KDE's Aaron Seigo Bashes Ubuntu Phone

sfcrazy writes "KDE's Plasma Active team leader Aaron Seigo has raised some concerns around Ubuntu Phone. He says 'We can start with the obvious clue: Unity currently does not use QML at all; Ubuntu Phone is pure QML. So, no, it is not the same code, it is not the sort of seamless cross-device technology bridge that they are purporting.' He then concludes, 'If you're a Free software developer, user and/or supporter and buying into these claims, I don't know how else to put it other than this: you're being duped. Consider what supporting those who employ such tactics means for Free software.'"

Comments

Hrm

[bigtomrodney]

Is this the same guy that tried to sell Kickoff launcher as being "One Click"?

Re:Hrm

[Anonymous Coward]

No, it's just Michael over at moronix who needs more clicks, so he misrepresents what someone says to get them. Slashdot gets on the bus for the same purpose. News at 11.

well it worked for google

[Anonymous Coward]

releasing a proprietary exploitation built on linux, i mean the fanbois eat it up even though you can't actually contribute to or even see developmental android code... ohh, yeah, so "open" but as long as it's someway vaguely linux related you get guaranteed sales from the neckbeard asperger kids.

Re:well it worked for google

[dfghjk]

The GPL doesn't ensure that you can "actually contribute to or even see developmental android code" and Google not offering that doesn't mean that their products are a "proprietary exploitation". The problem here is a nerd's sense of entitlement.

Re:well it worked for google

[drinkypoo]

The GPL doesn't ensure that you can "actually contribute to or even see developmental android code" and Google not offering that doesn't mean that their products are a "proprietary exploitation". The problem here is a nerd's sense of entitlement.

The problem is that Google sets expectations when they describe something as "open" (as if that meant anything by itself, but still) and then breaks them when they do not utilize an open development process.

Re:well it worked for google

[BanHammor]

Read Cathedral vs Bazaar to understand just what exactly open means.

Re:well it worked for google

[drinkypoo]

Read Cathedral vs Bazaar to understand just what exactly open means.

Uh, no. Not only have I read it, but he didn't invent the term open, nor for that matter open source. Nor did anyone else who claims to have done so, oddly enough.

Re:well it worked for google

[BanHammor]

Still, the "cathedral" model was used by GNU back in the day, and you'd probably be nuts not consider Emacs open.

Re:well it worked for google

[drinkypoo]

Still, the "cathedral" model was used by GNU back in the day, and you'd probably be nuts not consider Emacs open.

You will never ever catch me saying that GNU's Not Open. That's not how it expands anyway.

Re:well it worked for google

[BanHammor]

Then we can't blame Google for not being open - after all, they are doing the same thing GNU did, using the Cathedral model of development.

Re:well it worked for google

[drinkypoo]

Then we can't blame Google for not being open - after all, they are doing the same thing GNU did, using the Cathedral model of development.

Google is Open Source. That's a fact. But Google uses a closed development model. I don't blame Google for not being open, I blame Google for claiming to be more open than they are. If they call Android "Open Source" I cheer. If they call Android "Open" then I scowl, that doesn't mean anything.

Re:well it worked for google

[Anonymous Coward]

Google is open source? Where can I download the code that calculates their search rankings?

Re:well it worked for google

[exomondo]

If they call Android "Open Source" I cheer.

Well that seems dubious, you can't really call 'Android' open source, only specific versions. I suppose you could say Android is open source based on the released versions - well assuming Android was open source until 3.0, then was not open source for a while, then became open source again - but i think it's best to do it version-specific since when a new version is announced it isn't open sourced until the first devices are shipping to protect OHA member exclusivity. I don't think there's anything wrong with their model - it's their product so they can do with it as they wish - but I absolutely agree with you on the 'open' argument, it's pretty disingenuous.

Re:well it worked for google

[drinkypoo]

If they call Android "Open Source" I cheer.

Well that seems dubious, you can't really call 'Android' open source, only specific versions.

OK, all versions but 3. And all three customers are really bent about it. Your point is taken, and I was a bit miffed about it at the time, but 4 really did come out shortly thereafter and the lack of Android 3 code really didn't impact much. Still, yes, your qualifier is valid.

Language of choice

[Anonymous Coward]

Man, if only there was a way to take code written for one display device and. what's a good word, "compile" it into a program that uses a different display device.

Re:Language of choice

[icebike]

Or a shim to get from one API set to another API set.

Pretty heavy handed

[Anonymous Coward]

He has a point (actually two: the phone isn't using the same API, and Canonical marketers implied that it was) but he seems to think that that is disqualifying for users of free software. I don't think it is.

Point it out, but just add "KDE's approach is quite different. Here's what we're doing instead..." instead of talking about ethics and such.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[dfghjk]

He said that the ethical implications of the deceit might be "disqualifying for users of free software", not the technical details themselves. Talking about "ethics and such" is certainly relevant in that context especially in a community that thinks it's so ethically-minded.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[Anonymous Coward]

KDE's approach would be to add neon blue drop shadows, massive animated gif icons that look like they were drawn by a three year old that was having an epileptic seizure, and about 50 gaudy animated desktop widgets. You also couldn't have icons on the phone's home screen without adding some shitty plugin that's written in JavaScript and breaks on absolutely every update.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[node 3]

Something I've never quite understood from the "free/libre/open" software culture is the self-contradictory sentiment of, "you're not doing it our way, therefore you are wrong!" Isn't choice and variety and each person being able to take something and mold it to their wishes one of, if not the, primary points?

I wonder if decoupling morality from software the way it's so commonly tied together in the FSF/OSS movements would help? I don't mean entirely, just not that everything is a moral imperative. That's clearly not in the cards for the FSF any time soon, but ostensibly, that's one of the reasons the Open Source movement was started.

Personally, I find Ubuntu on phones to have great possibilities, and though it has a long way to go to prove itself as qualified and viable, I could see it surpassing Android in appeal to me. That it's a more honest offering of "Linux on your phone" than Android is. I haven't had a chance to flash it onto one of my Nexuses yet, but am looking forward to doing so sometime soon.

Honestly, seeing nerds rage against something on meta-reason grounds is often the first sign that it's going to be good!

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[Anonymous Coward]

Holding marketing drivel to a high ethical standard shows so much naiveté, I'm embarrassed for the guy.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[Anonymous Coward]

Imagine a Semantic Phone!!

KDE people must stop bashing others and listen to the huge amounts of complaints on their decisions. They force their view on others as much as any evil corporation. They should make features optional so the user can choose to install things like the Semantic Desktop or not if he doesn't have any use for it.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[Anonymous Coward]

> he self-contradictory sentiment of, "you're not doing it our way, therefore you are wrong!"

no contradiction there:

1) Everyone can act however they want (the obvious things like murder, rape, assault and theft excluded)
2) One of the things you can do is express your opinion, be it positive or negative. This is called feedback, and it is not force
3) What (if anything) you then do with that feed is up to you

As long as 3 is true, there's no contradiction.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[vizZzion]

The Semantic Desktop *is* optional, both compile-time and runtime.

Re:Pretty heavy handed

[node 3]

"You can do whatever you want. No, not that." is a contradiction.

FS/OSS advocates pay lip service to choice, but far too many of them have large sets of choices which they tell others are wrong.

Fixed

[Anonymous Coward]

KDE's Aaron Seigo Bashes Ubuntu Marketers.

Fixed that for you.

Poor little Aaron...

[Anonymous Coward]

In other news, after being picked last for the ump-teenth time in a row, Aaron Seigo was reportedly quoted as saying "I'm taking my toys home and telling mommy! You guys are mean!"

I Want A Phone As Secure As My Linux Box

[Anonymous Coward]

If it is just another spy phone, there is no reason to purchase one.

FUD

[Anonymous Coward]

Unity's 2D version is QML and is not the standard there up til very 'recently'; and has been used for the phone version.

Why making /. headline before even the people could check the phone version out.

Androidist's FUD ?
 

Re:FUD

[BanHammor]

Yes, it is QML, but it's long since discontinued.

Re:FUD

[KugelKurt]

Ubuntu Phone is based on Qt5 and QML2. The deprecated Unity2D is based on Qt4 and QML1. Granted, the effort to port from QML1 to QML2 is minimal (which is why KDE Plasma components are first being rewritten in QML1 to prepare for the port to QML2) but they are not the same.

poppycock

[drankr]

Not, he's not bashing Ubuntu phone, mostly because such a thing does not exist - yet. He is criticizing Canonical's less than sincere approach to the rest of the world. That's all.

Re:poppycock

[Knuckles]

But the Ubuntu press release explicitly says that the code will be shared when the project "is completed", which it is obviously not. And getting upset about a marketing video seems like a waste of time. It's not new that a marketing video may not present the actual current development status, but the one that you want to sell down the road.

Mod Parent Up!

[Carewolf]

There is almost no correlation between this story headline and the actual content Aaron wrote. Among other things Aaron wrote:

I want to make it crystal clear that I think Ubuntu Phone a great thing to see; more Free software mobile efforts, particularly ones using Qt/QML, warm my insides like a good bowl of soup on a cold winter's night

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Anonymous Coward]

The question is, if all of you can see how obvious it is that the editors here are misleading people to sell a few ad clicks, why are you still visiting the site? I had considered making an account to post this but to be honest I'd really rather not bother. I'd rather not help the editors make a buck off another pointless flame-war that THEY FUCKING STARTED!

I'm not saying that any other site is any better, but Slashdot used to be one of my favorites. I think I'm now getting a glimpse of exactly what made Malda retire from his post. The flame-war monster that he created has spun out of even his control so he got out while the getting was good. With any luck this place will go the way of digg.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[roc97007]

> The question is, if all of you can see how obvious it is that the editors here are misleading people to sell a few ad clicks, why are you still visiting the site?

The same reason I sometimes read the mail in my spam folder. Because it's amusing.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Anonymous Coward]

more Free software mobile efforts, particularly ones using Qt/QML, warm my insides like a good bowl of soup on a cold winter's night

It's this kind of faggotry that makes FOSStards so detestable: "Oh God, my beautiful Free Software! I would I could just eat it, poop it out, and smear the coded feces all over my body."

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Anonymous Coward]

So the same reason the trolls visit the site, then. In other words you're part of the problem, but when someone points it out to you, you have no defense.

Sorry, but you have no right to complain about a problem you helped cause.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Carewolf]

The question is, if all of you can see how obvious it is that the editors here are misleading people to sell a few ad clicks, why are you still visiting the site? I had considered making an account to post this but to be honest I'd really rather not bother. I'd rather not help the editors make a buck off another pointless flame-war that THEY FUCKING STARTED!

I am not sure they did it entirely intentional. The story was just so flamy-delicious looking they forgot to check it was actually true.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[fbobraga]

Sorry, but you have no right to complain about a problem you helped cause.

Yes, he has! You are very wrong here...

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[segedunum]

Nevertheless, Aaron is pretty critical of Ubuntu Phone, and frankly, he has a point. Ubuntu is not using the common codebase they try and claim and their use of Qt and QML in their phone is pretty amusing. They've wasted large sums of time and money over the years going down many different software avenues over the years, Gnome being one (and worse, doing a great deal to hurt others in the process), only to decide years later that they really needed to create Unity and then they decide that the mast they have nailed their development colours to is not good enough for phone and mobile development.

It's the kind of thing that doesn't make me interested in any form of desktop or GUI open source development and hasn't for years. It's the same old bullshit. Pardon my French but Ubuntu either needs to either produce something worthwhile and useful that will move open source desktop and GUI usage forwards dramatically or they need to run out of Shuttleworth's cash and fuck off.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Jane Q. Public]

"Pardon my French but Ubuntu either needs to either produce something worthwhile and useful that will move open source desktop and GUI usage forwards dramatically or they need to run out of Shuttleworth's cash and fuck off."

But traditionally, GUI is really not a "part" of Linux at all. It is an add-on. Thus X, and Gnome, and KDE. I don't mention Unity because I don't think it's worth mentioning... I view it as a niche attempt to corner the Linux interface market, which is likely doomed to fail.

I have been using Kubuntu -- the semi-official KDE Ubuntu -- for years. I like it, it's stable, and the interface with least surprise. It does what I want, when I want, and it doesn't try to "integrate" things that do not need to be, or should not be, integrated. (Like Twitter, or Facebook, or Google Search, or whatever... big FAIL on Apple's part to put things like that in the desktop interface. Twitter and Facebook are properly separate services, and will likely be replaced by something else in a few years. Google Search already has credible competitors.)

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[BrokenHalo]

Nevertheless, Aaron is pretty critical of Ubuntu Phone, and frankly, he has a point.

So he does. It doesn't necessarily mean Ubuntu Phone is a total crock of shit, it's just that it's not really the platform they imply it is. (Now what would be really cool would be a Slackware phone...)

What struck me, however, on following the link at the bottom of the article pointing to release of the phone product on 21st Feb, the first thing I saw was that YouTube clip of Stallman talking about Ubuntu and spyware.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Jane Q. Public]

I probably should not go on about this, but I think it needs to be said. "Social Networking" is in its infancy, AND some of the bigger services (I'm looking at you, Facebook and Google) are notorious privacy invaders. Trying to actually make them part of the desktop is grossly premature, or even inappropriate. For the people who want them (and maybe they want some service OTHER than the ones that are built-in), there are perfectly good apps. We do not need -- and in my case I do not want -- them to be "integrated".

To me, integrating Facebook or Twitter into your desktop is akin to bolting a payphone to your car.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Anonymous Coward]

It's true that he seemed to take back some of his criticism at the end of the blog, but the tone of the blog was very harsh regardless. Why didn't he take back the other stuff *before* he posted it?

Probably because he really meant what he was saying!

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[myowntrueself]

Nevertheless, Aaron is pretty critical of Ubuntu Phone, and frankly, he has a point.

So he does. It doesn't necessarily mean Ubuntu Phone is a total crock of shit, it's just that it's not really the platform they imply it is. (Now what would be really cool would be a Slackware phone...)
 

Gentoo phone. That you compile ON the phone.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[CAIMLAS]

It's a sad thing to see, really. Slashdot was the machine through which many of us saw all the awesomeness of the early years of the "world wide web" and when we cut our teeth on technology - I'd say 1997 through 2003, roughly. So it's sad to see stuff like this, particularly when we remember how it used to be, and how there really isn't much left on the Internet that's similar to "how it used to be" to such a large degree as even slashdot.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[TractorBarry]

> It's the kind of thing that doesn't make me interested in any form of desktop or GUI open source development and hasn't for years. It's the same old bullshit

Wish I had mod points today I'd mod this right up ! +10 insightful.

The latest Gnome/Unity fiascos has put me completely off desktop Linux. There are so many areas of Linux that are in desperate need of improvement (pro audio apps, pro image manipulation apps, pro video apps) - not to mention all the usability bugs that never get fixed.

But what do the developers do ? Continually fuck around with the desktop metaphor, keep breaking things, continually "reinvent the wheel" (extremely badly), or needlessly trying to push new paradigms down our throats. "Hey we haven't rewritten subsystem X this week so let's throw out what we've got (thereby conveniently ignoring all the bugs) and let's write something entirely new (with all nwe bugs that will never be fixed) instead".

It's a huge, huge waste of time.

Not to mention the fact I'd got quite a number of people in my locaility to start using Ubuntu. When they pulled that Unity shit every single one of them was on my case complaining how the latest updates had broken their computer and "how can we get rid of this rubbish ?"

Desktop linux is a waste of time. Excellent server. Complete waste of time as a desktop. Constantly moving operational metaphors, not enough pro quality apps and no desire to fix bugs (let's make new buggy, shitty "shiny" instead)

There I've said it.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[TractorBarry]

More like akin to bolting a jackbooted Stasi thug directly onto your face.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[KugelKurt]

Nevertheless, Aaron is pretty critical of Ubuntu Phone, and frankly, he has a point. Ubuntu is not using the common codebase they try and claim

Maybe I've looked at the wrong websites but I have yet to see a claim that both desktop Unity and phone Unity are written using the same codebase. I just saw the claim that one application's Qt codebase can be used on both systems and that's completely true. Canonical wrote various bits and pieces even quite some time ago to make sure that Qt applications utilize indicators, global menus, etc.
Canonical also rewrote at least their UbuntuOne desktop client in Qt a while ago. Canonical also forked MeeGo's Qt-based SSO framework and integrated that into Ubuntu for desktops and I'm 100% certain that Ubuntu phone just as regular Ubuntu will both use Maliit (another MeeGo leftover) as virtual keyboard. It just makes sense and which toolkit the actual shell is written is, is completely irrelevant.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[KugelKurt]

It's the kind of thing that doesn't make me interested in any form of desktop or GUI open source development and hasn't for years.

Obviously wrong because if you weren't interested, you'd not even read such stories, let alone comment on them.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Anonymous Coward]

Parent post (as is so often the case with such AC posts) has nothing relevant to add to the topic, but instead appears to reveal a bit too much information about their own fantasies and desires...

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[freezin fat guy]

The latest Gnome/Unity fiascos has put me completely off desktop Linux.

Quite the opposite here.

Indeed at first it did shake my confidence but it also made me look at the DE alternatives, which turn out to be many. There are even forks of Gnome 2, possible only because of open source. That flexibility has given me greater confidence.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[iampiti]

At least with open source you can fork. The computer stores over here are plastered with Microsoft flyers trying to convince people that Windows 8 is great and very easy to use with keyboard and mouse (*groan*).
I feel sorry for the sales guys who have to convince people to buy computers with Windows 8.
It almost makes me want to give a hand to Reactos to try to make a open source Windows clone.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Zero__Kelvin]

"The question is, if all of you can see how obvious it is that the editors here are misleading people to sell a few ad clicks, why are you still visiting the site?"

For one thing, it helps to know what kind of falsehoods the proletariat are buying into, and the actual truth, so that I know enough to counter it when I hear it.

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Sporkinum]

Openmoko.. http://wiki.openmoko.org/wiki/Main_Page

Re:Mod Parent Up!

[Anonymous Coward]

Don't drag Gnome into Ubuntu's waste of a desktop. Gnome 3.0 is very usable (been using it for years), but I still can't fathom that Unity interface. Not liking Gnome's UI choices is far different than Gnome not being usable.

Not seeing the writing on the wall with Ubuntu's case was sheer blindness to the warning indicators. I mean, they still donate a pittance to the open source development community they benefit from, and are still attempting to rewrite anything with visual impact to a Unbuntu version. They still routinely mislead people into believing that Ubuntu is the driving force behind major linux projects that they have only managed to skin, and they are the first to throw problems over the fence blaming the projects they benefit from.

Ubuntu is the "marketing version" of Linux. They take Debian and add marketing, until it smells as sweet as honey, without the actual presence of bees, pollen, or honey. When that doesn't work, they tell you it's because the rest of the world got non-Ubuntu shit on their product.

Sour grapes

[Anonymous Coward]

Sounds like he's got sour grapes that while they started earlier, Canonical will actually deliver a product people will use well before this guy.

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

homosexual cunt balls faggot ballsack fist nigger faggot cumdumpster cunt nigger
balls nigger faggot whore cumdumpster homosexual cunt cock cock whore cunt anus
balls cock anus whore jew fist homosexual cunt faggot fist homosexual faggot an
us homosexual cunt whore anus homosexual fist cunt nigger balls balls fist homos
exual jew cunt

13848 04603 26941 37883 81535 43659 54917 55418 83522 66784 17187 87744 91555 82
982 07485 83062 25227 15211 01876 00956 28594 39056 36308 40464 64384 00937 5729
7 56530 48555 42192 45862 51397 37502 18715 58567 94161 20445 97539 05563 26891
48871 93114 95909 34075 75064 78400 62474 18589 99337 73256 34060 40568 53768 67
184 97310 23718 93748 04057 00567 80657 34304 87595 32739 77953 33858 96042 3370
0 10300 38360 40924 92910 93003 01986 90164 48614 08103 11508 49305 23878 04571
06033 50232 71009 71745 17825 45301 94593 96640 82060 72981 16118 11500 83701 34
377 51266 54171 34861 50653 10195 76854 79666 67041 08148 84579 84588 94704 0653
8 51246 75505 20779 75399 49159 83090 76838 61967 89755 24944 79556 15913 88943
95174 51460 32214 77095 72976 82998 37126 17650 45123 72418 26039 49651 32690 03
953 11269 19061 73870 36914 14610 24043 17947 01152 22497 72090 71609 29602 8448
0 15111 51708 53796 31580 92433 90554 43822 64000 81767 14818 53193 91049 00032
82483 50067 07332 14008 73845 29098 05355 45116 19347 98075 84250 70768 23903 83
100 80476 16149 64284 49810 37434 81283 99961 73984 06346 97494 19670 97315 6451
2 88077 96012 32110 13800 94240 29792 23132 16810 60499 45069 08828 02095 35989
12840 10814 95902 35901 36904 02441 90215 49020 38216 83297 34861 15698 02267 61
213 65736 32503 73591 84089 58232 66634 42928 92567 28008 25803 23321 91639 1796
6 64445 76770 21143 74430 79994 41294 73090 31153 96318 13087 62914 12504 26763
41959 88873 88968 69596 86947 68138 08118 76188 35688 99372 38351 54229 15880 40
855 95773 76435 45694 36347 40750 25421 51600 23050 57480 60592 83762 98592 5591
1 44263 69104 58216 08478 17046 95329 41660 23358 18113 07235 83561 79248 39647
73174 96980 36654 23121 25648 01054 26795 91089 97969 05722 01505 64523 06471 18
520 11245 52323 11980 95242 35845 11041 61452 33684 83923 09272 27930 90158 2502
8 39930 15273 96492 35972 42467 59262 96998 03637 58771 61343 22111 23300 45701
86309 62846 62517 18407 71227 47573 89371 57572 44996 01623 59191 63640 81955 17
780 44539 65372 18421 06037 84795 33608 97459 75745 87959 66852 83933 39144 5269
5 03028 31786 86740 08764 63784 68230 44332 97971 33904 74180 88172 30604 80394
51107 04514 24067 15915 00594 34444 35777 24299 37006 62586 14780 27516 40589 23
268 36663 16219 74202 50212 37765 19979 06517 97359 28398 74176 02108 79472 9701
4 40597 55408 73748 75327 62228 05061 90275 24501 31710 97483 81296 52399 46720
61546 47556 41106 97793 25990 28366 37338 46301 65958 59140 62335 15285 20103 79
019 29691 60102 15047 35816 38602 69021 21798 76283 84963 23695 42171 94766 6734
7 07063 35026 68737 65468 31716 44959 84073 25110 29035 84841 00858 47280 25406
30052 20825 57474 00661 32585 05675 75356 32719 51760 56115 69047 23303 34273 17
976 14200 46973 93294 83955 70779 83097 18504 26099 89228 71269 58583 75445 0398
9 95384 77128 74265 30200 33883 21055 14478 85884 31245 96487 57363 67627 26311
48457 37536 81700 26974 75865 75791 19155 43439 12039 20940 69488 66248 17571 98
551 12294 34164 34314 89522 25933 09549 19385 70093 36505 24133 38311 79792 9015
1 36043 82065 72206 01859 33182 72115 79716 06219 14030 85075 79923 79979 98855
75945 62608 91450 78458 18525 10020 20105 04658 74934 64115 83723 51387 06919 04
581 71308 56434 75936 51890 97244 03184 88728 65727 90017 19047 65145 59999 2406
2 21047 37158 42858 20907 26880 39724 30158 73447 24994 75873 70303 68602 79167
18581 37023 29383 87086 35816 38477 26130 74159 26805 23575 28687 23661 94207 81
342 58277 57127 48351 93341 89387 23811 99016 37489 50775 86476 87219 76708 1225
9 18233 06240 17085 57415 99703 22394 14

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

anus nigger cunt anus nigger jew homosexual anus cunt jew faggot whore faggot an
us anus faggot cock jew balls nigger balls whore cock nigger fist jew whore jew
cock faggot fist cumdumpster jew homosexual jew nigger anus jew homosexual cumdu
mpster cunt jew fist nigger faggot faggot cunt anus ballsack faggot

88524 22045 11829 32123 68618 28067 97322 91994 72274 31255 94525 83433 94233 45
783 46516 72794 53384 17227 77524 51432 44710 24346 02757 06337 14953 39469 0165
2 33712 06639 59920 59553 13736 39880 24914 33479 59948 22125 12221 44431 49467
17151 11883 63090 68185 23943 08818 35945 17546 78357 90067 93407 63077 03320 71
958 61430 03827 85090 20780 88536 08455 11255 97817 41868 26978 39259 04252 1728
8 97725 87836 27647 79725 00565 77676 41064 40237 54778 52675 60462 88847 80836
33446 57424 34996 84798 20055 25800 16924 94747 61401 68239 01841 66859 75560 91
204 17015 33070 37592 10076 95678 87063 88491 01687 09460 39180 30819 11232 5736
5 84917 56207 08183 03923 38358 42190 25310 15246 41708 03300 20631 58263 96846
16195 76073 84669 76302 22447 34194 54914 64413 78803 02461 17171 65781 04820 56
704 35195 02567 72412 07775 11608 73548 23085 85317 40330 30178 33511 50544 4175
4 99142 30406 57973 59001 27144 52105 67454 15584 00198 04326 67595 30958 29886
30443 18863 36034 79289 45498 91943 52895 16370 98002 67059 20875 03142 16699 79
867 35952 99976 59493 71298 08503 67334 17205 28845 47673 91757 10346 79905 1437
5 32509 34267 01508 17354 29761 62795 97150 40269 06157 82419 45136 24944 85759
92858 14365 88156 19772 88985 82492 14982 11793 91301 46745 20481 90453 16650 77
090 80560 97027 50766 84628 58652 40288 11377 57954 13546 25860 26836 39642 8644
9 37156 91907 09881 63357 24188 70984 94568 76388 14681 27614 60535 73253 98655
12052 95356 64759 35269 78993 85713 36036 43345 50127 15477 08285 07756 57877 77
367 03952 18494 24515 34243 83259 78524 37517 27114 05376 15446 88346 18331 9113
4 97577 80650 21662 39297 74693 48387 90514 34009 01226 80362 08927 34101 24456
52951 10576 40315 00494 70375 33697 45463 25837 96561 84827 71610 06675 54410 53
969 20540 47608 65319 39565 89843 41598 34208 10687 91811 70285 48484 98538 7510
4 66852 06550 37870 50738 93033 58170 79708 88822 10184 97436 21989 92722 01447
43378 65352 77027 52388 20532 40820 07711 86478 00537 10863 24940 72648 51703 22
904 17527 09507 19786 15207 09059 45988 03420 10630 28568 51144 59691 92574 1674
3 06691 41217 00755 44942 09451 86829 80004 40293 91324 67271 52687 35161 53134
97831 74973 86763 27787 72255 44945 21549 54714 65007 74716 41694 42497 99061 91
911 17007 98206 57813 88960 87426 00409 75040 26605 44694 79112 74247 38442 8585
0 49337 08313 34399 54660 01781 84074 70962 17871 88447 02010 92788 15660 63329
24505 04272 39519 86577 91261 34092 00662 25513 27231 31500 16888 49506 55996 41
129 20977 11406 40199 70301 21287 43496 27376 89901 96777 63531 57034 76048 8048
2 61613 29140 51475 97573 41095 28931 98130 64358 67217 14014 17636 65075 70701
03744 37843 71033 87084 19698 86001 68274 77741 69364 48298 39972 97594 48837 33
493 09577 48969 19182 55783 15391 86602 72933 31758 30101 47372 90160 47567 9693
4 84402 88991 69013 20011 54654 77069 20068 70717 72997 28020 42706 92959 04846
07411 22483 36272 90229 91020 45373 88997 53110 85493 22610 86792 98650 55070 38
852 04783 80221 41505 09436 50022 56470 83398 18645 42220 45558 83934 57169 2144
0 04157 00223 39813 73455 03231 74567 56326 21747 10965 94001 16220 15359 57924
59735 26899 55318 78219 95354 30083 93258 21441 79369 14475 72525 70581 65911 27
211 51815 24215 95449 23816 69516 72428 29566 26750 06749 52874 48841 09245 1311
4 84089 41804 31683 28602 31411 48644 41866 19981 67954 16220 19508 15810 25327
28876 30808 72650 95233 13221 09441 55131 59224 15016 96921 89747 71381 92698 77
153 87840 53582 76023 97140 58717 99195 41061 41844 39939 37332 05697 55580 4889
8 45588 95074 13838 61086 78114 70734 77515 14062 47289 77507 19444 90843 67324
413

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

whore whore homosexual faggot balls fist nigger faggot anus cumdumpster fist fis
t whore jew nigger nigger ballsack cumdumpster cumdumpster homosexual fist cumdu
mpster cunt jew cock nigger nigger fist cumdumpster fist cunt nigger balls whore
ballsack cock whore anus fist jew cock whore homosexual homosexual ballsack fag
got whore cock homosexual faggot

69366 86379 87537 01792 89993 51242 98826 28303 63749 23634 55825 30097 49637 72
602 29449 05123 90848 31491 35380 27917 40861 54001 72195 38187 65199 17547 6669
1 70719 94408 09833 93904 95100 92798 19763 11149 79784 43970 71323 99595 01455
85737 42925 66794 13747 40773 80257 06566 88147 49314 14436 58501 66101 11781 15
074 30390 12319 80472 41239 85059 49662 90996 87408 98228 43575 25638 15175 0665
5 05322 45518 47160 03947 88937 77860 09927 82895 65786 96633 32796 30454 94535
42709 98695 67134 17856 89198 28184 88592 48723 11523 24761 13203 81688 25643 98
434 26213 48594 81681 01029 62779 18193 48428 92028 88723 75843 69191 05857 6177
0 06079 42094 77082 33990 82491 33646 61445 19123 70998 48724 56041 88340 64757
17938 18117 11332 49135 39653 34773 32943 50712 62453 83941 22080 05350 91890 82
728 33030 16372 63735 55103 08733 29292 25004 45102 25962 84809 66914 15990 4210
9 88520 93043 35264 77438 24921 44625 69659 99336 63951 90027 75308 31097 03963
14120 91123 77045 79694 58592 81108 22510 49434 26023 46982 28083 80358 79434 84
214 68683 50883 85544 46849 32622 46596 70531 57063 77949 84372 97358 17449 0711
2 94214 61119 27822 18790 67689 08106 49936 49817 48640 11993 15750 56651 12347
59334 03410 79050 09369 43062 35992 54346 60175 07098 86629 78941 84579 03784 77
523 31632 95106 99781 00923 15815 61580 88509 29000 33283 64625 19299 81570 6488
9 92303 44691 50377 61749 43914 41226 41640 33469 74333 41135 85996 52805 70792
44615 57886 18297 09392 09843 18807 95565 36544 76736 66643 41970 49320 67863 48
491 27418 67262 91202 63478 20430 64708 31098 70058 56177 88509 71310 25134 3081
8 57188 31687 72185 00543 70803 82134 43035 95942 89189 05928 08256 41398 00782
25460 10478 20950 66177 25827 64547 46249 10426 45370 01452 06881 70529 92987 49
909 23538 75453 71881 13563 20189 83573 35097 43701 79400 54193 48775 77560 6911
8 77234 18608 10572 40370 36341 72868 96795 33876 77221 61697 37685 65970 05322
17651 99641 20814 32399 77934 73399 49310 69144 09895 26253 65739 61126 77612 87
638 55680 69310 67374 35905 11718 61739 50110 83984 79953 42461 45804 68173 7973
7 97614 35744 88041 01561 28802 32629 70193 58217 33509 57384 72879 53243 04973
69449 63404 05204 27975 32630 80260 02667 92728 29868 53186 69374 55820 98080 82
256 36526 82533 34942 65409 26408 93173 07911 62733 46290 02375 27348 62228 2927
3 67806 66107 50380 79286 11212 19882 32968 45015 71357 66762 52498 34414 77971
65547 98421 67577 42253 03197 35091 50360 16035 34686 77026 61256 06331 15060 95
627 94282 45559 07922 53439 25336 81228 06184 96422 97439 02732 63996 65276 7720
0 70874 53510 47648 65910 44477 70979 55590 24859 91452 88897 59144 17092 32966
83010 57749 77656 90451 51041 11911 77498 56731 69952 00371 20333 47699 16464 07
218 94055 07399 87585 22001 66724 75753 74813 16994 75489 29628 85529 55844 7471
8 06844 05551 51800 25574 57694 81356 71494 27288 51862 48461 70133 45455 08680
97410 10144 59671 02243 04128 81245 97318 06161 82637 58355 77361 58264 60772 70
755 74566 46748 21711 12316 97473 35778 34549 58102 18539 85328 97788 37001 2714
2 89604 57291 21932 22638 61163 07276 63606 61138 85181 60170 10749 40422 09762
64011 70597 03655 60819 85796 82409 32387 14355 96762 40681 81120 78233 82018 42
008 24140 57566 92887 70868 55934 47582 91560 61450 97189 21303 60920 87452 9842
8 78816 10333 41480 02432 06897 82392 71996 93406 21485 61668 99238 43319 93882
74602 84355 06874 01534 49296 66910 96880 04356 68855 93905 97766 93902 84788 61
420 23421 56740 31509 28328 91437 05470 94730 95060 27028 83053 97334 64689 6657
9 85133 92239 87504 78229 840

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

faggot faggot fist whore ballsack jew ballsack cumdumpster whore anus cumdumpste
r faggot balls homosexual homosexual cumdumpster faggot ballsack balls nigger an
us homosexual cunt balls homosexual ballsack jew cunt homosexual cunt anus faggo
t cumdumpster cumdumpster anus homosexual faggot nigger faggot nigger balls nigg
er nigger faggot cunt balls cock balls fist anus

87777 83816 97585 19074 83271 31500 07933 51941 25804 42426 73669 54680 11578 02
300 49796 96700 62921 13141 60980 16518 55444 84771 63680 96245 70072 93400 9791
9 60269 52509 86983 22964 08890 00698 77997 08422 19363 51491 80851 50042 00117
30476 23576 58950 04395 85960 65296 88238 44330 99201 75444 68444 21743 31106 79
467 18853 07251 30512 74720 52027 77608 57001 12758 13282 07913 79240 70626 6240
5 02774 95519 71375 92825 05028 34346 19564 62417 57037 10308 67537 55122 77699
24121 83748 06035 50697 94805 20705 76809 26077 03824 09840 13625 97592 16274 38
362 15565 49693 64327 63104 89565 55697 93751 08197 96995 17054 23069 65411 3267
0 49720 56469 35634 52170 96492 86121 50008 80264 09084 14310 37075 80425 53591
70192 18722 46852 18491 17115 13359 50096 16964 45076 71510 84125 81512 57827 23
077 33863 01627 68405 99863 50486 13828 42845 44858 32591 50167 75047 38427 5940
3 16294 63041 71170 71000 86098 49765 36443 40382 87375 84667 34260 67237 17880
95935 34384 80700 08672 01870 92944 33456 68353 03676 08596 49158 90586 46811 41
523 68444 82984 17768 34693 31509 52522 92411 62314 91099 66934 73293 79751 3767
2 43688 70232 70931 45290 91355 56243 16365 76540 16435 37397 97109 35958 62228
25004 74685 91597 11885 17964 32686 72573 80585 89611 85273 24510 89242 48229 62
471 26557 73534 39213 82773 35145 21155 83007 24900 99176 82646 49927 69032 2022
6 31723 91264 66932 71806 27763 36224 06890 48413 74642 18631 98531 12846 12622
01650 85649 46692 18657 61879 80359 65307 39588 56991 20924 02898 93002 95842 74
487 50582 63538 37349 81407 30363 25316 05674 75219 07904 06133 41797 76471 8562
0 62241 55336 35739 02038 49868 68435 00056 50647 45529 25643 89973 20772 79386
08146 08357 79739 12104 52536 14474 53338 74633 29101 18811 63655 20858 38409 69
491 75914 24061 45739 46185 14077 72938 20492 18725 86189 59906 61752 37401 7939
6 84742 29539 93296 53289 75515 52115 05626 13198 35429 45276 86597 37397 42663
67317 00496 05738 17219 21705 81394 52108 45406 47042 58754 78818 56382 08124 52
448 47347 32851 78953 16860 25732 19976 56666 00121 30991 59441 97685 14430 0554
9 56880 25532 00774 73468 11692 38112 67025 38592 75448 65682 05051 72653 50344
16257 28787 92075 38856 50218 94017 78605 03187 73213 41540 73730 93919 36203 82
670 67386 45697 67784 75572 09768 30356 19450 77647 24025 97654 78788 30037 1197
5 76417 26841 67074 22205 75183 36213 51383 78901 96630 33638 82101 66541 84658
13283 80450 14698 08666 44399 70029 78897 42792 49443 43490 75805 82485 92482 64
150 37632 87267 70874 98680 55636 43525 19044 81316 58003 45273 66232 79792 7714
0 75616 72883 16511 67964 58604 12208 52077 76547 68505 29176 91065 54141 62174
97071 75718 68656 84289 73773 04563 01492 94735 41711 90409 21048 22486 54686 98
079 00763 31055 99132 52110 60104 04962 09618 59621 04917 21083 47563 81670 1243
5 45357 97480 07739 86762 34381 19231 77522 82068 55831 50363 30884 27075 92663
46678 33688 44856 76728 51193 87512 12884 50812 52409 09400 13525 74378 99044 04
214 04837 02870 33104 54960 30629 15017 93510 13822 68484 84683 67941 50197 9805
8 09605 69262 19942 43769 98853 58862 65576 68248 24656 39431 26276 92074 40984
60406 46498 94514 22331 94824 89023 52128 91601 98703 73579 89650 39810 71355 15
675 16779 17636 16217 23422 22656 40525 02458 29544 53398 42056 10203 48172 0402
9 77047 99163 25843 53804 46311 95345 71763 00001 01980 04885 09605 81503 51630
25480 71736 74462 98844 57536 28749 26576 27835 62102 99609 42123 49781 19512 25
140 14716 55474 66731 29507 72139 85537 71851 53937 32989 58375 98118 18515 5736
8 10176 80039 22426

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

balls anus nigger nigger jew nigger faggot anus anus faggot nigger jew jew homos
exual nigger faggot balls cock cunt faggot fist ballsack jew faggot whore nigger
fist cock faggot anus anus nigger nigger anus faggot homosexual homosexual anus
jew homosexual cumdumpster cock cock cumdumpster faggot cumdumpster cunt cock w
hore fist

95086 55371 96353 27297 22075 02713 48357 28991 34914 12514 14769 51942 95202 27
685 84107 97013 90398 75956 79599 11899 99763 89394 58426 09316 58229 36796 9905
1 95899 50353 96307 73813 17848 16564 97846 00004 17020 93542 49556 84050 32845
41348 43180 05855 77001 68873 06531 31495 19393 53323 76670 43833 89702 79414 14
985 47087 91201 67685 23083 34079 59435 93613 65031 74510 99569 38062 53813 2784
8 32837 11357 18066 28977 28537 76161 58755 52129 33318 96631 93597 63893 55522
69557 39259 91552 91856 91904 65743 03115 13712 26543 59708 35803 62825 10193 63
195 60105 89094 56685 94869 51674 61005 65746 76704 93591 95670 19406 49743 9433
0 25684 51175 17954 83608 62484 92927 48829 82655 63787 73678 08050 29991 08081
52519 29144 26297 83423 87668 03551 14601 22987 23126 27277 75106 94336 95044 46
195 23754 00439 44861 36004 09775 42832 54250 03995 35561 20412 95500 22578 5549
2 99617 62550 56797 15721 05818 73255 82144 82319 02740 39131 56250 69218 22294
60697 59552 52278 25161 33409 29319 60055 34285 68632 85514 12219 24083 80486 30
270 22607 44820 44739 73047 17932 89425 35484 28886 54281 50281 71923 18050 2806
0 06354 30753 35912 19546 17321 19072 79582 67731 68391 87696 24129 51789 60877
76672 86824 41730 87685 90166 09318 95812 50562 37098 80817 26067 24950 29169 35
493 57416 92469 94981 72530 86806 48215 49108 84744 75437 52487 29310 94591 5485
6 25913 46503 14883 19089 35709 13964 92931 73314 47561 80733 58164 03342 54915
89040 24897 04031 62553 33731 43962 82888 35454 96672 35290 13038 20196 81906 83
540 30603 74861 21389 44000 92571 35676 32170 83985 14185 08661 53821 23840 5372
9 26633 73500 57690 15533 77096 69020 69637 99956 99805 35087 40874 37727 44240
78842 21271 36558 87107 23207 42532 56295 56534 05568 25902 38300 95091 43301 05
372 87880 85390 78999 13975 06271 94709 97603 99867 65778 19416 60597 29905 3975
0 01511 23060 74067 65718 28594 74180 96884 64208 17604 39615 90786 30725 45524
01366 35164 72804 90784 44573 37809 99147 43584 07110 63955 78464 45592 21332 20
762 87722 41836 29112 50592 72273 57402 95929 03568 76937 15420 74107 47997 2293
7 45468 94557 48574 09840 07156 75896 21389 79541 42559 82201 75376 90924 42885
54140 50531 65185 55158 01556 34915 55056 95634 60737 31284 33298 00124 44906 37
834 98733 25309 72075 73251 35375 67236 25391 95904 95459 04999 24101 25212 0290
7 59084 42808 70988 50256 28207 12732 75359 64512 92869 03205 77074 01025 63563
14434 40536 41457 78506 96493 87635 97286 19205 34407 79534 94369 95297 50309 62
392 73010 49457 65982 87907 33867 93399 20665 71284 58091 12814 44842 42211 6802
5 47445 86950 28277 62682 00440 85901 58444 35970 32982 56668 93551 05581 24773
92088 68102 99003 98879 15194 47017 22629 79242 83648 31646 25240 09435 05969 88
121 16707 16678 41106 31003 40974 10076 36447 52720 35694 07095 00829 06924 5798
3 62870 76969 28871 75221 66843 07166 55392 44635 94943 68410 89659 70256 86604
06411 43747 07818 59679 67926 41691 47867 68359 14801 57904 16672 65904 29503 89
681 96381 79020 86768 70636 07818 20648 21558 57013 62632 33469 65667 48055 5120
6 96314 14553 85473 99254 18196 91308 93872 29342 66645 61037 46547 86524 42312
30056 22744 23685 21037 71349 28090 92575 05339 63307 21871 77269 51295 20480 41
472 24855 79094 76022 02223 98564 23600 73479 50390 67079 51015 70034 02058 5753
8 92485 45801 30643 21371 66565 81853 19496 85577 97064 90573 58407 65704 82936
04038 04162 04257 71083 36180 20473 70826 23962 91416 79394 66612 31332 95385 67
588 64030 67549 60635 29364 31775 59076 13224 05484 61093 29914 01333 99968 2170
9 95985 03794 42932 70411 68976 28945 71841 8

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

whore cunt nigger cumdumpster faggot nigger nigger ballsack homosexual cunt jew
nigger cumdumpster faggot cumdumpster fist jew cock fist cumdumpster cock whore
fist cumdumpster homosexual nigger fist anus cunt faggot cock cumdumpster whore
whore cunt ballsack whore balls cock ballsack cunt cock faggot fist homosexual h
omosexual cunt cock cock whore

01846 97545 45449 20639 12051 04866 48052 02566 97529 05922 52959 96749 14333 55
987 95201 24090 03077 75041 34902 43711 30083 99783 87998 88142 69062 00162 6832
7 24555 32078 41015 78313 79902 93507 97298 16551 83994 73407 02091 11502 92748
15736 06831 80611 87308 44852 65542 71201 05612 76871 21540 05388 85803 60141 73
813 19448 32086 49977 60180 02074 94513 52545 00734 05749 38904 97820 74738 1125
7 71446 24490 51235 16114 54885 60576 90070 22326 59266 23103 95407 09902 07222
06914 26360 65934 53762 49085 56602 84836 05412 30250 94765 58829 61140 83282 62
594 11261 19284 49024 52077 82419 07116 70137 15154 14832 09270 21437 79777 4740
7 79507 54349 21668 48602 64532 16690 94627 39666 80718 46153 24294 91279 07801
80730 51433 20360 37145 88261 55321 87216 11199 71367 02050 96021 60422 79282 44
312 74118 56450 15191 89048 98885 90782 26377 33171 08041 24590 42727 01768 6608
1 47625 26372 67542 53202 74587 47676 95348 75488 92874 17808 68459 44990 35682
66050 90637 85630 79000 44390 88492 40234 97931 49510 14941 44729 79528 05358 85
919 87006 78327 34188 85409 81809 22918 95533 27409 66088 33517 65452 62067 7165
9 54077 12925 33149 70042 84823 81651 73780 63734 68007 64923 04196 06517 08655
86256 34608 75495 04217 24165 82171 66494 76567 82285 10941 60968 01316 44810 40
994 28040 28262 98750 20069 49217 68795 67728 50425 17160 33736 05320 80420 6260
7 46957 97633 69979 54362 42382 46784 30989 23453 76035 21191 00477 86233 15148
78327 50449 81861 83398 18667 13714 88263 69916 13755 49519 22650 62584 11942 03
085 95768 56235 65431 77504 78149 17952 21450 13364 31950 08024 86765 83544 0724
9 23013 72991 44018 53722 64584 51221 91794 62360 79171 10191 26287 47161 83443
16433 39588 09778 25568 97012 88623 54685 86776 55235 24206 46540 67638 13619 67
714 01380 98416 56286 43437 83741 36905 24680 29445 05331 67413 76007 45206 9775
5 53410 51228 39961 07899 25277 52563 19922 60453 04665 10853 06756 69075 43935
13978 37342 63019 29203 05373 03654 08682 31082 08900 07525 63884 81485 07410 45
221 78456 79702 30887 84755 13678 83360 97687 49313 56760 75154 90228 71145 1508
7 41052 54663 39098 64621 15499 36308 25973 70602 29058 45954 67705 59370 03530
74848 66283 88210 58991 19371 59767 27503 82024 17414 03560 37503 76821 40742 89
319 63407 18363 85694 77174 16120 07661 07214 18582 58754 96248 85255 59311 5213
6 10679 06155 29754 48028 44318 14603 59112 43249 80409 84684 67175 20515 61973
14033 97476 63840 27763 89432 61476 19854 58242 28748 90231 49315 15365 19420 95
819 00233 83499 12093 28341 34533 52172 61856 42275 21519 34044 26966 85089 0357
8 77871 95828 16103 74329 09686 64186 53514 57935 22548 53023 79800 20852 21797
33580 17870 01183 45097 67740 49842 93582 45433 89640 99497 63711 80007 88705 81
917 82228 00191 99244 61707 92328 58936 84075 53887 50874 25325 13858 04128 2062
0 84278 28577 69298 09677 56244 35173 82806 12989 76342 78296 37295 76898 67404
12623 18285 88832 97540 04302 81199 15928 16170 81888 65070 71263 41829 12275 97
069 81145 76609 37095 66921 86944 94059 92807 47250 99911 99548 51955 01351 3898
3 55312 38311 77324 46056 00050 39561 09458 91151 03534 91463 83936 29713 71244
11521 45191 11922 98845 64777 69378 99959 74603 78026 42705 90113 62044 55395 52
032 38340 76748 93170 31016 62935 68669 54809 72524 38641 11656 95107 54335 6091
5 11961 22808 80698 66415 49626 43184 85128 16708 68559 28926 34880 05995 44127
18522 30915 73299 21153 40657 50950 48052 16979 53502 32795 37685 90212 97166 38
932 19815 14634 18697 09062 49539 13982 94603 16467 71637 02814 50850 47085 0960
0 29810 50813 21503 10928 73660 30089 136

begin sequence

[Anonymous Coward]

ballsack homosexual cock nigger whore cock anus faggot whore cock jew cumdumpste
r balls homosexual balls faggot faggot nigger homosexual ballsack cock homosexua
l anus faggot cumdumpster ballsack fist anus homosexual fist ballsack whore fagg
ot nigger jew jew cumdumpster homosexual faggot ballsack faggot nigger cumdumpst
er balls nigger cumdumpster jew nigger cock jew

87261 06895 17304 04222 46362 14677 09632 88020 57633 36744 53353 63661 74816 66
084 85235 89678 88083 42105 06547 74466 31250 65016 85355 58307 45017 40978 8860
7 66299 54513 25349 30962 21266 73701 14201 18034 41462 02215 93374 89386 86033
63114 59507 67907 10381 71560 04281 33607 27832 42990 08076 62677 11362 36483 47
907 61272 16546 60667 15917 46752 92447 69640 04629 37842 50404 61951 80976 5891
4 17954 55378 59478 91171 52402 47548 91853 16999 39087 42792 81670 12354 47416
26273 94158 31122 59941 03498 90292 96569 85328 28631 70753 70439 54873 43251 47
658 81062 46595 03675 98785 42237 66457 87924 19575 35302 42486 39137 35693 7764
4 53777 11556 33332 16070 64192 20193 39305 35776 03715 59942 48084 24931 70199
62379 61767 02909 51965 38311 95701 92745 93672 98807 84014 43478 24785 79242 79
409 45082 97527 93374 85549 01427 23053 46924 22922 40910 17565 77697 88241 0475
1 56659 88020 32777 85838 40599 34180 00250 13999 20621 97566 68894 24383 33542
13725 72478 35006 84368 75012 43970 26891 05533 16213 87623 98725 47861 99230 04
408 03349 48435 44532 90730 33908 94087 21427 96262 48371 93013 86913 59054 8793
4 09078 59187 58635 11967 46128 25198 25197 83363 82963 89541 76785 78915 17083
72496 31325 28632 07492 96158 71814 60428 84009 03133 45525 04162 10857 27137 39
942 77907 01794 22710 52532 89765 80807 84326 86686 25374 69291 41168 98487 2430
4 76505 18458 13198 51949 05380 75571 55597 70271 38164 34184 22962 98381 43282
29697 19202 39505 10893 43806 52397 80643 34116 01524 69945 23133 58759 55555 66
291 51324 41368 80864 33699 32452 08292 45444 07133 72086 12870 56372 79047 1677
9 59543 21163 44511 58689 79018 58501 00779 94368 23656 54138 99210 30243 71620
36788 56278 69261 86319 80802 88852 01171 86503 90700 67694 86036 61224 40433 45
365 84848 25883 86146 22052 64573 45906 19679 16035 27682 30199 73374 06233 0913
5 57471 56673 94165 17026 15544 70615 41562 09989 14344 37836 02483 95901 82747
17216 37563 72757 21040 47564 31373 69658 92056 97899 58957 14579 20208 62430 80
715 60676 61658 05349 78023 76720 95501 56981 31411 19244 66223 74777 02882 2131
9 01644 37508 55059 99994 56024 09661 74421 19320 92172 26560 94295 40057 14848
10321 24057 33462 95416 03817 46700 90156 17106 81054 36117 83953 26282 76631 61
347 63056 27124 85698 93767 72895 11788 00886 65972 80125 19202 11637 01757 6843
0 45522 86522 99075 69303 16158 81609 07128 13833 10972 11626 14543 30736 21503
72654 70613 54084 09041 81303 58765 55088 90013 78198 21494 89667 79019 88907 75
723 03338 81356 82169 49967 06948 46630 50004 26921 77250 80103 81856 33414 8485
8 27314 21796 88274 39949 23149 50636 27074 40278 70814 52870 84955 16053 78989
41033 78573 76038 36120 97406 50880 96120 95084 64317 08464 62569 34887 55279 55
111 12293 66795 41510 51706 81634 24234 20242 39421 25513 81749 78954 95069 5240
4 33315 67410 45600 06069 16840 95630 62517 27120 47864 56844 93614 29015 09876
06139 53382 61178 54846 90777 19204 20578 78584 50101 87168 35317 38630 82103 31
992 54779 45727 70769 37250 68090 07907 07308 19294 51357 39257 21531 01416 6144
4 28679 38070 33060 39671 50628 91311 01451 98425 29900 86609 62126 06989 04911
65722 93886 14878 57270 33786 47332 12259 67255 46857 18569 03631 47851 90400 14
219 94122 36424 01326 14942 83199 73181 84972 12112 93039 68062 33867 33852 3863
1 19277 57133 39923 95974 40578 83553 78394 19166 77219 06599 31516 25296 36559
44562 55697 69132 44297 78284 00746 08510 65562 24749 96721 51619 15537 38638 46
798 53828 30859 48384 51578 12297 81269 25081 99018 40698 06461 86125 56467 8730
5 59493 44464 15932 7

Not a problem with Ubuntu Phone

[suy]

I doubt Aaron has many complaints with the technology used in Ubuntu Phone, because that's Qt Quick using QML, the same is used in Plasma. The thing is, Plasma was conceived as a very flexible way to create the primary user interface (that is, the visible thing that is not the applications). At that time, that was the "desktop shell" (Plasma Desktop), and nowadays is also a touch-device user interface and others (Plasma Active, Plasma Media Center, etc.).

The vision the KDE guys had was right, and with few resources have created a great framework. Instead, Canonical had to write Unity several times. The "normal" Unity I don't even remember in what's written (GTK+, Clutter, Nux... can't follow it), but I remember that there is the Qt-based Unity-2D (dead, AFAIK) and the new Ubuntu Phone version, which uses Qt again.

They could have saved tons of resources by choosing the technology and sticking a bit to it, helping to develop it. And now they claim they provide a seamless user experience across devices. Well, that could be true, but not using the same technologies, so the user experience is not going to be consistent with different bugs, different features, because the code bases are totally different.

Re:Not a problem with Ubuntu Phone

[Anonymous Coward]

Why do developers seem to pick technologies based on that they ARE NOT what the other guy uses, rather than what benefits they provide? This seems to be the hallmark of the GTK-ish community.

Re:Not a problem with Ubuntu Phone

[Noughmad]

But QML _is_ what the other guy is using. It is not, however, what Canonical is already using, which was Aaron's entire point. In this case, Canonical is definitely moving in the right direction. Now, if
  - Canonical starts using QML with the same components (same API) it for Unity apps
  - Ubuntu Phone and Plasma use the same QML components
free software on mobiles should have a bright future. Even as a third option, like on desktops, it should be great.

Re:Not a problem with Ubuntu Phone

[rdnetto]

Why do developers seem to pick technologies based on that they ARE NOT what the other guy uses, rather than what benefits they provide? This seems to be the hallmark of the GTK-ish community.

The GTK community was created around that very notion. KDE pre-dated GTK, but used the Qt framework which at the time was published under the controversial QPL (it wasn't until 2000 that Qt was published under the GPL). GTK arose partly as a response to this, and since KDE used C++, using C mitigated the risk of the two projects competing for developers.

The more two competing open source projects use the same technologies, the less distinct their identities. Whether this is a good thing or not depends on how much diversity you prefer.

Re:Not a problem with Ubuntu Phone

[Anonymous Coward]

Gnome used C because there was and is a large group of people who hate C++ and think C a superior language to develop in. It wasn't anything to do with avoiding competition for developers.

Re:Not a problem with Ubuntu Phone

[rdnetto]

Gnome used C because there was and is a large group of people who hate C++ and think C a superior language to develop in. It wasn't anything to do with avoiding competition for developers.

I never said that they made the decision for that reason; simply that that was the reason it happened. If KDE had used C, it's likely that many of the people drawn to Gnome during its formation would have been those who preferred C++.

His actual post

[Noughmad]

on Google+: https://plus.google.com/u/0/107555540696571114069/posts/HSL2C21DJt7

fu

[Anonymous Coward]

Fuck Canonical

apt-get

[duckgod]

IF Canonical does this right. That is a big IF. We will have the same advantages of the linux desktop on our phones. That is the ability to install any window manager you want. No one corporation will have the power to decide what my work environment will be like. So if you don't like it what Unity is, it is 5ish magic words to get something else installed. Please I beg you Canonical just let me type "sudo apt-get install kubuntu-desktop".

Re:apt-get

[uM0p ap!sdn]

su password

apt-get remove --purge ubuntu-forever

apt-get install debian

There, fixed that for you

Re:apt-get

[Anonymous Coward]

Few years ago Mark Shuttleworth has thought it better to rewrite GNOME using Qt toolkit.

http://tech.slashdot.org/story/08/07/14/1245204/shuttleworth-sees-possibility-for-a-qt-based-gnome

Re:apt-get

[Anonymous Coward]

There, fixed that for you

sudo su

apt-get remove --purge debian-fossil ubuntu-unity
apt-get install ubuntu-forever gnome-shell

You had a few typos there.

Re:apt-get

[Anonymous Coward]

Kind of like Android?

Re:apt-get

[Anonymous Coward]

What the hell does "sudo su" do? You've obviously never used Ubuntu, because if you have, you'd know the right command to enter an interactive root shell is:

sudo -i

Re:apt-get

[Anonymous Coward]

sudo su - works just fine, thanks. It also flows easier; typing left-to-right segments is more comfortable than the right-to-left required by "-i".

Re:apt-get

[Anonymous Coward]

Is it really that obvious that I do not run Ubuntu on my primary workstation, we also use UNIX heavily in our education environment.

Perhaps you should man sudo sometime, or try the command first before making an anonymous fool of yourself, but I guess that wouldn't occurred to you with that flippant know it all attitude you're touting, seriously won't get you anywhere.

              Please note that sudo will normally only log the command it explicitly
              runs. If a user runs a command such as sudo su or sudo sh, subsequent
              commands run from that shell are not subject to sudo's security policy.
              The same is true for commands that offer shell escapes (including most
              editors). If I/O logging is enabled, subsequent commands will have
              their input and/or output logged, but there will not be traditional
              logs for those commands. Because of this, care must be taken when
              giving users access to commands via sudo to verify that the command
              does not inadvertently give the user an effective root shell. For more
              information, please see the PREVENTING SHELL ESCAPES section in
              sudoers(5).

Gnome-Shell is a much faster to use than Unity in my experience, the 3D transitions are chuggy on this machine and the laggy interface affects my flow. Additionally I have a 24" iMac to the left of my two Ubuntu monitors and running Synergy to give me access to the iMac by sharing my keyboard and mouse over the network. With the Unity menu, this was causing the menu to appear. And waiting for it to detect when I cursor up to the top corner was annoying when I adjusted this setting in the Unity UI options.

I do really appreciate the Alt menu search in Unity, would be great to see that in Gnome-shell, but other than that, Gnome-shell suits my productivity

Debian is great for servers. If you expect the latest developments to be available and become accustomed to these, then for a workstation environment I find the slow releases frustrating and I don't have time to build and debug something with the workload that I have. /end rant

Don't be a cock.

Pearls from the post

[suy]

Some pearls from the original conversation. Alan Pope:

We're agile enough that we can migrate our desktop to QML if that's the decision that gets made. Unity has existed on four toolkits already, what's a fifth between friends ;)

Daniel Stone on wether Ubuntu Phone uses Wayland or not:

No idea, no-one from the project will respond even to direct questions. They've said in the past that they're writing their own window system, which is pretty tragicomic.

And the best one, the only thing that Mark Shuttleworth had to say:

As Kipling put it:

If you can bear to hear the truth you've spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools

The rest of the poem is pretty apt, too. My kingdom for a link.
Mark

I wish success to Ubuntu Phone, really, but it hurts me a little bit that it receives the same or more attention from the community than Plasma Active, when the later delivered the same or more (specially if you value open governance and source code from day 1), with way less resources.

Re:Pearls from the post

[Kjella]

We're agile enough that we can migrate our desktop to QML if that's the decision that gets made. Unity has existed on four toolkits already, what's a fifth between friends ;)

I can't really make up my mind if this says the most about OSS or being "agile", but I think a facepalm is in order...

Something must be said...

[Anonymous Coward]

C-C-COMBO BREAKER!

Pot and kettle

[Dcnjoe60]

There is almost no correlation between this story headline and the actual content Aaron wrote. Among other things Aaron wrote:

I want to make it crystal clear that I think Ubuntu Phone a great thing to see; more Free software mobile efforts, particularly ones using Qt/QML, warm my insides like a good bowl of soup on a cold winter's night

So then the question becomes "Why is this false story being posted on slashdot?" Is it that the OP wants to slander KDE or Ubuntu or maybe slashdot itself? We all regularly complain about mainstream media and yellow journalism, so how come slashdot isn't doing something about this story?

Re:Pot and kettle

[Anonymous Coward]

And if Slashdot (and DICE) won't do something about this story, why aren't its readers doing the open source thing and "forking" Slashdot to something better. Make a new website, just like Slashdot, except with responsible editors (or any editors, for that matter).

Re:Pot and kettle

[BrokenHalo]

So then the question becomes "Why is this false story being posted on slashdot?"

Well, if you took the trouble to do such an unorthodox thing as reading the article, you might find out. Try it, it's only a few paragraphs.

Re:Pot and kettle

[Dcnjoe60]

So then the question becomes "Why is this false story being posted on slashdot?"

Well, if you took the trouble to do such an unorthodox thing as reading the article, you might find out. Try it, it's only a few paragraphs.

I did read it and that is why it begs the question. What is slashdot's motiviation in promoting this particular controversy?

Too slow anyway

[jones_supa]

We can start with the obvious clue: Unity currently does not use QML at all; Ubuntu Phone is pure QML.

I knew they wouldn't put Unity in the phone. It's just too slow. Even on the PC it takes almost a second to open the Dash or Alt-Tab between applications.

Thanks

[Anonymous Coward]

"We can start with the obvious clue: Unity currently does not use QML at all; Ubuntu Phone is pure QML. So, no, it is not the same code, it is not the sort of seamless cross-device technology bridge that they are purporting."

I hear what he's saying, but Ubuntu cross-platform seamless operation isn't really about what's going on underneath. Canonical know full well that we're entering into an age of dumbed-down users. It's not about smartphones, it's about dumbed down computers/PC's. One flavor of Linux had to dirty itself to go down this mucky highway. .and it was Ubuntu

Yes, things have changed. Stallman and his high horse are still back in the Unicorn land with HERD which is now leaving heaven to grace earth somewhat.. and we need him too. We need a pure reference in case the Earth does some day make a u-turn and we know how to get back to the origin

Then in the middle we have KDE, Gnome, Mint, Muffin, Cinnamon etc.

The true way for our society..as it is now.

But Ubuntu is more like the battleship - the one that has go in and work with these creatures that are pushing a centralized Borg-like server grid on us, with wire-tapped "smart" phones.

I still say Ubuntu will do a hell of a lot better across the board, including cross the range of devices, than any other offering out there including the jailed Linux that is Android..

Small steps guys and remember, Ubuntup on the phone won't even have a true Linux kernel, it's going to be an Android kernel.
KDE on the phone would still need the android kernel for now and they wouldn't be too happy about that you can be sure.

I've said this time and time again. Linux is not taking the lead anywhere. It's not pushing new types of interfaces, capability or user experience. We have our holier than thou / zen or source of things with GNU, but we're not getting our hands dirty with the new ways Linux on the warrantless-tracking mobile devices. Essentially we're in the matrix with no reliable way to dial out, unless you accept jailbroken iphones.. probably about the only good thing going in the mobile world really.

Well !

[Anonymous Coward]

Tisk tisk. An Ubuntu Phone is now years too late.

Perhaps Canonical should focus their attention of Ubuntu Glasses or Ubuntu Watches ... ah ha ... Google has the Glasses and Apple has the Watches. What next ?

Ah Ha ! Ball Point Pen ! How can Canonical get Ubuntu into a 'Ball Point Pen' ? ! And do more than a 'Ball Point Pen' !

Oh Yeah ! This IS a REAL engineering project. Uh ... Cough ... Cough. ... If Canonical WONT or CAN"T do the nasty ... I know some one who ... has ! Wink ... wink .... nudge ... nudge. :-0

Ahem... KDE4

[Anonymous Coward]

He let KDE4 exists and still dares to talk?!?