Slashdot Mirror
Apple Approves, Then Removes In-App Ad Blocker (reuters.com)
Mickeycaskill writes: Apple has pulled a number of applications from the App Store, most notably the "Been Choice" ad blocker, because of concerns the methods they employ to rid adverts could compromise sensitive user data. iOS 9 allows for the installation of applications that block adverts in Safari, but other apps like Been Choice go one step further and let users remove adverts from applications – including Apple News. Been Choice routes traffic through a VPN to filter out adverts in some applications, but it this technique has attracted the attention of Apple, which is concerned user data could be exposed. Apple says it is working with developers to get their apps back up and Been is refining its application for resubmission. In any case, Been says users must opt-in for in-app ad blocking and that no data is stored on its servers.
Just wait for macos to have the same level of lock down and app store only.
I'm the first guy in line to shit on Apple, but having an app that routes all traffic through some unknown server is a major security issue. Apple is right to pull this until they can figure out a way to make sure the user knows the implications and/or the server operator has no way of collecting data from the users routed through his/her VPN.
The summary is horrific because it paints the pulling of these apps as negative when in fact it's one of the better demonstrations as to why non-technical people need a curated app store.
Be honest, your mom or other family member is is not as technically knowledgeable tells you they installed an app that routes all mobile traffic through some VPN the developer runs (never mind how they knew enough to explain that to you!).
Would you SERIOUSLY let that stay installed, or would you run to un-install it?
This is nothing more than a giant security breach. If you really are STUPID enough to want to run all your traffic through some strangers VPN, you can do so easily with existing mobile VPN support on any platform. They can scrub ad blockers and run MITM attacks on your bank or what have you, but at least it would have required more effort on your part to get yourself into trouble.
"There is more worth loving than we have strength to love." - Brian Jay Stanley
I don't own, and probably never will, an Apple product, i simply don't think they worth what they cost, but i got to give a thumbs up on this one, i don't know how many of the app's users know (and understand) what was going on, and while there isn't any evidence that this actually happened, you only can "trust" they don't. Maybe if this app was advertise as such, it may be acceptable, because the user choose to trust them or not.
Downloaded BEEN when first posted online. I expected it too good to last. Here's why:
Websites are unusable due to advertisers banner attacks. Apps are quickly monetizing to un-usability too. BEEN stops that Shit! Not only did I download, install and turn on BEEN, gladly, I added VPN capability to Stop app advertising pollution.
Why? BEEN is my MITM gatekeeper. I have the Internet back ad-free and yes Shit from advertisers is trapped before It can waste my time in-app or online.
Advertising is POLLUTION. Stop that Shit at source. BEEN.app Thank you. Now I have only one MITM. No worry. It's BEEN. There's a problem? I have one place to go. BEEN is scrubbing Internet emissions at the source like smokestack emissions does for EV automobiles.
It's a fair trade-off no advertising pollution, screen contaminants and network degradation in exchange for a MITM scrubber at the source. Or you can follow the automobile tailpipe analogy spewing Shit out every user's car by the millions.
BEEN there. Thank you VW you lying builders of "Clean Diesel" advertising. Now I have control. I know my weakness. I know who it is. Ain't beholden advertising Shit ever again.