Slashdot Mirror
Feds Now Oppose Aereo, Rejecting Cloud Apocalypse Argument
v3rgEz writes "TV streaming service Aereo expected broadcasters would put up a fight. The startup may not have seen the Justice Department as a threat, however. The Justice Department has now weighed in, saying in a filing that it's siding with major broadcasters who accuse Aereo of stealing TV content. In its filing, the Justice Department noted it doesn't believe a win for broadcasters would dismantle the precedent that created the cloud computing industry, as Aereo has previously claimed. The case is expected to go before the Supreme Court in late April."
Get to make the rules. Yet another example.
---- Booth was a patriot ----
The same Justice Department officials will soon leave to work for the various broadcast networks.
Thank goodness we've got the Obama administration to bring some common sense back to government and stand up for the little guy.
You might want to look into vdr instead. It's not as flashy but it was very stable years ago. In my opinion it's as a DVR should be.
A Series 3 platform TiVo would let you record digital OTA for $12.95 per month maxium, but that figure is for the entire TiVo service which includes a license to use the software as well as the guide info, and they've always sold the hardware cheap with the idea of making up the loss on selling the service.
In fact, you can probably pick up a used S3 or S3 HD or HD XL with Product Lifetime Service for $300 or less (check area Craigslists), then another $100 for a 2TB WD20EURS to slip into it and $10 -$15 for Low ESR 105 degree rated capacitors to replace the ones in the power supply pro-actively, and the only monthly cost will be the electricity.
Lurk at tivocommunity.com for a while.
You'll also find discussion of Myth and WMC there as well.
When you're paying for Aereo, you're paying as much as anything to have somebody else worry about providing you with an outdoor antenna.
I see even classic Slashdot is now pretty much unusable on dial up anymore.
Sorry. XKCD
That would have been a great service model, which is why it couldn't possibly last. Fox TV, and now ABC, limit the free recent episodes to viewvers who can "verify" their cable service. In both cases, you can only "verify" if you have an account with a tiny list of services that are mostly unknowns. I get these stations through one of the nation's largest cable providers, but it's never in the select list. Torrents, here I come.
.... many networks will stream a good portion of the shows that they air, usually only a day or so after initial broadcast... and typically leave them available for about a week. There's commercials, of course, but it's really not that bad a way to watch television. I'm not sure what need Aero was really trying to fill.
Probably the needs of those for whom those qualifiers are problematic.
my, your, his/her/its, our, your, their
I'm, you're, he's/she's/it's, we're, you're, they're
Area Man Constantly Mentioning He Doesn't Own a TV.
Is anyone doing anything about that?
Yeah.
Didn't think so.
Look, in First World countries, you get high bandwidth internet that is 10-20 times faster than the US for $20 a month or less and you get fewer commercials and lower cable bills.
We live in a Second World country.
-- Tigger warning: This post may contain tiggers! --
The Golden Rule. Those with the gold get to make the rules.
Working at the shop I talk to a LOT of college aged kids, know what I've found? Frankly TV is The Lawrence Welk Show, something old folks liked that the kids honestly don't understand and don't want. They are used to having the net and "shows by appointment" is just something they really "don't get" and if they can't watch a show on THEIR schedule? Then they just don't care, they really don't.
Honestly the only young folks I found with TVs were the really poor, those without net use TV as a form of cheap entertainment. Even my fiance who swore "I'm not gonna be able to stand going without TV" when she moved in has been TV free for almost a year and the USB cap card I gave her for her lappy sits unused. Once I showed her the wealth of instant entertainment? She never went back.
So the broadcasters can bribe the government all they want, like the *.A.A they can't change the fact that their model has gone the way of the 8-track. The future is crowd funding and instant gratification, the days of "tune in, same bat time, same bat channel" as as dated as Adam West's Batman.
ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
OK how about this.
If I buy a DVR and antenna and put it on my roof am I in the right? - Yep
Ok, rent a DVR and antenna and put them on my roof? - I think we can both agree yes.
OK, rent a DVR and antenna, and whenever I want them they get mailed to me, I put them on my roof and when I am done I mail them back? NO guarantee I get the same antenna or DVR, but I think we still agree this is ok?
What if I rent a DVR and antenna, and rent some space at my neighbours house to store them. And run a long thick HDMI cable over the fence to plug the whole thing into my TV. Am I ok now??
OK; I get sick of the long cable I am running over the fence, and replace it with an ethernet cable, and use a PVR that has a web interface. - Still OK?
OK, I replace the ethernet cable with 2 wireless routers, both of which I am renting - still ok?
OK, so I get sick of using the wireless routers, and instead plug it into my neighbours internet connection, and use a point to point encrypted VPN link between my neighbours house and my house. Have I gone too far yet?
OK I got sick of maintaining the VPN link, and just put a password on it. Still good?
My neighbour sells his house to a DATACentre company and builds a datacentre on his plot of land, but dont worry cause I just ask them if I can keep renting that space and go back to my wireless routers solution. How am I going here?
OK, finally, I got sick of my wireless routers again, and once more plug into the datacentres internet connection. Is this legal?
Remember; every time I am done watching TV I ask the neighbour to return the antenna to the rental place. and when I want to watch it again he goes and picks one up from the rental place.
Which part of the above is where I started going wrong? When did what I do become a public performance?
Thats the whole reason the networks are fighting Aereo so much, everyone who uses Aereo to get OTA TV is (as far as they are concerned) one less person paying Comcast or Time Warner or whoever else for that same TV. And therefore its one less person paying x amount per month (via their cable provider) to the networks. (i.e. Aereo = lost revenue)
The story is that the US Solicitor General (whose office prepared this brief) is a former top lawyer for the MPAA.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious." Obi-Wan Kenobi
Help stamp out iliturcy.