Slashdot Mirror


Astronaut Chris Hadfield Performs Space Oddity On the ISS

An anonymous reader writes "With updated lyrics, commander of expedition 35 on the International Space Station, Chris Hadfield, sings Space Oddity on board the ISS. He's not Bowie, but he's pretty good."

60 of 212 comments (clear)

  1. Mission Accomplished by earlzdotnet · · Score: 5, Insightful

    That is all.

    1. Re:Mission Accomplished by DavidClarkeHR · · Score: 5, Insightful

      He's not Bowie, but he's pretty good.

      And, you know, he's actually in space.

      --
      - Nec Impar Pluribus, or so I'm told.
    2. Re:Mission Accomplished by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Funny

      He's not Bowie, but he's pretty good.

      And, you know, he's actually in space.

      And Bowie wasn't?

    3. Re:Mission Accomplished by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

      Nicely edited and well produced preproduction--obviously with sound in particular; this communist disregard for copyright law has been reported to DMCA Takedown.

    4. Re:Mission Accomplished by reovirus1 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      DMCA only applies to Earth and one small part on it.

    5. Re:Mission Accomplished by Joce640k · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I was expecting to hate it but I actually enjoyed it.

      --
      No sig today...
    6. Re:Mission Accomplished by PopeRatzo · · Score: 4, Funny

      DMCA only applies to Earth and one small part on it.

      For now.

      --
      You are welcome on my lawn.
    7. Re:Mission Accomplished by Creepy · · Score: 2

      That and the 6 string guitar. Space Oddity is a quintessential 12 string song... and for a segue, Brian May also played 12 string on several songs ('39 and A Night At the Opera come to mind) and he played with Freddy Mercury in Queen.

    8. Re:Mission Accomplished by JWSmythe · · Score: 2

          The only thing is, he may have already had the 6 string there. Sending up a 12 string to make it "correct" is a really expensive venture.

      --
      Serious? Seriousness is well above my pay grade.
    9. Re:Mission Accomplished by dkleinsc · · Score: 2

      Brian May also played 12 string on several songs ('39 and A Night At the Opera come to mind) and he played with Freddy Mercury in Queen.

      He also is one of the few people with a known and defined Erdos-Bacon-Sabbath Number: He's co-authored astrophysics papers that can trace back to Paul Erdos to get an Erdos Number of 7, is 3 steps away from Kevin Bacon on IMDB, and unsurprisingly has performed with Black Sabbath.

      --
      I am officially gone from /. Long live http://www.soylentnews.com/
  2. Ashes to Ashes by Bing+Tsher+E · · Score: 4, Informative

    That seems like such a weird song to sing up there sitting in a tin can.

    Bowie sorta updated the matter on Scary Monsters anyway.

    ashes to ashes funk to funky
    we know major tom's a junky
    strung out on heaven's high
    hitting an all time low

  3. Lens Flare by yincrash · · Score: 5, Funny

    Who knew that having that many lens flares was true to life?!

    1. Re:Lens Flare by sconeu · · Score: 5, Funny

      JJ Abrams?

      --
      General Relativity: Space-time tells matter where to go; Matter tells space-time what shape to be.
    2. Re:Lens Flare by PopeRatzo · · Score: 4, Funny

      Who knew that having that many lens flares was true to life?!

      Every video gamer.

      I've got retinal damage from all the flare in current games.

      --
      You are welcome on my lawn.
  4. Re:Viral Marketing by NASA by yincrash · · Score: 4, Informative

    Chris Hadfield is a Canadian (working for the CSA). I'm sure that Chris would like more people to want to go in to space and become scientists, etc. If you look at his previous videos though, I would say this is pretty in line with the other stuff he's done (just with more effort in to it).

  5. Um... by daveschroeder · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ...he's Canadian.

    And stop being so cynical. Sometimes stuff can be cool without being "viral marketing".

  6. Re:Viral Marketing by NASA by yincrash · · Score: 4, Informative

    Additionally, this is the person in the credits who edited it, also a Canadian, and doesn't work for any space agency. Let's try not to think everything is a conspiracy, please.

  7. Space oddity by Clived · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Attaboy Chris

    you sounded great, A Canadian space rock and roller.Hey, if you ever wanted to try your hand at karaoke .. we are at the Wally, Donlands and OConnor in Toronto.

    *grin* and have a safe trip back

    --
    Clive DaSilva Email: clive.dasilva@gmail.com Ubuntu 18.10 Kernel 4.18
  8. Even better - duet with Barenaked Ladies by SuperKendall · · Score: 3, Interesting

    That was pretty good, but I really liked his joint work with Barenaked Ladies (he sings there also, even though Ed Roberts does most of the vocals) in a nice tribute to the ISS...

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
  9. Hefty pricetag by Spazed · · Score: 4, Funny

    Most expensive music video ever.

    1. Re:Hefty pricetag by wonkey_monkey · · Score: 2

      Unless of couse its sarcasm, but you can never tell on the internet.

      Maybe you can't.

      --
      systemd is Roko's Basilisk.
  10. Re:If this is what we currently have on our task l by The+Bad+Astronomer · · Score: 4, Insightful

    "National pride"? He's Canadian, you know. Which nation do you mean? Do you also know they don't work 24 hours per day? And on their off time, ISS astronauts still breathe? Of course, he did use up a lot of electrons saving the files and transmitting them to Earth, so I'll make sure NASA or the CSA reimburses you per Coulomb.

    --
    *** Phil Plait, aka The Bad Astronomer http://www.badastronomy.com
  11. Re:Really? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    You are an idiot. The man is making space (geeky) real (taxpayers). Space is the future. Anyone with an actual personality is welcome up there. This is my new favorite astronaut. Neil Armstrong step aside. We need to get back. Did you see his other 50+ educational videos?

  12. Imagine How Disappointed Richard Branson Is.... by Petersko · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Bragging rights like "First Music Video in Space" don't come around every day!

  13. Re:Viral Marketing by NASA by DavidClarkeHR · · Score: 4, Funny

    Additionally, this is the person in the credits who edited it, also a Canadian, and doesn't work for any space agency. Let's try not to think everything is a conspiracy, please.

    The only conspiracy coming from up here (canada) is a push for more maple syrup for breakfast, and bacon in every meal. We're winning on one of those fronts.

    --
    - Nec Impar Pluribus, or so I'm told.
  14. Re:If this is what we currently have on our task l by hawguy · · Score: 4, Insightful

    ... then we need to shut down this thing NOW! We seriously have NOTHING BETTER TO DO WITH BILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF TREASURE than to record a music video? This is rediculous. Let's turn off the lights, lock the door on the way out and save that money for something more important. Don't give me this "national pride" or "scientific discover" B.S. If that stuff needs to get done, then F'ing do it and don't waste time singing in space. This is probably the most collossal waste of resources imaginable. How many resources were needed to scrub the air necessary for the singing? When you are in space, that stuff matters, A LOT! The first take wasn't the last take, that I know. Don't give me the "get kids into science" schtick either. Kids who are swayed by silly things like this, statistically don't end up any good at the math needed for real science anyway. I teach our "future engineers" in a top state university. Most can't even solve a triangle, let alone deal with any higher math. If you are swayed by this commercial, you don't have the chops to stick with an engineering career.

    Humans, even astronauts, need downtime - If you want a human to be effective, then you can't fill 100% of their waking time with work.

  15. Re:If this is what we currently have on our task l by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    > We seriously have NOTHING BETTER TO DO WITH BILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF TREASURE than to record a music video?

    Jesus dude, lighten up. If we took your activities performed at university over the course of 3 months, could we find anything that you did for 4 minutes that did not directly benefit the students you are teaching? Would it be fair to make a big spectacle and claim that we should lock the doors to your school and shut it down after giving it "millions of dollars worth of treasure" because you read an email from a loved one, or went to the bathroom, or ate lunch? Science is conducted by humans, and humans need to take a break from time to time. Just chill out already.

    > This is probably the most collossal waste of resources imaginable.
    Really? This is the most collossal waste of resources imaginable?

  16. Re:Viral Marketing by NASA by H0p313ss · · Score: 4, Funny

    Additionally, this is the person in the credits who edited it, also a Canadian, and doesn't work for any space agency. Let's try not to think everything is a conspiracy, please.

    The only conspiracy coming from up here (canada) is a push for more maple syrup for breakfast, and bacon in every meal. We're winning on one of those fronts.

    Let's not forget about operation Poutine.

    --
    XML is a known as a key material required to create SMD: Software of Mass Destruction
  17. Re:If this is what we currently have on our task l by sconeu · · Score: 3, Insightful

    On top of everything else, learn how to use a spellchecker. Your spelling of "ridiculous" is ridiculous.

    --
    General Relativity: Space-time tells matter where to go; Matter tells space-time what shape to be.
  18. Congrats by n3r0.m4dski11z · · Score: 4, Interesting

    This guy's near daily media appearances has certainly inspired many canadians including myself. I have watched many children sing along with his ISS song (not as good as david bowie, but its the thought that counts) and it really inspires. Hopefully helping lots of kids to think about becoming scientists, researchers and yes astronauts. Space can seem so dull sometimes, he really brings it to life.

    I may not care for much patriotically these days, but hes really doing canada a service being so media savvy. I am not sure if american astronauts do so much singing, and perhaps its covered extensively by their local media and I just never hear about it. But he really could be one of a kind.

    --
    -
    1. Re:Congrats by tlhIngan · · Score: 4, Informative

      This guy's near daily media appearances has certainly inspired many canadians including myself. I have watched many children sing along with his ISS song (not as good as david bowie, but its the thought that counts) and it really inspires. Hopefully helping lots of kids to think about becoming scientists, researchers and yes astronauts. Space can seem so dull sometimes, he really brings it to life.

      I may not care for much patriotically these days, but hes really doing canada a service being so media savvy. I am not sure if american astronauts do so much singing, and perhaps its covered extensively by their local media and I just never hear about it. But he really could be one of a kind.

      Before he launched in December, Chris mentioned he was going to do the first album recorded in space, I'm hoping this was just a taste of what's coming.

      I have to be honest, I've been watching a LOT of Chris' videos that get posted by the CSA (Canadian Space Agency) (an agency facing budget cuts from the Harper Government(tm)). I don't think I've seen anyone from the ISS do so much media relations in their off time.

      I know a few other commanders have done media work - Don Pettit did some as well. With the American Physical Society (any physics major should know them) he did a bunch of videos called "Science off the Sphere" (which I apparently finally got my T-Shirt from that).

      Chris is definitely very media friendly and has hosted a LOT Of media events while aboard - he even keeps in touch with Discovery Canada's Daily Planet, the longest running science program around. Honestly, Chris Hadfield is awesome!

      Safe journey home - your country eagerly awaits your arrival!

      (Alas, Canada's first astronaut was snubbed recently...)

    2. Re:Congrats by FireFury03 · · Score: 2

      I may not care for much patriotically these days, but hes really doing canada a service being so media savvy.

      He's doing the *world* a service. His regular youtube videos have been excellent; but more than that, his regular facebook posts really bring it home to you that this stuff is happening right now all the time. And he's not just followed by Canadians - no other astronaut from any nation has engaged with the public as much as he has. I'm hoping we see more of this from other astronauts.

    3. Re:Congrats by steelfood · · Score: 2

      I am not sure if american astronauts do so much singing, and perhaps its covered extensively by their local media's lawyers

      This is why we can't have nice things in the U.S.

      --
      "If a nation expects to be ignorant and free in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be."
  19. l'art pour l'art by gman003 · · Score: 2

    Does everything need to be about money? Can we not do things for the sake of doing them?

    Was that not the great driving force behind the space race? We may have done some science on the moon, but it was hardly worth the billions we spent. But it was worth it to go there, simply for the sake of going there.

    1. Re:l'art pour l'art by gman003 · · Score: 3, Informative

      You, and several other haters, are falling for a variant of the sunk cost fallacy - that, because it was so expensive to get him into space, every second of his time needs to be occupied in "useful tasks".

      That's not how it works. There has to be some "down time", both as a buffer against the "useful tasks" taking longer than anticipated (like that ammonia leak they had to fix a few days ago), and just because human beings cannot be working every waking minute.

      The cost/benefit analysis included those necessary "down times", and it was deemed worth it to send him into space. This music video was not planned for, but there was sufficient extra time found for it, and I'm sure once again, it was deemed more productive than anything else he could do (remember, a lot of "productive work" requires new equipment to be shipped up there, which is expensive).

  20. Re:Viral Marketing by NASA by Demonantis · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I am a Canadian and have seen Chris Hadfield at several presentation. He didn't market anything other than promoting people to pick up an interest in science. I think the high quality video/data transmission capability is something NASA is really proud of technically and they are trying to come up with reasons to show it off. And I agree its really sad that America has forgot how much research and technology NASA has spit out and how much more it could spit out.

  21. Re:Great footage too by ldobehardcore · · Score: 5, Informative

    Skylab was never really meant to be a long-term satellite. It spent 2,249 and only 171 of those were spent occupied. In comparison, the ISS has been in orbit for 5288 days, 4575 of them occupied. So I'd say ISS is over twice as kickass, and over 25 times as habitable as skylab.

    --
    Hectice, baby, Mercator says hello to you
  22. Space by gd2shoe · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I disagree.

    America may have forgotten about the drive to build, explore, settle, create, but humanity hasn't. Space isn't sour grapes. It's hard, and settling it is going to be a lot harder. But it will happen.

    --
    I won't join Slashcott. OTOH, If Beta goes live, I just won't be back until it's fixed. Sorry Dice.
  23. Re:Great footage too by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Yep, it makes it seem pretty fucking stupid that we used 37 Space Shuttle missions with a 25 tonne payload capacity to build and supply this space station when it could have been built simpler with a couple of Saturn Vs.

    The lesson here is that heavy lifting capability is how you win in space, not super fancy flying trucks. It probably would have been cheaper to build an ISS in orbit and another spare orbiting the Moon with heavy lift rockets than to go the piecemeal way that we did.

  24. Lyrics by XNormal · · Score: 2

    Ground control to Major Tom! Your ammonia leaks, there's something wrong. Can you hear me Major Tom?

    --
    Stop worrying about the risks of nuclear power and start worrying about the risks of not using nuclear power.
  25. Not very long delay, station is really close by SuperKendall · · Score: 4, Informative

    Isn't there a lag in communications?

    The ISS orbits around 330km - 435 km above the earth (around 230 miles on average). That's less than the width of a single province in Canada!

    If you look at various communication delays based on distance, and assume that during the performance the ISS was basically roughly over Canada or even the U.S, you can see that the delay would be substantially less than for most international phone calls! In fact calling from one major city to another in the same country probably has as much delay, and there's no discernible delay to the caller in that case (well if you aren't using Skype).

    It just goes to show how there's not much up you have to go before you are in space.

    Also one could imagine that if you were "super serious" and kind of nerdy about doing a performance (as both the commander and BNL would be), that you might also set up a synchronized metronome that really did clock off at exactly the same time at the two locations to help the performer on the ISS stay in sync. But I doubt that was needed, and for a performance it's probably far more valuable to be able to riff off how the other performers are playing.

    --
    "There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
    1. Re:Not very long delay, station is really close by FireFury03 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Isn't there a lag in communications?

      The ISS orbits around 330km - 435 km above the earth (around 230 miles on average). That's less than the width of a single province in Canada!

      If you look at various communication delays based on distance, and assume that during the performance the ISS was basically roughly over Canada or even the U.S, you can see that the delay would be substantially less than for most international phone calls!

      As far as I can tell, the high bandwidth connections they use for media events are done by bouncing a Ku band signal off geostationary satellites(*), and the delay is significant (watch any of his videos taking questions from school kids and you'll see a noticable communications delay).

      (* they don't seem to have global coverage with Ku band, only being able to use it when in range of certain satellites. This surprises me because I would've expected there to be enough geostationary sats for one to be visible from anywhere in orbit and it can't be *that* expensive to buy bandwidth on several.)

    2. Re:Not very long delay, station is really close by FireFury03 · · Score: 3, Informative

      Does anyone have an idea why they're doing this? IIRC the distance to geostationary orbit is bigger than the omne to ground, so why waste energy for that long distance stuff?

      At a guess: the Ku band geostationary satellites are already there commercially, so its cheap to just buy some bandwidth when they need it. Doing high bandwidth communications with the ISS directly would require an extensive network of dedicated ground stations with pointable dishes (and appropriate backhauls between them) - remember the ISS is doing an orbit every 90 minutes, so a single ground station isn't going to be able to keep a connection for long. A geostationary sat is going to be able to keep the ISS within its coverage area for much longer than a ground station.

    3. Re:Not very long delay, station is really close by Half-pint+HAL · · Score: 3, Informative

      Does anyone have an idea why they're doing this? IIRC the distance to geostationary orbit is bigger than the omne to ground, so why waste energy for that long distance stuff?

      The ISS orbits the Earth 15.7 times a day. It has an orbital period of 92 minutes and 50 seconds. That means that it's rotational velocity relative to the centre of the Earth is almost 4 degrees per minute, which is pretty difficult to track.

      Of course, that's assuming your antenna is at the centre of the Earth, and the Earth doesn't obstruct signals (not true). In the real world, your antenna is on the surface of the Earth, and is only going to be able to communicate with the space station when it's passing overhead. The angular velocity of the station relative to you is going to be much, much higher than 4 degrees a minute, because it's coming mostly towards you, passing relatively close. (The Earth's radius is 6371 km and the ISS orbits at 330 to 435 km of altitude, so it's pretty close.

      If you can't picture this difference in relative velocity, imagine a fast car on a long circular race track. Imagine you're standing in the middle and turning to watch it as it circles you at constant speed. Now imagine yourself trackside. The car whings past you in the blink of an eye, then takes a seemingly long time to go round the rest of the track, and when it gets back to you, it whings past again.

      So while the path of the ISS can be accurately computed in advance and could theoretically be programmed into a motorised antenna, it would have to be a very very expensive motorised antenna, and it would have to be meticulously cleaned before every use to avoid any of the bearings jammed even for a fraction of a second.

      Not only that, but if we picture ourselves back at the trackside, we get the familiar weeeEEEEEE-Yowoooooooooo as the car passes us: the so-called Doppler effect. Any direct transmission between the ISS and ground stations would suffer the same distortion due to relative speeds. A broadcast to geostationary orbit suffers no doppler effect relative to any point on the surface of the Earth (obviously -- zero relative velocity), and the distortion due to the relative speed of the ISS vs geostationary is pretty much negligible (the ISS's orbit has a radius of approximately 6700km, whereas a geostationary satellite's rotation has a radius of 42000km -- you're no longer at the race track; you're now watching someone driving in a small circle at the opposite side of the car park, and the engine noise doesn't change pitch perceptibly).

      --
      Got them moderator blues I blieve I walk out the do', With these mod-points I been gettin', I 'most never post no mo'
  26. Viral marketing? FINALLY!!! by Damon+Campagna · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Commander Hadfield is the most well known astronaut since Sally Ride -- and with this, he'll be right up there with Neil Armstrong. If this is viral marketing, then THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT THE SPACE PROGRAM NEEDS! Fun, excitement, exquisite beauty -- that's what Hadfield has been beaming back to Earth for the last five months. I've been following his facebook posts for the last couple months and I was genuinely concerned about the ammonia leak this week and his spacewalk, and so were millions of other people. How many "fans" will watch his live prime-time EDT re-entry tomorrow night after watching this video tonight? How many even bothered to watch the final Shuttle landing? This guy is a bona fide star and we who care about space exploration should be embracing him.

  27. Can we at least spell the astronaut's name right? by cmason · · Score: 4, Informative

    I mean, in the title. Really? The dude's in space. I think the least we can do for him is not space out on the spelling of his name.

    --
    "If you are an idealist it doesn't matter what you do or what goes on around you, because it isn't real anyway."-R.P.W.
  28. Re:Guitar playing by tbird81 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Here's the video of him talking about playing the guitar in space.
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rLRunqi1mDM

    Advantage is that you don't need a guitar strap, disadvantage is that you float around if you'd not holding something with your feet. Also tend to mis-fret when first in space.

    You can see the velcro on it in the Bowie song, but i think that is more for stowage than use.

  29. Re:If this is what we currently have on our task l by seebs · · Score: 2

    Please learn something. About something.

    Seriously, the chances are pretty good that if you learn anything about any field of human endeavor, you will find something that is part of a compelling rebuttal to your idiotic screed.

    Starting point: Humans cannot productively "work" all of their waking hours. They have to do other things to remain sane and functional. Do you think we should intentionally have the space station be run by, and maintained by, people who are no longer sane and dangerously incompetent from overwork? No?

    Then maybe they should relax and goof off sometimes.

    --
    My blog: http://www.seebs.net/log/ --- My iPhone/iPad app: http://www.seebs.net/seebsfrac/
  30. Re:Really? by AaronLS · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'm sure someone has been just as narrow sighted before... "How is the America the future? The future of what? It's an empty savage infested hell. It's good place to send those who disagree with our religious beliefs. That's it. America is the past, the Columbus Age is as dead as polytheism."

  31. Pretty good? That's all? by Begemot · · Score: 2

    He's not Bowie, but he's pretty good

    OMG, you guys are a very tough crowd. To me he sang perfectly well!

  32. Re:Great footage too by bickerdyke · · Score: 2

    *Impressive* would rather be a description of the Mir. Having a space station that consists 98% out of duck tape and paper clips, build around a actual former space station that broke down is pretty impressive....

    --
    bickerdyke
  33. Re:Surprise NASA didn't force him to return by Sun · · Score: 2

    To be fair, had I been in his position, I wouldn't want to sing those parts of the song too.

    He had other lyrics, about his mission being close to over, which I believe were written specifically for him.

    Shachar

  34. Re:If this is what we currently have on our task l by fishybell · · Score: 4, Funny

    Wait, what?! They're allowed to sleep?! OUTRAGEOUS!

    --
    ><));>
  35. Re:Really? by Half-pint+HAL · · Score: 3, Funny

    Space hasn't ratified the Berne Convention.

    --
    Got them moderator blues I blieve I walk out the do', With these mod-points I been gettin', I 'most never post no mo'
  36. Re:(My) definitive version by SternisheFan · · Score: 2

    The original David Bowie song is really about drug addiction. In his later hit, 'Ashes to Ashes', Bowie sings, "We all know Major Tom's a junkie."

  37. imagine that by reovirus1 · · Score: 4, Funny

    An astronaut and a rock star! Hope he doesn't try to run for Prime Minister next, that would be a downgrade.

  38. Brilliant by Skiron · · Score: 2

    Unlike most people posting tripe in here, I was 10 years old when Bowie released this - it was fantastic (and I also think the first music video?).

    I am now 53, and this version is brilliant (and apt) - would I as a ten year old expect this to happen 43 years later? No way.

    Brilliant stuff.

  39. Re:Music recorded on Earth by _anomaly_ · · Score: 4, Informative

    The guitar and vocals were, in fact, recorded in space.

    The music was mixed with his guitar and vocals on Earth. What else do you want? Chris Hadfield in space, mixing tracks with the original recording in Pro Tools? Him playing the piano accompaniment on the ISS?

    --
    "I have no special gift, I am only passionately curious." - Albert Einstein
  40. Re:Music recorded on Earth by loufoque · · Score: 2

    I want a full orchestra in the ISS

  41. When is Hadfield's disciplinary hearing? by markdowling · · Score: 2

    Obviously nobody sent him the memo where Canadian scientists and public servants have to get approval for talking to the media or even giving evidence to members of Parliament. All these pictures and videos - oh boy is he ever going to get it when he gets back to CSA HQ.