Slashdot Mirror


Microsoft Removes Wi-Fi Sense Feature From Windows 10 Which Shared Your Wi-Fi Password

Microsoft says it has removed the controversial Wi-Fi Sense feature that shared a user's password with their friends and people in the contact list. "We have removed the Wi-Fi Sense feature that allows you to share Wi-Fi networks with your contacts and to be automatically connected to networks shared by your contacts," says Microsoft's Gabe Aul. "The cost of updating the code to keep this feature working combined with low usage and low demand made this not worth further investment." Ben Woods, writing for The Next Web: The feature allows you to share Wi-Fi login information with friends automatically via your contacts, however it got a controversial reception due to privacy implications. Do you really want to share your Wi-Fi codes with everyone in your contacts? No, of course not. It seems that was the general response from users too, so that option will be removed in the upcoming Windows 10 Insider Preview update, Microsoft says. Public Wi-Fi login info will remain in the app though.

11 of 190 comments (clear)

  1. Can we get them to remove other annoyances? by kheldan · · Score: 3, Insightful

    How about removing all the so-called 'telemetry' and other privacy-invading malware bullshit and return control of peoples' computers to the people who own and operate them? Or will not being assholes cut into your profit margin too much?

    --
    Are YOU using the TOOL, or is the TOOL using YOU? Think about it!
    1. Re:Can we get them to remove other annoyances? by cfalcon · · Score: 5, Insightful

      > How about you just don't fucking buy it and stop whining.

      Well, Windows 10 has been pretty clever about sneaking into machines and installing itself, in the process downgrading your "pro" 7 install to a "home" one. So some victims of Windows 10 didn't consent, they were tricked.

      If you used Windows 7 (a pretty good OS!), you might expect that, at some point, Microsoft would make another good OS. It's reasonable to be disappointed or even angry that they have not.

      And you said it yourself- Microsoft is obsessed with capturing what you do and sending it to their servers. This means that someone must obviously care what people are doing on computers, because there is such a huge pressure to make that happen.

      I can't disagree with your overall point though: the solution is to stop using Windows. If Windows users continue to put up with anything, then "anything" is exactly what they will get.

    2. Re:Can we get them to remove other annoyances? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

      "but the fact of that matter is that this level of data reporting has been included in the three prior versions of Windows"

      You had the option to turn it off, dipshit. That's the whole fucking point.

    3. Re:Can we get them to remove other annoyances? by cfalcon · · Score: 4, Insightful

      > Did you complain about the so-called telemetry in Vista, 7, or 8?

      Windows 7 and 8 didn't have it 10-style until 10 launched. It is possible to run 7 without telemetry, and out of the box, 7 doesn't have it. So if people aren't complaining about it, it is ultimately because it doesn't exist. Certainly not the way it does in 10.

      > Do you complain about it Android?

      I'm pretty sure you can turn it off in Android. I know you can in ios. More importantly, phones are generally poor at privacy, because they must, by nature, broadcast your location constantly. To make this worse, there's no truly open phone.

      But just because phones suck doesn't mean desktops should. This does not excuse Microsoft's behavior in Windows 10. Windows 10 runs on a real machine, it is far more capable than a phone, and you could easily have most or all of your electronic life in there, and many do. It is disgusting to switch that to some kind of system that rings the mothership everytime you launch notepad, such that some profile about you exists for how you edit your damned files.

    4. Re:Can we get them to remove other annoyances? by pezpunk · · Score: 5, Insightful

      haha, why are you bothering to defend this horrible practice?

      she did not want the upgrade. somehow it wound up on there. there are THOUSANDS of people with the same story. you want to write a book on why she TECHNICALLY must have agreed to install it at some point, fine, but the bottom line is she was tricked into installing it, and her story is an extremely common one. It's a shitty tactic and it's creating millions of brand new microsoft haters who previously didn't really have an opinion on the company.

      --
      i could live a little longer in this prison
  2. They left out a clause by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Now that Microsoft knows 90% of its users' wireless passwords, We have removed the Wi-Fi Sense feature

  3. Option removed by fahrbot-bot · · Score: 1, Insightful

    ... so that option will be removed in the upcoming Windows 10

    Of course, we'll keep *collecting* that information ... 'cause it's Windows 10, which is all about data collection. /cynical

    --
    It must have been something you assimilated. . . .
  4. Re:How about adding back ip over firewire? by wicka_wicka · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This is why I love Slashdot. People (like you) are obsessed with comically niche features like IP over Firewire, which is utterly irrelevant, and yet you're too blind to reality to realize it. The last time I saw a thread complaining about Windows there was a similar post saying Windows absolutely MUST include built-in ssh. It's like you people are being willfully ignorant of how the end-user market actually works.

    --
    hi
  5. Wifi-CommonSense by cloud.pt · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Subject says it all. Somebody didn't think the least bit about the implications of generally sharing private passwords.

  6. Wow, they listen to their users? by Opportunist · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Who would have thought that there is low demand for a "feature" that broadcasts your passwords to others?

    Hey, MS, allow me to let you in on a secret: There's also really low demand for the thousand "apps" that nobody needs, can't be uninstalled and take up unnecessary space on the drive and the start menu (where you ALSO cannot get rid of them), and there is really low demand for updates we can't turn off.

    Maybe you could discover this great revelation next?

    --
    We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
  7. The real problem explained by Mr_Silver · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The problem wasn't so much that you could share access to your network with your friends - it was that if you gave your WiFi password to someone (which what the majority of people do when they visit someone elses house) then you had to make sure that they didn't share access to your network with their friends.

    The problem is that Microsoft cannot differentiate between someone who has the WiFi password because they own the connection and someone who has the WiFi password because they were told it. Microsoft made the assumption that if you have the password, then you have the right to offer that connection to others - but this is not what happens in the "real world".

    Because of this incorrect assumption, the onus was suddenly placed on the owner of the WiFi (who does decide to provide their password) to police the entry of it into Windows 10 devices to ensure that a bunch of random people that they have never met aren't suddenly allowed to use their network.

    That was why it was an issue.

    --
    Avantslash - View Slashdot cleanly on your mobile phone.