Slashdot Mirror


From Bicycles To Washing Machines: Sweden To Give Tax Breaks For Repairs (mnn.com)

jenningsthecat writes: The Swedish government is putting its money where its mouth is when it comes to encouraging the repair of stuff that would otherwise be thrown away, according to both The Guardian and Fast Company. The country's Social Democrat and Green party coalition have submitted proposals to Parliament that would reduce the value-added-tax (VAT) on bicycle, clothing, and shoe repairs from 25% to 12%. Also proposed is an income tax deduction equalling half the labor cost of repairing household appliances. According to The Guardian, "the incentives are part of a shift in government focus from reducing carbon emissions produced domestically to reducing emissions tied to goods produced elsewhere." Per Bolund, Sweden's Minister for Financial Markets and Consumer Affairs, said the policy also tied in with international trends around reduced consumption and crafts, such as the "maker movement" and the sharing economy, both of which have strong followings in Sweden. The VAT cut may create more jobs for immigrants as it could spur the creation of a new home-repairs service industry. Also, from a science standpoint, the incentives could help cut the cost of carbon emissions on the planet as it should in theory reduce emissions linked to consumption. "I believe there is a shift in view in Sweden at the moment. There is an increased knowledge that we need to make our things last longer in order to reduce materials' consumption," Bolund said. The Guardian's report concludes: "The proposals will be presented in parliament as part of the government's budget proposals and if voted through in December will become law from January 1, 2017."

13 of 146 comments (clear)

  1. It's the cost of the labor, stupid by macraig · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I doubt this will be a compelling incentive if the cost of repair labor in Sweden is comparable to that in the United States. People don't repair things because (a) many are deliberately designed not to be easily reparable and (b) the labor cost of the "experts" is disproportionate to the value of having it repaired. Shaving a little bit off the sales tax of the bill is not going to offset the disproportionate cost of the alleged expertise.

    1. Re:It's the cost of the labor, stupid by reboot246 · · Score: 3, Insightful

      And many times the labor cost is far higher than the actual amount the "laborer" is being paid. Somebody is making that extra money, but so many times it's not the person doing the actual work.

    2. Re:It's the cost of the labor, stupid by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Somebody is making that extra money, but so many times it's not the person doing the actual work.

      Go to Craigslist and hire someone direct. Or go to nextdoor.com and ask your neighbors for a recommendation. If someone does a good job, give them a good review on Yelp. Spread the word.

    3. Re:It's the cost of the labor, stupid by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 3, Insightful

      That is, of course, if you have the skill needed to perform the actual work

      For most repairs, no skill is needed. Just go to Youtube, type in the product you are repairing, and a short description of what the problem is, and you will get a dozen videos showing exactly how to fix it.

    4. Re:It's the cost of the labor, stupid by Pentium100 · · Score: 2, Insightful

      The best solution is of course to simply lower taxes and let the market and people themselves figure out where to put their money but well - can't have that, it's a regulated socialist shit-hole after-all.

      Regulated socialist shit-hole is better than unregulated US-style capitalism where private corporations are more powerful than the government and can do whatever they want. After all, the market is free, so you are free to choose any internet service provider serving your area:
      1. Cable company A - $100/month for 10mbps and 100GB data cap.
      2. Telephone company B - $100/month for 10mbps and 100GB data cap.

      You are completely free to choose from any of those options. Or maybe you have to choose one from the list of one - just like in elections in the USSR.

      I think that small companies should pay less taxes and be more free, bowever, once a company gets too large, it should be put under tight control from the (democratically elected) government, so the company serves the people and not its stockholders/CEO.
      The idea here is that a market with a lot of small companies offering similar products is quite free and self regulating. However, once one or two companies get too large, all the others would not be able to compete and it raises the bar to enter the market, therefore, the large company should be regulated more. An example would be Microsoft - a lot of people hate Windows 10, but still buy laptops with it, because it is really difficult to find a laptop without Windows (and one that works well with Linux) because of all the deals Microsoft has made with the manufacturers.

      Another example would be the cable TV STB fight between FCC and the cable companies. There is no valid reason to force subscribers to buy/lease the STB from the cable company if compatible ones are available. "Cable company wants more money" is not a valid reason.

      An example from my country would be the pricing of food after the national currency was replaced with Euro). It is cheaper to drive 200km to Poland to buy food than it is to buy it locally. The large stores blamed this on the farmers and larger VAT in my country. However, you can go to Poland and find milk from my country there cheaper (presumably the farmer does not give a discount to the foreigner). And the price difference is much bigger than the VAT difference. This results in a problem that if you buy stuff in Poland, you pay taxes to their budget and not the local one.

  2. Re:Who's gonna pay "THEIR FAIR SHARE"?!?!?! by PopeRatzo · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Sweden?!?!

    Tax cut?!?!?

    To encourage job growth?!?!

    "Progressive" heads explode!

    Until you figure out that the tax cut is not to corporations and the rich, but to regular people, and alt-right heads explodes instead.

    --
    You are welcome on my lawn.
  3. Good thinking by bnmm · · Score: 2, Insightful
    1. Re: Good thinking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

      As someone from Sweden I don't know if I should laugh or cry every time articles like these are brought up.

      It's cherry picking at best. Crime in Sweden is going down by all objective, measurable standards. Sure, we have problems like anyone else but this is just crazy.

    2. Re: Good thinking by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

      Get lost... Stop propagating the lies that everything is fine...

      https://www.bra.se/bra/bra-in-...

  4. What do you mean... by matbury · · Score: 3, Insightful

    ...we can't shop our way to a greener future? Consumer choice of which soon-to-be-landfill products isn't going to prevent climate change?!

  5. Yeah, don't worry about this by aliquis · · Score: 3, Insightful

    The immigrants set lots of cars on fire all the time.

    Where I live towards the end of August more or less all the windows in the area center had been smashed and two weeks ago a car was lit on fire on "my" parking loot, someone had to set the youth center and music and dancing activity center on fire as-well as the children facility of the primary care center.

    We also have all the immigrants in Malmö who use a in debt / criminal / social low-life "guardian" as owner of their car to not pay any taxes, insurance or parking fees and tickets and then when the cars are eventually removed from the system since no-one will pay all the fines on purchase they are just scrapped and what was it more that I was thinking off ...

    Our "environmentalist" (more like "immigrationalists") "progressives" hate any personal responsibility for progression and any progression you can accomplish yourself, but they totally want society to bring it for you, with .. well.. the usual result I guess, which is close to none.

    The Social rats dictatorship party know they need the beggars, the complainers, the demands, the free-loaders, the rats, the trouble-makers, the "the situation and actions of and in my life is someone elseÂs fault"-trash people to remain in power so they are so willing to bring in more of them and let them have their way.

    Also of course Sweden is a country where vehicles are upgraded with new ones ran on bio gas or ethanol and so on because we all know that's environment friendly to produce as is replacing the vehicle fleet.

    It's just a joke. But supposedly it's a good joke and if you're not in then you're a racist fascist anti-democrat.
    Oh, and our local municipal home owner (which own lots of homes in this city) has figured out that having a working income will be a demand to get 75% of the apartments they rent out in the most trashy immigrant dense areas whereas in other places of the city for some apartments if you've lived with them or been in queue for over four years (as in not newly arrived immigrant) you will not be able to apply for it.
    Because socialists politicians know best. Diversity & multi-culturalism - until the last European is dead and what was Europe is gone.

  6. Re: Now Assange has got more to worry about. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Insightful

    Sweden cares very much what the US thinks: they changed all of their copyright laws overnight to please the MPAA. It's not like they had any choices of course...

  7. Re:Who's gonna pay "THEIR FAIR SHARE"?!?!?! by Darinbob · · Score: 5, Insightful

    High tax rate but also high return on value to citizens. The US has a very low tax rate but also a very low return back to citizens. What pisses off people is when they pay taxes but get very little to show for it (except a gargantuan military).