Google Glass Will Identify People By Clothing
recoiledsnake writes "This article notes, 'A new technology built into Google Glass, dug up by New Scientist, takes Google Glass from interesting to down right creepy. Google Glass can now pick a person out of crowd based on their fashion style. The system, InSight, developed in partnership with Google, will take a nice little moment to assess the clothing in frame, and then point out exactly where your friends are in busy settings like a bar, concert, or sporting event. It could probably point you out in a protest, or shopping mall too.' We previously discussed the disorienting effects on the wearer of the device."
Lets face it, very soon everyone is going to know where everyone else is all the time. Unless you wear some sort of Scanner Darkly blur suit.
The Moore-Murphy Law: The number of things that will go wrong will double every 2 years.
first foursquare told me where all my friends are
now google tells me who my friends are and i don't have to look at their face
If it can't detect facecrime, I'm just not interested.
I'll just remain naked.
Captcha: anchovy
i don't have to look at their faces when i see them
It pop up with a box surrounding someone with the label "douchebag"
Or they're all wearing the same clothes?
On the one hand that's great, especially if there's someone in the crowd you'd rather avoid. On the other hand (and in a more serious light), this is just horrible for privacy.
I frankly hope Google Glasses will not be a hit. There are so many possible negative sides to it, just such as certain distractions (driving, talking to people) and how will your sight "adjust" (in a bad way) over time.
Personally I would not get some.
What if I have no fashion style?
This is a great read: http://creativegood.com/blog/the-google-glass-feature-no-one-is-talking-about/
From the article:
So then the moment you DON'T want it to pick you out, you just change clothes. Why yes, that IS my protest suit, thank you very much.
Support the EFF and Creative Commons. The war is coming, and they're supporting you...
...when the malware hits these things.
Warning: this article may contain humor, sarcasm, parody, and perhaps even irony. Read at your own risk.
I thought that the proportion between eyes and all that type of stuff was more pretty accurate. Also faces don't tend to change in a short period of time. Note that I'm not against two or more different methods being used to identify someone.
I've seen a bit of mention of this, but not much.
Anyone remember a furor not too long ago about assorted "creepershot" forums on Reddit? Google Glass will make creepershots trivial - at least now it's (generally) obvious if you're following people around photographing them.
fencepost
just a little off
"The system, InSight, developed in partnership with Google, will take a nice little moment to assess the clothing in frame, and then point out exactly where your friends are in busy settings like a bar, concert, or sporting event.
Really? At a concert or sporting event? So, based solely on clothing, exactly how is this magic software supposed to distinguish between me and the ten thousand other people who are wearing the exact same band t-shirt or team jersey?
So do they think that real life is like cartoons, where people usually wear the same outfit every day?
-- This and all my posts are in the public domain. I am a lawyer. I am not your lawyer, and this is not legal advice.
As long as people are either metallers or candy ravers.
I have a doubt or two about the efficacy of this technology.
Forget about identifying Ferengi women, they're not allowed to wear clothing.
So, now everything I go to the street I'll have to face people laughting at me because they'll see onto their glasses:
"Cloth: naff"
F**k you Google!
Do not track option for clothing. Coming soon
So Google Glass has prosopagnosia? As a sufferer of this, that is one of the main ways I can find people in a crowd. If I can do so at all... :(
Oh fuck there he is.
This is very useful to me; I often have trouble picking my wife out of a crowd. Mom, who has prosopagnosia (unable to identify faces) will also appreciate it. This kind of task, supplementing human failings, is exactly what we need. Many people don't need it; I'm sure most people will be as good or better than Glass at seeing friends in a crowd. But for those of us who are not? Useful!
I don't need a calculator to figure out which package of rice is the best-per-pound at the supermarket (when it is not labeled clearly), while my wife does. Should I say calculators are useless or stupid, just because I don't need them for that use case?
"I will trust Google to 'do no evil' until the founders no longer run it." Hello Alphabet.
The article explains that the application works like this: you have to start off by IDing your friend to it. It then analyzes the clothing they're wearing and their dimensions. When you want to look for them, it scans for a match, and picks out the person (or what could potentially be the person) for you.
The article goes on to mention a couple of reasons that they chose to do it this way: one is to protect privacy! By not using facial recognition, they make sure that the app can't easily be pre-loaded with a database of people and look for them all the time. For another, humans are already good at facial recognition. If you can see your friend's face, there's a good chance that you'll recognize them. This, however, helps when you're scanning the crowd and their back might be to you.
Honestly, it sounds like a good idea to me. Sure, it's going to have problems if you're surrounded by identically-dressed people, but you're not left any worse off by that than you were without it. Since it uses their bodily dimensions as well, it may still be of some use. And I know from times that I've been shopping with my wife and was looking for her that I, personally, have a horrible memory for what people are wearing. If I see her face, sure, I'll recognize her - but I often find myself remembering not the outfit she was wearing today, but the one she was wearing yesterday, or the one she was wearing when I met her for lunch.....
...It's technology that Google has had a hand in funding. The Project Glass connection is because the researchers used Project Glass as an example in their paper. Google may be able to use the technology, but it has not been included in the Glass software.
Google Funds Fashion Recognition Research
http://www.informationweek.com/security/privacy/google-funds-fashion-recognition-researc/240150399
an excuse to dust off that tank top made solely out of malicious QR codes and porn links.
Good people go to bed earlier.
That was sarcasm right?
We're just getting more reliant and stupider.
Take this sig and smoke it.
I'm sure I'll stand right out in public wearing my usual jeans, t-shirts, and Aeropostale hoodies. I mean, no one wears that stuff.
re: you have to start off by IDing your friend to it.
.
Ha. I misread your "IDing" as "iDing" ( or more clearly: "I-D-ing" as "i-Ding" ) as if it were a new electronic interactive way to ping or ding somebody. That would really be a cool new thing to trademark and create: iDing which pings and dings someone in real life, and if they're physically close enough to you IRL then you can hear the little submarine "ping" come out of their cell phone! Quick, Robin, off to the App-Mobile (TM, moi) to write this app!!!
Actually, this is not quite as far fetched as it sounds.
I have partial facial blindness, and over the years I have gotten better at identifying people based off their cloths and hair style. Even when people do not intend it, many people stick to certain colour types and cuts, and it is not unusual to pick people out based off those patterns, or be really confused when they do something out of character. I have never really been sure _what_ the patterns are, but something in the back of my brain has built up some rules that work better then pure chance.
"You wouldn't punch a guy with glasses on would you?"
I can't wait to earn free money by wearing by my Google Glass. Collect bounties just by having them turned on. If someone with a warrent is spotted the app will send your location and a photo to the goverment. The app splits the reward with you 50/50. I am sure there will also be an auto census application that gives you money. Turn it on and the application counts the number of people in your location, includes stats on gender and wealth. Free money.
Declare entire America a nudist colony ;-)
sed -e 's/Chuck Norris/Rajnikant/g' joke > fact
The creepy part of p
To me this sounds like the easiest way out. Just look for blobs of red or blue stripes rather than trying to match a face would be much easier to implement.
For people with Prosopagnosia (the inability to identify faces) this bit of technology will be a boon.
What if I have no fashion style?
Then google will target you with ads from vendors offering clothes with no style.
It's not going to work on me. I don't have any fashion style.
It may not work for your friend hoping to recognize you in the crowd but it still works for google and their delivery of targeted ads to you. Unless you are wearing homespun somebody is selling what you are wearing, fashionable of not.
I've been wearing the same 9 shirts for 2 years at my work and a recent survey has revealed only the women noticed :P
and white sneakers?
But on a serious note, I'm really curious about the output for people with similar clothes. Specially if you work in Japan, with all these salaryman in black suits or in any hospital with all doctors and nurses using nearly the same outfit(or any workplace that requires an uniform). Artists and celebrities may do their best to use different outfits in front of the cameras, but in the real world there is quite a significant overlap of clothing even between different people.
What exactly isn't downright creepy in those Google Glasses?
This is the real reason for those jumpsuits common in depictions of the future.
If everyone looks the same they won't be as easily tracked.
I'm thinking about getting one myself. But wearing it continuously?
Taking out your smartphone in a restaurant while you are in company is bad style. Taking out your smartphone while in restaurant to photograph your food is bad style.
Walking around with those glasses is akin to a tourist walking around with their Canon fuck-off photobrick dangling from their neck. Annoying but non-threatening.
We already have a functioning etiquette for stuff like this. Let's just stick to it.
That could be one of the first apps for that thing. Process what you see and tell you to take it off!
Public lavatory.Wang spotted. PLEASE PUT ME AWAY! I DON'T WANT TO SEE EITHER YOUR GENITALS OR THE GUY'S NEXT TO YOU!
Or the passive-aggressive variant: His is a little bit less crooked and considerably bigger than yours, you know?
Is that your face? Lucky I live on your nose and don't have to see it all the time.
Or how about its mother-mode:
You know you should really wash those dishes.
I've counted the beers you already had and you may have a bit of a problem
Watching sports again? There is a nice programme about knitting on the other channel.
The girl next door is really nice and has always clean laundry.
You should eat more salad. Urine is only supposed to look that way when you are Mr Spock.
I might do just that...
20 minutes into the future
So what is my choice regarding someone wearing these glasses around me, and I don't want to be recorded by them in any way, other than walking away from this person.
Start talking about REALLY bad stuff? Like trying to convince them not to place a bomb at some building near us, or to stop looking at underage porn before he/she gets really in to trouble, etc.
So will it still identify that person if they wore a bandana all the time, but wore nothing but that bandana in the privacy of a home? Hmm., it's experiment time!!
Sometimes I choose whatever I want to wear to go out, and according to my wife my tastes in clothes are horrible, so whenever she has the chance she will make me go out in clothing of her choosing. Does that mean that this device would think I am two different people?