Slashdot Mirror


Redesigned Seats Let Airlines Squeeze In More Passengers

Hugh Pickens DOT Com writes "AP reports that U.S. airlines are taking out old, bulky seats in favor of so-called slimline models that take up less space from front to back, allowing for five or six more seats on each plane. This gives airlines two of their favorite things: more paying passengers, and a smaller fuel bill (the seats are slightly lighter). Whether the new seats are really closer together depends on how you measure. By the usual measure, called 'pitch,' the new ones are generally an inch closer together from front to back as measured at the armrest. The seats Southwest has put on nearly its entire fleet are 31 inches apart, about an inch less than before, allowing them to to add an extra row of six seats to each plane. International passengers are feeling crowded, too. As recently as 2010, most airlines buying Boeing's big 777 opted for nine seats across. Now it's 10 across on 70 percent of newly-built 777s, Boeing says. American's newest 777s are set up 10-across in coach, with slightly narrower seats than on its older 777s. Airlines say you won't notice. And the new seats are designed to minimize this problem. Airplane seats from 30 years ago looked like your grandmother's BarcaLounger, says Jami Counter, senior director at SeatGuru.com, which tracks airline seats and amenities. 'All that foam cushion and padding probably didn't add all that much comfort. All that's been taken out,' he said. 'You haven't really lost all that much if the airline does it right.'"

27 of 466 comments (clear)

  1. Bullshit we won't notice by magic+maverick+ · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I recently flew on a rather old African owned plane (run by a state airline). It being my first experience with this style of airline (the only other African airline I'd flown was SAA, which is no better or worse than the average European airline), it was interesting. E.g. there was heaps of leg room! It was amazing compared to the other airlines I'd been flying. Economy class was actually comfortable for me, even without pushing the seatback back (which I never like doing if there is someone behind me, I think airlines should remove that option).

    On the newer planes though, I always have to get an aisle seat, otherwise I am uncomfortable the entire flight.

    Fuck the airlines.

    --
    HELP MY ACCOUNT HAS BEEN HACKED BY AN ILLIBERAL ART STUDENT SET TO DESTROY THE INTERWEBZ!
    1. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by Durrik · · Score: 5, Insightful

      You might have the same problem I have. But I don't think I'll notice the change personally. I'm 6'4" tall (190cm) and I'm in pain if I don't get up from those seats at least every two hours and walk to the bathroom. I have a hard time getting into them now as it is, and usually I fly on short notice and I'm stuck in the middle. I'm quite sure that the airlines are having some sort of joke on the big guys, and see how many they can sit next to each other.

      The last time I flew internationally (10 hour flight from Seattle to Amsterdam) I got lucky and upgraded to 'comfort' class and the booking agent apologized that I was tuck in the bulkhead row. Stuck? Man that was comfortable I could stretch out. But she was able to do better on the way back, and got me a proper seat. That was painful, and cramped. I had to get the guy on the aisle to let me out 5 times, and each time I was moving like an old man (and I'm not that old).

      So I don't think I'll notice the loose of 1 little inch. My knees already run into the back of the seat in front of me. My shoulders already overflow onto the seats besides me. I might notice that my butt will be snug in the seats though.

      But if they're jamming more people onto the plane, are they increasing the overhead bin capacity? When I fly I always take a small roller bag for my clothes and a laptop bag. I usually get these stowed (roller bag up top and laptop bag under the seat in front of course) but its usually cramped, and people who come in late always seem to try to jam in on top of everything. Somehow I doubt it as that is passenger convenience, and some airlines (I'm looking at you American) are charging for every checked bag you have. They're currently offering the checked carry on for free, but that might change in the future.

      --
      Software Engineer & Writer of Military Science Fiction and Fantasy Blog: petermwright.com Twitter: WrightPeterM
    2. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by blackm0k · · Score: 5, Insightful

      I do not share this experience. Typically, when the seat in front of me is pushed back, it collides with my knee-caps, sometimes in a fairly painful manner. After that the flight becomes a few hours of my legs being restricted to one fairly uncomfortable position.

    3. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by drinkypoo · · Score: 4, Interesting

      I'm 6'7". I do my best not to fly (don't really want to be sexually abused) but when I have to, I am fucking miserable. Most airlines seem to now only give you preferred seating if you're part of some kind of high-mileage club, so I usually don't get to pick the bulkhead. I'll regularly see short people seated there but they never seem to want to swap me; the people with the seat they don't need and the airline employees are both assholes. It doesn't just impact me; my knees are firmly against the seat before me, which cannot be reclined. If the person tries I will shove the seat forward, and hard; if you don't look before you recline, you're an asshole. And if they look back at me for more than the half-second it should take to figure out that I don't fit in the seat, then I look them right in the eye and explain that they don't get to recline their seat, and please stop looking back here.

      Americans are getting bigger; not just fatter but taller. But they're reducing the available room on the planes. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that this is bullshit.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    4. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by Joce640k · · Score: 4, Informative

      I do not share this experience. Typically, when the seat in front of me is pushed back, it collides with my knee-caps, sometimes in a fairly painful manner.

      http://www.gadgetduck.com/goods/kneedefender.html

      --
      No sig today...
    5. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by rickett81 · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I'm 200cm tall.
      On a flight from the US to Brazil, I was stuck in the back of the plane and my legs physically wouldn't fit in the seat. The flight attendant told me that I would have to get my legs in there or the flight couldn't take off. I had her call another flight attendant over and then I said "I will get in here, but something is going to break. It will be the seat in front, my seat, or my legs."
      I then jammed myself into the seat which broke the rivets/screws of the seat in front of me which slammed the seat forward (with someone in it) making the seat unusable. I foresee this happening again and more often if the airlines continue this stuff.

    6. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by NeutronCowboy · · Score: 4, Insightful

      The seats don't recline to make much of a difference for sleep. If you can sleep reclined, you can sleep upright. I would also argue that at your height, you have no idea what it means to have a seat reclined into your lap. Once you hit the critical limit of 190 and over, your knees physically touch the seat in front of you, even if both are upright. Someone reclining their seat can result in a very sudden impact on your kneecaps. So I do appreciate it when people at least carefully recline their seat and don't kneecap me.

      People like you, on the other hand.... a pox on you for not thinking about the ramifications of your actions.

      --
      Those who can, do. Those who can't, sue.
    7. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by idontgno · · Score: 4, Funny

      Your sleep. My health.

      Hmm. How to decide?

      Hey, interesting fact. You leaning your seat back towards me in the row behind you puts your vulnerable throat closer to my hands.

      Sleep tight!

      --
      Welcome to the Panopticon. Used to be a prison, now it's your home.
    8. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by bill_mcgonigle · · Score: 4, Insightful

      My knees already run into the back of the seat in front of me.

      The most reasonable measure of airplane seating would be a tuple: the distance from the seat to the seat back in front - the latter in both in upright and reclined mode.

      I'm an inch shorter than you, and frankly I'd rather sit on a metal chair with no cushioning and humanitarian leg room than a cushioned seat with no leg room.

      Heaven forbid there's ever an accident - tall people will probably wind up with fractured femurs or hips or both. No safety specs on that?

      --
      My God, it's Full of Source!
      OUTSIDE_IP=$(dig +short my.ip @outsideip.net)
    9. Re:Bullshit we won't notice by nightsky30 · · Score: 5, Funny

      Lovely view of giraffes. Horrible, terrible turbulence.

      Are they ok? How many did you hit?

  2. Stop carrying life jackets? by Bruce66423 · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Every plane trip you go on will offer you a life jacket. In the past 60 years, I'm confident that a life jacket hasn't saved a life, but it's cost a fortune in fuel over that time...

    1. Re:Stop carrying life jackets? by confused+one · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Funny you're so confident about that. You should go back and look at the water landings and ask the survivors if they used their flotation seats or life jackets. Life jackets and flotation seats were added, FAA rules making them mandatory, for a reason. While most of the water landings included fatalities, I'm confident the fatality rate would have been higher without the life jackets.

  3. Can I just stand? by Bongo · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Would be comfier at this rate.

    1. Re:Can I just stand? by agentgonzo · · Score: 5, Informative

      That was a marketing ploy by Ryanair. They're regularly doing things like this (also charging for the use of the toilet) and slip in that "it'll be trialled on their new route from X-Y". Bingo, free advertising as all the tabloids lap it up.

  4. slim is good :) by l3v1 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I'd start by saying that I'm bigger than the average. Still, having sat in the slim seats for several travels, I have to say they are more comfortable than the old ones, even in a 3-4-3 row setting. I actually feel like having more leg space (especially for my knees) even if the seat in front of me is reclined. If they all will be like the slim seats on transatlantic LH flights, then I'd take them anytime over the old style seats.

    --
    I am putting myself to the fullest possible use, which is all I can think that any conscious entity can ever hope to do.
  5. Depends which way you turn when you the aircraft by gnalre · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Jami Counter, senior director at SeatGuru.com, which tracks airline seats and amenities. 'All that foam cushion and padding probably didn't add all that much comfort. All that's been taken out,' he said. 'You haven't really lost all that much if the airline does it right.'"

    He shouted from business class.

    I wonder if we made a law that said all airline executives had to fly economy whether they would be so keen to make these changes

    --
    Choose your allies carefully, it is highly unlikely you will be held accountable for the actions of your enemies
  6. How many people buy a ticket based on leg room? by trout007 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    If people just go to their favorite travel website and sort flights by cost this will continue to happen. Consumers are giving the signal they care about nothing other than cost. If it becomes uncomfortable enough that people select airlines based on comfort over price the airlines will respond. They just want the money. If they could get away with charging more for bean bag seats they would respond.

    --
    I love Jesus, except for his foreign policy.
    1. Re:How many people buy a ticket based on leg room? by Rob+the+Bold · · Score: 5, Insightful

      If people just go to their favorite travel website and sort flights by cost this will continue to happen. Consumers are giving the signal they care about nothing other than cost. If it becomes uncomfortable enough that people select airlines based on comfort over price the airlines will respond. They just want the money. If they could get away with charging more for bean bag seats they would respond.

      Is there even a way to sort flights by leg room (or other seat size parameter) on any travel website? Even if one knew the seat pitches in the aircraft that a given airline uses from external sources, one doesn't necessarily know what "equipment" is being used for any given flight. And even then, they're not all necessarily furnished identically. And your plane could change any time between booking and boarding. If you know of a way to do it, I want to know.

      And besides, even wishing for this sort of thing will surely prompt some Slashdot griefer to call me "entitled" for stating my product and service preferences.

      --
      I am not a crackpot.
  7. Other news by mdsolar · · Score: 4, Funny

    Sardines claim conditions cramped in tin.

  8. Re:Another reason not to fly (unless you HAVE to) by captbob2002 · · Score: 4, Informative

    My last vacation I took the train (Amtrak Autotrain, Lorton VA to Sanford FL) it was a wonderful experience. Excellent service and food on the southbound trip. Northbound was...okay - I would say very good, except that the southbound trip crew was awesome.

    That said, even the "okay" service on the northbound trip was FAR better than any airline experience I have ever had- even when I've flown first class.

  9. Mandatory Come Fly With Me by StripedCow · · Score: 5, Funny
    --
    If Pandora's box is destined to be opened, *I* want to be the one to open it.
  10. Time for Tube Planes by Bigbutt · · Score: 4, Funny

    A bunch of tubes (or padded cubes) where the passenger slides in, a hatch is closed behind them and soothing music is piped in to help them sleep (or gas, whichever works best).

    [John]

    --
    Shit better not happen!
  11. Re:It not logical Captain by cjjjer · · Score: 5, Insightful

    No, more of them will need to buy two seats.

  12. Re:It not logical Captain by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    No, they'll just take up half my seat while the airline expects me to suffer in silence.

  13. Re:It not logical Captain by rolfwind · · Score: 5, Funny

    The american airlines should just carry things to their logical conclusion, sedate everyone, and then stack them like firewood.

  14. Re:It not logical Captain by MightyYar · · Score: 5, Funny

    The armrest can keep the solid parts of them away from you, but you still need to fight off the gooey parts.

    --
    W..w..W - Willy Waterloo washes Warren Wiggins who is washing Waldo Woo.
  15. Re:It not logical Captain by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 4, Insightful

    All this will do is piss off more people and turn them off to flying unless absolutely necessary.

    I doubt if most people will notice. When making flying decisions, most passengers care about three things:
    1. cost of the tickets
    2. fares
    3. ticket prices
    Discount airlines that have cut amenities to reduce costs, have thrived.
    Speaking for myself, I have a family to support, and renting a comfortable seat for a few hours is not a priority.
    If a thinner seat allows the airline to cut $20 off the price, that is fine with me.