate has been found in only trace amounts, dihydroden monoxide seems to have completely taken over the bodies of suicide victims, almost as if their bodies were made of the stuff....

  4. Flavour enhancer by maxwell+demon · · Score: 2

    Glutamate is a quite common flavour enhancer in processed food. Does that mean processed food can make you suicidal?

    --
    The Tao of math: The numbers you can count are not the real numbers.
    1. Re:Flavour enhancer by newcastlejon · · Score: 5, Funny

      Glutamate is a quite common flavour enhancer in processed food. Does that mean processed food can make you suicidal?

      No, but it does explain why brains are so tasty.

      --
      If God forks the Universe every time you roll a die, he'd better have a damned good memory.
    2. Re:Flavour enhancer by Dogtanian · · Score: 1

      Glutamate is a quite common flavour enhancer in processed food. Does that mean processed food can make you suicidal?

      No, but it does explain why brains are so tasty.

      These ought to be delicious, then! (Er, but you can try them first, though...)

      Warning; link NSFL ("Not Safe For Lunchtime").

      --
      "Slashdot - News and Chat Sites Deviant". (Click "homepage" link above for details).
    3. Re:Flavour enhancer by maxwell+demon · · Score: 2

      Reading your comment, I'm not sure that you know what you are talking about.

      Let's start with your last example, of sodium chloride. When solved in water, it is separately sodium ions and chloride ions. Sop yes, you are drinking chloride when you're drinking sodium chloride. And there's nothing wrong with that as long as you don't drink (or eat) too much of it. Maybe you were confusing it with chlorine (same element, but neutral molecules; drinking that certainly is not a good idea, although at normal conditions it's a gas anyway, so you'd more likely breathe than drink it; of course breathing it isn't exactly healthy either).

      Now to sodium monoglutamate. The "sodium" part means there are sodium ions (unlike for anions, kations are not named differently from their neutral form; however it's quite clear that it doesn't contain netral, i.e. metallic, sodium). The "mono" in "monoglutamate" means that there there's just one glutamate per sodium ion. So it comes doen to what is meant with "glutamate" here. Since it is very unusual to name two completely different things the same name in chemistry, I strongly doubt that the glutamate in sodium monoglutamate is a different substance than the glutamate in the brain. Moreover the basic function of glutamate, namely being a flavour enhancer, fits quite well with it being a neurotransmitter. That's because it does not taste like meat, but it enhances the taste, effectively making the taste buds transmit a stronger signal. It makes sense that a neurotransmitter might have that effect.

      Does that suffice to imply that processed food makes you suicidal? Of course not. It just means that there might be a connection. That's why I formulated it as question, not as claim.

      tl;dr: Before accusing others not to know what they are talking about, you should make sure you know what you are talking about yourself.

      --
      The Tao of math: The numbers you can count are not the real numbers.
    4. Re:Flavour enhancer by uninformedLuddite · · Score: 1

      Before accusing others not to know what they are talking about, you should make sure you know what you are talking about yourself.

      Welcome to the new /.

      --
      The new right fascists are bilingual. They speak English and Bullshit.
  5. Glutamate has become very common in modern food by dtjohnson · · Score: 3, Informative

    Glutamate has become very common in all sorts of pre-cooked prepared foods...everything from canned soup to rice-a-roni mixes. It's usually added as something called "MSG" or monosodium glutamate although it is also often added under names such as 'hydrolyzed protein,' 'autolyzed protein,' 'sodium caseinate,' 'autolyzed yeast,' or 'yeast extract.' Food manufacturers have found that adding MSG has a powerful on flavor and makes consumers more likely to 'like' the food and consume greater quantities. A more scientific name for 'glutamate' is 'glutamic acid' and it is a common amino acid found in protein. Food manufacturers have argued successfully for years that since it is an amino acid found in protein, there should be no restrictions on its use. However, as TFA discusses, the quantity of glutamic acid consumed DOES matter and artificially spiking a variety of food with it to make the food taste better may be causing a lot of suicides. Perhaps the school shooter in Connecticut was a heavy consumer of something spiked with MSG such as, for example, many (although not all) varieties of potato chips.

    1. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by 0111+1110 · · Score: 1

      You do realize that it is not only so called 'processed' foods that have MSG, right? Yes it is obviously a drug, but a very effective one. Used in the correct dosage it can make flavors more intense. Unfortunately I am highly sensitive to MSG and can only use very small quantities of it.

      --
      Quite an experience to live in fear, isn't it? That's what it is to be a slave.
    2. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      the blood/brain barrier is not permeable to glutamate

    3. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by chriscappuccio · · Score: 1

      More to the point, MSG is the beginning of modern food science. It was first extracted from seaweed. It was the first chemical extracted from food. Considered a "chemical condiment" which increased food reward and therefore food consumption. None of the potential effects of increasing food reward in such a high-potency fashion, or any negative effects from constant increase in brain neurotransmitter levels were considered (and hardly are today, over 100 years later)

    4. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by PolygamousRanchKid+ · · Score: 1

      Perhaps the school shooter in Connecticut was a heavy consumer of something spiked with MSG such as, for example, many (although not all) varieties of potato chips.

      Well, one thing is for certain, due to the demise of Hostess, if he had survived, he wouldn't have been able to use the "Twinkie Defense": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twinkie_defense

      --
      Schroedinger's Brexit: The UK is both in and out of the EU at the same time!
    5. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

      Oh horrors, better start avoiding that unnatural glutamate. All meat, fish, cheese and tomato products are evil and full of that stuff! All that savory tasting stuff.

      The reason it tastes good is because it is one of the few things we have taste receptors for. We like added glutamate for the same reason we like all those hearty tasting stews, roasts, casseroles and such that naturally contain it.

      That scary sounding monosodium, disodium and such parts in front of the name are mostly irrelevant. They just sound scary but mean that the glutamic acid is added in it's a sodium salt form. (like the scary sounding sodium chloride, table salt)

      Simply said:
      Glutamic acid is an non-essential amino acid (an amino acid that the body also synthesises by itself) and pretty important for cellural metabolism and liver functions. Perfectly natural thing. The glutamate you eat doesn't magically start screwing up your brain.
      Since most mental states (and many problems) are caused by different balances of neurotransmitters it not strange that a change in glutamate balance affects the mind in some way. That is how the brain works. Eating added glutamate does not directly affect the amount of glutamate released in your neurons.

    6. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by slothman32 · · Score: 1

      Glutamate and glutamic acid are 2 different things.
      One is an acid and the other the conjugate base of it.
      Glutamic acid has 2 Hydrogens it can lose.
      MSG has 1.
      In a basic enough solution it could even lose the other Hydrogen.

      --
      Why don't you guys have friends or journals?
    7. Re:Glutamate has become very common in modern food by RivenAleem · · Score: 1

      That explains why when I eat a REALLY good curry, I think to myself "I could die now, happy". Damn that MSG!

  6. Glutamate linked to suicide? by Ralph+Spoilsport · · Score: 3, Funny
    Then just lay off the cheap chinese food, and "things will get betterer"?

    How does this account for all the people committing suicide in Finland? There aren't many cheap chinese food places there, but those people kill themselves all the time.

    Monosodium? Whatever. Listen, I got an AGENDA to push, so don't get in the way with chemistry. The shit's like alchemy - bad for you.

    We live in caves. We speak with our hands.

    --
    Shoes for Industry. Shoes for the Dead.
    1. Re:Glutamate linked to suicide? by Ralph+Spoilsport · · Score: 1

      Wow. All Finland's neighbours have to do then is open up a bunch of cheap chinese restaurants in Finland, and you fuckers will all be dead at your own hands in a matter of weeks!

      --
      Shoes for Industry. Shoes for the Dead.
    2. Re:Glutamate linked to suicide? by Bruce+Perens · · Score: 1, Interesting

      How does this account for all the people committing suicide in Finland? There aren't many cheap chinese food places there

      Finns in general have an asian genetic admixture. So, their food is chinese :-) . They also culturally drink incredible amounts of coffee. And there are cultural differences, including a stoicism that may lead to people getting less help for emotional issues. But perhaps the biggest issue is:

      It's dark there. For much of the winter. People are sensitive to light.

  7. Re:Mod parent up. by Culture20 · · Score: 1

    my father kept his rifle in his high school locker and went shooting after school, as an after school activity! Now a pocket knife invokes a zero-brain policy.

    Toy guns and rubber knives apply to the zero-tolerance policies too. One kid got suspended for an Optimus Prime gun (the miniature size for the toy to hold).

  8. xCT cystein antiporter ! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    It may all come down the the xCT cystein antiporter on glial cells. These cells mop up excess extracellular glutamic acid and turn it into inactive glutamine which can be safely returned to neurons as well as producing Glutathione together with cystein

    as our bodies produce superoxide radical O2^- as a by product of respiration we've developed a defense mechanism the SuperOxideDismutase enzyme which turns it into the less harmful H2O2, consuming glutathione in the process. Glutathione is a tripeptide manifactured from Cystein Glutamic Acid and Glycine. Now while none of these are classed as essential amino acids, disruption of their metabolisms are being linked to disease states. Glutathione has recently become more famous due to experimental use in ameliorating parkinsons, and also due to its skin whitening effects.

    Glutathione is also crucial for many detoxification systems in the body, recycling other antioxidants, and in defending the body and CNS from certain heavy metals, and other toxins.

    The body makes around 45g/day of glycine, although other products such as serine and trimethylglycine depend on the levels of homocystine and if the person is suffering from a methylation block. Interestingly Glycine has shown therapeutic effects in schizophrenia, and for improving depth and quality of sleep. Cystine is a particularly important aminoacid, involved in the methylation cycle and a necessary component of many enzymes. It can become a limiting factor for synthesis of Glutathione.

    When the ratio of cystein to glutamic acid swings too far the xCT cystine antiporters on Glial cells do not function correctly leading to excess extra-cellular glutamic acid and excitotoxicity. This is compounded by the decreased production of Glutathione which would alleviate this excitotoxicity.

    The body recycles cysteine through a cycle involving the conversion into homocystine and back, utilising folic acid, B12 and B6. Homocystine is neurotoxic, a factor in cardiovascular disease, and typically accumulates with age.

    the enzymes involved in the synthesis and recycling of of glutathione have been shown to be induced by melatonin, another very important antioxidant that concentrates in CSF, the nucleolus and mitochondria where is protects DNA. read Jennifer Anne Lukes thesis.

    So part of the problem could be a deficiency of Glutathione, and or cystine, and or methylation block leading to to excess homocysteine, possibly exacerbated by reduced melatonin levels seen in the mentally ill.

  9. Focus the research where it matters by Beryllium+Sphere(tm) · · Score: 1

    The important part is that the suicidal people had dihydrogen monoxide in their cerebrospinal fluid.

  10. MSG makes you clevererer by formfeed · · Score: 1

    Just let me summarize this whole discussion:
    1. MSG is brain food.
    2. If you eat lots of it you become really smart.

    3a. That's why Chinese kids are good at math.
    3b. American teens eat it and realize that they are losers, so they become suicidal.

    (People in Finland just kill themselves because they are Finns.)