Slashdot Mirror


The Guardian Publishes Comment Abuse Stats, Invites Debate On Moderation (theguardian.com)

AmiMoJo writes: British newspaper The Guardian has published some stats on its popular comment sections attached to each story. So far the Guardian's site has received 70 million comments, of which around 2% were removed for violation of community standards. Articles written by women tended to get the most blocked comments, especially if they were in male-writer dominated sections like sports and technology, while fashion was one of the few areas where men got more abuse. Further down the article the reader is invited to moderate some sample comments and see how their actions compared to those of the paper's staff. You can leave suggestions for improvement here.

2 of 303 comments (clear)

  1. "Community"? Orwellian terminology... by mi · · Score: 5, Insightful

    violation of community standards

    What's with the "community"? There are no "community" standards — the removed messages were deemed offensive by a handful of moderators. Moderators prone to keeping some posts more equal than others and susceptible to manipulation by evil regimes.

    Calling them "community" is redefining terms...

    --
    In Soviet Washington the swamp drains you.
  2. Re:The so-called 'community standards' by GNious · · Score: 5, Insightful

    (I'm in Belgium)
    When governments and societies take foreigners and group them together geographically, you end up with small enclaves where there's ca no reason or need to learn the national language.
    I can show you places in here in Belgium, where Arabic will help you more than French or Flemish, there are sections in Frankfurt where you might as well speak Turkish, large area in northern Mexico where half the population only speaks german and sections of Spain where no-one speaks anything but UK English.

    Yes, some people have no interest in integrating, but when there's no way to even use the national language, at lot of foreigners end up giving up trying to learn it.