Slashdot Mirror


Italian Military To Switch To LibreOffice and ODF

jrepin writes: The Italian military is transitioning to LibreOffice and the Open Document Format (ODF). The Ministry of Defense will over the next year-and-a-half install this suite of office productivity tools on some 150,000 PC workstations — making it Europe's second largest LibreOffice implementation.

54 of 106 comments (clear)

  1. Confusion Intensifies by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Truthfully, I wasn't entirely cognizant of the existence of an Italian military.

    It's kind of like the Canadian Navy. If you think about it; well sure they would exist. But did you actually realize that they exist?

  2. Satya: by Snufu · · Score: 4, Funny

    Handing a black briefcase to Clippy, "Get these free Office licenses to the Italian Ministry of Defense by any means necessary."

    1. Re:Satya: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      Clippy: "I see you are about to buy some persuading services from the Italian mafia. Would you like some help formulating an offer they can't refuse?"

  3. Erm....what? by Notabadguy · · Score: 1

    Wasn't there just a slashdot article a couple weeks ago about how Italian government is switching from LibreOffice back to MS?

  4. Not exactly... by mschaffer · · Score: 2

    The article was about how the city of Pesaro, Italy was switching back to MS.
    http://tech.slashdot.org/story...

  5. Re:Italy has a military? by PopeRatzo · · Score: 1, Flamebait

    Italy has a military?

    Italy had a powerful military when Americans were crapping on the ground and worshiping buffalo.

    --
    You are welcome on my lawn.
  6. Of course they have an army... by mschaffer · · Score: 1

    Of course Italy has an army. It gives the Italian designers something to practice on.
    Apparently even Armani has had a hand in their uniform designs.
    http://www.styleite.com/news/r...

  7. Hmm, maybe the next step'll be... by Type44Q · · Score: 3, Funny

    ...Sabayon Linux, baby! (And if you don't like it, vaffanculo!!)

    1. Re:Hmm, maybe the next step'll be... by MechaStreisand · · Score: 1

      Sabayon? Gross. Why would anyone choose the Gentoo derivative that forces you to use systemd? The main reason to use Gentoo is that it doesn't force that on you, unlike almost every other distro.

      --
      Disclaimer: IANAL. This post is, however, legal advice, and creates an attorney-client relationship.
  8. Re:Italy has a military? by Type44Q · · Score: 2

    Italy had a powerful military when Americans were crapping on the ground and worshiping buffalo.

    What, Florence and Venice?

  9. Re:Italy has a military? by Type44Q · · Score: 2

    Florence, Venice and the Vatican all relied on a private military known as Condottieri; was that what you were referring to?

  10. Re:Italy has a military? by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 2

    There are 16 countries without a military, and Italy is not one of them. There are about 175,000 people in the Italian Armed Forces, and according to TFA, 150,000 of them produce documents. I believe that the last time they won a war, was their invasion of Albania.

  11. Re:Italy has a military? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Way before Florence and Venice. You know, there was this thing called Roman Empire, which basically amounted to 90% of the civilized world 2K years ago. If we look at more recent times, Italy was part of 3 wars over the last century, it won two of them (one against the Ottoman Empire and WWI). It lost WWII only because it was driven by an idiotic dictator who entered the war after a 3 month preparation. As for the US, the last three wars it was part of were in Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq, not to mention the recent "proxy war" with Russia in the Donbass region: the brilliant results speak for themselves.

    But probably in US high schools History is not cool enough to be taught, they teach you "courses" like rollerblading and "home economics" instead, and at night you might enjoy the katrashians.

  12. Re:Italy has a military? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    1939. Which was just 6 years before the US won its last war, in 1945.

    Unless you consider what happened in Iraq a "victory" (is ISIS your ally?), let alone Afghanistan, that is still today largely controlled by the Talibans.

  13. Let's see how it works out by chipschap · · Score: 1

    I thought I would post something, you know, on topic .... as strange and possibly inappropriate as that concept might sound.

    It appears that when something like this happens, Microsoft picks its moment, finds the moment of maximum chaos (all radical transitions have such moments) and offers a "deal" like cheap Office 365 (or is it 360, or 666, or some other number?) licenses, and some panic-stricken execs go for it rather than wait until the chaos dies down and a stable operating state is achieved.

    I'm as anti-Microsoft as it gets, but no denying that marketing is something they are good at. This is not the same thing as pleasing the customer --- witness the forced Windows 10 downloads --- but they sure can sell things despite everything. They wouldn't be where they are if they weren't such a powerful marketing force.

    I hope this works out for the Italian military but I'm not overly optimistic.

    1. Re:Let's see how it works out by tom229 · · Score: 1

      They also aren't the first public entity to try this. Many don't weather the transition as Libre has great difficulty with legacy file formats, macros, etc.

      As one anecdotal case, I use LibreOffice in my office while literally everyone else uses MS Office 2010. I'm constantly running into formatting inconsistencies and straight incompatibility with complex spreadsheets. I muddle through it as I have the technical expertise and ideological philosophy that allows, and demands, that I do so; but I wouldn't wish it on my users.

      The fact of the matter is that when the business computing industry was naive and young, it got into bed with Microsoft. Now they're regretting it, for good reasons. They put too much faith in that relationship and built their entire lives around it. Now they've been together so long and become so co-dependant that it's going to be a really messy breakup.

      --
      If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
    2. Re:Let's see how it works out by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      AFAIK, the Scottish police and the French police (or was it the Gendarmerie?) are still using Open/Libre Office, and have been doing so for quite some time. Haven't heard anything about if for quite some time, so I guess they're happy with it.

      And actually, Microsoft isn't very good at marketing. They are good at corruption and on playing on peoples fear and ignorance, which might explain why they are having some problems with convincing the police. : >

    3. Re:Let's see how it works out by darnkitten · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Anecdotally as well, I have had the opposite experience.

      Admittedly, I don't see complex spreadsheets or macro-heavy documents in my library, but patrons bring in old doc, docx, MS Works or WordPerfect documents, as well as a variety of simple spreadsheets and presentations--LibreOffice opens them all, with only minor formatting problems. Libreoffice will even open a large number of Office templates.

      The only persistent problem I have is that whenever I do a LibreOffice upgrade, Windows switches all the open/save preferences from Libreoffice back to MS Office.

    4. Re:Let's see how it works out by chipschap · · Score: 1

      I should have been more clear. When I said "marketing" I meant to include Machiavellian meanings. Perhaps saying "Microsoft is good at selling" would have been better --- selling, whether through persuasion, coercion, etc. .... or, heaven forbid, offering value if there's no other way.

    5. Re:Let's see how it works out by turbidostato · · Score: 1

      "And actually, Microsoft isn't very good at marketing. They are good at corruption and on playing on peoples fear and ignorance"

      Why do you think corruption and FUD are not marketing tools along many others?

      And given current corporate ethos, as dignified as any other, I should add.

    6. Re:Let's see how it works out by esonik · · Score: 1

      Anecdotally, I have the opposite to report.

      Where Excel 2003 would fail to load an complex file, OpenOffice (didn't try LibreOffice at that time) would load the same file just fine.
      Complex in the sense of lot's of cells used ( a few hundred rows with about 50 columns - not that much actually), with only basic arithmetic- no funky math or functions used.

  14. Kind of. Coast Guard. Same size as 1 carrier group by raymorris · · Score: 1

    > It's kind of like the Canadian Navy. If you think about it; well sure they would exist.

    Technically they exist, and they do serve a role, a role similar in some ways to the US Coast Guard.

    Canada's navy operates 1 destroyer, 12 frigates, 4 patrol submarines, 12 coastal defense vessels and 8 unarmed patrol/training vessels. They have about 8,000 sailors.

    Each US carrier battle group includes about eight surface warships like those of the RCN, and typically two submarines. Plus a carrier. With 70 planes on it. Each carrier battle group has about 7,500 sailors - roughly the same size as the entire Royal Canadian Navy.

    It's good to be close friends with the country who has 10 such carrier groups - Canada doesn't really need much of a navy when they're buddies with the US. That's an an under-appreciated benefit to the US of having a navy roughly as powerful as all other navies combined. Sure, we can defend ourselves materially, but we get just as much benefit from the fact that friendly nations enjoy our protection, and therefore want to be our close allies.

  15. Goof for them! by nospam007 · · Score: 1

    Va bene cosi.

  16. Re: Italy has a military? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Go ahead and walk right into Iraq and Afghanistan and show us all how it's done

    Why should I? And why should Italy? Saddam Hussein didn't do anything wrong to Italy, he was a pretty good leader, he kept its country stable, I don't remember any refugees coming here when he was in power. I wouldn't have attacked him in the first place, just like Khadafi in Lybia, just like Assad in Syria, two other pretty good leaders. And there wouldn't be massive amounts of refugees coming to Italy and several other european countries as a result. As for the Talibans, sorry, but Bin Laden was harbored by Pakistan, not Afghanistan, as events eventually proved. But Pakistan has nukes, so you were afraid to bomb it, right?

    Basically everywhere you go you make a massive mess, just like the obese kid in the class when he tries to decorate the christmas tree: many kilograms on the belly, zero neurons inside the head. Except that the damages of your mess are paid for by somebody else.

  17. Re:Kind of. Coast Guard. Same size as 1 carrier gr by greenfruitsalad · · Score: 2

    wouldn't canada (or anybody) be safer without a friend who goes around the world stirring shit at every possible opportunity?

    i.e. if they had United States of South Canada for a neighbor, i'd imagine the south canadian (mounted) navy wouldn't just run around the world rattling guns and meddling in people's shit.

  18. Re:Italy has a military? by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1

    You know, there was this thing called Roman Empire, which basically amounted to 90% of the civilized world 2K years ago.

    If you somehow failed to know about China.

    --
    Watch this Heartland Institute video
  19. Re: Italy has a military? by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1

    Well if your army is so great and superior to the US then by all means show us how to do it. Go ahead and walk right into Iraq and Afghanistan and show us all how it's done.

    History tells us that "walking into Afghanistan" is how it is not done

    --
    Watch this Heartland Institute video
  20. Re: Italy has a military? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Indeed. One does not simply "walk" into Afghanistan.

  21. Understand your needs and pick the right solution by Ravaldy · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Company CTOs or equivalent need to understand the needs of their company before they pick a product. Here's a list that shows the products side by side:
    https://wiki.documentfoundatio...

  22. Tested. Canada invaded? Needed a Navy? by raymorris · · Score: 1

    > wouldn't canada (or anybody) be safer

    Well, we've seen the results . Has Canada been invaded since the US Navy was formed? Have they had any need for their own Navy? (Other than for Coast Guard type operations).

    Liberal:
    One who is full of their own ideas, and refuses to learn from historical facts about those ideas.

    1. Re:Tested. Canada invaded? Needed a Navy? by jbengt · · Score: 1

      Has Canada been invaded since the US Navy was formed?

      Yes, they were invaded by the US.

  23. Re:Italy has a military? by behrooz0az · · Score: 1

    And Persia, Britannia, Egypt and bunch of others.

    --
    Moderating "-1, Disagree" is simple censorship. Have the guts to post your opinion. -- Spazmania (174582)
  24. Guessing they didn't like MS's spyware as an OS by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    This is going to quickly become a trend as more and more foreign governments realize MS can't be trusted.

  25. Re: Italy has a military? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    How to do it is to not do it. Simple. It is not possible to conquer a complex country like Afghanistan. If you really want the territory where the Afghans are living, than you have to kill them all, just like the Romans did in their prime time when tribes didn't want to join the empire. But a war to spread democracy and liberty in Afghanistan? It can't be done.

    Iraq? It's easy to kill a dictator, but it was not the solution to the non existing problem. It was a dictator with blood on his hands, that is something we all know. But there flows even more blood without that dictator. Iraq is a country that shouldn't exist. It should be divided in different nations or it should be part of a pan-Arabian state with a part joining a Shiite empire and another part joining a Sunni empire, where all other religions have to pay their taxes or convert to Islam. Or again, if you just want the territory, commit genocide. Hunt down the people, village after village. Scare them with brutal executions. IS shows the way. They don't even have to kill everyone, most people are on the run. But a war to spread democracy and liberty in Iraq? It can't be done.

    So many empires in history have failed in Iraq and Afghanistan. Yes, many have won battles, but nobody ever won a war. Just leave them alone in their misery. Maybe they become enlightened some day. Maybe the genocide by IS is what is needed to stabilize the region? Maybe this apocalyptic end of Syria and Iraq is the plow that prepares the land to plant the seeds for a successful and peaceful society that has turned its back to this awful religion?

    Now Europe is planning to also start dropping bombs on Syria. So both the US and the EU will be dropping bombs on both Iraq and Syria. But to what purpose? What bloodthirsty minority are we going to help this time? Do you really think that removing Assad or IS from those deserts will all of the sudden bring peace to those countries? It was rather calm over there when the dictators where still in power. The Arab spring didn't bring democracy, it only made it clear to me that Islam is a religion that wants total control of the world. Moderate or not, it's what Islam is all about. Islam is not just a religion, it's a complete way of live including laws, politics and culture. Islam is not competing with Christianity, but with Globalism and liberalism.

    Look at Egypt. There was democracy when the previous dictator was gone but the majority chose to live in a totalitarian theocracy. Egypt would have been a totalitarian theocracy if the new dictator didn't take action. This is what the current Islam is all about. Once it might have been a tolerant religion that brought peace over a large region and brought prosperity and scientific progress. But something went wrong when some theologists started to reinterpret the holy scriptures and demanded total submission to Islam and only to Islam. That's why the crusades where necessary back in those days. Europeans still have to apologize for the crusades, but the region was rather peaceful under the Crusader states. To protect the 'moderate' people in the 'holy lands', the crusaders had to become ruthless killers themselves. Islam has radicalized again, and only a small percentage of radicals in a sea of moderate Muslims is needed to bring terrorism and this horrible IS.

    Do you want to stop this? Kill everyone who doesn't want to submit to your authority and place someone of your own kind as the local leader. Don't want to just randomly kill people because that is an unethical thing? Than stay out of that area, you can't solve their problem without bloodshed.

  26. Re:Italy has a military? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Britannia and Egypt were both part of the Roman Empire. And London itself was literally founded by the Romans. Finally, the Persian dynasties lost many of their western territories to the Romans, especially in the 2nd century AD.

    You must have attended elementary schools either in the USA or in the fourth world.

  27. Re:Italy has a military? by RabidReindeer · · Score: 1

    I had a friend who claimed the the Italians had never lost a war, even if it meant they had to change sides to make sure of it.

    He was Italian, BTW.

  28. Re:Italy has a military? by fph+il+quozientatore · · Score: 1

    As far as I know, Alpini have a specific training only for drinking grappa.

    --
    My first program:

    Hell Segmentation fault

  29. Re:Italy has a military? by redmid17 · · Score: 1

    Not trying to take away from Italian special forces here, but are you seriously saying that they have roles/forces not found in any other army? The 10th mountain division has existed in the US army since WW2. Hell they served specifically in Italy. The US military has 4 mountain training facilities. As to the Carabinieri, well they are basically a mixture of MPs and the FBI. They aren't unique either. The French Gendarmerie are the identical (national police as part of the army). The Dutch and Portugese have one too.

  30. Re: Italy has a military? by Rakarra · · Score: 1

    As for the Talibans, sorry, but Bin Laden was harbored by Pakistan, not Afghanistan, as events eventually proved.

    He was harbored by both. In the ten years before he was caught, he had a lot of time to move around. He was in Tora Bora when the US invaded Afghanistan, but managed to evade capture, at which point intelligence agencies lost track of him.

    But Pakistan has nukes, so you were afraid to bomb it, right?

    You may have missed the part where once the US tracked down Bin Laden, they invaded without telling the Pakistani government. Caused a bit of a stir.

  31. Re:Italy has a military? by unixisc · · Score: 1

    What do do, guard against an invasion from the Visigoths?

    That was gonna be my question as well. Ever since the end of the Cold War and the open-border approach of all European countries, it's a wonder that any of them have militaries at all. In Italy's case, who do they defend themselves against? Austria? France? Switzerland? Croatia? The only people invading them are refugees from Libya, and they don't even have the balls to turn them away w/o needing a military. So what good does it do Italy to have a military?

  32. Re:Italy has a military? by unixisc · · Score: 1

    You have to go back pretty far to get to the time that Italy had a decent military. In the Middle Ages, it was a part of the Austrian Empire.

  33. Re:Italy has a military? by unixisc · · Score: 1

    The US won a war against Iraq in 1991, unless you consider the non-removal of Saddam as a stale-mate

  34. LibreOffice 5.x is a big improvement by MrL0G1C · · Score: 2

    I've slated LibreOffice in the past for constant crashes and formatting problems.

    They've done a great job of fixing bugs, it no longer crashes regularly and I haven't noticed any formatting issues with 5.0.x

    --
    Waterfox - a Firefox fork with legacy extension support, security updates and better privacy by default.
    1. Re:LibreOffice 5.x is a big improvement by vandamme · · Score: 1

      I've found God to be fairly useable, but you have to do things his way. Same way with LO too, I guess. I don't know what's so "unuseable" about it. I only use 2% of its capabilities.

    2. Re:LibreOffice 5.x is a big improvement by MrL0G1C · · Score: 1

      I knew I was missing a trick, life is too hard, how do I use God? Is there a trick to opening some console?

      --
      Waterfox - a Firefox fork with legacy extension support, security updates and better privacy by default.
    3. Re:LibreOffice 5.x is a big improvement by vandamme · · Score: 1

      Yes. RTFM!

  35. Re:Italy has a military? by unixisc · · Score: 1

    The war that Garibaldi fought was against foreign powers who colonized Italy - namely the Austrians and the French. And that was during the post Napoleonic period

  36. Who Cares? by nicoleb_x · · Score: 1

    What I really want to know is what kind of toilet paper they use.

  37. Re:Kind of. Coast Guard. Same size as 1 carrier gr by turbidostato · · Score: 2

    "wouldn't canada (or anybody) be safer without a friend who goes around the world stirring shit at every possible opportunity?"

    Well, it depends. Our current world is only big enough for a limited set of military bullies, and it can be argued that the current set has a cardinality of one. So, if you happen not to be friend of the bully... what do you think is the alternative?

  38. Re:Italy has a military? by youngone · · Score: 1
    My Grandfather was in Italy during the war and ended up in Trieste

    He like the Italians, and learned to speak Italian quite well, so that he could order wine for his unit. His take was that Italians pretty much wanted everyone to go home, they generally had no interest in fighting.

    His view may have been coloured by the fact that his unit, (the New Zealand Division Signal Corps, so not front line troops) took a lot of Italian prisoners during the Middle East campaign.

  39. Re:Italy has a military? by Archwyrm · · Score: 1

    Unfortunately the 10th "Mountain" Division carries this title only in name. They are simply another IBCT and conduct no specialized mountaineering training. They are located at Fort Drum, NY which is flat as a pancake and much closer to the Great Lakes than any mountains. In fact, there is no large formation in the US military with that capability. As far as training facilities/schools go, I am only aware of the Army Mountain Warfare School and the USMC Mountain Warfare Training Center. The former is located in Vermont (and both NY and Vermont's mountains are a joke compared to say.. the Alps or the mountains of Afghanistan) and I have never met anyone in 11 years of Army service that has attended the school (seems to be mostly a "fun" school for Vermont National Guardsmen and ROTC Cadets). The latter Marine Corps school seems to take things a little more seriously, located in the Sierra Nevadas and offering some pretty advanced training. I can't speak for Marine attendance at this school but the Corps is small and mostly concerned with the ocean. I would imagine the school gets some patronage from Special Operations Forces, for example the Army maintains a number of Special Forces mountaineering teams. Again, that is very small though. So no, unfortunately the US military has very little mountain capability. The days of the 10th Mountain skiing down the slopes in the Rockies is long gone.

    --
    Fascism should more properly be called corporatism because it is the merger of state and corporate power. -- Mussolini
  40. Re:Italy has a military? by vgerdj · · Score: 1

    Allied invasion of Sicily, codenamed Operation Husky, was a major World War II campaign, ... began on the night of 9/10 July 1943, and ended on 17 August. Allied invasion of Italy was the Allied landing on mainland Italy on 3 September 1943. How much wronger can you be?

  41. Re:Italy has a military? by Eunuchswear · · Score: 1

    Roughly the same period as the Jin dynasty (265–420) in China.

    Population around 22 million, maybe a third of the population of the Roman empire at its greatest.

    --
    Watch this Heartland Institute video
  42. Re: Italy has a military? by Rakarra · · Score: 1

    Oh, reality bites, huh? So why was the Afghan war fought even after Bin Laden was killed?

    Because the United States was not at war with Bin Laden, it was at war with Al Qaeda, of whom Bin Laden was the head. Killing Bin Laden does not kill his terrorist networks.